Forum
eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
JSS · 11 Apr 2005
God is one- the Ominipresent, the Omnipotent, the Omniscient, and is best represented by His NAME, theSHABAD or WORD or LOGOS or NAAM. The entire universe is existing and sustained under His supreme law. This supreme law is called HUKAM.
The more we meditate upon his NAME and contemplate on His virtues, the more we enjoy His Presence and Bliss.
The meditation on SHABAD alone will lead us to the inference that there is, in this creation, onl ONE GURU and Dispeller of the Darkness of Ignorance, and Harbinger of the Light of Knowledge.
Thus, SHABAD is the Supreme GURU of all and the Revealer of the Reality.
Such a GURU has only:
1. One Sermon to preach to all humanity
2. One knowledge to disseminate
3. One light to show the way out.
'Tis all one, all One,; the same, the same, the sam, the same EVER...
Gurbani embodied in Guru Granth Sahib is the sermone of ONE, the Supreme God of all. Guru Gobind Singh bequeathed this Gurbani as the ever-living Guru of all. Whatever is from the Divine, is, therefore, univeral, and not sectional or sectretarian at all.
The Gurbani that descended down to man and mankind through the Body called Guru Nanak, was this very SHABAD-Eternal, whose visible forms may vary, but Essence remains the same....
Naam, or Word, or Logos has no caste....
It is for all, being above all, above caste, coummunity clime and country; it is as much for the masses as for the classes.
And those, who followed the teachings of Guru Nanak, came to be called "sikhs"
A sikh is one, who is a student of the spiritual science ( a devoted disciple of the Guru), one who willingly and voluntarily comes forward as a seeker of the Supremem, and to that end is ready to receive spiritual instructions.
Thus, the word Sikhs stands for those, who came to Guru Nanak seeking to know his SHABAD.
Guru Nanak bani or Guru Nanak's Word or Gurbani is meant to enlighten and illuminate the entire mankind.
To say that Guru Nanak is, or was a Sikh Guru, and Gurbani is for the Sikhs only - spoken or sung or written by a Sikh Guru - is to disown Guru Nanak and belittle bani. It is as bad and as wrong as branding the Sun, the Moon, the Stars, the air and the water we live by!
Only because Guru Nanak-bani or Gurbani has been propounded in what we like to call Punjabi, it does not follow or mean that it has to remain confined to the punjab or must be kept confined to the Punjabis or to Punjabi speakers only.
Let this be made very clear that the WORD or SHABAD is the only Guru - because it alone is capable of removing the darkness of ignorance, being itself Prakash Sarup
Remember:
Shabad is Prakash-Sarup; and Prakash is Shabad-Sarup
Therefore, our Psyche or Surat is to be attuned to, and to be made to live at, "at-one-meant" with these both - forming a -
"Shabad Guru, surat dhun chela"
Surat-shabad prakash.
The Nirankar expresses HIMSELF through His "shabad" in order to enlighten the whole humanity, and in the process becomes mankind's Guru, the only Guru, the Sat Guru:
Aad-ant ekay avtara, soi guru samjhio hamara.
He who be Sans Alpha, San Omega, and ONe and the same EVER,
Know ye Him, and Him alone, to be our GURU - The Dispeller of the darkness of our ignorance.
It is unwise of us to tend to limit the UNLIMITED! there we err.
So the urgent need is to be 'introverts', seeking the Supremem "within" the centre of us, the core of us, the remotest recesses of our heart. 'Right-About-Turn' and inward march - deeper, deeper, deeper, down to on ABSOLUTE.
What we call 'religion' is in a sense, two progned or two faced or two aspected.
One aspect of it is the 'outer' aspect and that we term as karm kand.
But it is to be remembered that this karam kand was never meant to be an end in itself.
It is only a 'means' to an end.
the other aspect is to enter within and that is the END.
For, only when we merge with the Ultimate, do we begin to live for ever.
If the karam kand does not justify itself, with that end as "END", it is useless for us, for, it's only objective is to impel us , to compel us and to propel us 'inward' - to drive us deep within, and deeper and deeper and deeper, till we arrive at the ultimate Depth, and are able to say to ourselves:
NIJ GHAR (My own home)
Just to teach us this, Guru Nanak toiled taking ten different Bodies and full two centuries and a half to drive the lesson home - this lesson of Returning Home; and thus putting us in direct contact with the Shabad, the Ultimate.
How much did people heed then, and how much do we heed now?
Does, or does not our 'honest answer' put us to shame- burning shame?
And that is the trouble; that is the tragedy
- with our entire being,
- with the entire fabric of our Society today,
- with our leaders in the political field, and
- with our leaders in the religious field and more with them than with any other.
Before the Bar of Divine Justice, our religious leaders will be judged and found wanting and worthless clay; will be called to account and, you can well imagine what will be the judgement.
The Jyoti or the Prakash that impelled and propelled the Shabad-Sarup Body, named Nanak and the Bodies that followed, now dwell in Sri Guru Granth Sahib. Thus, this is the eleventh Body that NANAK Abides in and resides in; this Holy Guru Granth Sahib that we see here is the emobdiment of the JYOTI - the Prakash - the Sefl-Effulgent Light Eternal, as also the Shabad- Brahm - thus of both Shabad and Prakash: hence, venerable and worthy of worship.
Since it is that, it goes without saying that Sri Guru Granth Sahib, the sup-up of Shabad-Prakash, summed up in this Body, will ever live, survive and surmount all winds and whirlwinds and all the onsloughts of the diabolical forces of darkness.
This LIGHT will out-light all darkness, and out-shine all lesser lights.
We have to meditate on this SHABAD, ponder over it, and imbibe it - by turning inward....becoming INTROVERTS (antar-mukhi).
For then and then alone will the secrets of the Gurbani be revealed to us.
This Shabad-Guru is ever with us.
Shabad alone as GURU can best perform this function.
And we are NOT goig to be blessed with all these Blessings till we turn WITHIN- INWARD.
We people do not need or deserve all this talk, for we are not an entirely ignorant lot. We already know much. And we know enough. Not that we do no know, we do know. Only we have deliberately and consistently chosent to ignore this lesson.
we don't care, and,
We don't want to be bothered!
We have become what we were when Guru Nanak's advent took place half- a-millenium ago. We are today what we were before His advant. All what we now have for Guru nanak or Guru nanak bani, the Shabad Guru and the Gurbani is a 'deaf ear' or 'indifference'!
To understand and imbibe the DIVINE WORD, we have to make a 'RIGHT-ABOUT TURN', turn inward within aided by advice from Enlightened Souls. Their sangat (company) will lead us on - deep down to the remotest recesses of teh ETERNAL and the ONLY REALITY.
The SHABAD or REALITY is 'Only One' - not two; no dulaity is involved.
THe Truth or Reality is One. The learned ones expound and propound it in various and varied ways - the Muslims one way, the Christians another way.
But the actual-factual Reality remains the same, the same EVER; the Eternal and Infinite.. It is the ONLY REALITY.
EKO YAZDAN, DEEGAR NEST
God alone is there, nothing else exists - except in name and form.
The ultimate reality Namless and Formless.
We have to search for it, find it, locate, reach it and realise it in our 'insides' - within our 'within' - in the 'within' of our within - by churning that 'within' of ours.
We have to search and find the LIGHT or PRAKASH that the SHABAD is.
BUt the tragedy with us all is that we, like the winter-rats, have gone deep down into our dark holes, obstinately refusing to receive LIGHT that is being beamed at us by Baba Nanak. We singh Nanak's praises, but do not practice his advice.
What wisdom!!
We have become the silk-worm - warm in its cocoon - quite oblivious of the Prakash witin and the Prakash without.
And all this only because of our 'illusionary EGo'
We have carefully and confidently confined ourselves to a closed cage- caught in an EGO complex of our own making.
Again, what wisdom!!
Heeding to the Shabad-GURU or GURU-Shabad or Guru-bani is the ONLY WAY OUT, to get out and to remain out of this world of negative thoughts and materialism. I repeat, the Gurbani way or the "nanak way' is the ONLY WAY.
This is the only way that will take us out. AND keep us out.
Out of the maze of, this muck, this mud, this quagmire.
This Art or this Science, we will learn only in the University of Sadh-Sangat, with the Gurbani as our Guide and Text.
Sadh ke Sung Nahin Kuchh Ghal,
Darshan Bhetat Hote nihal.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Bhopinder singh · 12 Apr 2005
jss ji
What is your stand on sikh freedom KHALISTAN.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
KHALISTAN ZINDABAD · 12 Apr 2005
sikhs will get sovrein rule as prescribed by the Guru.
