Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Water can retain Gurbani: Attn: J. Singh

Water can retain Gurbani: Attn: J. Singh

Kulbir Singh · 04 May 2005

Many skeptics have questioned how water of Siri Raamdaas Sarovar can have curing powers. Many have dismissed the whole power of taking ishnaan at Siri Darbar Sahib and other sarovars that have charan-chhoh of Siri Guru jee as superstition and pakhand. They ignore the fact that for centuries devout Sikhs have benefitted from the power of Gurbani and of Charan-chhoh of Siri Guru jee, on Sarovars. These people who don't have faith on the charan-chhoh of Satguru jee are extremely dry people who have been blinded by their extremely materialistic logic. They will believe a mortal scientist and a sinful pakhandi like Deepak Chopra but will ignore Guru Sahib's amrit baani. They will start jhooming (making rhythmic movements in ecstasy) when they hear a kaafi of Bulle Shah but will get bored listening to Gurbani. What can you say of such people? They are unfortunate. They took birth in the house of Sikhs but have totally wasted their janam by not realising that their salvation lies in following the hukams of Siri Guru Dashmesh jee. Here is a study done by Masaro Emoto. Not that I need any verification or authentication from scientists but it is interesting to read this. My special appeal to J. Singh to read this and see if you are willing to review and re-ponder your old views that there is no use of doing ishnaan at the Amrit Sarovar of Siri Darbar Sahib Amritsar Sahib. While I am typing this, the pavitter-paavan-muqaddas-nikhaalas thought of Siri Raamdaas Sarovar is bringing tears to my eyes. I remember it fresh when I went to the great sarovar of Siri Dukh Nivaaran Sahib, Patiala for the last time, before coming back to Canada. It was a bairaagmai vichhorra (tearful separation) from the Gur-asthaans and I did not know (still don't know) when I will get darshan ishnaan of Gur-asthaans again. Anyway, here is the link. http://www.life-enthusiast.com/twilight/research_emoto.htm Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Water can retain Gurbani: Attn: J. Singh

Premi · 04 May 2005

It was 1978 or so, a man had got a stroke and was paralyzed on the right side, a while later he got another stroke and his left side and he was totally paralyzed. he did a benti and some sangat took him to Harmander Sahib, the sevadars basically put him in the sarovaar under the dukh bhanjanee beri and he walked out on his own. He was cured buy the holy sarovar of his dukh. Why would the Guru jee's have set up sarovar's if they were of no use? There were set up to show us the path to god, i.e physicall then mental cleanliness. It is the same idea when we put water near our place of bhagtee.paat etc, the banee takes effect on everything. "Dharat suhavree akash suhundaa japandreoo har naam" Yes the our clothes the carpet, rumalaas, everything becomes pavitar. If banee can't purify a carpet how will it purify your dirty, filthy mind? "Bhalee suhavee chapree , jaa main gun gaiee" Premi

Re: Water can retain Gurbani: Attn: J. Singh

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 04 May 2005

Waheguru Ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh. If the message is for me...what can I say but Satbachan veer ji..Guru Ji Kirpa Karan. imho, an ardass to Guru Ji has always worked in the past and this time too i know i will not be disappointed...No one is perfect..at least i know that much.

Re: Water can retain Gurbani: Attn: J. Singh

Kulbir Singh · 04 May 2005

Saaday Praan-pyaaray, Guru-Savaaray, Daas-Muraaray, Sada-hushnaaray, lekhak-karaaray, Bahut-Niraaray, Guru-dulaaray, Gurmukh Veer Arshee Giyani jeeo, This message was not targetted at you. It is, as the title says, partially targetted at another pyaaray veer - J. Singh and partially at other veers and bhains who jump too quickly to dismiss centuries old Gursikhi traditions. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Water can retain Gurbani: Attn: J. Singh

Tera baap ka baap · 04 May 2005

I can imagine the blood flowing to giani jee's face. His already radiant sabat gurmukh face shining with naam kamiee must have an incredible contrast with the pink hue that his cheeks must now surely have at being adressed with such admiration and sincerity from a gurmukh veer like Bhai Sahib Bhai Kulbir Singh jee, Toronto wale. What a sight our pyare Giani Jee must be. In the heart of the Malaysian farming community, a gem of a Sikh not only perseveres against all forces of kalyug but also excels in spreading gurmat around the world. Long flowing white dara, a navy blue dumalla, the silvery beads of a simarna constantly playing on his fingertips .... rare is such a sight in Kaljug.

