Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Trying to Give up Meat

Trying to Give up Meat

TUF · 06 May 2005

Its in Gurbani that to fight over whether or not to eat meat is pointless. I'm thinking about giving up eating meat, however, after reading numerous Sikh articles about the "meat debate" its left me with the opinion that it doesn't really matter whether a person does or does not eat meat. Some people say you cannot eat meat if you're amritdhari. Others say you can eat meat but only as a last resort. Then theres all this debate about "Jhatka" meat and the fact that the Shiromani committee has endorsed this viewpoint saying that an amritdhari Sikh may NOT be excommunicated for eating meat, so basically its okay for a Sikh to eat meat as long as its not Kutha/halal etc. Without religion, on a fundamental gut basis, I feel that its wrong to eat meat and YES, there is something wrong in killing another living creature for our own pleasure when we can simply eat other things (plants). On the other hand, I've eatten meat my whole life and have become quite a connouisser. And since we don't kill the animals ourselves, is it really that bad? I've already read interpretations of Gurbani quotes and I'm really confused and need some clarifications and opinions. What are others thoughts on this topic and do you or don't you eat meat? ***Admin Note***: [i]The issue of meat has been discussed manyt imes on this board. Please see earlier discussions. Only posts that add something to the discussion or personal experiences will be accepted.[/i]

Re: Trying to Give up Meat

singh · 06 May 2005

I used to eat meat, drink alcohal, and smoke marijuana then this one hukam from guru granth saahib ji changed all that, here it is...... This Shabad is by Bhagat Kabeer Ji in Salok Kabeer Jee on Pannaa 1377 kabeer bhaa(n)g maashhulee suraa paan jo jo praanee khaa(n)hi || Kabeer, those mortals who consume marijuana, fish and wine theerathh barath naem keeeae thae sabhai rasaathal jaa(n)hi ||233|| - no matter what pilgrimages, fasts and rituals they follow, they will all go to hell. ||233||

Re: Trying to Give up Meat

proteh makki roti sag jalebia · 06 May 2005

ok im not gonna begin any debates but just want my dear brother or sister to experiment something. Analyse your present state and measure yourself up against the bhagti you are doing. Then give up meat for a month and carry on doing the same bhagti and see if you start noticing any differences.

Re: Trying to Give up Meat

jugroop singh · 06 May 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Dear Veer Ji, Siree Guru Sahib Ji has already shown you the Truth of the matter - you have displayed a great vichaar. You wrote: 'on a fundamental gut basis, I feel that its wrong to eat meat and YES, there is something wrong in killing another living creature for our own pleasure when we can simply eat other things (plants)'. But dubda (duality) is powerful; it overpowers me continuously. i hope you do not mind Veer Ji when i say that here you display dubda when you go on to say (DESPITE what your 'gut feeling' is): 'On the other hand, I've eatten meat my whole life and have become quite a connouisser. And since we don't kill the animals ourselves, is it really that bad?' i think deep inside you kow the Truth. Veer Ji, Siree Guru Sahib Ji is waiting to smile the smile of grace, when you finally realise He has already shown you The Way. bhul chuk maaf karna ji. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: Trying to Give up Meat

... · 07 May 2005

When i walk past a butchers the stench of animal flesh makes me want to puke up. Meat is spiritually filthy, any1 with a conciouce wud be unable to eat it. Other day i was doing prosection of a human body, and i cudnt eat properly for days after. If you knew how much crap (eg. urea) is in flesh you wud be unable to eat it

Re: Trying to Give up Meat

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 07 May 2005

TUF ji, Personally, I am a non-veg. This may surprise you to hear me say this: You have a very, very important reason to go veg - that you feel it is wrong. Please follow your instincts, they are trying to tell you something. I'll share a personal story on a different topic. It doesn't have to do with veg/non-veg but it it does have to do with breaking a habit, and a change in lifestyle. Over a year ago, I made a decision to not have a television or movies in my home at all...not even DVD's to play on the computer. I gave away my DVD's, videotapes, their players, and my televisions to a local charity. I disconnected my cable service. Now...is television universally anti-gurmat? I do not know. Guruji made the decision for me...and was gracious enough to share the darshan that allowed me to quiet my ego and listen. When I stuggled with the regret of making such a drastic move...I asked Guruji for help. He helped me. Many, many times, he helped me. TUF ji...my humble suggestion is, you have read words of Gurbani and that is wonderful. But do not forget to ask Waheguruji for guidance. He understands these things. He will listen. And, He will help.

Re: Trying to Give up Meat

TUF · 07 May 2005

Thank you for your responses. I honestly do think it is wrong to kill animals for our own consumption. What about eggs? I suppose eating them is also considered killing an animal, but for some reason, I don't consider this to be as wrong as eating meat.

Re: Trying to Give up Meat

PSS · 07 May 2005

HAVE QUORN OR SOYA

Re: Trying to Give up Meat

ex meat eater. · 07 May 2005

its simple tuff, i am in no way a sikh, i drink, goto clubs etc. but i recently gave up meat to make 1 step 2wards sikhi. Its definatly immoral to eat meat, killing an animal (taking a life) to fullfill the lust of our tongues. It has definatly helped me cut down other bad things that i partake in.

Re: Trying to Give up Meat

" · 08 May 2005

jIA bDhu su Drmu kir Qwphu ADrmu khhu kq BweI ] jeea badhhahu s dhharam kar thhaapahu adhharam kehahu kath bhaaee || You kill living beings, and call it a righteous action. Tell me, brother, what would you call an unrighteous action? Awps kau muinvr kir Qwphu kw kau khhu ksweI ]2] aapas ko munivar kar thhaapahu kaa ko kehahu kasaaee ||2|| You call yourself the most excellent sage; then who would you call a butcher? ||2||

Re: Trying to Give up Meat

Manjit kaur · 08 May 2005

Singh jio, The second part of Bhagat kabir Ji's slok refers: Doesnt GURBANI clearly say that ALL PILGRIMAGES, FASTS and RITUALS..are absolutely USELESS ??..So whats the take on going to Hell or Being SAVED through DOING or NOT doing these. Does it say anywhere WHICH particular "pilgrimage/ritual/fast" can send us to Heaven...that is IF we stop eating meat.. MK