KHALISTAN ZINDABAD.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Piara Singh · 12 Apr 2005
I have read what Jss wrote somewhere else too.
Oh yes some body by the name of "Khoji" wrote in a booklet
Although what is written is a good philosophy, I was not impressed because it is the copy of the mixture of "Emerson" "Prof. Puran Singh" "Bhai Vir Singh."
Books written by "Khoji" is compulsary to read by Dodra Sangat. Are you from Dodra Sangat Jss.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Kulbir Singh · 12 Apr 2005
---------
To say that Guru Nanak is, or was a Sikh Guru, and Gurbani is for the Sikhs only - spoken or sung or written by a Sikh Guru - is to disown Guru Nanak and belittle bani. It is as bad and as wrong as branding the Sun, the Moon, the Stars, the air and the water we live by!
-----------
JSS jeeo,
Could you please elaborate on this?
In my humble opinion, Teacher can only be teacher to those who accept to be his or her students. Same way, Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj is Guru to only those who submit to Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj and become his Sikhs.
I don't understand how Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee would want to be Guru of those who don't want to become his Sikhs. Those who call out to Guru Sahib and those who open their hearts to Guru Sahib reap benefits of being a Sikh.
Other than this, this is a good article. Thanks for the article JSS jeeo.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Dogma · 12 Apr 2005
Kulbir Singh Bhai Sahib Jee!
I think that phrase about Gurbani not belonging only to Sikhs may have been in accordance with "Gurbani Iss JUG Meh Chanan". No offence to any other faith out there, but I have had the oppurtunity to read some of the "bani" from other faiths. In my opinion, nothing is as deep as Gurbani. Nothing as advanced as Gurbani either. Of course...I may be biased (MOST LIKELY).
That's why, it's is my FIRM belief as well that Gurbani cannot and SHOULD NOT be limited to just Sikhs. I think Gurbani should be heard by anyone who wishes to hear the words of the Divine! Even listening to Gurbani and understanding what it has to say will AUTOMATICALLY turn the motivated devotee onto the path of Guru Nanak!
sunee pukaar dhaathaar prabh gur naanak jag maahi(n) pat(h)aayaa
From this thukh, I think that Guru Nanak was sent here for ALL of this world.
But I agree with you Kulbir Singh, we can only be GURU kay Sikh if we follow the hukam given to us by Him.
Please correct me if I have said anything wrong..
Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
JSS · 12 Apr 2005
dear veerjis..
this article is a english translation of a speech taht bauji gave at a samagam in 1982...i posted it up here because of it's take home message is that Guru Granth Sahib ji is our shabad guru from whom all spiritual wisdom is to be obtained from.
dea piara singh ji,
bauji's lekhs aren't compulsory for anyone to read...they are read at sangat and samagams just like any other gurdwara where you might have a kathavachik doing katha..same thiing...
i don't think bauji copied anyone...he wrote what came to him after doing khoj of gurbani and doing simran...rightly so..it makes sense that his writings would be similar to those great gursikhs like bhai veer singh ji and prof puran singh ji...
Dear Kulbir singh ji...
the way i interpreted this section:
"To say that Guru Nanak is, or was a Sikh Guru, and Gurbani is for the Sikhs only - spoken or sung or written by a Sikh Guru - is to disown Guru Nanak and belittle bani. It is as bad and as wrong as branding the Sun, the Moon, the Stars, the air and the water we live by! "
i interpret this to mean that Altough guru nanak dev ji began sikhi and is a sikh guru...He is also the guru of the world....i interpret that as meaning the teachings of our beloved Guru jis should be spread to every corner of the world...i take this as a challenge to myself to firstly read gurbani, do khoj of gurbani, do simran, do paat, do seva...and then go out and help spread this divine wisdom of our gurus....to others...it shouldn't matter that someone isn't a sikh by definiition....we should show them gurbani...and i BELIEVE that once a person has seen gurbani...seen this great treasure, this ocean of spiritual wisdom, they will want to become sikhs of guru ji...and slowly slowly more people as they get exposed to gurbani will give their heads and truly accept guru Granth sahib ji as their guru...could you imagine the whole human race becoming amritdhari?...i dunno...that's my intepretation of it...
i know it's been said by outsiders ( not within the religion) that todays sikhs should be ashamed for keeping Gurbani out of the eyes of the rest of the world...for it is perhaps the most complete spiritual guide in the universe... and i have seen the effects gurbani has on people who are not sikh....i know a bhenji who happens to be white...first time she attended a samagam...she fell in love with gurbani...she then went home...taught herself to read gurmukhi...started doing paath...then just two years ago gave her head to guru ji...and when her family found out..they were upset at first but now she has introduced them to gurbani...and they are trying to read and understand it too...
another thing just popped up in my mind...
i once heard that to be a disciple, one needs a teacher/master...
but on the other hand, to be a teacher/master...one does not need disciples...for one has to only have mastered the subject/art that they are supposed to be master of..
likewise...i believe that Sri Guru Granth sahib ji is teacher/master/guru of the world...and that doesn't need to be substantiated by guru ji having students...rather He is there for all...it is up to the people to recognize the master and become His students....
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Bhopinder singh · 12 Apr 2005
What is the stand of dodra sangat on Khalistan and also can you tell if the respected bau ji ever said anything with regards to Khalistan or sikh freedom as it was going on when he was alive any personal talk or any lekh please.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Piara Singh · 12 Apr 2005
I think JSS is misleading the sangat by saying that what he wrote is from a speech given by Bau ji in 1982. I have read the same in a book written by Bauji.
I have seen a video in which Bauji claims that he had a Hukam from Guru Nanak to extend his life to serve the sangat, This is self proclaimation of Sant hood.
I have listen to the speeches by this man, in which he makes fun of people
in sangat by calling their names.
In the same speeches he says one should steal to go to Dodra and Samagams.
In the same speeches he gives good example of Mahatma Gandhi (Where as Gandhi was against sikhs).
He gives example of self less seva of Mother Teresa, which is true. But how about Bhagat Puran Singh no mention of him why. To make a lecture in a
pind in Panjab what example one should give.
People call him Guru Nanak in front of him and he says nothing that means you accept it.
****Admin cut. Please ask questions respectfully. ****
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
JSS · 12 Apr 2005
Bhopinder singh ji...
it needs to be clarified that "dodra sangat" isn't an organization like the akj or damdami taksaal...in the way that it doesn't issue out stands as a group....
if you were to go to a sadh sangat samagam...you'll see people from the AKJ there, you'll see taksali singhs there, you'll see american singhs there...you'll see singhs who only attend sadh sangat samagams...everyone is welcome to sit in guru ji's hazoori and enjoy the bliss of simran, seva, kirtan, sangat...
i don't know if bauji ever mentioned anything about khalistan...i think each member of the sangat looks at the issue of khalistan for themselves and makes a decision for themselves....for me personally....
i agree with idea of khalistan...but i feel at present we need to concentrate on educating the youth about sikhi....here in canada, US and in india...we all know the stats of drugs, teen pregnancy, crime among the youth in punjab... i think we need to tackle these issues...help the you become the khalsa that is deserving and ready for the responsibility of khalistan...
it's like sant attar singh ji said i believe...
tha when all sikhs start getting up at 3am, doing ishnaan, do their nitnem, do simran..then khalsa raaj will be possible...
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
JSS · 12 Apr 2005
piara singh...
sorry...but you are mistaken.... what i have typed up is exactly from an english translation of bauji's speech in dodra in 1982.... i could send you a copy of the translation booklet...then you could see forself..
secondly...bauji didn't say that he got hukam from guru nanak to extend his life....he says he got hukam to do seva of spreading sikhi....
i have all the speeches of bauji...and have listened to them...no where does he go around making fun of people...
he mentions names of people in sangat, of sevadaars in the sangat...uses examples..never made fun of anyone...
you really need to go listen again...
i think you've got your facts wrong and twisted.... you obviuosly have your own agenda...and i'm tired of trying to correct the misconceptions spread by hateful nindaks like yourself...
anyway your post has nothing to do with the original post...if you'd like to discuss anything...you should stick to the topic...which is eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichar...
no one calls him guru nanak....and if you actually did listen to any of the tapes..you'd know that he used to say that "i am nothing...nothing but a slave of guru ji...time and time again...he used to say "don't come meet me...i have nothing....go to sangat"...
the very fact that you forgot to mention these things..shows that you have really NOT listened to anything....probably not have read much either...probably not have attended samagams...
but that's okay...you go on and keep doing ninda....continue to ruin your life..cuz that's really all you're doing....
