Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Apr 2005

waheguru ji ka khalasa waheguru ji ki fateh. There is a long time "myth" propogated by the rara sahib Sants that Sri Sukhmani Sahib Gurbani has 24,000 akhars....and a human being breathes 24,000 times in 24 Hours...so ONE Path of Sukhmani Sahib makes safla 24 Hours and 24,000 swaass... When this myth was propogated...no one bothered to actually count the akhaars in Sukhmani sahib....but now tih computers and word count just a click away...it has been verified that Sukhmani Sahib is FAR SHORT of the magical 24,000... And the "Scientific" "fact" about 24,000 swaas in 24 hours....well that is another myth as humans breathe faster or slower according to many causes and phyiscal conditions... With the ongoing controversy about 40 days chalisa...etc it must be shown that in the Entire GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE, the ONLY time NUMBER is mentioned is EK in front of EK Oankaar.....NUMBERS are NOT IMPORTANT in any way..BUT the SANTS lsy very heavy emphasis on NUMBERS and NUMEROLOGY....malaa and beads and 101 sri jis sri 108 ji etc NOTE" THIS in no way is to be construed as being agaisnt Sukhmani Sahib paath DAILY..I myself do more than one Paath daily and sometimes up to FIVE If Guru Ji does Apaar kirpa on me.. Jarnail Singh

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Me · 16 Apr 2005

maybe u shud do 24?

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

can't think of a name.. · 16 Apr 2005

Author: Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Date: 04-16-05 07:18 it has been verified that Sukhmani Sahib is FAR SHORT of the magical 24,000... ***** Hmm, just how many akhar's are there then?

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Kulbir Singh · 16 Apr 2005

I think this myth of doing one Siri Sukhmani Sahib to make all your swaas of the day successful and acceptable to Guru Sahib in a way reduces the importance of Naam. Does this mean that if one does one Siri Sukhmani Sahib a day then one does not need to do any simran? Having said that, I do think one Siri Sukhmani Sahib paath a day is vital for chardi kala of a Gursikh. Nothing against doing this paath. My comments are reserved for the myth that if we do one Siri Sukhmani Sahib then we can rest assured that all our swaas are safal and we don't need to indulge in Naam then. Nothing can replace Naam. Thanks for bringing it up Arshee Giani jee. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Rupinder · 17 Apr 2005

Sant isher singh Ji Rara Sahib Wale did used to say that one path of Sukhmani sahib, balances out 24000 swaas. THIS DID NOT MEAN THAT YOU DO NOT HAVE TO DO ANY MORE PATH OR SIMRAN! INFACT IT MEANT THAT IT BALANCED OUT THE DAY, AS TO NEUTRAL IT! YOU HAVE TO DO MORE! it is easy for us to question the acts of sant Isher Singh Ji, while sitting at our pcs, but can any one do for the panth what they did? They spent 50 years of their life selflessly in parchar of Guru Nanak's Mission, baptized over 700000 people into the khals fold, and in England they are held responsible for bringing Sikhs back to their religion! More importantly it was Sant Isher singh ji who battled withe SGPC and WON over the Mangals of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj. If it was not for them the text of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj would have been changed forever! And before any of you start saying that sants only are in it for the money etc, When Babaji went back to India from the Uk in 1974 The comititee of Singh Sabha Southall gave them £5000 and said this is for your Langars at Rara Sahib. To this Babaji replied, tell me whose langar is being served here? the comititee replied Guru Nanaks, to which Babaji replied at Rara sahib it is Also guru nanaks langar and please put the moneu into use here! Tell me is this the action of a Pakhandi sant!!! If people spent less time on this forums attempting to riducle and critize sants, they might be able to learns from their lives and better themselves! Guru da Dass Rupinderpal Singh www.bhorasahib.com

