Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

DEGH!!!!

DEGH!!!!

...... · 05 May 2005

We know that their is a maryarda for degh, which many gurughars in western countires dont really follow (i.e. doing full ishnaan including kesi ishnaan, making it sarbloh, doing abhiyaas etc etc). So my question is that if we go to a gurughar and we know that the degh prepared their is not done by full maryada should we accept it wether we are bibeki or not. Would it be wrong for someone who was not a bibeki to refuse the degh which is not prepared by maryada? I mean after amrith the most imporatnt thing one could shak is degh, and we all know that if we knew an amrith sanchaar was doing dhils we wouldnt shak it there. Would it be worng for a person who is not bibeki to refuse degh which is NOT prepared by maryada????

Re: DEGH!!!!

me · 05 May 2005

Degh is of such a high level. How can we call it "Degh" if theres been no marayda in the preperation? As Khande Bateh dee pahul as maryada so does Degh and so does Langar. I personally dont feel there being anything wrong with not accepting the "Degh" made without Marayda. After all, its the Marayda that makes that Atta, pani, gheo and khand with Naam Gurbani Abhiyaas with the person making it DEGH. Not just the ingredients with any aunty or uncle stiring. If theres a big deal, then take the "DEGH" and pass it on after if you do not wish to cause a scene as sometimes people start to look or the sewadar wil insist on you taking even 'little' bit. People will say that... how can you not accept it when Guru Jee has? I ask those people, Nihangs do Bhog to Maas. Does that mean Guru Jee has accepted it? People to bhog to Outside made food when bought into the "Langar" Does that make it Langar? Accepted? [%sig%]

Re: DEGH!!!!

Manvir Singh · 05 May 2005

Degh is 'parshaad' Parshaad deriving from 'parsaad', meaning grace. Degh is the Guru's grace. Whether it is prepared by Maryada or not, who are we to turn away from the Guru's Kirpa and refuse the gift of Guru's kindness which has been blessed with the Sri Sahib (the manifestation of Akaal Purkh). We should have "faith" and "humility". Be eating degh which sadly has not been prepared in accordance to full rehat does not mean that we are less of Sikh or that our Sikhi is being robbed from us. Thinking that eating degh given in the Guru's House will have a negative effect illustrates our insecurity of our Sikhi and faith in Guru ji. Be refusing Degh are we showing humility? Refusing the food prepared in the home of someone is different to refusing to eat Langar or Parshaad in your Guru's House. Ask yourself what would Guru Ji do? What would chardikala Gursikhs like Baba Deep Singh Ji, Bhai Mani Singh Ji and Baba Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale do? Rather than refusing parshaad or langar shouldn't we help to "INSPIRE" and "ENCOURAGE" the following of rehat by helping to prepare Degh and getting others involved in Naam Abhiyaas and offering Sarbloh utensils (if the Gurdwara doesn't have any?). What will have more of a "positive" effect - refusing Karhah 'Parshaad' or helping to prepare and educating (pyaar de naal) how to prepare Degh? You decide. bhul chuk maaf Manvir Singh

Re: DEGH!!!!

Kulbir Singh · 05 May 2005

If Degh is not prepared according to Gurmat Maryada, a tyaar bar tyaar Khalsa Jan of Siri Gobind Singh jee is not obligated to accept such so-called degh. The foremost duty of Khalsa is to restore maryada at Gurdwaras that violate maryada and if Khalsa Jan is not in mood to do the sudhaayee of sewadaars who prepare degh against maryada, he or she to the very least has the right to refuse such degh that is not made with maryada. Instead of fixing the maryada and doing sudhaayee of sewadaars who prepared degh without maryada, it is not prudent and wise to accuse the Gursikhs who want to follow maryada, of not accepting degh. To coax them to accept degh using arguments like “it is not humble to refuse degh” etc. is not right. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: DEGH!!!!

Roopkaur · 05 May 2005

I agree with the above post. I think not accepting the degh is more HUMBLE than accepting it because by not accepting it you are following guru ji's hukam, but while you accept it, you are following what aam lok want you to do. I would rather submit to guru ji than popular opinion. You ask what would guru ji would do, and I answer with full conviction that if that degh is not made with maryada, it is not accepted by guru ji. Without guru ji's acceptance it is just karah, not parshaad or degh. The lame excuse that it is in guru jis ghar does not fit. We can use this to justify many things. There are many other things that happen in guru jis ghar that is against sikhi, but is it alright just because it takes place in a gurdvara? A while back you posted about the bhangra and Naamdhaarees at a Nagar keertan, this was guru jis nagar keertan, does that make it ok for these people to come and sabotage Sikhi? NO. The same way it is not acceptable to force bibeki SInghs and singhneeaa to accept degh not prepared in maryada because by accepting you are admitting that that is infact parshaad from guru ji when in fact it is not.

Re: DEGH!!!!

Dogma · 05 May 2005

I guess this is a personal decision. some people will outright refuse this degh.Others will feel wrong refusing it. I think it's a personal decision. Each side has it's own strong arguments.

Re: DEGH!!!!

singh · 05 May 2005

there is the dhooks of people in the deg and it is distributed to the sangat. You get kirpa from eating deg (if you don't eat a lot - otherwise it becomes food, not kirpa). However, how much kirpa will you get if you eat deg made with wrong maryada? Gyani Takhur Singh ji said in katha that it's best for us to not eat deg that's not made with maryada. bhul chuk maaf.