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Bhopinder singh · 12 Apr 2005
I appreciate your answer. Please try let the sangat know about the issue.We can do that by writing lekhs about freedom and its utmost need.Once again i thak you for answering my question.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Bhopinder singh · 12 Apr 2005
In my humble opinion i believe Jaswant singh ji never called himself Guru Nanak cause there is no such evidence. its a different story if somebody else did it.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
yo mamma · 12 Apr 2005
a former akal takhat jathedar was quoted as saying any sikh that is not KHALISTANI...
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Piara Singh · 12 Apr 2005
How old are you JSS, I am old enough. My Dad used to go to Dodra. No more.
I have original tapes, You might have edited version. I don't want to mention people's name here who Bauji made fun off and the whole Sangat laughed with him.
You cannot deny Dodra Sangat is not an organization. It is an organization
which is run by bunch of people in Dodra. All the Jathedars are appointed by Dodra from India. Anybody who goes against the Tenets of Dodra is let go.
Money goes from foreign countries to India. It is just like Radhasaomis and Nirankaris.
To Mr. Bhopinder Singh "If Jaswant singh ji never called himself Guru Nanak"
If people called him and He did not do any thing about it, That means he accepted it.
[%sig%]
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
singh · 12 Apr 2005
i remember reading a thread on sikhsangat board few months ago bout khalistan... and jss was totally attacking the idea of khalistan. so were all the other dodra affiliated people on the site as well. finally, some guy pointed this out, that dodra seems against khalistan, and they all stpoped relplying right away. but here jss says he's in favour of khalistan, what's up wid that? should stick to your stand, man.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
JSS · 12 Apr 2005
Piara (ironically)
i don't have edited versions of the tapes...cuz i have the ACTUAL original recorded tapes..the tapes that ALL OTHER copies were made off of...
i never denied dodra is an organization..i said it's not an organization in the same way as the akj or taksaal...it's run differently...operates differently...
yes..the sevadaars in each city are appointed by the committee in pind dodra...what's your point???
seems like you're picking on anything to make sangat look bad... but obviously even a ten year old could tell that you got nothing...
calling sangat radhasoamis and nirankaris????....wow...you are totally off the rocker on this one...here let me try to educate you a little...
sadh sangat (dodra) samagams are APPROVED and fully SUPPORTED by akal takt....if you ask akal takt for their stance...they'll show you the letter written by the akal takt jathedar in which he clarifies all doubts of dodra samagams being panthic...he even thanks and conveys his admiration for the way in which samagams are run and all the amrit sanchars going on...
even more recently two years ago akal takt jathedar came to dodra during the samagam (i was there) to present a chandni to the committee and again thank them for all the sikhi parchar going on at samagams...
if you call yourself a sikh that means you bow to the authority of akal takt... or maybe you don't consider yourself a sikh...
furthermroe..you keep making this assertion that bauji didn't say he wasn't guru nanak...but i told you to listen to the tapes and that you'll see the humility that bauji had....but i guess you aren't interested...you're just interested in doing ninda of gursikhs....of gurmukh piyaraay who have sacrificed everything in seva of guru's sangataa....
that's okay...you'll meet dharam raaj one day..and he'll deal with your case...not my place to do anything....
once again...your reply has nothing to do with the original topic at hand....i ask the admins to either close this topic or keep everyone at the topic at hand...
oh one more thing....just somethiing interesting i noticed.....people like piara and other nindaks never leave an email address or anything like that....i wonder why they hide... they act like such defenders of the panth..but yet hide behind their computer screeens.....shows us all how much faith we should put into anything you have to say....
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
JSS · 12 Apr 2005
i never attacked khalistan...
i attacked the idea the it is the most important task right now...
i believe that MAKING khalsas to inhibit and then take responsibility for khalistan is more important right now...
when khalistan is finally made...i'd want to see gurmukhs running it...not politicians...if it's going to be politicians...well...we already know the situation in punjab as it stands...
i hope i have made myself clear...
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
<> · 12 Apr 2005
<>
even Sant Attar Singh said, when the sikhs wake up 3am for naam then they will get a Rule. It is our problem that the day keeps on getting delayed.
Are you going to kick out all the other people and run the country with the 1000 odd gursikhs that you can find?
Bhai Rama Singh in his book said that it suppose to be like SachKhand on earth.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Dogma · 13 Apr 2005
Piara Veerji,
"Let this be made very clear that the WORD or SHABAD is the only Guru - because it alone is capable of removing the darkness of ignorance, being itself Prakash Sarup "
...Didn't Bauji himself clear up the issue of WHO Guru is? If Piara Jee says that he thought of himself as Guru Nanak then why would a person so intent on creating a "Gurudom" be saying that SHABAD Guru is the ONLY GURU?
"Thus, this is the eleventh Body that NANAK Abides in and resides in; this Holy Guru Granth Sahib that we see here is the emobdiment of the JYOTI - the Prakash - the Sefl-Effulgent Light Eternal, as also the Shabad- Brahm - thus of both Shabad and Prakash: hence, venerable and worthy of worship."
...Again, is it just me or did Bauji just say that Guru Nanak resides in Guru Granth Sahib? Did he just say that only Guru Granth Sahib Jee is worthy of worship? Piara Jee, you have stated that you agree that these are the words of Bauji. Please explain why would he be praising Guru Granth Sahib and claiming that the jot of Guru Nanak Dev Jee is in Guru Granth Sahib Jee while at the same time saying that he Guru Nanak (as you say)?
"Since it is that, it goes without saying that Sri Guru Granth Sahib, the sup-up of Shabad-Prakash, summed up in this Body, will ever live, survive and surmount all winds and whirlwinds and all the onsloughts of the diabolical forces of darkness. "
...what's this? MORE praise for Guru Granth Sahib Jee?
Veerji, please make statements based on facts. JSS Veerji has posted the words of Bauji for ALL to see and ALL to comment on. However, you speak of imaginary tapes of which only you have.
I disagree with JSS veer about something though. I ask ADMIN to NOT close this thread. Piara Jee I would like to hear your comments on some of the quotes that I have posted above.
Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!
p.s.> I congratulate JSS veerji on his post as it *may* eradicate some of the bias that is associated with Dodra/Sadhsangat. Many people have a negative attitude when it comes to Sadhsangat and/or Bauji. It is nice to have someone actually POST Bauji's thoughts on Gurmat for all to view and discuss. I believe this is very GOOD way of alleviating some of the doubts associated with Sadhsangat. Education dispels ignorance.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
singh · 13 Apr 2005
Why do people hate so much, calling them nirankaris radohswamis that just uncalled for. I dont know anything about dodra never been to a program or anything but in general they might not be as strict as akj or taksal but they seem panthic to me. What happened to ekta within the panth, agreeing to disagree all that stuff.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Piara Singh · 13 Apr 2005
Dogma Ji,
Let me make it clear that I have never mentioned that Bauji himself claimed to be Guru Nanak. What I said - to elaborate if you misunderstood is that If some one calls you Guru Nanak and you are quiet being a head of an organization, that amounts to accepting it may be in the form of Sant, Guru
etc. If you are not familiar with The Deras like Radhasaomi or Nirankaris, Gobind Sadan or other Sant Deras,they all have Guru Granth Sahib.
What made you say that my statements are not based on facts and Yours and JSS are based on facts.
How can you say that my tapes are imaginary and JSS's are not. You are being biased.
I did ask few questions before, admin cut it. I will ask again respectfully and tell me in if these are the facts or not.
What was Bauji's stand when a Dodra preacher from Calgary was convicted of molesting girls. Did he condemned him (No)or barred the affected families from Sangat (yes).
Why was the woman called Mataji living with him, what example is that to society.
Isn't it true one of Bauji's daughter is film actress (yes).
Moreover you are no body to judge me if I am a Nindak. Bringing out facts does not mean Nindiya. The facts, probably you are naive not to know.
Every body defend the organization they belong to, You ask a Radhasaomi or Nirankari or any sect anybody belongs to they will always defend them.
Baba Maan Singh has good thoughts about Gurmatt so is Balraj Singh of Calgary, I have heard his tapes original not imaginary.
Dhanwant Singh has good thought about Gurmatt so is Santokh singh Dharam.
You don't have to listen to noobody except "Guru Granth Sahib" and understand the Grammer.
I surrender my case.
