Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Please answer - Amrit!

Please answer - Amrit!

learning · 01 May 2005

Dear Sangat, particularly Kulbir Singh ji and Jarnail Singh ji, I have a question which has never concerned me before but has been gnawing at me of late. When water is kept in a glass and bani is read, be it in a gurdwara or at home, does that water obtain any special qualities? I've always, unquestioningly believed that to be the case and have accepted such water as 'amrit' (not amrit in the sense of amrit-sanchar but amrit in the sense of something greater than simply H2O). Respected Singhs I know also recommend that water kept near Guru Maharaj ji, as bani is being read, path is being done is 'special'........but now, for some reason, I am having some doubts. Could you please advise me. Thank you very much.

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 02 May 2005

I will let veer Kulbir Singh ji have a go at this first. ( if you dont mind veer ji)

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Gurcharan Singh Kulim, MBA Phd · 02 May 2005

Veer ji, this is a ritual probably copied seeing the Hindu practices.someone may have got a bright idea and every body has followed blindly.Individual sharda , people will argue, but this sharda had destroyed much Sikhi of the Guru . This practice is man-mat.think, if water kept near where Gurbani is being read becomes "amrit"-than what about all the clothes, bartan, carpets etc al that near and dear, includingthe pathi singh ji, do they become Sant mahapurash and all near the gurbani become "blessed " too ??? Sikhs should discourage such practice.Shabad Guru is the only practice and take marit is the next step.

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

...... · 02 May 2005

It becomes pavitar paani/jaal but not amrith, same thing with sarovar at harmindar sahib, its not amrith but pavitar pani. theres only one type of amrith for sikhs and thats khandey batte da amrith.

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Gurcharan Singh Kulim, MBA Phd · 02 May 2005

okay, if that becomes paviter jal ,will the carpets and all become paviter carpets etc.....every thing in life is paviter ...there is ONR SRM , just read it and follow it ...and it is not very confusing either....sorry ..I am kinda in rush ..

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

NaamRas Singh · 02 May 2005

Gurcharan Singh Kulim - why do you put "MBA Phd" on your name ... isn't Gurcharan Singh enough? Perhaps if you are writing on professional issues, then the educational qualifications might be relevant. But on a Gurmat message board, your worldly qualifications are absolutely pointless and needlessly advertised. Please forgive my mistakes, NaamRas Singh

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Singh Jee · 02 May 2005

That's a bit rich coming from someone who calls themselves "NaamRas Singh".

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Gurcharan Singh Kulim, · 02 May 2005

bhai sahib,I can only apologise to you, This was already printed on my name column, for something I wrote professionally sometime ago.I did cancel it once but it seems to have come back, I did not realise, as sometimes I just go through fast.My humble apologies.I am actually a Doctor(not medical), BUT I have never used it either. kamaal hai afrin Na ko bairi nahi begana sagal sangh hum kau bin ayee na ko mera dusman reha na hum kis ke beraii Nanak karta sabh kish jaanda jiduu kish na hoye

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

NaamRas Singh · 02 May 2005

...My name is NaamRas Singh...What's wrong with that? Please explain "Singh Jee" - at least I've given my e-mail address.

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

...... · 02 May 2005

whats wrong with the jaal becoming pavitar after being left there whilst reciting baani. why do poeple do ishnaan in sarovar if there was no good to it, reason being theres so much baani being read around that it becomes pavitar. You ask such silly questions for a person who has a phd. i.e. does the carpet becomes pavitar aswell lol. I think your intellectual enough to answer your own question. I dont know whats the reason of leaving jal there or how it started but all im saying is that i wouldnt consider it to be amrith but would call it pavitar jaal not amrith. Im sorry if my answer makes your skin crawl, but this is a message board to do vichaar and learn. Bhulchukmaf

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Gurcharan Singh Kulim, · 02 May 2005

Bahi sahib, your reason is not at all skin crawling...quite the contrary it is mind opening to see how another thinks ...often ..but it would be nice if you read the threads again..it may dawn to you ..it was not me asking the question for a phd,...I never said there was anything wrong, after all there is nothing wrong with bot pooja either,...what is wrong is when the SRM says one thing and we do something else...contrary...if taking ishnan in what you call paviter jal, and you beleive in such rituals, then be my guest ...that is your beleive ...obviously you do not adhere to SRM ,that is all...sorry if your skin trembles with all the pollution from so called paviter jals etc...paviter itself is a very big word...often misunderstood...but then who am I ?after all I cannot think ..cleverly ..like many others...forgive me ... Jio jal mahe aye khatana tio joti sangh jot samana appe har ek rang hai appe bauh ranggi jo tis bhave nanak sayiin gal changgi

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

vaheguru · 02 May 2005

jaal is different then nytin else if u luk way bak thru many religious scriptures water is the first substance to have formed according to the genisis and according to guru sahib ryte after the universe was made

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Question Bhai · 03 May 2005

It is not the Jaal that is important but more over the Shabad Guru and Gian that is being read from Guru Granth Sahib Ji. KHUMBE BHADA JAAL RAHEY, JAAL BIN KHUMB NA HOVEY, GIAN KA BHADA MAAN RAHEY, GUR BIN GIAN NA HOVEY.