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Gurpreet SINGH · 17 Apr 2005

sukhmani sahib is a form of naam simran anmirth bachan saadh ki bani jo jo japai this hee gath hovai har har naam nith rasan bhakanee Naam Simran literally means remembering the name, if you remember the name through reading bani, instead of sitting and meditating on vaheguru, does it really make a difference? Dhur ki bani aie, thin sagli chint mitiaee remembering and chanting the bani that came from akaal purakh is a form of naam simran. amnrith bachan sathigur ki bani jo bolai so mukh amrith pavai Obviously one sukhmani sahib a day cant make all your breaths saffal, but doing sukhmani sahib once a day and truely remembering akaal purakh while you do it seems like another form of naam simran

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

ms · 17 Apr 2005

Jarnail Singh and Kulbir Singh thank you for always mentioning the importance of Naam it makes things just that much easier

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

etka · 17 Apr 2005

i'm sure they said that so more ppl would do paath.

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Bijla Singh · 18 Apr 2005

"More importantly it was Sant Isher singh ji who battled withe SGPC and WON over the Mangals of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj. If it was not for them the text of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj would have been changed forever!" Please provide more information on this. What were the reasons of Sant Ji? Why did he want to keep the Mangals the way they are now? I do not want to debate but only want to learn this side of the story since I can't seem to find any information anywhere else. thank you. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

... · 18 Apr 2005

thankyou sooo much rupinder singh jee for the website!! such beautiful photos. cant thank you enough :) ive never been to that site..is there one of sant waryam singh jee as well?

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Another Gurpreet Singh · 18 Apr 2005

Gurpreet SINGH the whole point in reading gurbani is to reflect on the message it is giving...even with naam simran, u reflect and concentrate on the word.... blindly reading it...has no impact, because how can we bring it into our lives, if we dnt kno what it is.... sikhi is not magic, we use the word to make changes in our lives...slowly... sehj pakey so meetha hoye

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

can't think of a name.. · 18 Apr 2005

It seems as though to some people it does not matter what is said and more importantly in what context. All that matters is that if an opportunity presents itself to have a 'bash'/dig at people, including Sant’s etc, or to nit pick at a point, some people just can't let it go.. [%sig%]

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Bored Boy · 18 Apr 2005

Good old "Sant Bashing".....like it Arshi....SGPC are the best....!!

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

answer to bijla singh · 18 Apr 2005

Mid 1900's SGPC started to implement a lot of new ideas and started making changes in Sikhi. This resulted in much confusion within the Panth and caused for many splits, and other things to start up. One of the major and most dominating issue of the time was the SGPC's implentation of Pad-Ched printing of Maharaj Saroops. This "noise" being made, led to the main sevadaars, great and respected Saints, and leaders of the major Jathaybandi's etc to come together to oppose such actions that where being taken by the SGPC. The various Jatha's and samparada's of the time got together with a common goal and had several meetings at different venues to do veechar on this issue. Such meetings occured at Sri Amritsar Sahib, Damdama Sahib, Keeratpur Sahib, Rara Sahib and one of the largest at Bhinder Kalaan on the 11th of September, 1959, at which time all the big time saints of the day came together and created a committee, which consisted of the following Mahpursh: 1. Sant Baba Hari Singh Ji Kahaarpurieea 2. Sant Giani Gurbachan Singh Ji Bhindranwale 3. Sant Ishar Singh Ji Rara Shib 4. Sant Ishar Singh Ji Kalairaa(n) (Nanaksar) 5. Sant Baba Bhagvaan Singh Ji Rairoo Sahib Mangal is also called 'Mangalaacharan'. In Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, ik onkar to gur parsaad is called mangal or mangalaacharan. There are many forms of this mangal, for example: ik onkar satgur parsaad, or , ik onkar satnam gur parsaad etc etc.