[%sig%]
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
jss · 13 Apr 2005
piara nindak...
all your questions have been answered on this board a while back...
you should do a search on this forum and will see that all of them were answered and your slanted thinking is totally off ...
first off...balraj singh...the man who was convicted has never attended a samagam since the time he was accused...further proof....he has been out of jail for a couple of years now and is not allowed to attend any samagams...he tried to go to dodra a couple of years ago..wasn't allowed to step in...tried to go to see mataji...wasn't allowed either....
so if that doesn't spell condemnation...you must be very warped....again...your accusations are baseless...
and it's funny you'd bring up an instance that happened more than 15 years ago and was dealt with in a matter that NO other jathebandi has dealt with...
i could cite you examples in the jatha of at least TWO kirtanis who still attend samagams who have been accused of several indecent actions...the admins of this site know who i'm talking about... but since noone has had the guts to take legal action, they cannot name them here right now...
and your second accusation..another baseless accusation...
mataji was a sevak of bauji...she was a sevadaar...who lived and studied with bauji....where in sikhi does it say that only males can learn from spiritually enlightened souls....for you to think anything else just shows the DIRTY mind that YOU have... oh well...keep it up.....if your goal is to go through 84 lakh joons...you're doing a great job...
what bauji's daughters or sons do is of no consequence to him or the sangat...i don't know if you know this..but right after bauji's wife passed away, he had a meeting with all his children and told them that he was given a seva by guru ji (as any other parent is given) to look after his children, he provided them with guidance as a parent, made sure ALL of them got higher education, and they were all well settled...he said now is the time for me to do seva of sangat....from now on...you shall be to me as any other sangat...no attachment....
what does that tell you???
furthermore, i have never heard of his daughters being an actress...if you wish to bring up accusations like that plz provide proof...of course you dn't have any...nor have you provided an email address where we could get a hold of you and discuss this...of course not...cowards like you never provide that kind of information...
you say that dodra is like the radhasoamis and nirankaris..once again...i suggest you take that matter up with akal takt..who OBVIOUSLY as mentioned previously fully APPROVE and SUPPORT the samagams... it is easy for you to sit behind your screen and say whatever crap that comes out of your demonstrated dirty mind...i find it interesting that you could not comment on the fact that akal takt came to dodra two years ago...maybe you skipped over that part...maybe you're soo set in your twisted thinking that you cannot see reality...or maybe you did see that part but you have no RESPECT for the institution started by our guru jis...
and another thing...next time you're in india...go to the nirankari headquarters, go to beas...go to the naamdhari place..you'll see their gurus there..they'll fully claim to be gurus..and when one guru dies they appoint another guru...
then go to pind dodra...in the entire compound... you won't even see bauji's name anywhere except at the lekh stand where they distribute the gurbani vichar lekhs....and even then...all it says in his lekhs is "khoji"....ever think why he didn't put his real name???....possibly out of pure humility??? but of course a nindak's mind cannot go to those heights in thought...
you won't see any pictures of bauji...or mataji...nothing of that sort....
all you'll see pretty much every where on each building, in each room is pangtis from gurbani painted for people to concentrate on gurbani...you will see the maryada that is kept there...you will see the satkar for guru ji...
and you keep saying bauji didn't deny he was guru nanak....but if you look at what he wrote...no denial is necessary..becasue he CLEARLY outlines where guru nanak's jot is to be found : GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI...
oh..btw..it is not me who is calling you the nindak... i just read gurbani...and gurbani describes to us all what a nindak is...gives us a clear description of what a nindak because guru ji wants us to steer clear of niindaks...and lets just say....i won't in your company anytime soon...
i don't know what more you would want...but this is my last post in response to you...you not only have done nindiya of a great gurmukh but you have steered away from the topic of this thread...i don't know why the admins keep allowing you to steer the topic away at hand....which is Eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichar...
like dogma said..it would nice to have a discussion based on what the gurmukh piyaraay have said....although it looks like with this group, it's highly unlikely...
with that said..
i would like to thank Kulbir singh ji for two reasons....one for keeping his reply directed to what the topic of the post was, for discussing the bachans of a gurmukh...
and two...it is well known that me and kulbir singh don't agree on issues concerning sangat....but i respect the fact that he doesn't hide behind a computer screen...provides his email...has invited me to tapoban sahib in the past... that said...i hope this thread put his concerns of "gurudom" to rest as i believe that bauji's thoughts express his undying devotion to guru granth sahib ji, the shabad guru, the jot of guru nanak.......
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Dogma · 13 Apr 2005
Piara Singh Jee,
my apologies if you felt I was biased. I did not want to come off as being as such.
"If some one calls you Guru Nanak and you are quiet being a head of an organization, that amounts to accepting it may be in the form of Sant, Guru
etc."
...Wouldn't you say that the original post by JSS in which Bauji clearly states that Guru Granth Sahib Jee is GURU is NOT keeping quiet? This was katha given in front of an entire congregation. Would you say that is keeping quiet? Personally, I think this speaks volumes more.
If someone asked me in privately "Are you a Gursikh?", I can
a: keep quiet (which last I heard does not AUTOMATICALLY imply that I agree with the statement)
b: Stand up in front of the whole Sangat and proclaim that I am NOT a Gursikh.
I think the fact that Bauji in his katha and writing has repeated COUNTLESS times that Guru Granth Sahib Jee is the ONLY Guru. What more evidence do you strive for Singh Jee?
WHY are you taking his SILENCE and twisting it to fulfill your own views? Why not listen to HIS WORDS? Surely, a man's WORDS count more than his silence?....no?
Although the rest of your questions have been answered before on this forum (please SEARCH), I'll provide brief answers as per my knowledge.
"What was Bauji's stand when a Dodra preacher from Calgary was convicted of molesting girls. Did he condemned him (No)or barred the affected families from Sangat (yes). "
Veerji, if you wish to genuinely ask questions, please do not provide your own answers. ****** Singh was not allowed to enter back into Sangat. He is still currently unable to attend any samagums since what he was convicted of doing. (Guru Sahib maaf karna if I am doing any Ninda of anyone). Secondly, no such thing as a Dodra preacher...not even sure what that means.
"Why was the woman called Mataji living with him, what example is that to society"
...again, please perform a search on this topic. I believe JSS's answer is much more clear and concise compared to anything this moorakh can provide you with.
"Isn't it true one of Bauji's daughter is film actress (yes)."
...not sure what this has to do with anything. I thought we were talking about Bauji's character. Now we're going after his children?
"Every body defend the organization they belong to"
That's true of anyone veerji, Taksal, AKJ, Nanaksar. I agree with you.
"Moreover you are no body to judge me if I am a Nindak. Bringing out facts does not mean Nindiya. The facts, probably you are naive not to know."
...I'm not judging you veerji. Please do not think this. I never said you were a nindak. However, the fact remains that I too have listened to Bauji's talks and read his writings and I do not find anything that is against Gurmat. Nor do I find him to be propogating any type of Gurudom.
To be perfectly honest veerji, your arguments are quite loose and you have no evidence which support them...
You're assertion that he has accepted some type of Santship is refuted by Bauji's OWN words that JSS has posted.
You compare Dodra with Radhaswamis and Narakdharis but AKAL TAKHAT disagrees with you.
Nirankhari's, Radhaswamis, Gobind Sadan...all refer to a SANT. Never has JSS or myself refer to Bauji as Sant Jaswant Singh. Still you speak of this Santhood...
Why this hate for Bauji veerji? It is quite obvious that you were at one time quite involved with Dodra Sangat since, according to you, you have many different type of tapes available to you. Do you have an agenda against Dodra Sangat or Bauji? Based on your statements it seems you do veerji. You seem very determined to prove that Bauji is some evil person who encouraged anti-panthic/anti-gurmat ideals.
If you wish, you may take JSS and I as examples. Ask either of us and I'm sure we'll tell you that I only regard Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee as my Guru. Doesn't this mean anything to you?
maaf karna if I offended you in the slightest Veerji.
Despite our differences I still remain,
Your humble Veer.
Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Piara Singh · 13 Apr 2005
JSS Should refrain from using foul language -"What ever crap comes out of your demonstrated dirty mind"
It is not What ever. JSS is in a state of denial and trying to justify the
actions of Dodra.
Don't mislead people by shouting and calling names.
Why don't you ask Dogma to give out his e-mail. Most of the posts doesn't have e-mails and I have the right to do so.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
jss · 13 Apr 2005
Piaray nindak...
your last response shows how much you hate you have in your heart and how little substance you have...why?..because we have given you facts and you have not been able to respond to anything....that's okay...i'm sure the cyber sangat can see what a joke your posts are...
also..yes you have the right not to give you email...
however, when someone makes such bold, baseless accusations and then doesn't want to give an email, doesn't want to give contact info, doesn't want to be held accountable for their disgusting words, one and only one thing can be inferred...that you are a COWARD!...not only a coward but a LYING COWARD!!...
btw...i think you need to grow up..i didn't use foul language anywhere...
