Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Call to Akal Takhat to dishonour some Rehitnamas

Call to Akal Takhat to dishonour some Rehitnamas

Kulmohan · 15 Apr 2005

I give a call to support the following Akal takhat should dishonour some of the illogical and irresponsible lines of some rehatnamas, written by some purattan sikhs like the lines below 'Sikh hoye sir topi dharrey, saat janam kushti hoye marrey' (a sikh who wears a cap will die a leper for 7 births) has this ever been proved, does it seem logical ? Guru Nanak Dev ji pardoned Kauda Rakshash (one who ate human flesh), Malik bhago (one who ammassed wealth by not giving the poor their due) , Sajan thag (one who cheated the passengers of their belongings and killed them) Did Guru Nanak Dev ji Pardoned them all ? or Did he not ? If he Pardoneed them, then will a sikh guy who has worn a Cap on some occasion, not be pardoned and left to be born and die as a leper for 7 lives ? any secondees for this call .......... (Well in the larger perspective my call is asking us all to rid ourselves of the feelings of guilt, feelings of sin that are often attached to some trivial matters by referencing saakhis or rehatnamaas as above)

Re: Call to Akal Takhat to dishonour some Rehitnamas

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 15 Apr 2005

"dishonour"...?? what a word to use kulmohan veer... maybe the better word is REVOKE.... I agree wholeheartedly some of the Rehatnamas written by obviously biased "sikhs" contain "rules" that are not applicable or practical today and can be REVOKED. Actually a LOT of this type of Stuff that was patently ANTI GURMATT and Anti-Gurbani of Sri Guru Granth ji was REMOVED in the 30 Year Process of Preparing the Sikh Rehat maryada approved by the Akal Takhat....in the early 1940's. Some references to Muslims etc are very biased and wrong in fact..and reflect the time based ideas of the writers...others support Hindu Brahmin rituals etc. This is why GURU JI has Given His GURU KHALSA PANTH the RIGHT to amend/remove/revoke/add.....under the GUIDANCE of GURBANI of Guru Garnth Ji..and a Sarbatt Khalsa can do all this. Jarnail Singh

Re: Call to Akal Takhat to dishonour some Rehitnamas

Kulmohan · 15 Apr 2005

Sorry, I meant to use the word 'Disown' instead of 'Dishonour' . Thanks for the correction veer Jarnail singh

Re: Call to Akal Takhat to dishonour some Rehitnamas

Kulbir Singh · 15 Apr 2005

While it is true that some rehitnamas have been contaminated by the enemies of Panth and they added anti-Gurmat stuff in there but this does not negate the whole rehitnama or those commands that are in accordance to Gurmat. ----------- 'Sikh hoye sir topi dharrey, saat janam kushti hoye marrey' (a sikh who wears a cap will die a leper for 7 births) has this ever been proved, does it seem logical ? ----------- What proof do you want? This hukam of the rehitnama is a very important hukam in order to protect dastar from vanishing from Sikh Panth like it did from the Jewish faith. Guru Sahib's hukam is to wear a dastar and no doubt if a Sikh wears a topi or a cap that person will dies seven times a leper i.e. in a very diseased condition. This hukam is an eye-opener for those misled Sikhs who wear baseball caps when they go out. ---------- Did Guru Nanak Dev ji Pardoned them all ? or Did he not ? If he Pardoneed them, then will a sikh guy who has worn a Cap on some occasion, not be pardoned and left to be born and die as a leper for 7 lives ? ------------ This rehitnama is not talking about not forgiving a person who commits this offense. Any offense or violation is pardonable if a person follows proper protocol i.e. repents from making the mistake and then presents himself before sangat seeking forgiveness but if a person wants to continue wearing the baseball cap and then beg before Guru Sahib for forgiveness; that person will never get Guru Sahib's forgiveness. One has to stop committing the violation, feel true remorse and then alone one can be forgiven. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Call to Akal Takhat to dishonour some Rehitnamas

Kulmohan · 15 Apr 2005

Veerjio, I don't want a proof of an unreasonable statement. You have talked about following the 'Hukam of the Rehatnama' , but I question the authority of the rehatnama writer, who wrote the lines 'Sikh Hoye Sir Topi Dharey Saat Janam hoye Kushti Hoyey marey' Religion to me is all about love, all about compassion, all about pardon Only if we are to believe in Gurbani, Gurbani (read below) has tons of love and loads of compassion to offer for our souls "Kaun ko kalank rahyo, raam naam leit hi, patit pavit bhayey raam kahet hi" ("Has there ever been a sinner who has not been pardoned by the utterance of the word RAM") friends, In the light of compassion and pardon extended by the words of Gurbani written above, I would urge you all to unburden your souls and urge you all to rid yourselves of the feelings of guilt, feelings of sin over such petty things as wearing a cap. But Instead of Gurbani, if we choose to be a believer in everything that some of the Rehatnamas would say, we stand to be a loser. In doing this, we are sacrifising the comfort of Gurbani and succumbing to the fear psychosis of Rehatnama Bahmanwaad, that has been handed down to us by our older generations. I am not saying that everything in the Rehatnama is incorrect, but only asking that Akal Takht and the Vidvaans of the panth sit down and decide what is incorrect and what is not.