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 03 May 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Gurbani says very very clearly that..Nanak AMRIT EK HAI DOOJA AMRIT NAHIN..menaing there is ONLY ONE AMRIT..NO OTHER. Below I have chosen 31 pankatiyaan from Guru Granth Sahib Jee..out of a possible thousand more.... And EACH ONE says that AMRIT is NAAM/GURBANI/BACHANS of GURU JI. The First pankatee itself from japji Sahib relates the PERIOD "Amrit Vela" to NAAM Jaapna...This "period" is "Amrit Vela" ONLY IF it is used to Chant NAAM. NOT a Single Pankitee states anywhere that "Jaal placed NEAR to Naam Chanting/Gurbani paath" TURNS INTO AMRIT and this so called "AMRIT" is then EQUIVALENT to NAAM/GURBANI/GURUS BACHANS... I frimly beleive that the SAROVARS are for Bathing/washing the BODY....NOT AMRIT. IF "AMRIT" was available OUTSIDE the Harmandir Sahib ( in the Sarovar) there is no need to go INSIDE for GURBANI/Kirtan/Naam anymore. IF "water in the Sarovars" becomes "Amrit" due to being near GURBANI/Naam japping activities....then the WATER FLOWING through the MUNICIPALITY/COUNCIL PIPES "in the GURDWARAS is also "AMRIT"...this same "water" flows to other places in the Gurdwara....car parks for watering/gardens/toilets/... Further more this same water gets mixed with the entire CITY's WATER SUPPLIES....so an abundance of "amrit" is flowing throughout !!!! There is NO NEED to go to the GURDWARA at all...AMRIT is flowing from your House Tap/Garden tap/Bath shower/etc etc etc.....even the City's BARS and Hotels have Amrit????? IS this Assumption correct ?? IF NOT why NOT ?? WHY can water placed in a container near gurbani turn into "amrit"...BUT water flowing in a pipe under/around/beside/above Guru Granth Sahib ji cannot turn into Amrit ??. I rest my case. Lets hear from the "Mahapurakhs" some of whom have written above...PLEASE QUOTE GURBANI ONLY. 1. Page2 Line 5 Raag Jap: Guru Nanak Dev AMimRq vylw scu nwau vifAweI vIcwru ] anmrith vaelaa sach naao vaddiaaee veechaar || In the Amrit Vaylaa, the ambrosial hours before dawn, chant the True Name, and contemplate His Glorious Greatness. 2. Page31 Line 14 Raag Sriraag: Guru Amar Das gur ky Bwxy ivic AMimRqu hY shjy pwvY koie ] gur kae bhaanae vich anmrith hai sehajae paavai koe || The Amrit, the Ambrosial Nectar, is in the Guru's Will. With intuitive ease, it is obtained. 3. Page36 Line 14 Raag Sriraag: Guru Amar Das ijhvw rqI sbid scY AMimRqu pIvY ris gux gwie ] jihavaa rathee sabadh sachai anmrith peevai ras gun gaae || The tongue imbued with the True Word of the Shabad drinks in the Amrit with delight, singing His Glorious Praises. 4. Page41 Line 16 Raag Sriraag: Guru Ram Das Awip dieAw kir dyvsI gurmuiK AMimRqu coie ] aap dhaeiaa kar dhaevasee guramukh anmrith choe || In His Kindness, He blesses the Gurmukh with it; the Ambrosial Nectar of this Amrit trickles down. 5. Page96 Line 3 Raag Maajh: Guru Ram Das AMimRq rsu scu AMimRqu bolI guir pUrY AMimRqu lIcY jIau ]3] anmrith ras sach anmrith bolee gur poorai anmrith leechai jeeo ||3|| The True Essence is Ambrosial Nectar; through the Ambrosial Words of the Perfect Guru, this Amrit is obtained. ||3|| 6. Page118 Line 13 Raag Maajh: Guru Amar Das AMimRq bwxI sdw slwhy AMimRiq AMimRqu pwvixAw ]1] anmrith baanee sadhaa salaahae anmrith anmrith paavaniaa ||1|| By continually praising the Ambrosial Bani of the Word, I obtain the Amrit, the Ambrosial Nectar. ||1|| 7. Page118 Line 15 Raag Maajh: Guru Amar Das AMimRqu bolY sdw muiK