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Kulbir Singh · 18 Apr 2005

Manglacharan must always appear on the top of each new baani, not afterwards. The printed saroops today have manglacharans all mixed up i.e. sometimes they appear after “Mahalla” and at other times they come before Mahalla. At some places they appear even after "salok". All old saroops have Mangals either on the top or right hand side (slightly on top). Out of respect, mangals were always kept on the right. SGPC was going to fix the printed saroops but the sants got together and disrupted this correction. I will give just one example of how wrongly the mangals are placed now a days: In Siri Sukhmani Sahib the mangal comes as follows: Gauri Sukhmani Mahalla 5 Salok Ik Oankaar Sat Gurprasaad. Now tell me how is this right? Is the mangal (Ik oankaar Satgur Prasaad) part of the salok? This is implying that the mangal is part of the salok and that it is the baani of Mahalla 5. At other places it implies that it is baani of Mahalla 3 since it appears after the mahalla there. At one place it even implies that this manglacharan is the part of Bhagat Baani, which it is not. Which one is correct? The salok is “Aad Guraye Namah” and not “Ik Oankaar Satgur Prasaad”. Mangals should always be written or pronounced before Mahalla or salok. We have a saroop which has mangals in the beginning. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Bijla Singh · 18 Apr 2005

I can understand protest against pad-chedd saroops but why against Mangals? I know what Mangals are but you did not give any reason for keeping the mangals the way they are. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

tera baap · 18 Apr 2005

i think the reason is vey apparent, maybe u should invest in glasses or pursue further education, but just a suggestion.

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

ns · 18 Apr 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalasa Waheguru ji ki fateh. Inteestng observation on the wordcount Jarnail Singh Ji. I've read in the nanaksar maryada of Sukhmani Sahib, it doesn't mention wordocount of 24000 but just 24 asthapdi, relevance to 24000 swas. I think the aim in those days was to get people to start doing Sukhmani. People always get confused over whether it's important for reading bani or naam.But what does Sukhmani say about this: SUKMANI SUKH AMRIT PRHAB NAAM,BHAGAT JANAA KE MAN BISRAM, clearly naam simran is the ultimate and resides in the minds of bhgats, however there is no reason why anyone shouldn't recite sukhmani due to lines mentioned above by Gurpreet Singh. Could others please reflect and translate this line in better way than I have.

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

singh · 18 Apr 2005

The reason why these MahaanPurakhs of the Khalsa Panth opposed the changing of Mangals was because Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaj is Dhur Ki Bani. Just because some Bani or its structure does not make sense to an academic does not mean he has the right to suggest that Bani should be changed. No one can change Bani, no matter how clever they claim to be, or whatever research they have!!! Next you will have individuals trying to change it in other ways. Bani is a Universal Truth - it cannot be changed by anyone!!! On a side note, imagine being there when all these great Gursikhs were together - truly amazing!!! "Gyani" Arshi - you can keep having a pop at Sants like Sant Ishar Singh Jee - any Sukhmani Sahib dae Paath that you do - you are only negativing by doing Sant Di Ninda - you obviously are not acting on the warnings given in Sukhmani da Path of those that do Ninda of Sants. Why do you always pick faults out in others - How many hundreds of thousands have you inspired into Sikhi? Why do you seek to find any shred of criticism that you can, rather than looking at all the Parchaar Sant Isher Singh Jee did. At no point did Sant Ishar Singh Jee seek to undermine the importance of Naam. They said Naam was most important. Tthey only encouraged Sikhs to do as much Paath as possible - even if you act on one shabad or tukh of Gurbani a day, that is enough to change a person's life - look at the power of Sukhmani Sahib - its way stronger - if you act on it, of course it can have a positive effect on the individual's swaas in a day. At no stage did Baba Jee say Sukhmani Sahib should be read ritualistically. You have just gone crazy dude - you don't know the full story about what Sant Isher Singh Jee said, or if you do know it, you hide half of it just to slander the supreme Sants of Waheguru. Carry on Arshi - your bad luck!!!

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Singh · 18 Apr 2005

The Mangals in puratan saroops of Sri Guru Granth Sahib are all at the top or to the right. Just because present printed saroops have the mangals all over the place, doesn't mean Guru Sahib put them there like that. Stop being ignorant. Changing the way saroops are printed today doesn't mean that we are "changing bani", it means bani is being restored to its original form. If you don't believe me, do some research on your own. Check out the saroops in the British Library and tell me where the mangals are on the oldest birs.

