Sant Atter SINGH NIKETAN VIDYALA-MALAYSIA
Gurcharan Singh Kulim, · 06 May 2005
Sant Atter Singh ji Niketan Vidyala was set up some years ago to preach Sikhi, as the founders claim.Its origin and presence actually created an era of divison among the Sikh community.The divison came about mainly between the established Sikh Naujawan Sabha Malaysia and the Sant atter Singh vidyala, as the Vidyala sought recruiyts from the youth who already had one organisation.
It was an unhealthy act and a very undesireable phase in Malaysia Sikh history.But , once the SASN Vidyala was set up, there was no turning back.The sangats hoped that since both portayed panthic values, they could both work together in only promoting Sikh values and parchar, so let them both be.
However, apart from the back door bickerings that went on ,the SAS Niketan vidyala stole the opportunity to organise the first national nager kirtan in Kuala Lumpur.It made no difference to the Sikh sangataan as it was a sikh organisation.The hope was all will work together.
However, concerns arose at once the nager kirtan was over.WHY ?why is the big question all wil be asking??
Let me explain ...the Sant Atter Singh Niketan Vidyala controlled the main podiam.The SASN Vidyala presented to the sangat a ghona mona "sikh" who goes by the name of datuk Jaspal Singh, as the MAN responsible to explain the ocassion of the 400th Parkash of Guru Granth sahib to the thousands of Sikhs gathered there.
Datuk is an honorary title given to people in Malaysia in recognition of some community participation etc.It is said that because this man donates money , therefore he is often appointed as the chief spokesman.HE HAS ALSO BEEN GENEROUS TO OTHER SIKH ORGANSITIONS.So some of the so called Gursikhs are quiet over this issue, as they see money!
I know there are some niketinis here, can anyone explain how COULD THEY PRESENT A GHONA MONA ON A SIKH STAGE to offer the message of sikhi to the Sikh sangats?
WHAT SORT OF IMPRESSION WOULD THIS MONA BE GIVING TO PEOPLE ABOUT THE CONCEPT OF SIKHI AND GURBANI ?
i HAVE NO QUESTION AND PROBLEM WITH HIS MONAPAN ,BUT I have when he is being presented as the LEADER OF KESADHARRI SIKHS.
khalsa ji, this is not acceptble that a ghona mona, who himself has failed to accept even the basic identity of the Sikhs be parading the podiams of sikh organisations and talk of sikhi?Which Sikhi?His version or that one given by Guru Gobind Singh ji?
One would have thought this man would have had the slightest commonsense to have even donned a dastaar over his head on this ocassion.NO,he was clean shaven.For someone who cannot even think this simple logical thought, what sort of guidance will he give the panth?the clean shaven image that he has?
What are the youth going to think...man it is okay to cut our hair the community will still accept us ...man it is okay ...go and cut off your hair ????????
The Sikhs in Malaysia have a proud history.They hold great esteemamong their countrymen.Our Forefathers built up thekaum from scratch.They maintained their Sikhi saroop and built great Gurduaras and organisations for the new generation.what are these new youth doing ???Inviting clean shaven so called "sikhs" and giving them positions of importance and seting a very bad example to the future generations.
I have no problem with any ghone mone Sikhs, I can only hope throughsewa they will one day realise their folly and come back to sikhi.
But we cannot have ghone moen leaders...talking of sikhi ...on public stages of Sikh events.
I call on all sikhs world wide to give their opinions on this issue.
I also have an uncut CD of the event, where this so called jaspal is giving the main speech on behalf of the SATN vidyala.Any one is free to view it if so desires.
I also like SASN vidyala to respond.Recently, members of this organisation tried to claim political milage over the SNSM follies,but interestingly, IT WAS THE SASN VIDYALA THAT SET OFF THE BAD EXAMPLE OF PROJECTING MONA AS THE SIKH LEADER,on a Sikh stgae and very unashamedly the SASN VYDYALA tried to steal some levarage over the SNSM.
It is basically the pot calling the kettle black.
Can the Sant atter Singh Vidyala explain their Video and their bad examples?
Are they denying they did not have a mona,( while some Gursikhs were standing in the background)...talking of Sikhi and Sikh values to the crowds, among whom there were many none sikhs??How could a mona explain the need to keep kes.
My argument is simple.If he or any ghona mona aspires to be a Sikh leader,then please adopt the roop of a kesadhari Sikh at least, we can over look the amritpaan until you are ready to take it.
Please explain here ,so we can all see it clearly .