vYxI ] AMimRqu vyKY prKY sdw nYxI ] anmrith bolai sadhaa mukh vainee || anmrith vaekhai parakhai sadhaa nainee || Those who continually chant the Ambrosial Words of Nectar see and behold this Amrit everywhere with their eyes. 8. Page118 Line 16 Raag Maajh: Guru Amar Das AMimRqu gur prswdI pwey ] anmrith gur parasaadhee paaeae || They chant the Ambrosial Name with their tongues day and night; their minds and bodies are satisfied by this Amrit. ||3|| 9. Page118 Line 17 Raag Maajh: Guru Amar Das AMimRqu rsnw bolY idnu rwqI min qin AMimRqu pIAwvixAw ]3] anmrith rasanaa bolai dhin raathee man than anmrith peeaavaniaa ||3|| They chant the Ambrosial Name with their tongues day and night; their minds and bodies are satisfied by this Amrit. ||3|| 10. Page118 Line 18 Raag Maajh: Guru Amar Das hukmy vrqY AMimRq bwxI hukmy AMimRqu pIAwvixAw ]4] hukamae varathai anmrith baanee hukamae anmrith peeaavaniaa ||4|| By His Command, the Ambrosial Bani of the Word prevails, and by His Command, we drink in the Amrit. ||4|| 11. Page119 Line 2 Raag Maajh: Guru Amar Das gur prswdI sbid slwhI ] gur parasaadhee sabadh salaahee || In Your Sweet Will, the Amrit is found; by Your Will, You inspire us to drink in this Amrit. ||7|| 12. Page119 Line 3 Raag Maajh: Guru Amar Das qyry Bwxy ivic AMimRqu vsY qUM BwxY AMimRqu pIAwvixAw ]7] thaerae bhaanae vich anmrith vasai thoon bhaanai anmrith peeaavaniaa ||7|| In Your Sweet Will, the Amrit is found; by Your Will, You inspire us to drink in this Amrit. ||7|| 13. Page119 Line 5 Raag : nwnk AMimRq nwmu sdw suKdwqw pI AMimRqu sB BuK lih jwvixAw ]8]15]16] naanak anmrith naam sadhaa sukhadhaathaa pee anmrith sabh bhukh lehi jaavaniaa ||8||15||16|| O Nanak, the Ambrosial Naam is forever the Giver of peace; drinking in this Amrit, all hunger is satisfied. ||8||15||16|| 14. Page119 Line 14 Raag Maajh: Guru Amar Das AMimRqu pIvY ijs no Awip pIAwey ] anmrith peevai jis no aap peeaaeae || They alone drink in this Amrit, whom the Lord Himself inspires to do so. 15. Page148 Line 14 Raag Maajh: Guru Angad Dev sbid svwrIAwsu AMimRqu pIivAw ]22] sabadh savaareeaas anmrith peeviaa ||22|| But she who is adorned with the Word of His Shabad, drinks in the Amrit of His Nectar. ||22|| 16. Page352 Line 16 Raag Aasaa: Guru Nanak Dev siqguru syiv AMimRq rsu cwKy ]3] sathigur saev anmrith ras chaakhae ||3|| Serving the True Guru, they drink in the Amrit, the Ambrosial Nectar. ||3|| 17. Page494 Line 9 Raag Goojree: Guru Ram Das AMimRq bcn siqgur kI bwxI jo bolY so muiK AMimRqu pwvY ]2] anmrith bachan sathigur kee baanee jo bolai so mukh anmrith paavai ||2|| The Words of the True Guru's Teachings are Ambrosial Nectar; this Amrit trickles into the mouth of the one who chants them. ||2|| 18. Page511 Line 19 Raag Goojree Kee Vaar: Guru Amar Das AMimRqu Kwxw AMimRqu pYnxw nwnk nwmu vfweI hoie ]1] anmrith khaanaa anmrith painanaa naanak naam vaddaaee hoe ||1|| The Ambrosial Amrit is his food, and the Ambrosial Amrit is his clothes; O Nanak, through the Naam, the Name of the Lord, greatness is obtained. ||1|| 19. Page522 Line 2 Raag Goojree: Guru Arjan Dev pIviq AMimRq nwmu jn nwmy rhy AGwie ]14] peevath anmrith naam jan naamae rehae aghaae ||14|| Drinking in the Ambrosial Amrit of the Naam, the Name of the Lord, His humble servants remain satisfied with the Naam. ||14|| 20. Page634 Line 15 Raag Sorith: Guru Nanak Dev iBiKAw nwim rjy sMqoKI AMimRqu shij pIAweI ]3] bhikhiaa naam rajae santhokhee anmrith sehaj peeaaee ||3|| He remains content, satisfied