"crap" - an accurate way to describe everything you've writtten
"dirty" - an even more accurate way to describe everything that is contained in your mind...
in fact it is you who are in denial because you refuse to accept the facts, refuse to acknowledge the facts, or even at least try to refute the facts...
fact is...you have nothing to go on...fact is...the HIGHEST institution in sikhism, Sri Akal Takt Sahib totally disagrees with waht you have to say...and fact is...this is the third time i'm telling you this...either you read very selectively or have no regard for akal takt sahib...which one is it veerji???
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
singh · 13 Apr 2005
One point. Akal Takht didn't go to any smagam or dodra pind or anywhere. The main sevadaar at Akal Takht Sahib (or Jathedar if you will) may have come, but not the Akal Takht sahib. Just a technical point, but it is a big different. Also, as far as I know, smagams of anyone except SGPC are usually not 'supported' by Akal Takht sahib. Officials may attend and may not disapprove, but once again, there is a difference.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Heera Singh · 13 Apr 2005
DUDE GIVE IT UP.... sheesh... ur wasting EVERYBODYS time including ur own... with the amount of time u spend doind nindya u could be reading gurbani or even one of bauji's lekhs :)...
your REPEATED attemps to give sadh sangat (dodra sangat) and Bauji a bad name have been shot down with evidence... don't u ever give up?? seems like u have nothin else better to do ... ah well... if u want to disrespect a sangat or a gurmukh, that's ur own choice... i would love to see the peoples reaction if somebody said that about Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh and the AKJ.... and u know what.. it wouldn't happen because nobody is that ignorant...
with unbiased and FACTUAL evidence JSS veerji and Dogma veerji have answered all the questins thoroughly... however u CONTINUE to spread ur slander.... i think the whole sangat needs to ask WHY?? and don't say u don't have a hidden agenda because it's VERY OBVIOUS that you do.. quit playin games, stop talkin smack... and either a) stick to the topic that JSS veerji lovingly posted for the sangat (which YOU are the ONLY person who seems to have a problem with, and YOU are the ONLY person which has gone OFF TOPIC) or b) stop spreading ur slander or c) simply do not post ur garbage on this post.. if u wish to learn more or discuss more in depth about sadh sangat make a new thread... or to save everybody the headache, search old threads...
now PLEASE STOP WASTING EVERYBODY'S TIME....... THANK YOU..!!!!
Vaheguruuu Jee Ka Khalsaaaaaaaaaaaaa
Vaheguru Jee Kee Fatehhhhh..!!!!!
[%sig%]
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
amrithari · 14 Apr 2005
Just a side note, Akal Takht also says only amrithari people can do keertan on stage. So take note Dodra Sangat, if you want to use Akal Takht as your reference point.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Apr 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki Fateh.
Singh Ji is 100% RIGHT.... the "Akal Takhat" also came to SELAYANG....and our Gurdwara has Langgar on Tables and Chairs...but "Akal Takahat" didnt say a word !!!! is that APPROVAL ??
The "Akal Takhat" also came to KUALA LUMPUR....and removed His Sri sahib and handed it to a lowly Security Guard.....even before the Singh Ji's accompanying him were running around trying to convince the Higher ups that this was Sikh highest Authority who should be allowed to carry His sri sahib with him...they werre SHEEPISH when they found they did the running around for nothing !!!
The "Akal takhat" also attends weddings of ordinary people/friends/ and sant smagams of sant deras..etc etc IT DOESNT MEAN APPROVAL at all...for the Simple Reason that THE AKAL TAKHAT doesnt go anywhere...It is the Takhat Of Akaal..and is sthir in one place.
Lets NOT DROP this August name around....haan ji IF there is a WRITTEN BLACK AND WHITE HUKMNAMA from Akal takhat about anything..that holds some weight !!! ( Not much as the Selayang experience shows..but something...???)
Jarnail Singh
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
jss · 14 Apr 2005
jarnail singh ji and singh ji,
i understand waht you are saying,
however, i have said time and time again, that dodra committe DOES have WRITTEN approval from AKAL TAKT...it IS in BLACK and WHITE....signed by akal takt jathedar...
and when the jathedar came to dodra samagam, they didn't come as individuals but as representatives of Akal Takt...and they came for the specific PURPOSE to present the chandni and acknowledge the seva and parchar being done.....
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Dogma · 14 Apr 2005
Amrithari Jee,
Kirtan (Devotional Hymn Singing by a Group or an individual)
Article VI
(a) Only a Sikh may perform kitran in a congregation.
Definition of Sikh:
Any human being who faithfully believes in
(i) One Immortal Being,
(ii) Ten Gurus, from Guru Nanak Dev to Guru Gobind Singh,
(iii) The Guru Granth Sahib,
(iv) The utterances and teachings of the ten Gurus and
(v) the baptism bequeathed by the tenth Guru, and who does not owe allegiance to any other religion, is a Sikh.
Please note the word "believes". Although personally, I believe that ALL kirtanees should become amritdhari at some point in their lives. But at the same time, I cannot tell a young child that he/she cannot do kirtan because they are not amritdhari. This is quite similar to Jatha programs or Gurmat Camps where young children amritdhari or not are allowed to do kirtan. With that said veerji, I must say that over the past few years the INFLUX of kids and adults recieving the gift of amrit has been exceptional! I believe you would be proud to see so many people becoming Gursikhs. Allow me to relate a personal story...
I was on MSN just a few days ago with a Singh that I know. Last time I saw him he was a mona struggling with family to let him keep his hair and wear a distaar. When I spoke with him, he showed me a picture of him in a distaar! Although, he still didn't have that much kesh, he still looked GOOD. In any case, he was speaking with me about how he wanted to recieve Amrit but was "scared." I asked him if he had been keeping Rehit. He said that since he started keeping his kesh in August 2004 he had not missed doing Nitnem. Needless to say, I was QUITE impressed. I know AMRITDHARI Singhs who don't have that kind of record. Veerji, this person had learned to do kirtan and also plays tabla but has not yet taken amrit. In the span of a year or so, he's managed to keep his kesh, start wearing a distaar, learning all of the Panj Baniya and becoming serious about taking amrit! Now here's the kicker...He's only a teenager, 14 or so! I can relate probably 5 other stories similar to this off the top of my head to you veerji. My point is that although you may find that having someone who is NOT amritdhari doing kirtan and other seva is wrong...I think that it is nothing but an aid in pushing a person to fall at his Guru's feet and recieve Amrit!
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Piara Singh · 14 Apr 2005
JSS
You may say whatever you want to say "Baseless allegations" "little substance" "COWARD" "LYING COWARD" "CRAP" etc. these are all name calling and it shows which sangat you belong to.
None of my statements are baseless. They are all True. Why don't you pickup the Newspapers from 90s, The posters of the facts of Dodra posted in the Gurudwaras of North America.
Heera singh ji how could you claim that Statements of JSS and Dogma are unbiased and "FACTUAL" and mine are not. Probably you are in the same group.
I am not only the person having problem. You are well aware of other posts and different people who write about Dodra group.
How can JSS, Dogma, Heera Singh say I have hatred for Bauji. Bringing out FACTS is not hate. As a matter of fact Dogma called Nirankaris "Narakdharis", that is hate who are you to call them Narakdharis.
JSS called me all the above names that is hate.
What hidden agenda you are talking about. If you are getting headache
don't get invovled in discussion.
By the way you know Bhai Puran Singh The Granthi of Darbar Sahib attended a function of RSS (Rashtriya Sikh Sangat) a branch of RSS(a radical hindu group).
No more post from me.
[%sig%]
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Bhopinder singh · 14 Apr 2005
I think piara ji is bent upon dividing the panth,If the sikh brothers are time and again saying GURU GRANTH SAHIB as guru why should we put words in their mouth .Do we want them to argue the opposite? will that make us happy.
I think jss , heera and the other veer have cleared the doubts and i take them for their word.Please dont misunderstand i have never gone to any of the samagms at the same time i have never gone to any samagms of taksal.Taksal is panthic and so are these singhs.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
jss · 14 Apr 2005
again..another post by piayara ji...with no new information...no refuting of information provided but yet the same crying about "facts"....and saying he doesn't hate...
and then again, no email provided...i wonder why does he want to hide behind the computer screen..i mean...you're supposed to be this gursikh who isn't afraid of exposing anti-panthic elements..well then do it the real gursikh way... take the example of kulbir singh ji... me and him don't agree on everything, but i respect that he doesn't hide behind a computer..he is stands behind what he says like a man, a gursikh...
and piara ji..do you believe EVERYTHIING you read...especially when it's from secondary or tertiary sources?...would you believe that there's a letter in BLACK and WHITE signed by akal takt jathedar....which would you like to believe....punjabi newspapers or written approval from akal takt...you make the choice...
i'm glad you decided not to post anymore... it's about time you realized that your attempts to defame the character of gursikhs were pretty lame....
best wishes
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Dogma · 14 Apr 2005
You're right veerji, I shouldn't have called Nirankari's Narakdhari's. Although I believe they are excommunicated from the Panth....whereas Dodra is not.
