Re: Punjabi Singers singing religious songs
Taksaal Student · 26 Apr 2005
Yeh - Very True - Love the tapes - Manak has got the record for the most relegious albums and he has done them very well.......
.....and by the way TUF - these songs are not Kuchi Bani, because they are not bani in the first place and if it was - there is NO bani that is kuchi as it is all 'Dhur Ki Bani' straight from Sachkhand - these are just songs tellin the history of our great Sikhi......sorry if I offended any1.....
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Punjabi Singers singing religious songs
Manvir Singh · 27 Apr 2005
In regards to Kachi Baani - Kachi Baani is someone else making up Baani which tries to impersonate the Sikh Gurus, or who changes words and tries to portray it as the Sikh Gurus Baani
Kachi Bani = deception
Baani Di Beadbi = adding a word or not saying Gurbaani correctly
e.g.
"Tudh aage ardaas hamaari, jee'o pind sabh tera.
kaho naanak sabh teri vaddiaaee, koyee naa'o naa jaane mera"
(Before You I pray to you: my soul and body belong to You.
Nanak says, all glory is Yours, no-one knows my name.)
This above is what Guru Ji says.
Below is a Gurbaani Di Beadbi --- because an extra word has been added on to the shabad (which Guru ji did not add or intend to use).
" Tudh aage ardaas hamaari, jee'o pind sabh tera "Vaaheguroo".
kaho naanak sabh teri vaddiaaee, koyee naa'o naa jaane mera "Vaaheguroo" "
(Before You I pray to you: my soul and body belong to You "Vaheguru"
Nanak says, all glory is Yours, no-one knows my "Vaheguru's" name.)
at all costs we should avoid adding our own words to Gurbaani and not listen to those who try to impersonate the Baani of the Sikh Guru Sahibaans.
(This is what Bhai Jasvir Singh ji Panjab Radio wale explained to me)
Re: Punjabi Singers singing religious songs
Student Of The Guroo · 27 Apr 2005
Very True Paaji Manvir Singh Ji - but we are talking about Dharmak Songs - Which is not Kachi Bani as it is not bani in the first place......they merely explain Sikh History - not Bani.........
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!!
Re: Punjabi Singers singing religious songs
Manvir Singh · 28 Apr 2005
Veer ji i was responding to the first post which said:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
.....although it also helps the average pindhu turn to Sikhi even though its kuchi bani.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Singing history or singing something which is awakening people to Sikhi is all good.
Dhadi, Kaveeshree, Dhaarmik Prasang/ Geet are all good ways of conveying a Gurmat message, relating the past to the present through the tool of music.
Re: Punjabi Singers singing religious songs
Student Of The Guroo · 28 Apr 2005
Very Sorry Veer Ji - Galti Maarf Karni - I understand what u mean now......
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!!
Re: Punjabi Singers singing religious songs
;;;;;;;;;;; · 28 Apr 2005
not only is it good it makes you picture the event and with a folk legend voice of yamla/manak/surinder sets the scene right in ya heart.
Re: Punjabi Singers singing religious songs
teray baap ka baap · 28 Apr 2005
>>>>
these songs are not Kuchi Bani, because they are not bani in the first place and if it was - there is NO bani that is kuchi as it is all 'Dhur Ki Bani' straight from Sachkhand - these are just songs tellin the history of our great Sikhi......sorry if I offended any1.....
>>>>
This is verbatim the explanation that Dhadrian wala used.
Please, if nothing else, be original.
"Satgur bina hore kachi hai bani."
Re: Punjabi Singers singing religious songs
Student of the Guroo · 28 Apr 2005
I agree with "Khalistani" and "?"......lol.....
........but "Terey Baap Ka Baap" - This is the explanation that Baba Isher Singh Ji used - it is the explanation that Baba Attar Singh Ji used - and most importantly it is the most important explanation given to us by Waheguru - as it is in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji - No Bani is Kuchi Veer Ji - and get that straight!!!...... - I still cant think why in the world do people think Dharmak songs can be bani.........lol.......
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!!