Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

united we stand divided we fall

united we stand divided we fall

raj karega khalsa · 10 Apr 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Sangat Ji one thing i've started to notice more n more is people callin themselves Akj Singhs , Taksaali singhs, Nanaksariyaan singhs also Goray Sikhs, Kalay Sikhs Nepalese Sikhs etc....Why can't we just be Singhs? On Vaisakhi in 1699 Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji created ONE khalsa panth, not Akj Khalsa Taksali Khalsa etc....We shud b SIKHS and SINGHS/ SINGHNIS of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI and KHALSa PANTh b4 AKj Dhaddrian Wale taksal etc...n dont get me wrong i like having differe jathas, many flowers in a garden are more beautiful than one boring flower...BUT we shud all rembr r roots, the Khalsa panth n our gardener, GURU GOBIND SINGH JI Bhull Chaak Maph Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: united we stand divided we fall

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Apr 2005

This is an "impossible" dream... Why do I say this ?? With Banda Singh Ji..the KHALSA was split into TWO - Tatt and Bandiyaa.....and then.. Just 30 years after Guru Gobind Singh Ji.....the 13 MISLS came about.......BUT THEY ALL had the SAME MARYADA....Those following a different maryada..the BANDIAS...failed and disappeard with the fall of Banda Singh bahadur. Until the Singh Sabha Movement ALL Sikhs belonged to ONE KAUM....but after 1984.... the various groups seem to be flourishing....some ( Narakdharees and Namdharees and even the Radhasoamis) are HERETICS but still claim to be SIKH PANTH...others like Nanaksar have a very SANTISH Maryada...more inclined towards Hinduism and Holy persons than SHABAD GURU- Guru Granth Ji...many more follow their own Maryadas which differ from one another... Until and UNTIL every SIKH follows the Maryada of Akal Takhat...there will be groups and jathas... The Guur Khalsa panth can sit down and make changes to the present Akal Takhat maryada...BUT ULTIMATELY the Entire Panth has to be UNDER the AKAL TAKHAT UMbrella...no more individual sant dera maryadas...until then dream on... Jarnail Singh Reality Check !!

Re: united we stand divided we fall

RosEEE · 11 Apr 2005

We are all one panth. I see no differences.

Re: united we stand divided we fall

Dogma · 11 Apr 2005

Interesting points veerji.. However, regarding the whole issue of following Akal Takhat Maryada.. I think many deras, jathas DO follow A.T. Maryada however, not ALL follow it to the letter. By this I mean.. Akal Takhat allows eating meat - most jathay strictly forbid this. Akal Takhat allows reading Raagmala - AKJ as well as others disagree. Akal Takhat says kesh is a kakaar - AKJ as well as others say KESKI is the kakaar. So how does one reach a solution?? I do not believe that eating meat is acceptable, however Akal Takhat says it is. So do I: a: Also start eating meat. b: Make my own personal choice to avoid meat while respect others who do? c: Avoid meat and try to convince others to stop as well? As you can see there's really not alot of options available. I don't think I can change the mind of anyone regarding eating meat when he/she can easily say "Who cares what you say AKAL TAKHAT says I can!". So the only logical option is "B". So veerji, although I agree that all Sikhs should be under the "Akal Takhat umbrella"...I don't think this answer will solve anything. The key, in my humble opinion, to a unified Panth is acceptance..tolerance! Can a Singh who believes in Raagmala, be content listening to an Akhaand Paath with bhog at mundavani/salok M:5? Can a Singh who believes in kesh as a kakaar be content to see bibi wearing a distaar and see her as a sister? THIS, imho, is what will unify us. Also, veerji, no offence directed at your generation, but talking with other singhs....the older generations have managed to spilt this Panth along the lines of Jatha vs. Jatha. Granted there are NUMEROUS loving older individuals in each different jatha, but there is also those people who "use" the youth as a means of spreading propoganda within the Panth in order to lift their jatha/group to some imaginary plateau. ....but i digress. So, in a nutshell, I believe tolerance (based on GURMAT!) is the answer. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!