"What hidden agenda you are talking about. If you are getting headache
don't get invovled in discussion"
No veerji, no headache here. It just seems that you never answer any of the questions that are posed to you by myself or JSS. Meanwhile, JSS has given you clear and concise answers to all your questions. Perhaps it's you who's getting a headache. It's hard when you keep churning the propaganda machine and no one's buying your cra..."merchandise".
"By the way you know Bhai Puran Singh The Granthi of Darbar Sahib attended a function of RSS (Rashtriya Sikh Sangat) a branch of RSS(a radical hindu group)."
...hmmm, interesting. So WHO can give credibility to this sangat in your eyes veerji? Apparently the jathedar of Akal Takhat, REPRESENTING Akal Takhat, is not good enough. Now you say something about the Granthi at Darbar Sahib? 'Let's face facts veerji...to be a Granthi at Darbar Sahib is no easy task. I'm sure this man is waay more of a Gursikh than you or I. But apparently you think everyone doing seva at Akal Takhat or Darbar Sahib are just a bunch of clowns. Nothing can change your mind can it veerji?
Then how about you answer this for me? BHAI SAHIB BHAI JEEVAN SINGH JEE, expressed his LOVE for Bauji and praised him as well. Now if you want to add ninda of BSB Jeevan Singh along with your ninda of Bauji then please....step right up! I'm waiting for you to say something about how BSB Jeevan Singh cannot be trusted as well because he did ____(fill in blank with baseless allegation) _____.
You'll have to excuse my tone in this post veerji, it just seems you like to duck all the questions posed to you by JSS or myself. This really annoys me. I don't mind discussing things but it would help if you actually realized what the word DISCUSSION means. An EXCHANGE of ideas. Not advertising your own opinions and ignoring people's responses to them. If you're so SURE of your position that Bauji is such an evil person then you should have the courage to back it up....otherwise you're just another Internet-Sher (Lion).
"No more post from me."
...let's hope. Because this is NOT how I planned on spending Vaisakhi.
Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
jaoks · 14 Apr 2005
*****Admin Cut-Your comment will trigger hatred********
Piara Singh, You HAVE NOT provided evidence. Your whole story is made up from propaganda and i request you to stop.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
jaoks · 14 Apr 2005
and nirankaris are NARAKDHARIS...
I completely agree with dogma
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Apr 2005
just a small puzzle...can one "beleive" in AMRIT of Guru Gobind Singh Ji....and NOT be AMRITDHAREE at the same time ??
Its EASY to say.. I "BELIEVE" in the Ten Gurus teachings, utteraances, Teachings, Guru Granth Sahib Jee......BECAUSE NO ONE can LOOK inside ones heart and CHECK....
BUT AMRIT CHHAKNA is a THING everyone can SEE..Being an AMRITDHAREE is VISIBLE to sansari eyes....so how does one "beleive" in AMRIT and yet..cut hair, trim beard, and NOT keep AMRIT REHIT.
I beleive the Para (V) in the Definition of SIKH in the Rehat maryada above makes clear that a SIKH MUST be an AMRITDHAREE...otherwise without AMRIT a "sikh" is NOT a "sikh" as defined and thus NOT entitled to the Privileges of Kirtan/Katha/Paath in Diwan of Guru Ji.
The "beleifs" in the first 4 paras can be hidden but NOT the "BELIEF" in AMRIT....because that requires POSITIVE VISIBLE ACTION.
Can somebody who advocates kirtan/katha/Paath/Hukmanama/Ardass/Akhand paath raol by cut haired/beard trimmers Kirtaniyas/kathakaars/Granthis...care to Elaborate how the above para in the Rehat maryada exempts all these from being AMRITDHAREES. because IF such a "sikh" can perform KIRTAN on Gurdwara Stage....WHY cant He do ARDASS, Take Hukmanama, Do Akhand paath, Distribute Degh...???? WILL this be considered as "pushing away" such "sikhs"...driving them away from Sikhi /? Where do we draw the line. First it was argued..Whtas wrong if the Tabla Player is Ghona.Monah ( he is just playing the tabla for heaven's sake !!)..so IF a Monah can play the Tabla in a Kirtan Jatha...why CANT he play the LEFT WAJA...WHY CANT he Play the MAIN WAJA ?? WHY cant he then Go TABIAA and Take the HUKMNAMA....proceed to DO ARDASS.... Proceed to distribute Degh....and IF a MONAH can do all those why cant he be the JATHEDAR of the PANJ PIYARAS at an Amrit Sanskaar Ceremony ?? YAAA I was talking about "where we draw the LINE "??? Yes where ?? at the TABLA PLAYER STAGE or AT the JATHEDAR STAGE ?? after all we dont want to be accused of DRIVING AWAY a Potential JATHEDAR ??? or just tabla Player ??
Jarnail Singh
PS I DONT HATE MONAHS "LESS" or LOVE AMRITDHAREES "MORE"...each has its own place in Sikhi...and the boundaries should be respected by all. ALL monahs can very easily become AMRITDHAREES in order to perform all the actions of kirtan/katha etc.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Heera Singh · 14 Apr 2005
"No more post from me."
... thank the lord.....
"Heera singh ji how could you claim that Statements of JSS and Dogma are unbiased and "FACTUAL" and mine are not. Probably you are in the same group."
wow... what logic... where does it come from???... so that would mean the Bhopinder Singh Jee is apart of the same 'group' as u call it?.. yet he has said himself that he has never attended a samagam organised by Sadh Sangat...
so wait... would that make Bhai Sahib Bhai Jeevan Singh jee apart of the same 'group'?? or how about Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh who himself had respect or bauji... he never said ne wrong about bauji or the sangat... if the sangat or bauji were SO anti-panthic, why are there NUMEROUS sants, gurmukhs, and gursikhs that read bauji's lekhs?
so what next... u've insulted bauji and the sangat... are u gonna start badmouthin his lekhs.. which by the way translate and quote gurbani...??
bro u need to open ur eyes.. and ur MIND... and PLEASE stop hurting urself...
"None of my statements are baseless. They are all True. Why don't you pickup the Newspapers from 90s, The posters of the facts of Dodra posted in the Gurudwaras of North America."...
pick up a newspaper from the same time frame and u'll see it says that those 2 gursikhs that were charged in the air india bombings were terrorist... however they were proven not-guilty were they not???
challo... ur life.. u do as u please... the sangat humbly requests u stop ur slander... heck.. u have all these claims, why not come out to a samagam and see for urself?... i dunno what experiences u mite have had, but that was a while ago... if ur referring to that thing that happened more then 15 yeasr ago (which i don't know much about myself) thats DONE with.. it's been settled.. it was taken care of.. nothing like that has ever happened since then.. be happy that the sangat decided to take the issue head on and settle it... rather then hiding behind it and pretending like nothing happened, which is what u see every so often these dayz...
bhul chuk maaf....
Vaheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Jee Kee Fatehh....!!!
[%sig%]
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
jss · 14 Apr 2005
just a clarification...
at samagams (at least in NA) kirtan is not done on a stage...the sangat sits together on the floor facing guru ji and does kirtan together...in one sense, no one is actually leadng the sangat in kirtan except for guru ji..the person at the vaja is really just playing the vaja and doing their seva...half the time, most people dont even loook up or even know who is doing kirtan...they are just absorbed in kirtan...
also...
in pind dodra, there is a stage, and i can say that 95% of the people who do kirtan on that stage are amritdhari...the few that aren't are working their way towards that..(i'm talking about adult kirtanis)...they are actually pretty strict with the kirtanis who do seva over there...i know of at least three bhens that do not get any kirtan time anymore there because of choices they've made...
last thing about rehit maryada...
the fact that SGPC has wrote "faithfully believe" instead of "must have taken" amrit....leaves room for interpretation...i've asked friends who are english majors, modes of reasoning majors..and they all agree that by writing faithfully believes does not mean "must have taken"...although it is assumed that the person should be trying their best to adhere, and moving in the right direction...
just my perception on that issue..
interesting discussion topics...
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 15 Apr 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh.
