Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Disabled at Gurdwara

Disabled at Gurdwara

Premi · 21 Apr 2005

Sangat Jee, What are your views on disabled people coming to gurdwara? My father had been disabled for a while now and I notice there are no facilities for them to enjoy sangat. I find the mentality of the committes is very non-compassionate. Someone who's limbs don't work, or who can't sit on the floor or is in a wheelchair, should we not adjust for these people? I mean if they sit on a chair or crate at the back of the gurdwara or in the entrance way, is it such a big deal? The takhat of Guru JEE is still higher than them, or if they can't sit on the langar hall on the floor and require a table and chair because they only one arm works or can't swallow while on the floor? I always thought the Gurughar was a place that was acceptable of the down-trodden and weak? It is Guru jee who is the only patit -pavaan, is it not? Disabled people are living in so much pain as it is, do we have the right to deny them access to God House and increase the agony in there life? Please let us do vichaar on thsi subject, I would like to hear from especially Kulbir Singh and Gyani and Jasbir Singh Jathedar as they have done quite a bit of sangat.

Re: Disabled at Gurdwara

jss · 21 Apr 2005

i think accomodating people with disabilities is our DUTY... i mean..i'm sure they have a tough time outside in the world...the gurdwara should be at least one place where they can come find peace in listening to paath, kirtan, katha...

Re: Disabled at Gurdwara

Amritpal Singh · 21 Apr 2005

most gurdwara's in toronto have ramps and other things. I know scarbrough Gurdwara and DIxe both have ramps for wheel chair access. But yes their should be accomodations for disabled people, I think in Toronto if you want to have a gurdwara you have to have disabled access. Might be a by -law

Re: Disabled at Gurdwara

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Apr 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Dear Premi Jio, imho...no problems with accomodating disable persons in a Gurdwara...we should be proud of them in the sense that instead of sitting at home and feeling sorry for themselves...and moping around "cursing" God and others for their disability...they take the trouble to come to Gurdawra, have sangat of Gursikhs and participate in the Guru darbar. The Committees who have "trouble" with these people are usually the ones who have "no problems" with the ghona monahs etc serving in their gurdwaras because of money contributions...but no no to wheelchairs because they "offend" Guru Ji due to sitting on chair which is against Maryada !!! They are pretty selective about where to apply their scanty knowledge of maryada....in one gurdwara i know wheelchairs were a no no..until a rich lady in a wheelchair started coming....and lo and behold the gurdwara committee had a ramp installed ( and not one but THREE ramps in different parts !!)...its pretty obvious the wheelchair lady contributed a hefty sum to their goluk... so lets not be so materialistic. The injunctions in the Sikh Rehat maryada aginst gadellas and pillows and special seating arrangements were meant to STOP certain SANTS/BEDIS/SODHIS etc ec from doing this in Gurdwaras...who were doing this deliberately to show their special status in the sangat..... this provision was never meant to chase out disabled persons. Jarnail Singh

Re: Disabled at Gurdwara

jss · 21 Apr 2005

jarnail singh ji you hit the nail on the head... i went to a wedding a couple of years ago at a gurdwara in Toronto and the committee made the biggest deal when we put some chairs in for the old bibi jis who couldn't sit on the ground...they started crying about maryada of guru ghar and respect for guru ji....then as soon as the lavaan were finished, the committee president was giving a siropa to the bride and groom in front of sangat...and funny thing is that the groom didn't have kesh and knew jack about sikhi (although a nice guy)...but certainly not big on sikhi...and i remember laughing and thinking where's the maryada in that... btw...I have seen true saints and not one of them has ever used a special gadella or pillow..they sit simply among the sangat and get up to do katha in front of sangat how any kathavachak does katha...

Re: Disabled at Gurdwara

charanjeev singh · 21 Apr 2005

My brother and sister are in wheellchairs. We went to Gurdwara Sahib, and some older baba jee began making a fuss with me about allowing them to sit inside in their wheelchairs. I made sure he knew i wasnt going to accept his thoughts. We sat right in the front of sangat. Guru Sahib first and formost takes care of those who have been abandoned Be Kesai Yaar Gur Gobind Singh

Re: Disabled at Gurdwara

:)>> · 22 Apr 2005

in Uk there is legeislation to ensure disabled have access to ever building, Gurdwaras come under that. If a disabled perosn cannot access a building, he can sue its owners. If disabled are having problems with Gurdwaras, then approach the committee. If it is typical punjbai nonsense, they tell that you can sue, and possibly will. They will soon sort things out. Every gurdwara has more than enough money to pay for disabled facilities.

Re: Disabled at Gurdwara

ONE · 22 Apr 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Admin Note: We had to delete this message since it talks about one marriage in particular. Don't want to start a debate someone's personal life.