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 19 Apr 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. This question on Mangals was asked before..not a single reply. This time i beleive it "accidentally" slipped out in a sant "supporter"..and looking at the "replies" to this obviously open and shut case query..all i see are half truths, half replies...and a lot of slithering about on a slippery slope.. "ALL" the sants mentioned dont have a clue about the Mangals...that in my mind proves they are not what is said about sant nindidya in Sukhmani Sahib..blaming academics and all that doesnt prove anything..it is obvious the issue was all about "OPPOSE SGPC" doent matter what it is just OPPOSE SGPC... and thats why no prrofs are beign offered as to WHY the Mangals should be HAPHAZARD as they are in the sroops today and this is an insult to them Bani ( RESTORING the Mangals to their RESPECTED ORIGINAL positions is in NO way "changing bani or anything"..How can a "sant" not know this simple fact ?? I know what i am about....veero dont need to worry about my fate..just ask your "nearest sant" and tell us all WHY the Mangals are UP and DOWN in Pritned Sroops whereas they are ALL at the TOP in Most Handwrittten ORIGINAL SROOPS ??? Prof Sahib Singh Ji has given NUMEROUS EXAMPLES in his Darpan.....lets have FIVE EXAMPLES from the SANTS... Jarnail Singh

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

jss · 19 Apr 2005

one question, those people opposed it in the past...but are the academics trying to do anything about it now?? i mean i;ve never heard of this issue except here... i trust you guys saying that is how it was in the past and i trust that originally it was larrivarr....so why aren't the learned ones making a bigger deal about it??? the way i see it, the longer the learned people don't take actions, the innocent population won't know any better... and nothing will change.... are there any current initiatives?...ways to get involved??

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

question · 20 Apr 2005

If the mangals are at the top in puratan saroops then how did the sants have the power to change them??

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Apr 2005

Dear Jss Ji, Currently the "sgpc" is under the control of the SANTS.....most of the Jathedars are former dera students, the President Bibi jagir Kaur has her own DERA at Begowal and is thus a "santanni"..most of the granthis, parcharaks etc of sgpc are all from deras.... THAT is WHY you can notice that the Maryada at Harmandir Sahib Akal takahat is highly mixed up/MESSED UP and NOT following the SGPC Maryada at all. IF the SGPC was not infiltrated, it would be natural for Akal takaht under tis control to be following the Akal takahat maryada ?? BUt it is NOT so. The RSS control of all Sikh Institutions Akali dal (thru badal), SGPC ( thru badal) etc is COMPLETE..and we all know the Santsamaj is the bedfellow of the RSS. Jarnail Singh

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Bored Boy · 20 Apr 2005

Aw man.... Sants in the SGPC.....What next? Gurmukhs??!!