with the charity of the Naam; he drinks in the Ambrosial Amrit with ease. ||3|| 21. Page698 Line 14 Raag Jaitsaree: Guru Ram Das myrY min qin AMimRq mIT lgwnw ] maerai man than anmrith meeth lagaanaa || His Ambrosial Amrit is so sweet to my mind and body. 22. Page734 Line 4 Raag Soohee: Guru Ram Das hir Dnu rqnu jvyhru mwxku hir DnY nwil AMimRq vylY vqY hir BgqI hir ilv lweI ] har dhhan rathan javaehar maanak har dhhanai naal anmrith vaelai vathai har bhagathee har liv laaee || The Lord's wealth is like jewels, gems and rubies. At the appointed time in the Amrit Vaylaa, the ambrosial hours of the morning, the Lord's devotees lovingly center their attention on the Lord, and the wealth of the Lord. 23. Page734 Line 5 Raag Soohee: Guru Ram Das hir Dnu AMimRq vylY vqY kw bIijAw Bgq Kwie Kric rhy inKutY nwhI ] har dhhan anmrith vaelai vathai kaa beejiaa bhagath khaae kharach rehae nikhuttai naahee || The devotees of the Lord plant the seed of the Lord's wealth in the ambrosial hours of the Amrit Vaylaa; they eat it, and spend it, but it is never exhausted. 24. Page918 Line 15 Raag Raamkalee: Guru Amar Das suir nr muin jn AMimRqu Kojdy su AMimRqu gur qy pwieAw ] sur nar mun jan anmrith khojadhae s anmrith gur thae paaeiaa || The angelic beings and the silent sages search for the Ambrosial Nectar; this Amrit is obtained from the Guru. 25. Page918 Line 15 Raag Raamkalee: Guru Amar Das pwieAw AMimRqu guir ik®pw kInI scw min vswieAw ] paaeiaa anmrith gur kirapaa keenee sachaa man vasaaeiaa || This Amrit is obtained, when the Guru grants His Grace; He enshrines the True Lord within the mind. 26. Page918 Line 17 Raag Raamkalee: Guru Amar Das khY nwnku ijs no Awip quTw iqin AMimRqu gur qy pwieAw ]13] kehai naanak jis no aap thuthaa thin anmrith gur thae paaeiaa ||13|| Says Nanak, those with whom the Lord is pleased, obtain the Amrit, through the Guru. ||13|| 27. Page1113 Line 9 Raag Tukhaaree: Guru Nanak Dev piq nwmu pwvih Gir isDwvih Joil AMimRq pI rso ] path naam paavehi ghar sidhhaavehi jhol anmrith pee raso || Through the Naam, you shall obtain honor, and come home. Eagerly drink in the Ambrosial Amrit. 28. Page1126 Line 8 Raag Bhaira-o: Guru Nanak Dev AMimRq kw rsu ivrlI pwieAw siqgur myil imlwey ] anmrith kaa ras viralee paaeiaa sathigur mael milaaeae || Only a few obtain the sublime essence of the Ambrosial Amrit, united in Union with the True Guru. 29. Page1189 Line 10 Raag Basant: Guru Nanak Dev AMimRqu cwiK hir nwim invwsw ] anmrith chaakh har naam nivaasaa || tasting the Amrit, the Ambrosial Nectar, they abide in the Lord's Name. 30. Page1213 Line 2 Raag Sarang: Guru Arjan Dev sMig mnohru AMimRqu hY ry BUil BUil ibKu KweI ]1] rhwau ] sang manohar anmrith hai rae bhool bhool bikh khaaee ||1|| rehaao || The Enticing Ambrosial Amrit is with you, but you are deluded, totally deluded, and you eat poison. ||1||Pause|| 31. Page1326 Line 4 Raag Kalian: Guru Ram Das inrKq inrKq rYin sB inrKI muKu kwFY AMimRqu pIjY ]5] nirakhath nirakhath rain sabh nirakhee mukh kaadtai anmrith peejai ||5|| She watches, and keeps on watching all through the night; and when the sun shows its face, she drinks in the Amrit. ||5|| Note: the originals contain the Gurbani in Gurmukhi..I am sorely disappointed that all this truns into "gibberish" due to Fonts problem...There is actually NOTHING MORE BEAUTIFUL THAN GURBANI IN GURMUKHI PRINT....seeing all those english words takes away the entire pleasure...some computer savvy veer please do something..my ardent plea..