Re: Water can retain Gurbani: Attn: J. Singh

J Singh · 04 May 2005

I see "Attn: J Singh" posted by Kulbir Singh Veer ji and thought he must be missing me terribly!! Veer ji, looks like you are itching to joust with somebody but, sorry, I am not that someone :-(. Too busy you know, lol. Veer ji, now seriously, being sansational doesn't traslates into being right. Don't make up stuff to suit your needs. Self rightiousness is a disease by itself you know :-(. Where did I ever say that taking a dip in Ramdaas sarover is superstition and pakhand. I love Gurbani. Who wouldn't want to be at the same places where Guru Sahibaan had spent years. Don't attack people you don't understand and please don't blow things out of context. And, millions of simple innocent devotes are being tricked by these Express "48 Hour Fixes to All Your Problems" Fraud Babas with similar promises. Please, for the sake of Guru Sahib, don't help their cause by indirectly agreeing with them. You are a great Gursikh. We must follow Gurbani and the hukam of our Guru to get His kirpa drishi. Let me restate what I had said again, IT'S BAANI NOT PAANI that has all the powers (I am not yelling :-)). You can use bottled water to cure people of diseases and sins but Gurbani is good enough for me. Isn't our Shabad Guru, Shri Guru Granth Sahib ji, good enough for you veer ji? I don't know who is unfortunate here. It seems to me that you are the only one who is obsessed with Deepak Chopra stuff. I don't care if you don't believe in the existance of atom or any other science. Keep you eyes closed like a pigeon and keep on reciting that "the cat isn't here, it just doesn't exist" :-) :-). And, who is giving references from science now (as oppose to refering to Sachi Gurbani!!!). Tell me, do you really believe what this Dr Emoto has written? I request you to stick with Gurbani Veer ji. There are a lot better sources out there than this. Please stick with Gurbani. We need you here! Here is a bit of the interview from your link: REIKO: Do you believe that water itself is conscious and is reacting to the words? DR. EMOTO: I understand that many of your readers are people interested in spiritual matters, and I would like to answer this question from that perspective. I believe that prior to Adam and Eve water itself held the consciousness of God -- that God's intention was put into the medium of water, and that this was used in the creation of Earth and Nature. In other words, all of the information needed for God's Creation was reflected in the water. And then we -- Adam and Eve -- were placed on Earth to be the caretakers for this Creation of God. I believe that water held the consciousness of God until then, but that after the caretakers were placed on Earth, water became an empty vessel to mirror and reflect what was in the heart. It became a container to carry energy and information. Therefore, since this time, I think water has taken on the quality of simply reflecting the energies and thoughts that it is exposed to; that it no longer has its own consciousness. Water reflects the consciousness of the human race. REIKO: Would you tell us your philosophical thoughts about what you believe these water crystals really are? DR. EMOTO: After the book was published, I was wondering about this, and I came to the realization that these crystals are spirits. There are many parallels. When ice melts, the crystalline structure becomes an illusion. It's there -- and yet it's not there, because you can no longer see it. Similarly, when a person dies their body loses several grams of weight -- what some people think of this as the weight of the soul. But then we can often visually see them. I think that the soul has mass, and that it returns to water molecules. And because it has mass, it is affected by the gravitational pull of the earth. And so sometimes the soul cannot transition over to the other side. In Buddhism, we talk about attaining sattori, or reaching enlightenment. People who attain sattori do not become ghosts. They are able to achieve a certain stage of development at the soul level and return to God for a while before they move on to their next assignment. We traveled here to Earth on the water crystals of spheres of ice [Editor's Note: You will hear more about this amazing phenomenon in an upcoming issue of the Spirit of Ma'at on the subject of water.] Earth is not our native home. There was nothing here. So these souls can return to their native homes for awhile. That is sattori, or enlightenment. However, most people on the planet are not able to attain enlightenment. To reach enlightenment means to be able to completely let go of the ego and our worldly attachments. >>>>> It was a bairaagmai vichhorra (tearful separation) from the Gur-asthaans and I did not know (still don't know) when I will get darshan ishnaan of Gur-asthaans again. >>>>> Veer ji, don't spill tears of vichhorra because your Guru ji is always with you!! vjkk vjkf

Re: Water can retain Gurbani: Attn: J. Singh

singh · 04 May 2005

I don't doubt for a second that water from the Harmandir Sahib sarover can cure. But this website that you linked to has science that may or may not be true. There is a lot of pseudo-science out there so we need to be careful. Pseudo-science is when people/groups use a seemingly scientific approach and do research on a subject with results that end up supporting their views. In pseudo-science, there is often a problem with the methodology- it is not truly scientific. These guys are good at tricking people who don't have a solid grounding in scientific methodology. Take for example the Transcendental Meditation people - they would actually fund their own studies at their own labs (i think) - very fishy. I know for a fact that Gurbani will have a positive effect on the taste of water. However, this scientist on this website - I don't know how truthful his research is. Not that I'm saying he's lying, just that we need to take it with a big grain of salt. Who funded it? Which group? What are their beliefs? Is the study published in a reputable peer-reviewed journal? What scientific methodology 9if any) did they use?

