Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

In need of Advice... ASAP

In need of Advice... ASAP

.... · 08 Aug 2003

FATEH, Sadh sangat jee, im in need of some help. My army unit has recently been deployed overseas to work with the malaysian military. We are currently staying on a malaysian air force base that we are operation out of. My problem is this. My kirpan has seemed to have attracted some attention recently. I've never had this problem before in my country. but since we are working on malaysian soil we also have to abide by their rules, and they are seeming to classify it as a weapon/concealed weapon. Ive spoken to my platoon staff and they are very supportive of the fact it is a religious requirement for me to wear it, but it seems its come from further up that i have to remove it as its causing some concern amongst the other people on the base. Ive tried explaining the significance of it, and have been pretty much told that when i go off base, as in malaysia you can get arrested for carrying a concealed weapon that i can get arrested and as part of the duty of care of the army i've been ordered not to wear it. This isn't a big concern as i was going to wear it anyway regardless of the order. But now i cannot also wear it on base. They have said the small one i have which i wear on a neclase sometimes (the ones people use when they shower) should be acceptable as its only 3 -4 inches and doesn't actually have a sharp edge on it. Now i normally only wear this when im doing a kesi ishnaan, or i wear a smaller kirpan on a gatra approximately 6 " blade, but they have refused to allow that. I am currently in the process of appealing this decision and am to put my case forward on monday but at the moment it seems as if the decision has already been made. My question is this, do I go with what the army has said, and wear the smaller neclase kirpan..... or do i go with my heart is telling me and that is that my kirpan stays on me, and if they wish to remove me from this base and fly me back to my home country so be it. The thing isi sometimes do wear the other neclase kirpan in the shower or in some other rare circumstances. and since i already sometimes wear it , should i just comprimise and be happy that i can still wear the symbolic necklase kirpan... or do i tell the army where to shove it and tell them that im not willing to take orders in regards to religous matters...... please if someonce can give me some advice that would be excellent!!!! and also if there is anyone who knows of any singhs who live in malaysia or in the malaysian armed services, if u cuold give me yur email or theirs so i could get into contact with them to seek advice and maybe learn if there are any exceptions granted to gursikhs, which my unit may not be aware of!! bul chuk maaf FATEH

Re: In need of Advice... ASAP

Balpreet Singh · 08 Aug 2003

I think that you should follow Guru Sahib's orders and wear your kirpaan at all times and stop wearing the small one completely. Guru Sahib's orders are higher than any military officer's. Many Singhs in the military have faced simmilar problems but when they followed the hukams of Guru Sahib, they emerged victorious. One particular example I like is that of Col. Daljeet Singh jee, who was a Jatha Singh who was willing to give up his rank in order to follow Gurmat ideals but Guru Sahib let him do both. His life story should be posted soon I hope. Other Singhs who chose Guru over military officer's were Bhai Ajit Singh and Subedar Harbachan Singh. Both emerged successful. Please read http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=1872&t=1852#reply_1872 Consider this a test of your dedication and resolve yourself to emerge successful by obeying Guru Sahib's every hukam to the fullest.

Re: In need of Advice... ASAP

Indy · 08 Aug 2003

Contact: 71, Jalan Maarof, Bangsar, 59000 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Tel: 603 - 2283 3713 Fax: 603 - 2283 6327 EMail: [address removed] URL: http://www.snsm.org.my == http://www.sikhs.ca/kirpan/ == http://www.sikhcoalition.org/InfoKirpan.asp == See if you can make contact with Karpal Singh of the DAP in Malaysia.. these maybe able to help apply pressure. Certainly helps to have a reputed Sikh body fighting your case on your behalf.

Re: In need of Advice... ASAP

Ranjit Singh · 08 Aug 2003

I agree completely with Balpreet Singh on this one. See this as a test from your guru. Also remember that this wouldn't only affect you. Whatever you do will set a precedent for any future gursikhs in your situation. If you compromise, any gursikh facing the same problem in the future will also be expected to compromise and will have a much harder time convincing the authorities otherwise. Do Ardaas and have full faith in Guru Saahib.

Re: In need of Advice... ASAP

Akali Sirtor Singh Khalsa · 08 Aug 2003

You should think.. which fauj (army) do I belong to first and foremost? Guru sahib's fauj or some temporary countries fauj? Guru sahib is the highest general of them all, to disobey his order for one of a lower ranking officer is indeed a high crime.

Re: In need of Advice... ASAP

domalla premee · 09 Aug 2003

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh Guru peeareo, You need to make a stand here. You are standing up for everyone as Sikhs and for Guru's principles. Find out clearly what their objection is.Be reasonable and calm. If possible get it in writing. If not take notes. Then contact human rights, anti-discrimination and Sikh associations local and otherwise and tell them your story. If applicable contact an attorney bro bono or someone willing to take a discrimination case. I don't know what the laws are there so these are just open suggestions. You can contact newspapers and print a story about it. No on wants bad publicity. Do these steps in order of increasing intensity. If they discharge you early and they very well might go straight to the press and rights groups. Publish this everywhere. Be sure you know what your rules books say as well as policies and procedures. If they break the rules and are doing this arbitrarily you have them over a barrel. Always keep Sikhi first. Be truthful, fair and firm. Whether they keep you or let you go you win either way whether you stay or go. If they keep you it is good for them, good for Sikhs everywhere, and good for you as a Sikh. If they don't then people everywhere need to know of their duplicity. If you leave strong and intact, you have followed Gurujee's will faithfuly and not the capricious whims of the world. You will come out stronger as a Singh conquering this challenge. :) dass

Re: In need of Advice... ASAP

.... · 10 Aug 2003

FATEH, thank you everyone for yur advice, but im still having trouble contacting sikhs in malaysia, it seems none of the contact numbers work and they are not responding to emails, does anyone know of any sikhs in malaysia???? it would be greatly appreciated

Re: In need of Advice... ASAP

Jagdish Singh CA · 10 Aug 2003

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh Have you tried Sikh Naujawan Sabha, Malaysia on [address removed]?? dass

Re: In need of Advice... ASAP

satnam · 11 Aug 2003

Call Malkith Singh of Sikh Naujawan Sabha, Malaysia at h/p 012 2880 557.