Re: united we stand divided we fall

. · 11 Apr 2005

sikhs used to be poor humble simple but spiritually powerful relieing on Waheguru practically walking with their heads with mountain of faith. now their very educated smart well off at the price of religion going down. The price of religion down in each house, people end up blaming the standard of religion and look to belong to something they feel is pure. But what their soul is searching is inside them, not inside a name.

Re: united we stand divided we fall

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 11 Apr 2005

I agree with Dogma. Very well said.

Re: united we stand divided we fall

JSS · 11 Apr 2005

great post dogma veer

Re: united we stand divided we fall

kanwaldeep singh · 11 Apr 2005

that was very well put dogma ji. You have summed it up pretty well. [%sig%]

Re: united we stand divided we fall

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Apr 2005

Jss and Dogma..BOTH right. BUT the Akal takhat DOESNT ORDER us to EAT MEAT ( that is compulsory)..so there is actually a lot of leeway here. IT just BANS the "hypocritical" way meat eating is treated as was by the Brahmin Pandits of old... Secondly...the BHOG stops at mundawni....those who beleieve in raagmala can continue and there is nothing to stop them in a compulsory way as well..after all a lot of other things also continue to happen long after ardass and karah parshad is distributed.... Thirdly there is NO KESKI IF the KESH are NOT there....so IF you have KESH...it naturally follows that KESH MUST be RESPECTED and kept COVERED at ALL TIMES...Hence KESKI is a MUST....it is just a matter of egg came first or chicken !! NO KHALSA JI in his right mind would advocate keeping his Kesh UNCOVERED !!!..and a SIRGUM would naturally keep no keski around !!!!since he has NO KESH to cover/Protect. ALL these are very MINOR "differences" (IMHO).....those that we cannot allow are the Dehdharee Guurs, Wanna be Gurus, sants and Bedis Sodhis etc trying to push their Genes over and above the SHABAD GURU....NO WAY. Jarnail Singh

Re: united we stand divided we fall

Bored Boy · 12 Apr 2005

Here we go with the Sant Bashing. Again. Yawn.......Yawn. All our discussion lead to this. We really need some inspiring Gianis to post on this forum.

Re: united we stand divided we fall

5 rivers valey · 12 Apr 2005

i think its even more complex than that. if there was no akj taksal nanaksar group then people would divide themself up another way. As soon as mughals and rss are not around skhs start eating each other up. it is a mad thing look at the some of the most loyal panth wali jathas around akj and taksal even they have numerous splits. So as one group expands peoples opinions differ and then a little group forms and breaks off. sikhs have to get on with each other first.

Re: united we stand divided we fall

Dogma · 12 Apr 2005

"ALL these are very MINOR "differences" (IMHO).....those that we cannot allow are the Dehdharee Guurs, Wanna be Gurus, sants and Bedis Sodhis etc trying to push their Genes over and above the SHABAD GURU....NO WAY." Veerji, interested to know how you believe Sants break up the Panth. Please elaborate.

Re: united we stand divided we fall

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 13 Apr 2005

Dear Dogma ji, I would love to elaborate....but wouldnt "bored boy" be more bored ?? and i will wait for some "really inspired Gyani" ( whoever or whatever that is ) to come in and make bored boy stop yawning... seriously..we already know what i mean....the "sants" in So called SANT SAMAAJ..who insist on having their own petty little "Rehat maryada" to challenge the one already accepted by AKAL TAKHAT and the Guru Khalsa Panth for DECADES...are the ones trying to "crack" up the solid foundation of the panth ( UTTER FAILURE as the record of sant samaaj shows..but that wont stop them.) The "sants" who set up their own DERAS...and practise "wanna be GURUSHIP" are also into this....no need to elaborate on who and who as they are all very well known to all. Jarnail Singh