And we all ignore a very very important point from our History.... GURU GOBIND SINGH JI....did not waste any time waiting/considering etc BEFORE ASKING FOR AMRIT from the Panj Piyaras....IN FACT GURU JI was the FIRST PERSON t take AMRIT from the PANJ.....and just REMEMBER HE WAS GURU JI...not an ordinary "SIKH".....
BUT today "sikhs" can be heard saying...." ia m sehajdharee"....I am considering it.... I am not yet ready Ji...I will take it when I am ready ???? When is a person ready ??? He is "ready" to perform kirtan/kathapaath BUT not ready for Amrit ?? How come ??
I am puzzled and intrigued as to what types of "sikhs" all these people are..They Beleive in the Ten Gurus, Guru Granth Ji' teachings, utterances, etc etc etc.....BUT NOT IN AMRIT...the absolute PINNACLE/APEX of the above mentioned Guurs and their Teachings...
Jarnail Singh
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Bhopinder singh · 15 Apr 2005
jss veer
It is very clear on who should do kirtan vaak distribution of deg and the jathedars of the punj so there is no doubt about that.One of my friends who goes to dodra pind says 100% kirtan is done by amritdharis only and there is no exception in this rule it is only the people away from india that are making their own laws.
Law has no exceptions or it is not law.A very good friend and learned sajjan of mine reads a lot of gurbani but is bare face and he always tells me that the thing of uncut hair should be changed so that he can take amrit .He has been going to sangat for the last 15 years and still believes in the same thing.My answer is always no it cant be cause you dont want to change yourself but you want to change everything also why do we talk of Bhai Taru singh ji he could have done the same.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
jss · 15 Apr 2005
bhopinder singh ji
i respect what you have said...
but at the same time i have seen the changes in people's lives when they come to sangat and do kirtan...( vaak, distribution of degh, panj piyaraay is without a doubt seva of only amritdhari gursikhs)...
kirtan...is simply singing guru ji's bani...and the way the samagam is organized in NA..is that everyone sits on the floor together facing guru ji....and everyone is doing kirtan together...should we also be going around in sangat and spotting non-amritdharis and tell them not to recite during kirtan?...should we tell them to close their mouths?...(not being argumentative...just want to know where we all draw the lines)
again back to the changing of lives..i have seen soo many people go from totally not into sikhi , then come to sangat, they love listening to kirtan, start learning to do kirtan, then start getting in to the meanins of the shabads, falling in love with guru ji's pavitar bani, and then give their heads to guru ji... i mean in the last two to three years soo many youth have taken amrit at samagams...and i honestly don't think they would have done so if when they came to samagams, the amritdharis told them to sit quietly and don't get involved in any way...i believe that they would never return to a samagam and be put off from sikhi...it's not watering down sikhi, but it's about working with people, giving them love, telling them the sakhis of our guru ji's, exposing them to gurbani...and then they will CRY and BEG for panj piyaraay to give them khanday battay da amrit...
i know in our own family, both my parents were amritdhari since before i was born...but they didn't tell me or my sister to take amrit...HOWEVER, we grew up in a household where there was always paath going on, kirtan, siimran, our parents took the tiime to make sure we knew about how Great our guru jis were, and how great gursikhs of the past and present were...instead of telling us to take amrit, they created an environment where me and my sister yearned for khanday battay da amrit....and then guru ji blessed us with it...and that's what happens with a lot of kids in sangat...so many little brothers and sisters in sangat have been taking amrit because they are INSPIRED to take it....i think that's key....
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Kulbir Singh · 15 Apr 2005
JSS jeeo,
It is okay if sabat-soorat (ones who don't remove hair) kids do kirtan even if they are not amritdhari but to allow those individuals to do kirtan who have removed their hair including their hair on the head is totally wrong. To allow a monna person or a person who consumes drugs including liquor, or a person who actively commits sin of fornication or adultery, to lead sangat in doing kirtan is totally wrong. Such persons are welcome to come in sangat and listen to kirtan or sing along but they can never be allowed to lead sangat in doing kirtan.
It looks horrible when you witness such bibiyaan doing kirtan who have done full make-up on their face or have defined their eye-brows by plucking hair of their eye-brows. What example are we setting if we allow such individuals to do kirtan in sangat? I think we are setting very bad example by allowing them to do kirtan in sangat. They are welcome to come in sangat but not to lead sangat in kirtan. This is totally unacceptable.\
And how can these non-amritdhari persons japp Naam when they don't have Naam? How can they lead the whole sangat in doing dhuni style Naam when they themselves are without Naam?
There should be no compromise on Gurmat principles.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
- · 15 Apr 2005
what is fornication?
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
----------- · 16 Apr 2005
for·ni·ca·tion (fôrn-kshn)
n.
1) Sexual intercourse between partners who are not married to each other.
2) voluntary sexual intercourse between persons not married to each other.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Apr 2005
IMHO it is "easier" to just look up the dictionary...but if one doesnt have one..then go ONLINE...
Online the answer would be even faster if you "Google" it..and much more comprehensive....I do that all the time.....and then spend so much more time as i find many interesting articles and info as well.
No offense..just advice.
Jarnail Singh.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
singh1979 · 16 Apr 2005
Recently one of my friend ask me to attend a Kirtan programme in Clevland.
I went with him on saturday.
I enjoyed the Kirtan done by a Bujurg then a girl.... . she was doing nice Kirtan too. Every thing went down.... when I opened my eyes..... She was loaded with make up.... her chunni keep coming off. Her hair were cut..and
she was wearing a low cut. I was totally distracted.... I told my friend I am leaving ...he ask me to stay till Bhog I didn't want to stay. We left for the day. He drop me back home which is 2 hrs drive. On asking him.... he told me that the programme is organized by Dodra Sangat... I didn't like it(not the Dodra sangat)
I didn't say any thing... I kept thinking may be my mind is dirty.... I decided not to go there.
I started attending the Akhand Kirtanias kirtan .... or I go to Gurdwaras and enjoy Kirtan by Ragis.
A personal thought I decided to share with you all.
Bhul Chuk Maffi
Guru Fateh
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
R Singh · 16 Apr 2005
Where to draw the line? That's a simple question with a simple answer. Draw the line with the kirtaniya's. When you start talking about picking out non amritdharees in sangat and stopping them from singing, you're just trying to sensationalize the issue. If you can draw the line at degh distribution, then why not kirtanyia? Also, there is a clear difference between the kirtaniya and the other sangat behind him/her. It's not as difficult to pick out the main kirtaniya from the rest of the sangat as you're trying to make it sound.
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Well · 16 Apr 2005
A Singh doesnt need to be at a very high level to work out the avastha of a Keertanee doing Keertan. When you have moneeaa and all sorts doing Keertan, alot of the Singhs will be able to tell, something aint right!
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Apr 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
all that "********" about "everybody in the sangat" is doing kirtna..blah blah blh and .."how to see who is doing what" ..blah blah. blah.."where to draw the line" blah blah blah is all GOOBLEGOOK and referred to as Dhuurr wich tattoo ralaonana...stir up so much "dust" that everybody gets confused......a MONAH is a monah and he cant be in the "Kirtaniya Group"...BUT HE/SHE can be in the SANGAT..and so this "undisguised attempt" to MIX up Sangat with Kirtaniyas is....self explanatory.
The KIRTAN JATHA can be as big as one likes....1 person...3 persons...30 persons...50 persons..BUT the "jatha" is well defined as LEADERS in the Sangat.......and the "members of the sangat" are also well defined.
During Guru Ji's time also there KIRTANIYAS were well known as such...ref Satta and Balwand...Dhadis of Guru Ji's Darbaar...here even when GURU JI PARTICIPATED in LIVE KIRTAN along with the SANGAT... the "kirtaniya" was still DEFINED as somebody apart from the sangat and Guru Ji. ( RE to Satta and Balwands action in getting "annoyed" with GUru Ji and going home to sulk "strike"...and make GURU JI beg for their "return"..IF EVERYBODY in the SANGAT was doing KIRTAN....why would Satta and Balwand resort to their action)...as always the KIRTANIYAS are well defined meembers of the sangat and not "each member" and no body knows who is who type .
Jarnail Singh
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Hakam Singh · 17 Apr 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki Fateh..
Daas has been spending time in Toronto with family for some time and nephew who doing study here has brought this site to my attention and topics which discussed. First you all Gursikhs blessed with good sangat in Toronto, very much unlike most other cities in USA and Canada. I was happy to read many of the posts that come up and discuss Gurbani—very proud of the positive effort being made. But very disaapointed to read some very harmful writings that people have written. I believe this murakh can add something here to dispel some doubts some persons may have.