Re: Sant Atter SINGH NIKETAN VIDYALA-MALAYSIA
BS Dhaliwal · 06 May 2005
This is very bad of a Sikh organisation to try and gain leverage over another Sikh organisation.This just shows the true picture of some of these organisations.
Bhai saab, you are very right.I saw your argument for the sikh turned muslim's presence on the stage in Malaysia, and I think it is great you brought to the attention of the sikh world.I saw some lost people arguing about foods music ect ect and not addressing the issues, a giddhar will always go around but not come to the point.
Let us see what these people from the sant atter singh niketan vydyala have to say about their own manmat act..I read elswhere how they tried to say theirs was the best programme, I am sure they are reading this now.let us see what they say.I come from malayisa too.
Vahguroo vahgurooo keep up the spirit
Re: Sant Atter SINGH NIKETAN VIDYALA-MALAYSIA
Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 06 May 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
The "trouble" imho begins very early...the PATRON GYANI of the SNSM are Sant GYANI Sohan Singh Ji Melaka and SANT GYANI Naranjan Singh Patiala. BOTH these firmly and unequivocally BELIEVED in and PARCHAARED the AKAL TAKHAT MARYADA known as the Sikh Rehat Maryada. NEVER ONCE did they ever practise any other Maryada... IN fact Sant gyani Naranjan Singh patiala was bestowed the Title and Siropa of SHIROMANI KATHAKAAR by the SHIROMANI GURDWARA PARBHANDAK COMMITTEE (SGPC). ( this same sgpc which all these hate so much as corrupted, alcoholics, bunch of no good etc etc..which as far as the present members go i agree BUT NOT those who FORMULATED the ORIGINAL SGPC MARYADA)
Interestingly enough the Sant Attar Singh Brahm Vidya Niketan ALSO adopted BOTh these SANT-GYANIS as their PATRON..but then went on to Parchaar their own version of Maryada...one of its main contention being that the MOOL MANTAR ends at NANAK HOSEE BHEE SACH.....while BOTH Sant gyani Sohan Singh Ji Melaka and sant gyani naranjan Singh Ji patiala have always maintained that the Moolmantar ends at GURPARSAAD.
From this minor difference the maryadas now being introduced in various gurdawras are causing a lot of divisions in the sangat..the Youth are confused to say the least...many have approached me asking questions like can I marry the girl who took amrit from Niketan as I took mine from SNSM ?? Is their Amrit the same ? long rehrass, short rehrass, this bani and that bani etc etc
Then came this Masterpiece...PEHL....the 400th paraksh Diharra..which fiasco GS Kulim asks questions above ??
I am sure the sewaks of Niketan must have a good explanation...after all they are all professionals
Re: Sant Atter SINGH NIKETAN VIDYALA-MALAYSIA
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 08 May 2005
it is amazing that the Niketan that was trying to gain political millage over the sNSM , and came out to claim that they did a wonderful job at the 400th anniversary, are now NOT responding when exposed about their own folly, which started the ghone mone appearing as leaders and spokesman of Sikhs.......on Sikh religiouis stages .....
sangat ji, does this explain something ??It certainly does, because if one watches their CD it explains everything clearly ...they are no better than anyone else..
I would ask leaders of such organisation to pack up and just join the mainstream Sikhs ,if you ever have one iota of Sikh love left ...in your bloods...
Unite the Sikhs rather than divide as has been done...
UNITY is the strength of the community ....
or explain your own doings at the 400th annivesary ....
Sant Atter SINGH NIKETAN VIDYALA-MALAYSIA
hardave singh · 08 May 2005
Waheguroo.
GSK and JSG keep up the good work, we all know you guys are so free with all these negative discussions.
iam afraid these organisations don't have the time to discuss about whatever that both of you have mentioned in this forum.
In fact you should know that the time is running out and we all need to do more naam bani rather than the bla bla bla allllllllllllllllllllll the time.
If you think any of this organisations have done something wrong then you should speak to their committee’s rather than putting up on the board like a coward and telling the whole world about their weaknesses and you want to be most famous and well known commenter.
Gosh!!!
pls grow up and be a gentleman.
Waheguroooooooo.
Re: Sant Atter SINGH NIKETAN VIDYALA-MALAYSIA
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 09 May 2005
Sangat Ji, interestingly, I did not think , the organisation would have had any time for a constructive discussion and explantion of their actions.
Strangely enough, it has the time to misrepresent the face of Sikhi, and also try and claim political milage.