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Rain drop · 04 May 2005

Sorry, I am here again , with fake name. -------- Logic, Logic, Logic-------------- and I wonder, how they are living on the planet, with that much of that, in their wisdom. Strange enough, we love only our kids and their mother, and still say, we stand by logic. What is wrong with kids of my neighbour and his wife? We kiss loved ones, yet not every part of theirs. Knowing that the body is same throughout. Nothing is sacred, If you have the courage, say aloud. What makes the Amrit----- Amrit. Sweet water is sweet, simply. Nitnem, does not changes me, stop it. I can change it with convenience. Read four only. Kachera is foolish dress. All these dress of blue and high turbans, what logic they have? Dying like moths for the cause with the belief that Guru is there to receive us. Millions laid their lives and they say that was sikh spirit. Fools were they; is not it. Nothing is secred; no bricks are important. That is why, they have thrown down Gurdwaras; to see marbles all around. No land is secred; all is of God. Why "dhoor mukh laava". No "then is Suhaava". And they discuss Gurbani cures. Backward people. They read the Gurbani, continously --- "Akhand Path". What is wrong, with a brief interval ? Interval is logical. No to Pad chhed, they say, persons of stone age.

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

.... · 04 May 2005

Kulbir Singh, we are waiting for your views.

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Kulbir Singh · 04 May 2005

What happens during Amrit Sinchaar? What makes this water amrit? Scientifically talking, the Khanday baatay da Amrit is simply sweet water. It becomes amrit because of presence of Punj Pyaray, Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee and above all because of recitation of 5 baanees while stirring Sarblohi Khanda in it. There is no doubt that water retains the affect of Gurbani. Everything that comes in contact with Gurbani and Naam gets affected by it. There is no doubt about it. Ponder upon the following Shabad: Jithay jaaye bahai mera Satguru, so thaan Suhaava Raam Raajay || (that place becomes purified and sacred, where Satguru Sachay Paatshah seats himself) Gursikhee so thaan bhaaliya, lai dhoor mukh laavaa|| (Loving and devoted Gursikhs earnestly find such places (as above) and place the dust of that spot on their foreheads). Everything that comes in contact with Guru Sahib gets affected by Guru Sahib. Anything that comes in contact with Gurbani gets purified. I fully believe that Gurbani does make the water sacred. Having said this, I don’t think this means that if people drink such sacred water but continue to do manmatt, they will reap any benefit from it. Benefit will come only if we also change our ways to Gurmukhi ways. If we lead a Gursikhi life, then surely amritmai water helps. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 04 May 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. I can agree with Kulbir Singh Ji....but I maintain that the "AMRIT" of the KHANDA BATTA ( which is actually PAHUL..The WORD "AMRIT" in GURBANI is always specifically used only for NAAM/GURBANI/GUR BACHANS.)..becomes SO because the KHANDA is STIRRED INTO IT....the KHANDA is not merely "stirred" ( not shaken !!) in the Amrit...the PANJ doing so MUST keep their Bir AAsan/Right Hand on Batta, and EYES DEEP INTO the AMRIT while RECITING GURBANI over it...ONE by ONE, in the Presence of GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB. Ardass, Hukmnama is also necessary. This PROCEDURE MUST be followed to the LETTER 100%....that is why the PUNJ have got to be PHYSICALLY FIT, SIGHTED in BOTH EYES, STRONG and FREE of any disability that prevents all of the above. ONLY when this Procedure is faithfully followed all the way does the Water turn into "Amrit ( Pahul). We are Bringing down the SANCTITY of "AMRIT" that is GURBANI/NAAM...by calling a bottle of Pepsi-Cola filled with Tap Water put next to Guru Granth ji sahib...AMRIT..... IN THAT CASE WHY did GURU GOBIND SINGH JI go to all that trouble to put forward HIS METHOD of KHANDA BATTA AMRIT CEREMONY ? HE IS SAME GURU JYOT as GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB....couldnt HE have had a batta of water put next to his bed....and called it "amrit"...quoting the pankatee So Thaan Sohavaa.... Even the SACRED Karah parshaad, prepared with so much SUCHAM, with Japji Sahib recited while it is prepared, has an ARDASS done, and KIRPAN PRESENTED in it....to make it "AMRIT MAIYEE KARRAH PARSHAAD/DEGH"...Just putting a batta full of GAFFEH next to GURU JI DOESNOT MAKE IT KARAH PARSHAAD..if the proper procedure is NOT followed it remains just gaffeh/karrah. Never in our history has anyone dared distribute just karrah as "karrah parshaad" without following the ardass, kirpan bhet procedures.....BUT in the "amrit in a bottle" the people, even moneh bring their own bottles, and take them home later as "amrit"....DEGH, is being left behind in the gurdwara premises, extra degh is disposed off in rivers...BUT PLAIN WATER in a bottle is kept so "preciously" and given the name of "Amrit" ??? we have our priorities wrong..somewhere ??? I too firmly beleive that "anything" that comes into contact with My Guru Ji becomes Sacred and purified.... that is things like the rumalleh. palakaan, palki, chaour sahib etc..."sacred" in the sense that i would NOT use them for humans, throw them around like ordinary things, etc etc and keep them properly as they have been used by My GURU JI.....BUT then AMRIT is AMRIT...water in a bottle cannot be AMRIT...or GURU JI would have said so. In a separate issue, GURBANI time and again in panktee after Panktee ASSERTS so clearly and plainly that AMRIT of NAAM/GURBANI is SWEET BEYOND DESCRIPTION....words used are NECTAR...AMBROSIAL....yet what do we do...???? .WE PUT IN SUGAR to "artificially sweeten" the "AMRIT" citing the case of Mata Sahib Kaur Ji putting in Patashay. Isnt this tantamount to admitting that the AMRIT is NOT naturally sweet ......as claimed in Gurbani...OR since GURBANI is ALWAYS TRUTH...100% TRUTH... this is indeed Khande Batte DE PAHUL . The Panktees also say clearly..PEEVOH PAHUL KHANDEDHAAR hoveh janam suhela...BUT since this is already widely named Amrit and the Amrit sanchaar ceremony is so named..I ahve no problems with it....BUT I DO SERIOUSLY OBJECT to further degradation of this SACRED NECTAR..to even mean tap water in pepsi cola bottles, kept in the Darbar sahib for a few days...Nanak Amrit EK hai DOOJAH Amrit NAHINH must mean something. Having said all that I also long for and Pray to GURU JI to have my own opportunity to allow this servant of his a dip in the SAROVAR at Harimandir Sahib...because that sarovar was constructed by my GURU JI Himself for this purpose....and that is a PRIVILEGE for a SIKH. I know thousands gave their very lives for this privilege....

