Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Clarification on Tatt Khalsa Dinner(personal comments)

Clarification on Tatt Khalsa Dinner(personal comments)

SIKH · 30 May 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh, After reading the various messages, I was equally hurt by the practices of the various Sikh organization recently and proceeded to seek clarification from the organizers of the Tatt Khalsa Fund Raising Dinner held recently which I also attended. Firstly, as informed the main purpose of organizing the Dinner was to raise funds to lower the bank loans taken by the Gurdwara. It was not a religious function but purely a dinner organized by professionals Sikhs from the private sector (non committee member of Tatt Khalsa) to raise funds for the said purpose above. Secondly, as informed by the organizers of the dinner, they did not at any time associated themselves in the sales and distribution of any hard/soft drinks. There were some who brought in liquor bottles on their own accord and paid a corkage of RM20/- to PWTC management directly. The beer was also sold by PWTC for RM10/- per mug. Under no circumstances, were the organizers involved with the sales distribution or received any profit or commission for the sale of hard/soft drinks. Furthermore, there was no beer booth set up. Your have to place your order through the PWTC staff. Thirdly, the organizer informed me that the price list was a standard list displayed at any function held at PWTC and they have nothing to do with the sale, consumption, distribution or profits of hard drinks/ soft drink. Fourthly, in respect of halal food (chicken), vegetarian food was cooked in the temple and the chicken was cooked by a Punjabi chef especially paid to do so in PWTC. Fifthly, on DJ Dave issue, after reading the various messages, the organizer informed me that they did in fact terminated the services of DJ Dave a day before the dinner. Nevertheless, he still showed up on the dinner day and insist on performing based on a contract executed in early January 2005. The organized did not want a scene, paid RM10K and told him to perform as an entertainer for 15 minutes for the non sikhs and not to seek any donation from the audience. I was also told he was not the star attraction for the night but an ordinary performer. If you have attended, you may have noticed that there were many real stars like Reshmonu, Comedy Court and Gunjit Singh of UK. It is my personal view, the writers are ignorant and rely on hearsay news to write messages without actually inquiring the actual facts from the organizing committee of the said dinner. My apologies if my clarification annoys anybody but it is strictly from my observation and clarification from the organizing committee of the said dinner.

Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM

Me · 30 May 2005

Jarnail Singh, the original post was about SNSM and another organisation, do you have to bring sant bashing into every thread? Why are you so bitter?

Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM

Manjit kaur Sidhu · 30 May 2005

[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani] imho...after all this dust settles...everything will be back to square one..because the "differences" between the "Organsiations" are in actual fact differences between PRSONALITIES controlling these Organsiations..and none of these will ever "give up" his control to the other. I am on the ground...and am painfully aware of why so many Organisations keep struglling along..when by self admission they say ..we dont have this and we dont have that..and to let soemone who "has this and has that" to come in...will mean their own organsiation/pardhangee/jathedari will be "diluted" or even in danger. The Holla mahalla Games began some years ago...the Commanders in Chiefs prepared so many "rules and regulations" and had "uniforms" , "compulsory memebership" etc of their own pet organisation BEFORE the Youth could take part....THE SNSM , dispensed with all the "rules and regualtions/cum compulsory membership", opened the Games to ALL GURDWARAS....and the mini organsiation that pioneered the Games disappeared in the "dust" of following Years successive games..... This is a personality difference...just like in Punajb where we have multiple Akali dals.. even the Akal takhat FAILED to dissolve the various Dals... The SNSM has rvial organisation just because of MARYADA differences.. money of sangat being spent on duplicating many Youth Programmes..Gurmat samelans etc and "differences" being perpetauted instaed of beign removed The SNSM has a very active and Registered SWAT...Sikh Women's Awareness Team to deal effectively with LADY ISSUES and liase with the Govt on these...another SIMILAR Organsiation sprang up to deal with the SAME issues..another duplication... The SNSM also had ongoing Mother Language programmes and such... The LIST is endless..personalities clash and failure to get along lead to new organsiations or old ones take on new issues ..whatever... IF you "absolutely have to have " your own SWAT to "swat" the established swat....then how can you reasonably expect that "cooperation" will be forthcoming in other areas..in which you claim you have the "expertise", the students, teachers etc etc..COPERATION is a TWO WAY STREET. It is the HUMAN FACTOR that ultimately FAILS us all the time. [gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]

Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM

S Singh · 30 May 2005

>>However, it does not remove the fact, that SGPC is still the premier organisation of Sikh authority in the world.I respect that, despite other "failures", as I have seen. Should this letter not be going to the Akal Takht which is the premier organisation of Sikh authority ? The SGPC is a management committee and nothing more. They are headed by Jagiro who has been excommunicated from the Sikh faith and has been charged with murdering her daughter. SGPC members also organise mass alcohol distribution at the time of SGPC elections so I doubt they will find anything wrong with what veer Gurcharan Singh Kulim has written to them about.

Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 30 May 2005

Dear Me Jio, Looks like its you who are Bitter and uncomfortable. IS YOUR SANT or BRAHMGIANI named by me as Bad ?? SO why do you "see" your sant/babaji as being bashed ..when in fact ONLy the WRONG DOERS are being taken to task ?? On one hand you people tell me..Jarnail Singh Ji..we HAVE STOPPED reading your posts because they are always sant bashing..blah blah blha....but then you still pick up "one sentence out of a hundred" and point it out..Either YOU saw ONLY that one sentence...OR what ?? Those AGAINST the SNSM maryada here ARE "SANT SAMAJ FOLLOWERS". That is a fact even they wont DENY. SNSM follows Akal takhat maryada..they DONT. It is also a fact that these sant samaj followers spread unsubstantiated 'sakhis", maryadas such as ghee jyots, coconuts, and red cloths and water in bottles under Guru Ji , extra readings of Japji sahib along with Akhand Paath, NO WOMEN PAATHIS, read Raagmaala...etc etc. I will not support such maryadas that are NOT in line with AKAL TAKHAT ( which they "support" ?? because they very well KNOW the POWR of Akal takaht") I have no axe to grind "against" any particualr sant babaji..BUT I will support only Akal Takhat. In fact I have many "sants/babajis? as friends....and their followers as close friends....and i certianly dont hate anyone.

Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 30 May 2005

ref: SIKH's Personal comments on Tatt Khalsa Fund Raising Dinner. I find the personal comments of SIKH quite reasonable. Its true that this was a Fund raising dinner, held outside Gurdwara Premises. Secondly the Organsiers did try to remove the Patit DJdave, but due to legal contract, they could only minimise his exposure...and that is perfectly acceptable under the difficult circumstances. Others hould learn from this experience and avoid such messes. We all make msitakes but the wise learn from them. I am pretty sure in the future No SIKH Organsiation will commit these same mistakes. Much water has flowed under this particular bridge...time to let go...and MOVE ON.

Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 30 May 2005

A Sikh writes: 'It is my personal view,"" the writers are ignorant and rely on hearsay news"" to write messages without actually inquiring the actual facts from the organizing committee of the said dinner. My apologies if my clarification annoys anybody but it is strictly from my observation and clarification from the organizing committee of the said dinner.' ------------------- A Sikh has to hide behind a pseudo name to write here first and foremost explains all. I think ignorance starts here, with him. The fact TATT Khalsa Divan tried to back out of was NOT out of the IGNORANCE they had before: but the education by the exposure of the UNSIKH activities by individuals. ONE DAY BEFORE THE EVENT THEY TRIED TO PULL OUT ...explains ..all.. and for your information clever sikh .... THE ISSUES started long before that ONE day. Had the dust NOT flown and kicked up TATT khalsa would have not bothered cancelling the event even three days after the date. This is VERY SMART move now to take the heat off, after many weeks. So please do NOT turn up weeks after the event, and having thought about it all, to limit their damage.A Good try. So who did the organising committee clarify to?To you?Who are you ?Someone hiding behind a pen name? Just who are you that has all the education and not ignorance of other's intelligence? The fact is the dirt has now reached the malaya samachar newspaper..Issues are being discussed on the ground.I have had a phone call from Penang that tell me another story. Now these guys are trying to clarify and try to justify THEIR OWN IGNORANCE , thinking their stupidity is cleverer off the ignorance they percieve in others. Sangat ji, this """billi Sikh""..expects us to think as ignorantly and stupidly as them ......how clever or ignorantly stupid these people were...having organised and invited this adulterer dave for their function....then when the dust kicked up after the vesakhi , they sat on it for many days...at the last minute when the heat really turned on...they tried to cancel him...but whatever their internal arranged lies,that Irfan abdullah caught them out still ..with their pants down ...and got RM10,000 so they tell us....and it is out side the gurduara premises ...so it makes it all alright ...tomorrow a granthi will come say ..I smoked ..but outside the gurduara ..so all is well and fine within the gurduara.... This sikh looks like a real ignorant, and beleives the whole world is ignorant as him. There is more to come ....the issue is not dead and gone.

Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 30 May 2005

My original issue about tatt Khalsa was as follows in the first post :- The next worrying issue is, the TATT Khalsa Gurduara sahib, which is now known by the name of Guru Nanak Darbar, Kuala Lumpur,is organisng a fund raising dinner, has again invited this ex Sikh turned muslim to attend as the guest of honour or main fuctionary at this event.Surely,this is against Gurmat. What example are these parbandhaks trying to offer to the younger generation?That,it is all right to denounce sikhi and become whatever, but Sikh organsations will continue to honour such people?We can understand if it was someone born as a muslim, attending as a friend of the Sikhs, but in this case, this cannot be acceptable. ------------------------------------ The FACT THAT TATT KHALSA (ACCORDING TO THIS SIKH) tried to pull out shows, had the FUSS NOT been kicked up, they would have gone ahead.They had arranged to invite this lesser than perfect adulterer. Clever Sikh tell the sangat what is based on heresay in my above realting to tatt Khalsa post ?Or are you trying pull wool over others eyes? The rest of the excuses given by this Sikh are just excuses...of no consequences....like saying I did not pee in the church , but on the christian cross outside on the road....wow ....these people...can really buy and sell the Gurbani on the share market ...if given half the chance!

Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM

BS Dhaliwal · 30 May 2005

hahaha, I have followed this thread and all related to it very closely, the thread was raised by veer Dr Gurcharan Singh Kulim of UK. I am amused by the so called defence put up by Sikh.veer Dr Gurcharan Singh only raised the issue of a patit turned muslim,but this Sikh then goes on to explain, about alcohol etc, halal foods etc .The fact remains it does not matter who brought the alcochol, there was alcohol...there was halal food, there was the Dj whatever,there was an organised attempt to abuse, but given the stint kicked up by Dr sahib and Giani ji, these organising committe walahs have really cheek in tongue to ask some chicken hiding under a pen name of SIKH to wash their dirty linen clean.Sorry mate we no suckers to buy your story. Amazing the guy had TWO contracts with which he caught out these tatt khalsa tattoos, with ignorant brains. So he was after all only interested in MONEY, and what happened to the chap that said he sings good kirtan and comes to gurduara????see how one lie leads to another these organisers are such tattoos The fact as said by Veer Dr Gurcharan Singh ji,remains that these organisers have waited long enough thinking a way out to explain,and then explained what they think people will buy, hoping that will settle off things. Funny how like Dr sahib GS KULIM said these pople have been caught red handed with their kahcerra or is it pants down and now will use a straw to hide their little wrinklly bits that have been burnt badly. I think the point remains it will be a long long time before anyone will ever thinks again of organising with such stupidity.I wonder how stupid must be those that put these morons into place and then also stupid ones like SIKH who buy their story to tell us all!!!

Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM

Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 31 May 2005

I have to go with Veer Gurcharan Singh Ji Kulim on this one....Veer Ji Gyani jarnail Singh Jio..this issue is NOT DEAD....its Ramifications will last for YEARS. IF the vasakhi Fiasco had not taken palce earlier...and heated up by the write ups on this issue of a patit convert taking centre stage and another political tattoo Mona Sikh trying to Project His own Sikh leaderee on to the Sikhs..i dont think the tatt khalsa people would even have thought twice about removing djdev. As it is he ended up having the LAST LAUGH...he got the 10,000 fee ( for 15 minutes of dancing on stage), got his act on stage too..IF they had already PAID HIM 10,000 WHY on earth ALLOW him 15 minutes on STAGE ?? As far as I know the Tatt Khalsa OWNS Malaya Samachar lock stock and barrel...and it will carry thier side of the story...and the FACT that from the INTERNET BOARDS this ISSUE has flared up in the PUNJABI PRESS..is something we are PROUD OF as our views are NOTICED. I call upon Veers GS Kulim, Jarnail singh Gyani Arshi, BS Dhaliwaal and other WELL WISHERS of the GURU KHALSA PANTH to not let this issue DIE..but reach a stage whereby NO ONE will wever dare to call a convert/patit/adulteror/mona wanna be leader to LEAD the SIKHS at such Mega Events in future. I have read elsewhere that in the USA there are attempts being made by MONAS and PATITS to AMEND GURDWARA CONSTITTIONS to allow Monas in Gurdwara Comittees and excos....next they will DEMAND MONA GRANTHIS, MONA RAAGIS and MONA PANJ PIYARAS as well. We must all co-operate and DRAW the LINE HERE and NOW....one is either a SIKH or a MONA..no one can be BOTH.

Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM

Sher Singh · 31 May 2005

Well done Singho...this 'Sikh' is another tatoo that is carrying information around from his masters.fact is a Sikh writer like Kulim ji and Arshi ji stood out against all these tatoos from and made the scene, the heat go too hot for them to handle ...they decied to drop that musslah but they are such stupid bumkins- these tatt khalsa fellows that he stung them for 10000. SIKH be the son of a father and tell your name instead being another tatoo like the the tatt khalsa fellow nerds.

Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM

Manjit kaur Sidhu · 02 Jun 2005

i am amused. All along some people have been saying...."dont bother..this is just some "internet kharrkoo" writing on a message Board in far away Canada..who in malaysia reads it anyway ( THAT is if the Message tells the TRUTH about them, their so called maryada, gurbani classes, school, brahmgiani, or vidya etc..)...then these same people go ahead and BASH the poster ( which they have already claimed NO ONE READS).. The Tatt Khalsa Diwan has been REBUILT from the Ground up..and will be the MONEY EARNER in years to come...and these "Maryada vidyaks" are eagerly awaiting in the wings to take over..ONCE the DEBTS are settled and the Gurdwar is FREE of any encumbrances..but ready to earn for them..Same story as in Australia and elsewhere. Fisrt they will try and bring in Panj piayaras/Maryada..etc to take over the Gurdwara and once they have full control...the maryada etc will take back stage while they run the gurdwara by keeping all opponents out. I am releived that even messages on Tapoban..in far away canada have an EFFECT on MALAYSIAN Parbhandaks .... proves my point.

Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM

Guru Ka Sikh · 02 Jun 2005

Manjit Kaur Sidhu, What nonsense you talking about...wat is that to do with maryada, gurbani classes, school, brahmgiani, or vidya...You said they will try to bring Panj Piayaras/Maryada....hey... you must know that Panj Piayaras do sewa based on Guruji's hukam and it is Guru's Panj Piayaras & Maryada, so please respect!!! Panj Piayaras sewa is the greatest sewa....you must know that Mind your language........ Phul Chuk Maf.. Guru Ka Sikh

Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM

Hurchatran Singh Kulim · 02 Jun 2005

Dear bibi Bhen manjit kaur jio, Please read MALAYA SAMACHAR under the heading ...Kalam Kulim di...London Ton .....these activities are being exposed....already two parts to a four part article have been published..... I have not minced my words in that articles.The second two parts are another hot stove for such mona and aspiring Sikh leaders, and djdave supporters,....and the poor suckers who landed up paying RM10,000 to him .....We are also calling strongly for an all malaysia national sikh conference ...we MUST have that .... To turn the events against the opportuinities and non Sikh looking individuals asspiring to distort the Sikh identity. One aspiring to be a leader of the Sikhs must look like a basic SIKH>