Funnily, the writer does not state if he is speaking on behalf of the organisation or as someone who supports that actions of the organisation.
He has even written in, witholding his own identity.Now HONEST, KIRITT Kamii karan wale bande do not write under pen names.Honest people write openly, which is not relective of this individual.
Let me dispel some of his misconceptions...about cowards,cowards hide, and hover in the background, and when they see something anti Sikh they keep a low profile and have no comments.
in fact, from their half opened one eye they increase the volume of their fictitious naam japna ...from a low ..waheguru waheguru ...to a higher tone and volume ....
Let me also tell you, I have written to that organsiation, and I am sure my letter was binned.It has not replied.
So, after another organisation has followed that poor example of the Niketan, I have written openly ....so that all can see.This a Panthic issue, not a private "love hate "affair.There is more to come, dont worry.I have every intention of rocking the very strata of the Sikh society to awaken it, to the inappropriate behaviours under the garb of 'Sikhi' that errrant organisations are putting out.
Interestingly, they did not have time to answer, but still managed to spend ten minutes at the least writing under fictitious identity.
I am sure the sangats, can deduce from your ..wrong, irrelevant ,and totally off the mark answer what you are hiding by NOT answering to the point.
There is more to come ...worry not, as they say ......look out on the Malaysian scene.
Re: Sant Atter SINGH NIKETAN VIDYALA-MALAYSIA
Manjit kaur Sidhu · 10 May 2005
PLEASE ANSWER the questions posed and do write Your Id and Email...thats the least a honest Sikh of the Guru can do. No point bashing gyani or kulim...they are the "devils advocate"...to open up the trash for the sangat to see and make amends......IF you dont want a stink..CLEAN UP your act.
Re: Sant Atter SINGH NIKETAN VIDYALA-MALAYSIA
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 12 May 2005
hello Hello Niketan, We are awaiting your responses!You were QUICK to TRY GAIN MILLAGE over the SNSM blunders........and fairly QUICK to try and "rubbish" me and Giani JS ARSHI JI .....NOW I call you to explain, and alo label you with the title ...a WHITE ELEPGHANT and a WRONG example to the Sikh people.BUT THE NIKETAN IS VERY QUIET.
DID YOU PEOPLE PASSING OVER THE PRINCIPLES OF GURU GOBIND SINGH JI, defying the SRM, showing your low mentality towards Sikhi, offered a MONA to speak from your stage or not ?
DID YOUR ORGANISATION NOT START THE WRONG THINGS FROM YOUR STAGE , while one of your kesadhari Malkith SINGH JI STOOD alongside and watched?He took a secondary role .
Can you explain if that role was reflective of Sikh identity ?
It is NOT a hard question, give us the answer or explain please..if there is any anakh left in your people, who are bent in defacing the Sikh values?
Enough of your silence,and hoping this will walk away,
any anakh left ?Please answer or explain ....
Re: Sant Atter SINGH NIKETAN VIDYALA-MALAYSIA
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 14 May 2005
No answer ???NO did NOT think so when I put the pen to make the words ..at the top ...
Re: Sant Atter SINGH NIKETAN VIDYALA-MALAYSIA
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 15 May 2005
NO veer Ji...kion sharminda kardeh hoan..we all know very well they have NO ANSWERS...and they cant even use that "excuse"..."our LEADER JI" will appear to answer all queries...just wait...20 years or thereabouts..all questions will be answered....
TO BE quite FAIR..they have done some GOOD too you know. THeir GURBANI CLASSES ( so far FREE....but the going is getting tough now..ONLY WAHEGURU can afford to give FREE for LIFE !!) although a bit too derawaadi on some points, are getting the YOUTH towards GURSIKHI, Amrit, Gurmatt ( I dont know the exact numbers..but the figures do run into the hundreds..and that GLADDENS MY HEART). Their Punjabi classes are also doing a lot of good..this also gladdens my heart as Punjabi is my first love...
From the "number" of their Gurbani Students who come back to me for the "real arrths" of Gurbani...every week...shows that modern Youth are not so easily fooled by the derawaddi aarths..especially when they have resources like Faridkoti Teeka, Prof harbans Singh teeka, Prof Sahib singh Jis' Darpan, manmohan Singh teeka, Bhai Sahib bhai veer Singh teeka....etc on LINE, together with mahan kosh and Punjabi Dictionaries/ Varaan etc etc on their Desk tops
imho they have learnt their lesson and will from now on concentrate on their good points and leave such MEGA Projects aside....or have they ?? only time will tell.