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

rain drop · 07 May 2005

No, Arshi ji, no; I find some "sand" in your ice cream. Veer Kulbir Singh is there to feel and filter it. But humbly, most humbly, I want to add some foolish talk in this intelligent discussion. Guru asked for heads; He did not publicised "Dates for Amrit sanchar Smagam". And after beheading ceremoney; He sprikled Amrit. Why, we bother study, why and how Amrit turns Amrit. or at which step water changes chemically to Amrit. Beggers are no chosers (it is said). Beggers may be chosers, in this case, but they are at least not allowed to ask and inquire, what makes the food food. And who prepared and how prepared, the food. Sorry, I continue. As far the tradition of keeping a clean, thoroghly washed, earthen pitcher, in the Akhnd Path Sahib room is concerned; it is "scientific." One may or may not find any electro-chemical changes in water. But it is scientific because it translates the idea that water is for the body as the Gurbani is for the soul. And by driking water of that pitcher we want to make sure, we have swallowed down something, that was miraculus about Gurbani.

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

14 · 07 May 2005

u jokas lolllllllllllllll ur fighting over ur names.. how bout we get on wiv what "learning" is asking

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Manjit kaur Sidhu · 09 May 2005

This one set me thinking....and i have visited all the sites on the interntion...including... the allaboutsikhs.com website there are a number of books like the Mahan kosh, Prof sahib Singh Ji's darpan, Faridkot wala teeks, Guru Granth Sahib ji kosh etc etc....and i spent the entire day looking through all the references to AMRIT..that occur in GURBANI...every possible meaning is there EXCEPT the one that says WATER in SAROVAR/WATER kept in a pitcher/bottle/batta NEAR GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE "is Amrit".. every time Amrit_SAR is written it is always SADH SANGAT..and NOT SAROVAR/CITY full of WATER. Can anyone give just one Pankatee from Gurbani that confirms that water near Guru Ji becomes Amrit. I will be most grateful. My parents always bring back "amrit" from Amritsar....but NEVER from Damdama sahib/Muktsar/SantokhSar...and hundreds of other gurdwaras that have sarovars..are they making a mistake ? I desperately need confirmation from GURBANI/Bhai gurdass Ji for this. MK

