Canadian prosecutors not to appeal verdict in Air-India case
Bhopindersingh · 04 May 2005
Canadian prosecutors not to appeal verdict in Air-India case Vancouver, May 4, 2005 The Canadian authorities have decided not to file an appeal against the verdict in the Air-India bombing in which two suspects -- Ripduman Singh Malik and Ajaib Singh Bagri-- were acquitted by the British Columbian Supreme Court Judge, Justice Ian Josephson, on March 16. In an e-mail sent to the families of the victims of the June 23, 1985, bombing of the Air-India flight 182 off the Irish coast, says, "Members of the prosecution team, seniors members of the Criminal Justice (Branch), have conducted an exhaustive review and have come to the difficult decision that there are no grounds on which the Crown could launch an appeal." A formal announcement in this regard will be made later. The relatives of the victims had a closed-door meeting on Saturday with Deputy Prime Minister and Public Safety Minister Anne McLellan, Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) chief Giuliano Zaccardelli, Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) director Jim Judd and former Ontario premier Bob Rae who will look into the possibility of a public inquiry into the case. In this meeting, the families were informed about the work of the intelligence agency prior to the bombing. Jim Judd informed the families that the intelligence agency (CSIS), which criticised the judge in his verdict for erasing tapes of conversations between Bagri and the plot mastermind Talwinder Singh Parmar, had warned the RCMP as many as 13 times about the threat to Air-India from the militants. As per what he told the families, intelligence agents followed Parmar for 39 of the 72 days before the bombing, and for 17 consecutive days from June 1, 1985 onward. However, the surveillance was withdrawn on June 17 to focus on a Soviet spy. However, Parmar was kept under watch from a particular place till June 22, Judd told the families. About the destroyed tapes of conversation between Bagri and Parmar, Judd told the families that in any case the tapes would not have been admissible as evidence in a criminal trial. However, he said, the tapes were thoroughly listened to and their threat content noted before they were destroyed. But had there been any information about the plot, CSIS agents would have told the RCMP, he said. Judd informed them that the destroyed tapes would have no bearing on the outcome of the trial, though the judge in his verdict has slammed the agency for its "negligence'' in the matter. The families were also told that the Government of India agents had no hand in the Air-India bombing as alleged by some radical groups. "Based on all of the information and intelligence available to the Service, we concluded that the Government of India played no role in the events of June 23, 1985," the Vancouver Sun quoted Judd as saying.