We must be careful in not doing ‘nindia’ of Gurmukh piyaray roohan. Daas has spend much time doing sangat of many oochay soochay jeevan valay gurmukhs. Daas' has grown up in family blessed by Guru Sahib and with sangat of such Gurmukh piaray such as Sant Baba Jwalla Singh Ji, Sant Baba Harnam Singh Ji and Bhai Sahib Bhai Jeevan Singh Ji. Although I do not know Bau Ji (Jaswant Singh), I have read many of his lekhs on Gurbani and can say that anyone who has done abhyaas and kamaii will find nothing wrong with them. I have also listened to many of his talks, some of which I have kept personally and given to my family here. In one of his talks on tape, which I can provide for any gurmukh veer who needs, please forgive, for I have tried to do my best for direct english translation:
in talk on ‘Rabh kyon nahi Milda’: Bau Ji was talking to sangat and said as follows: “saday oothay Dasvay Patshaaa nai kinni kirpa keeti hai, panth sajhya aur Dassan patshaian da saroop bakshia, jis de pichay Dassan Patshian di daaamnik shakti hai, Mahaaan shakti, aainee oochi Durho hoiii ayeee‘direct’ Bani, jairee hor kisay Dharam vich hai nahi, jairee aaatma-Rabh nal mel karwaa sakdi hai---par assi es mahan pavittar Bani di asleehat nahi pachania, es da amal nahi kita, kadar nahii kiti! Kinii sharam vali gal hai, ke assin Patshah de Patshaah, Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji de Sikh hundia, asi maya vich fusssay hun. Kinni sharam vali gal hai! Jis maya vicho es Gurbani sahnu kadhan ahyee si, osay maya vich ussi changee tarraan vich fussay han’ Aur es Bani di ek thuk nahi saday hirday vich vasaieee, ainaa kirtan karday haan, aynay akhaand paath karday hun par saday ek joon nahi sarkdee kion ki saday othay haumai de sanjor (metal armor of haumai) payhay hun’ Gurbani de desh athay bhavna tho ussi vanjhay jaa ray hun. “Ehs pavittar Bani, Patshaah da Patshaah hai, sada Guru hai-Dhan Guru Granth Sahib! Eh sirf matha tekan vastay nahi—ehnoo jeeauuna hai (we have to live it)†[this is just introduction, talk continues]
Someone in sangat then says “tussee kirpa karoâ€. Then Bau Ji reply pause, and then give reply that “nahiiiiii Bhaiiii…..nahii……kirpa Guru Nanak di hai! Kirpa Guru Nanak ne karni hai! Dhan Guru Nanak! Guru Sahib aaap kirpa karan ge—sangat de vicho, kion ke ‘vich sangat Har Prabh vasay jeeo’ Eh gal kai ke tussee Sangat nuu hi condemn karkay sut ditta (by asking me to do kirpa on you, you have condemned ‘Sangat’ and thrown it aside). Pehal (priority) Sangat de daivo. Sangat! Sangat! Sangat! Jeevan valia di sangat karian karo—oh bhaii jithay 2, 4 baldi jot valay Gursikh hunday hun, ohna di bhaj ke sangat karia karooa. Waheguru ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh’
Someone also asked on this post what is Bau Ji says on Khalsa, in other part he is saying how we are lost people, walking around lost and not realizing we are sons of a King—“aapa haumai vich guwachay firday han, sanu patha hi nahi ke ussi ‘Kisay’ de hun, kisay Rajay de bachay han, assii Kalghian valian de Sahibzade han, eh sari duniaaa sadi jaidaaad hai, Khalsa hi Khalsa da raaaj!!! Par je aapa Gurbani de sur vich rahangai’ Par bhaii, eh gal aukhiii hai, gal hor hai—kamaii karni paiigeee [then in other part talks about shaheeeds]aapa nu samaj nahi lagdi, na aapa kamai karday han...Sant Siphai! Sant kidha ban sakdey jadho simran nahi karday? Dekho bhaii, jinay vi Gursikh shaheeed hoyay hun, ohna di Surti ehni pak gayeee sii ke ohna nai Guru de pyaar vich aapna sareer nu bulaaa ditta si, aapna aaap vaar ditta si, thay Guru Sahib agay bhet karwa ditta si (then gives further example of shaheedi) Par aaapna ki haal? Aaaapa tha simran vi nahi karday...Khalsay banay firday hun’ then ends of by talking about Guru Gobind Singh and how he was ultimate example of sacrifice and what touched me most was when he said difference or ‘farak’ between Guru Gobind Singh was that ‘Guru Kalghian valay di talwaaar vich Pyaaar Si’
Haiiii…Haii……Dhan Guru Gobind Singh Sahib!!!!!!! Someone earlier mentioned Bhai Taru Singh….vaaaaaaaaah…….mention of such name ‘sareeer nu hilaaa dinday.’ Bhai, how can we criticize such Gurmukhs who put us towards Guru Sahib? Death of the soul and utter suffering will be the result. I wish I had good fortune to know such person. I even heard my son say some people criticize Bhai Sahib (Jeevan Singh) on his rehit—how he is becoming birdh and doesn’t do Nitnem. Hai!!! Please, my benti at your charna, do not say such thing. You will suffer more than you can ever imagine! Dhan Gursikh!!! Someone earlier said mention connection with Bhai Sahib and Bau Ji—this is true, Bhai Sahib told daaas about ‘satkaar’ he has for Bau Ji and how he would often visit him in Ludhiana –he also told me how he once gave his favorite sarbh-loh mala to Bau Ji as gift. Bhai Sahib also gave me Gurbani Vichaar lekh when we both in U.S together about 20 years ago.
JSS and whoever else talk about this topic before, you seem at odds with your words, and seem harsh when talk to other singh ‘Piyaara’. Yes, he is wrong, but if you and other singh (above) have done sangat of this Gurmukh than you will speak with pyaar and do ardaas for that soul that Guru Sahib forgives him and gives him bibek budhii. That is path of Sikhi-forgiveness. It is obvious from some posts (JSS, Dogma, Heera jio) that you may have not read Bau Ji’s lekhs yourself or listened to his talks—may have cleared up misconceptions much earlier (maaf karma). Please you all, read Gurbani first and lekhs and talks of Gurmukh pyaray before you can tell others to do same. But must do Simran and abhyaaas. You all are pyaray Gursikhs who write on this posting need to do more abhyaaas. We all do. Maaf karna.
That is my only benti.
If somebody need talks and literature on Gurmukh Pyaaray (Sant Attar Singh, Khoji, Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh, Puran Singh, Bhai Veer Singh) please do not hesitate to email me. And if you have some things that can benefit this moorakh please share as well. Dhan Waheguru tera lakh lakh shukar hai...
Daas,
Hakam Singh (Principal)
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Dogma · 17 Apr 2005
" JSS and whoever else talk about this topic before, you seem at odds with your words, and seem harsh when talk to other singh ‘Piyaara’. Yes, he is wrong, but if you and other singh (above) have done sangat of this Gurmukh than you will speak with pyaar and do ardaas for that soul that Guru Sahib forgives him and gives him bibek budhii. That is path of Sikhi-forgiveness. It is obvious from some posts (JSS, Dogma, Heera jio) that you may have not read Bau Ji’s lekhs yourself or listened to his talks—may have cleared up misconceptions much earlier (maaf karma). Please you all, read Gurbani first and lekhs and talks of Gurmukh pyaray before you can tell others to do same. But must do Simran and abhyaaas. You all are pyaray Gursikhs who write on this posting need to do more abhyaaas. We all do"
Thank you for the slap in the face. It was much appreciated and needed. Of course everything you said was correct. Too often I got caught in my own emotions and forget about the pyaar I should have towards my fellow Gursikhs...even ones who think differently than myself. Nevertheless, I ask Pyaara Singh to forgive my comments if he found them rude. However, I would like to say I have listened to Bauji's talks and read his lekhs....but what good is it if I didn't absorb any of the message?
Lastly, welcome to the this forum Hakam Singh jee...I have a feeling that your posts will be a refreshing change to this forum.
Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
JSS · 17 Apr 2005
Dogma veerji summed it up quite well...
thank you for that wakeup call Hakam singh ji, it was much needed and hopefully with guru ji's kirpa, we may improve our jeevans...
and to Piyara singh ji, i 'm sorry i was rude when addressing you. I hope you can forgive me
Re: eka bani ek guru eko shabad vichaar
Heera Singh · 17 Apr 2005
Hakam Singh... ur right on...... i agree with Dogma veerji as well...
I ask for sangats forgiveness....
bhul chuk maaf....
Vaheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Jee kee Fatehh..!!