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Princess · 09 May 2005

Vaheguru jee kaa khalsa, Vaheguru jee kee fateh! I don't understand what is the purpose of having sarovars inside almost all historical Gurdwara sahibs if that water is not capable of having any spiritual power in it? Did Guru Sahib jee made those sarovars to entertain visiters who love to see water or what else? Guru Sahibaans never did anything meaningless in their jeevan kaals. My own family member was cured by getting ishnaan in these savovars from a disease which is claimed by doctors of this world as not cureable. It happened just few months ago. One day we will be able to tell sangat all details about that but not yet because of the hukam of Guru Sahib jee. When we condemn the purity and amrit shakti of these sarovars we try to make our history false. There are so many saakhies(stories) related to amrit kala of these sarovars. Respected Giaani Arshi jee, Amrit does not only mean "khanday baatay dee pahul", it means water and it means medicine to cure diseases too. Bhainjee Manjit kaur jee please check Mahaan kosh once again. On pages 76, 77 abd 78 Amrit has many meanings. In Gurbani 'Amrit' word is not only used as one meaning but also used for salt and thirty six kind of foods. "Kabeer khoob khana kheechree ja meh amrit lon"..Salok bhagat Kabeer jee 'lon' means salt(loon). "Jeh parsaad chhateeh amrit khahe(n)" .......Siri Sukhamni Sahib 'chhateeh amrit' means 36 kind of foods. We all (I hope)are aware of this fact that when we cook food we are supose to recite Gurbani or Naam to make that food amritmaee. What ever we do while cooking it leaves good or bad affect on food and on a person who eats it. So, we can't condemn the affect of Gurbani or Naam on food/water. All vegetables, cooking oil, ataa after gunn, butter, daals while being cooked or bread etc foods contain water which retain Gurbani, Naam or bad stuff while cooking. If Gurbani/Naam does not leave any affect on food what's the point of reciting it while cooking? Water close to Gurbani becomes pure and amritmaee and is really good for drinking and ishnaan to cure our inner and outer diseases.

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

< · 09 May 2005

kbIr suoeI muKu DMin hY jw muiK khIAY rwmu ] kabeer suoee mukh dhha(n)n hai jaa mukh keheeai raam || Kabeer, blessed is that mouth, which utters the Lord's Name. dyhI iks kI bwpurI pivqRü hoiego gRwmu ]110] dhaehee kis kee baapuree pavithra hoeigo graam ||110|| It purifies the body, and the whole village as well. ||110|| (Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee)

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Manjit kaur Sidhu · 10 May 2005

SAROVARS were made from: Cleaning/washing of the BODY/FEET etc before entering GURU Darbaar. Now a days many Gurdawras have Piper water to perform this function IF sarovar is not built. SAME FUNCTION. READ my mail once more please....AMRIT is NEVER used to DESCRIBE WATER. Of all the hundreds of meanings..WATER is NOt even mentioned ONCE as beign "AMRIT". Please quote even one panktee from GURBANI or Kosh/dictionary meaning where Amrit means water. No offense or any disrespect to Amrit as I am full practising amrtidharee and keep full rehit. NO one has answered the question WHY even Karah parshaad needs to be KIRPAN BHET, Guru Ka Langgar also needs to be Kirpan Bhet..but not water in a bottle !!! Mk

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Question Bhai · 10 May 2005

Amrit ? Naam Parmesar Tera Which bathes and purifies the Soul. A spiritual medicine ( Sarab Rog Ka Aukad Naam ) which only works on a spiritual basis. Any physical side effects are purely the "User's vivid imagination".

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Anon · 10 May 2005

There are five Sarovar's in Siri Amritsar Sahib and each were construsted under the guidience of the Guru Sahib(an). Amritsar (siri Darbar Sahib) Kaulsar Santokhsar Bibeksar Ramsar Each Sarovar has its own significance, i am about to qoute from a book called "Sau Suwal" by Principle Satbir Singh Pg44. "According to the old tradition among the Sikhs it was essential to take a bath at Kaulsar before taking a dip at Amritsar; though some devotees took a bath at all the scared pools before coming to the Amrit sarovar. The Spiritual significance of these pools is: Ramsar: Keep the Name of God (always)in your mind. Kaulsar: Stay in a state of happiness while living in this world, full of worries, like a lotus flower that blossoms even while located in muddy water. Santhoksar: Stay contented in whatever God has given to you. Forsake avarice. Bibeksar: Lead a disciplined life. Amritsar: Those who take a dip in Amritsar (the pool of Ambrosia) discard their problems and maladies." [%sig%]

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Princess · 10 May 2005

Dear Manjeet kaur bhainjeeo, Please check mahaan kosh again. I have given you page numbers in my previous post(76, 77, 78) where 'Amrit' has many meanings and one of those meanings is water. ///////////////// SAROVARS were made from: Cleaning/washing of the BODY/FEET etc before entering GURU Darbaar. //////////////// Above is nothing less than a childish view. Do we need thousands of square feet sarovars to wash just our feet??? In case of washing body, everyone who goes to Guru darbar takes shower/bath/ishnaan before leaving home. This is funny.