Re: Disabled at Gurdwara

Khalsa Ji · 26 Apr 2005

I have a father who is now wheelchair bound - the one thing that he most wishes for is to go to the Gurdwara and sit in the darbar free from hassle. Unfortunately that is not always the case. It is most unfortunate that 1 or 2 Amrithari Sikhs seem to make up there own rehat and have made the most insensitive comments. In one Gurdwara they threatened to break his wheelchair if he should ever sit in the darbar again. We lobbied our local Gurdwara and found that all is not lost. Our local Gurdwara has put up a notice welcoming those in the wheelchair to the darbar and offering assistance if so required. Therefore the moral of the story is for Sikhs to lobby each Gurdwara to put up a similar notice to deal those with there very funny notion of Sikhi WJK,WJF [%sig%]

Re: Disabled at Gurdwara

TUF · 26 Apr 2005

I think wheelchairs should be allowed but there should be some way to clean the wheels before they enter.

Re: Disabled at Gurdwara

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 27 Apr 2005

dear Tuf veer, thats commonsense....the person using the wheelchair or his companion should do the needful BEFORE entering the Gurdwara sahib....i dont think anyone will look sympathetically towards one in a wheelchair spreading mud all over the carpets/ramps/floors... Responsibility is a two way street

Re: Disabled at Gurdwara

Khalsa Ji · 29 Apr 2005

JARNAIL SINGH jI I AGREE WHOLE HEARTEDLY WITH YOUR POINT - IN FACT THE NOTICE I REFERRED TO EARLIER IN MY LAST POST STATED THAT IF ANYONE NEEDS HELP WITH CLEANING THE WHEELCHAIR, THEN THEY CAN ASK FOR HELP IF SO NECESSARY. IMPLYING THAT CLEANED WHEELCHAIRS ARE ALLOWED IN THE DARBAR. IN FACT OUR LOCAL GURDWARA HAS A WATER TAP CONVENIENTLY SITUATED. I DON'T THINK IT IS THE PHYSICAL HURDLES THAT ARE SUCH A OBSTACLE - IF MY MOTHER TAKES MY DAD TO THE GURDWARA THERE IS USUALLY A KIND HEARTED MEMBER OF THE SANGAT MORE THAN WILLING TO HELP - BUT IT CAN BE THE MENTAL ANGUISH WHERE THE POINT BLANK REFUSAL OF ALLOWING A WHEELCHAIR MEMBER OF THE SANGAT INTO THE DARBAR THAT IS TOTALLY ANTI GURMAT WJK,WJF

Re: Disabled at Gurdwara

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 29 Apr 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Then we are all agreed that there should be no discrimination in the sangat due to " physical disablity". The 1 0r 2 Amrtidharees who disagree or are not happy about this..well.... we cant change eeryone.. Personally I have Full Faith in GURU JI..and my Daily Prayer is that GURU JI, PLEASE BLESS me so that I can WALK into YOUR PRESENCE under my own steam till the very last day of my life....GURU JI is All POWERFUL and BAKSHANHAAR. Please DO ardass daily that HE may take away the wheelchair/disability...who knows GURU JI may one day answer your ardass and then you wont have to face such discrimination.....meanwhile go to GURU JI with full and total humility....ignore the snide remarks, funny sarcastic looks...some "grown ups" are also like children.....they see someone different and they stare and point fingers etc...IGNORE THEM and Pay full attention to GURU JI.

Re: Disabled at Gurdwara

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 30 Apr 2005

Why must a disabled person do ardaas daily to ask Guruji to take away the disability? Yes, Guruji does have the power to take away the disability. HE will not turn down the request of HIS children, but it may take HIM more than one lifetime to fullfill that request. What if a disabled person of any kind has accepted their disability as Guruji's hukam? In gurdwaras, do we install sinks that are 10 feet off the ground? Absolutely not, no one could reach such a sink. But to a disabled person, some actions are just as impossible. Is it not worthy karseva to assist such a person in getting in to a gurdwara? As far as those that do not like the idea of the disabled in the gurdwara, perhaps they need a bit of education about injustice and how any Sikh worth their kirpan should FIGHT injustice, not ENFORCE injustice. It takes courage to stand up to another person's denigrating attitude. Our gurus spoke of courage and surviving battles. Sometimes, that courage needs to be reawakened.

Re: Disabled at Gurdwara

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 01 May 2005

Our local Govt Minister this morning first got herself blindfolded and "walked" the streets to get the feeling of how a blind person must feel...she began to cry after a few minutes.. Then she sat herself down in a wheelchair..and realised just how "impossible" buildings and stairways, road shulders, pot holes etc..are in the way of such a person.. Maybe the Gurdawra Committe members who feel "antipathy" towards disabled persons...should get such a lesson and see for themselves. As for ARDASS..it is a DAILY HUKM of GURU JI....we MUST do ARDASS at the beginning and Conclusion of Nitnem, and everything else we undertake.. OF course everything is under GURU JI's HUKM ( in that case why do ardass at all ??)..BUT GURU JI HIMSELF TELLS US..TUM Thakur Tum peh Ardass..so we follow GURU JI.