Re: Water can retain Gurbani: Attn: J. Singh

Kulbir Singh · 04 May 2005

J Singh, ------------ I see "Attn: J Singh" posted by Kulbir Singh Veer ji and thought he must be missing me terribly!! Veer ji, looks like you are itching to joust with somebody but, sorry, I am not that someone :-(. Too busy you know, lol. ------------- Well, is there anything wrong in missing you? If there is, please let me know. And I am not itching to joust with somebody but I do remember the views you expressed in our last discussion on the condition of bhagats thread. I came across this article accidentally and thought I share it with you. ------------ Veer ji, now seriously, being sansational doesn't traslates into being right. Don't make up stuff to suit your needs. ----------- You are not accusing me of setting up that website to just “suit my needs”, or are you? How did I make up stuff? That person has clearly shown something very important, something that homeopathy is based on, i.e. that water can retain vibrations. Everything that exists has vibrations and these vibrations are of different nature. The vibrations that Gurbani has are purifying and vibrations that other Manmukhi stuff has is detrimental for us. -------- Self rightiousness is a disease by itself you know :-(. Where did I ever say that taking a dip in Ramdaas sarover is superstition and pakhand. ---------- You clearly attacked the practice of revering the Holy sarovars and I had even told you in our last discussion that you had hurt the feelings of millions of Sikhs by saying so. You may not have used the words “Pakhand” but you were certainly alluding to something along these lines. ----------- Let me restate what I had said again, IT'S BAANI NOT PAANI that has all the powers (I am not yelling :-)). You can use bottled water to cure people of diseases and sins but Gurbani is good enough for me. Isn't our Shabad Guru, Shri Guru Granth Sahib ji, good enough for you veer ji? I don't know who is unfortunate here. ------------ Gurbani is one way of curing diseases, Naam Abhyaas is another way. If one keeps rehit, follows basic Sikhi principles and then with full devotion takes a dip in Raamdaas Sarovar, he or she too will be cured of his diseases. You are right that it is baani and not paani but this paani does retain Baani, hence attaining curing powers. ------------ It seems to me that you are the only one who is obsessed with Deepak Chopra stuff. I don't care if you don't believe in the existance of atom or any other science. ------------ I did not say anywhere that Atom does not exist or it does exist. I did however comment that no one has to this date an atom with eyes, or through microscope. Whatever theory they have on atoms is based on experiments. ----------- Keep you eyes closed like a pigeon and keep on reciting that "the cat isn't here, it just doesn't exist" :-) :-). ----------- How is being oblivious of existence of atoms equate to being a pigeon oblivious of cat? If the pigeon stays ignores the cat, it can lose its life but if I ignore the existence of atoms, what will I lose? So it seems like your misaal or tashbeeh does not add up here. Hehe! ---------------- And, who is giving references from science now (as oppose to refering to Sachi Gurbani!!!). Tell me, do you really believe what this Dr Emoto has written? ---------------- No I don’t believe in everything he is saying. I have some belief in the results that have come out of his experiments but I don’t necessarily subscribe and nor there is any need to subscribe to what he deduces for these results. We can deduce our own theories from these results. What I decipher from this experiments of Dr Emoto is that water can retain memory. If Water can retain expressions and emotions, it can surely retain Gurbani too. This retaining property of water is the basis of the maryada of Khanday Baatay da Amrit. J Singh jeeo, how does the “Thaan” (place) become suhaava with the presence of Guru Sahib? If a thaan can become suhaava, can’t water become suhaava? What to talk about Guru Sahib visiting a place; even if Guru Sahib glances at something, that place becomes sacred and revered. Kulbir Singh

Re: Water can retain Gurbani: Attn: J. Singh

J Singh · 05 May 2005

Veer ji, I was just kidding around with you about itching to joust or closing your eyes to science. I meant no disrespect, really. >>>>> ------------ Veer ji, now seriously, being sensational doesn't traslates into being right. Don't make up stuff to suit your needs. ----------- You are not accusing me of setting up that website to just “suit my needs”, or are you? How did I make up stuff? That person has clearly shown something very important, something that homeopathy is based on, i.e. that water can retain vibrations. >>>>> No, I wasn't talking about the website or that article here. Tapoban is a great site. This was my answer to your first two paragraphs (starting with Many skeptics...) where you laid your accusations (I visualized you raising your arm and talking like a politician to get your troops all prepped up, LOL!!): "Veer ji, now seriously, being sensational doesn't traslates into being right. Don't make up stuff to suit your needs. Self rightiousness is a disease by itself you know :-(. Where did I ever say that taking a dip in Ramdaas sarover is superstition and pakhand. I love Gurbani. Who wouldn't want to be at the same places where Guru Sahibaan had spent years. Don't attack people you don't understand and please don't blow things out of context." >>>>> You clearly attacked the practice of revering the Holy sarovars and I had even told you in our last discussion that you had hurt the feelings of millions of Sikhs by saying so. You may not have used the words “Pakhand” but you were certainly alluding to something along these lines. >>>>> You are welcome to review my old comments if you wish. At that time you were being way too sensational by saying that "I had hurt the feelings of millions of Sikhs." So, I could help but laugh at your remarks. Veer ji, disagreeing with your interpretation doesn't mean attaching sikhi practices. Attacking sikhi would be no different than attacking myself!! >>>>> This retaining property of water is the basis of the maryada of Khanday Baatay da Amrit. >>>>> I can respect your belief and understanding that "retaining property of water is the BASIS of the maryada of Khanday Baatay da Amrit" as long as you don't go on to promote bottling this Holy Water to cure some "Shinda, Bhinda, Jaggi or Joe". vjkk vjkf