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Singh · 10 May 2005

I also wondered if sarovars had any significance and maybe they were just for bathing. But doing yatra of Amritsar clarifies this. Bibeksar Sahib and Ramsar Sahib are essentially across the road from each other. Kaulsar and Amritsar are a 3 minute walk apart and Santokhsar is only 7 minute walk away. Why so many sarovars bunched together? Just because my logic cannot explain it, doesn't mean the sarovars don't have significance. They must have some special significance just seeing from the way they were built and where they were built. Tarn Taaran Sahib has a HUGE sarovar dug by Guru Arjan Dev jee. If sarovars have just "bathing" purposes, then why did Guru Sahib need such a massive sarovar built there?

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Manjit kaur Sidhu · 10 May 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.. Those "meanings" are NOT "MEANINGS" of "AMRIT"...they are ADJECTIVES.. look up what is an adjective and what is its function. One of the "meanings" also refers to GURU GOBIND SINGH JI ?? in reality that use of the word is a DESCRIPTION of One of the attributes of Guru Ji...NOT that "GURU JI" (body)is "AMRIT" and can be "drunk" What we are more interested in is the NOUN "AMRIT"....this is NAAM GURBANI.....anything that comes "close" to the "out of this world taste of AMRIT"...is described by adding the ADJECTIVE form of AMRIT before it.. Example: Amrit FRUIT...(phal) is Sita Phal.. Khande Batte de Pahul Jal is AMRIT jal Ordinary Gaffeh which you can buy in a restaurant or make at home becomes AMRIT MAIYEE KARRAH PARSHAD...once ardass/kirpan bhet hukmnama is taken in Guru's darbar. On the other hand I am very intrigued by Anon's mail on the Five Sarovars... food for thought.hmmm.. As to "thousands of feet" to WASH.... THOUSANDS/HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS of SHARDHALOOS obviously NEED thousands of Feet of Water to wash in.... can everybody be accommodated in a small "cubicle" ?? As to someone else claiming "everybody " takes a shower before going to Amrtisar....that is TODAY lol....NOT when Sangats came from as far as KABUL to visit GURU JI....trudging for YEARS in the dusty conditions.... Travel BACK IN time lol...no showers and no wells and no water...THATS why Our GURU JI dug wells, built Baolis, Dug SAROVARS....1. To do HUMANITARIAN WORK SEWA of providing drinking water...and 2. REMOVE JAAT PAAT CASTE UUCH NEECH etc BY having everybody...Jatt/chhorra/nai/chamaar/shudar/brahmin BATHE in the SAME SROVAR, EAT in the SAME LANGGAR. Guru Ji ERADICATED this jaat paat inone stroke...as a YOUNG GIRL many years ago I distinctly remember that ALL INDIAN RAILWAY STATIONS had SEPARATE " WATER PIPES"..One labelled MUSLIM PAANI" and the other "HINDU PANNI" ( Never mind that BOTH these pipes UNDERGROUND UNITED to come from the SAME water source..the Municipal water supply..NO one BOTHERED to ask that embarrassing query !!!) Bottom Line is SAROVARS/BAOLIS/WELLS like the one at Chherta sahib etc are for DRINKING/BATHING/CLEANING...of the EXTERNAL BODY ONLY. None of them can clean the Mann/Soul/AAtma..ONLY NAAM GURBANI can do that. A lot of people have heard stories of miracles...has anybody got concrete evidence of a LEGLESS MAN/armless woman/ etc GROWING a NEW LEG/ARM after bathing in any SAROVAR ?...all the DIVINE INSPIRATION comes from NAAM GURBANI....Body remains as it is. MK

Re: Please answer - Amrit!

Rain drop · 13 May 2005

Bhen Ji Manjit Kaur Sidhu is not only firm with her views on "No spirtiual significance of Amrit Sarovers", but also unfolding more rigidness with new questions. Do we need seeing, New legs/arms sprout with Amrit, to see the amritmai effects. If so, then why not we need similar type of responses of Gurbani to prove its Amritmai effects. If Gurbani treatment also "fails" to show such type of results (in an experiment); how Sidhu is going to prove Amrit effects of Gurbani. Whole of the world says, doctor treats but God cures, why this belief is being denied by an Amritdhari sikh. God has His own methods to show His mercy. He may show it through Amrit Sarovar Ishnaan. We have the chances, that this happens to us. Why? Guru made these Sarovers. Guru asked us to bathe in those. Hundreds "paid" with their lives, to pay for an Ishnaan in it.