Re: DEGH!!!!

Jugraj Singh · 05 May 2005

>>>> I guess this is a personal decision. some people will outright refuse this degh.Others will feel wrong refusing it. I think it's a personal decision. Each side has it's own strong arguments. >>>> I suppose your right. It is a personal decision. Guru Sahib tells us to keep our kesh and wether we do or not is up to us. Guru sahib tells us to not eat meat and wether we follow the hukam is also up to us. Its the same with degh maryada. Guru sahib gave us a rehit and maryada for preparing degh and its up to us wether we follow it and support it or give into the manmatt. Your right. Its a personal decision. Following rehit usually is.

Re: DEGH!!!!

..... · 05 May 2005

well how about someone who does not keep bibek, would you think its ok if a NoN bibeki does not eat degh, or would you say to him/her that you dont keep bibek anyway why you refuse this. I personally believe that if its not made by maryada then there is not point accepting it wether bibeki or not, becuase degh is maha parshaad. but would like the sangath views.

Re: DEGH!!!!

Dogma · 05 May 2005

*** I suppose your right. It is a personal decision. Guru Sahib tells us to keep our kesh and wether we do or not is up to us. Guru sahib tells us to not eat meat and wether we follow the hukam is also up to us. Its the same with degh maryada. Guru sahib gave us a rehit and maryada for preparing degh and its up to us wether we follow it and support it or give into the manmatt. Your right. Its a personal decision. Following rehit usually is. *** As far as meat is concerned veerji, I agree with you. I don't eat meat either. But according to Akal Takhat maryada it IS allowed. So go figure? I guess that ulitmately depends on WHAT Rehit you keep. Keski as a Kakaar is believed by many, however many believe that Kesh is the kakaar, Akal Takhat Maryada says that the choice is yours. Raagmala is read by many, whereas many end at Mundavaani. Akaal Takhat Maryada says that the choice is yours. I completely agree that the Maryada for making Degh should be followed to the strictest, but who am I to give instructions to someone for REFUSING Degh? The fact that you think eating degh made by following improper maryada is manmatt is fine. Another person might disagree with you...(see Manvir Singh's post above). My point is that everything is not in BLACK and WHITE for everybody. I applaud you for having STRONG beliefs and having solid asools. However, I'm still learning so based on whatever little buddhi I have I posted. Forgive me if you didn't like what I posted. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!

Re: DEGH!!!!

Jugraj Singh · 06 May 2005

>>>> My point is that everything is not in BLACK and WHITE for everybody. >>>> In my understanding, either something is right according to gurmat or its wrong. We learn this from jeeven of puraatan Singhs such as Bhai Randhir Singh jee. But I also recognize that many times we compromise on rehit. For example, I should be wearing bana all the time, but when I'm at work I don't wear bana but rather pant and kameez. This is a choice that I make. But that doesn't mean it is acceptable to wear pant and kameez. What I do is wrong, but I'm too duniyavee. I think its the same sort of logic that many people apply to eating parshad and langar that is made without maryada. However, the difference is that if we continue to make compromises in Gurdwaras then what hope is there of ever improving our current state. I don't think that anything that deviates from Tat Gurmat should be encouraged in any gurdwara. That leaves the matter of what is Tat Gurmat? Its not my place to answer this but I've often heard Singhs recommend books of Bhai Randhir Singh Jee. Like you said before, following rehit is a personal choice, however, where maryada for Gurdwara is concerned, it is not a personal choice anymore but our duty and our dharam to discourage any anti-gurmat practices. But like you said before, not a lot of people know what Gurmat is so they don't know what side to support and just go along with the majority.

Re: DEGH!!!!

Min Singh · 06 May 2005

I know a keshadhari person belonging to the Radhaswami faith and he makes the Degh at a very prominent Gurdwara in Canada. This is one of the main reasons why I think that only a qualified Gursikh should make degh. Today it is a keshadhari Radhaswami, tomorrow we will even allow Monaas to make degh at our Gurdwaras. Our traditions are being eroded away as time passes by because of Dhilay people who don’t even want to acknowledge the existence of this problem. The problem in this case is dhil in rehet. We already have dhilay people allowing Monaas to lead the sangat in Kirtan, what next? Monaas allowed doing Granthi seva and Degh seva? Even though I am not Babeki, but I perfectly respect and understand Gursikhs who don’t accept Degh prepared without rehet. [%sig%]

Re: DEGH!!!!

Dogma · 06 May 2005

*** In my understanding, either something is right according to gurmat or its wrong. We learn this from jeeven of puraatan Singhs such as Bhai Randhir Singh jee. *** In an ideal world that would be perfect. But I find even among people of the same jatha it is the INTERPRETATION of what Gurmat is that causes us to have rifts between us. I can say something is wrong and support it with Gurbani, however at the same time someone can say that same thing is right and support it with Gurbani. Gurubani is PERFECT. It is only us moorakhs that try to manipulate it to satisfy our arguments. I believe even Puratan Singhs like Sant Attar Singh Jee and Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh had minor differences in opinion of what is or isn't Gurmat. I agree with you wholeheartedly about Gurudwaray following Tat Gurmat for making Degh. I believe that Akal Takhat HAS outlined the proper method for making Degh. I think that we should all follow that method as well..