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Apr 2005

dear question ji, The "SANTS" didnt change the Mangals....heck man they didnt even "know" about it.... The Commercial Printers who SELL ready Printed Birs and Sroops in Amritsar...CHANGED them ( perhaps unknowingly, as in the handwritten versions SPACE was always at a premium...and it is soemtimes hard to discern whcih is which..EXCEPT at Places WHERE it is VERY VERY CLEAR that the Manglacharan is WAY AT THE TOP and RIGHT hand side of the AAng..in THAT case they left the mangalacharan at the TOP..BUT where it was difficult to discern ( BUT VISIBLE nevertheless and Understandable to a Real Gurmukh Pathi and not a person out to make a profit)..they made a mistake and messed it all up. When the SGPC ( in those bygone days when the real GURMUKHS were running it and not like rsss buddies now)...DECIDED that there were TOO MANY MISTAKES in the Commercial Birs, and that the SGPC should take the initiative to Print a CORRECT version of the BIR by Proofing and then PHOTOPLATING the AAngs so that the "correct" version would be permanent, thta it came about that it was NOTICED that the Manglacharans were messed up in the printed Birs....and should be corrected in the SGPC version. The LOBBY that made NOISE was the Commercial Printers who were going to LOSE a whole huge sum of MONEY to the SGPC birs if their BIRS were "proved" wrong ( who wants to buy a bir with mistakes !!)...and WHAT can the Pritners do with their Birs ??...and the SANTS jumped on the PRINTERS BANDWAGON.....to these people anything the SGPC did was 100% WRONG ( even if this was 100% RIGHT in this case )....and who else would PRINT the "SANTS GUTKAS and own MARYADAS" if and when needed ?? the PRINTERS of course...so it was a classic case of You scratch my back and i will scratch YOURS..a UNHOLY ALLIANCE !!! As I said before....Prof Sahib Singh Ji has GIVEN PAGES after PAGES of PROOF that the Printed Birs cotain errors in Manglacharans PLACING.... all the SANT SUPPORTERS have to do is ask their NEAREST SANT/MAHAPURAKH etc and enlighten us all as to HOW the PLACING OF THE Manglacharans in PRINTED BIRS are CORRECT and those in the Handwritten and KARTARPURI BIR as well are WRONG. Just enlighten us on Kulbir Singh's EXAMPLE given above about SUKHMANI SAHIB....this is just ONE example out of a few dozen. Any "child" can get the POINT that a MANGLACHARAN has to COME FIRST.....ALWAYS...100% of the TIME......it just CANNOT be SECOND PLACE...and IF that happens it is NOT a "MANGLACHARAN "...!!!! so you decide which is which ?? IS EK Oankar..( and all its Variations) a Manglacharan or is it NOT ? IF it is manglacharan..IT should rightly COME TOP RIGHT HAND CORNER and ALWAYS at TOP before a Bani begins...if "it" is mixed up in the second line third line etc ?? whose mistake is it ?? and WHY do the Sants want to go on perpetuating this mistake..When in the KARTARPURI BIR this "mistake" doesnt occur even ONCE . Jarnail Singh

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

jss · 21 Apr 2005

jarnail singh ji, if what you say about the sgpc is true, that they are involved with sants...then wouldn't the sgpc have rejected the nanakshahi calender cuz from what i hear sant samaj and other organizations don't accept it....so if they were all together, why would they go the opposite route??... sgpc in my eyes is controlled all by politicians....

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Apr 2005

veer jss ji, the Nanakshai Calendar is too little too late...and the sants have got their say in it also.....just look at all the Sangrands, poooranmashis etc which are all anti gurmat and have no place in a Nanakshahi Calendar...the "clever politicians" running the sgpc have got away with 'satisfying" everybody..badals, sants, rss, etc etc...just look at all the mixed up maryadas at Akal takhat harmandar sahib....if everything was all right the SRM of Akal takhat should be 100% followed in Akal Takhat itself...BUT it is NOT ?? why ?? Recently the Punjab Govt failed to grant a Public Holiday on VASAKHI !!! How can we malaysian Sikhs persuade our Govt to grant us a Vasakhi holiday when even in PUNJAB it is not a holiday ?? All around us the ava is ootia... recently i met a French Official in the French Embassy KL and we were discussing the Turban....he told me..YOUR JATHEDARS find no difficulty in "REMOVING" their KIRPANS when they board planes etc....so WHY cant the Sikh Students in a French School REMOVE their Dastaar for a few hours and leave it outside the gate..Arent your Five Kakaars EQUALLY important or not ?? I had no answer....IF we can remove our kirpaan..so the karra also can go, the kachhera can go, the Dastaar also can go ???? they are all removable ?? Jarnail Singh

Re: Sukhmani Sahib...24,000 akhars ??

Bijla Singh · 21 Apr 2005

"OUR JATHEDARS find no difficulty in "REMOVING" their KIRPANS when they board planes etc" Time to start Sachkhand Airline or Khalsa Airline. Plane and school are two different issues. Why people still don't see the need for Khalistan, I wonder?