Re: Call to Akal Takhat to dishonour some Rehitnamas

Kulbir Singh · 15 Apr 2005

Kulmohan, ------------- You have talked about following the 'Hukam of the Rehatnama' , but I question the authority of the rehatnama writer, who wrote the lines 'Sikh Hoye Sir Topi Dharey Saat Janam hoye Kushti Hoyey marey' ------------ Before questioning the authority of the writer of these lines, please let us know what is wrong in this. If you read Gurbani, you will find harsher statements for some offenders. Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee in Majh kee Vaar says that if Jainis (an ancient religion of India) don’t believe in taking shower and cleaning their body then may the ash of seven chullay (clay stoves they use in India) be on their head (satt chuliyaan dee suyaah uhna de sirr pavay). There are many more examples where harsh language has been used for serious offenders. A person who claims to be a Sikh and still wears a topi would surely meet the fate written in the rehitnama i.e. will die seven times suffering from a disease. This person is already suffering from a mental (inferiority complex) and spiritual disease( of disobeying Guru Sahib). What surprise is there if this person also gets a physical disease? ----------- Religion to me is all about love, all about compassion, all about pardon ----------- I agree it is about compassion but why should anyone get pardon if that person does not seek forgiveness? Where does the rehihtnama say that this person will not be forgiven if he or she truly seeks forgiveness? ------------ "Kaun ko kalank rahyo, raam naam leit hi, patit pavit bhayey raam kahet hi" ("Has there ever been a sinner who has not been pardoned by the utterance of the word RAM") -------------------------- And what Guru ka Naam Abhyaas Gursikh will want to wear a cap or a topi? And if this person does choose to wear a topi and thus disobey Guru Sahib’s hukam then no amount of paath or naam will save him. For such persons who want to disobey Guru Sahib’s hukams but want to japp Naam, Guru Sahib has written that their sewa of Naam and Gurbani will never get accepted by Guru Sahib. ----------- friends, In the light of compassion and pardon extended by the words of Gurbani written above, I would urge you all to unburden your souls and urge you all to rid yourselves of the feelings of guilt, feelings of sin over such petty things as wearing a cap. ------------- Sadh Sangat jeeo, please don’t listen to Kulmohan’s ignorant appeal and don’t believe that wearing a cap is a “petty thing”. What is petty is the punishment i.e. dying 7 lives as a kusthee i.e. a diseases person. They deserve something much worse than this. -------------- But Instead of Gurbani, if we choose to be a believer in everything that some of the Rehatnamas would say, we stand to be a loser. In doing this, we are sacrifising the comfort of Gurbani and succumbing to the fear psychosis of Rehatnama Bahmanwaad, that has been handed down to us by our older generations. ------------- If you call this “fear psychosis” then you would probably call the reference to Narak and Jamdoots the “Fear psychosis” as well. Right? To suffer the negative consequences for violating Guru Sahib’s rehit despite being a Sikh cannot be called fear psychosis. Kulbir Singh

Re: Call to Akal Takhat to dishonour some Rehitnamas

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 16 Apr 2005

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH. If the intention is to "weed out" certain anti-gurmatt practsies mixed in with the Rehatnamas....its OK with me... BUT on this TOPI thing..I am 100% BEHIND DASTAAR. This is an unviolable LAW of SIKHI.....ONLY DASTAAR and under no circumstances any other thing like cap/topi/helmet etc. This is a very BASIC and FUNDAMENTAL Principle of Sikhi and Amrit.....no compromises can be made on this. And YES "IF" one accidentally or otherwise wore a cap etc...then ONE can go to the PUNJ and ask for FORGIVENESS....and it will be granted....the INJUNCTION is Against INTENTIONALLY wearing something other than DASTAAR. GURBANI nowhere states that it is OK to go on sinning/going agianst the laws of gurmatt....and then ask for forgiveness..and then continue your old habits..and ask for forgiveness....THAT IS A JOKE ?? I suppose a sinner can go through hsi entire life "sinning" and then at the very end ask for "forgiveness" and Guru Ji may/may not forgive him..BUT I wouldnt want to take THAT RISK !!! NO way..I may not be in time to ask for forgiveness..then what ?? Chaurasi lakh joons await me....I would ratehr Listen to Guur Ji NOW and HERE...and GURU JI says NO TOPI. Jarnail Singh

Re: Call to Akal Takhat to dishonour some Rehitnamas

khalistani · 16 Apr 2005

if one commits the worst sins, every single sin, but at the end remebers vaheguur je even once he will be spared and taken to sach khand guruj e forgives all sins in one breath but the thing is, will u have the kirpa of remebering him?? bhula chuka maf

Re: Call to Akal Takhat to dishonour some Rehitnamas

jaoks · 16 Apr 2005

if one commits the worst sins, every single sin, but at the end remebers vaheguur je even once he will be spared and taken to sach khand guruj e forgives all sins in one breath ummmm NO!! not sachkhand- how can he be equated with great gursikhs with just one swaas...life as human again? yes maybe

Re: Call to Akal Takhat to dishonour some Rehitnamas

singh · 18 Apr 2005

khalistani jee is right: a(n)th kaal naaraaein simarai aisee chi(n)thaa mehi jae marai || At the very last moment, one who thinks of the Lord, and dies in such thoughts, badhath thilochan thae nar mukathaa peetha(n)bar vaa kae ridhai basai ||5||2|| says Trilochan, that man shall be liberated; the Lord shall abide in his heart. ||5||2|| [%sig%]