Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Dead body Vs Living Body

Dead body Vs Living Body

Kulbir Singh · 06 Apr 2005

I read the following comments by a person who viewed the dead body of Pope John Paul 2: [i] Marc Adam Werblowsky, composer As one of the Vatican’s singers, I was allowed to see the body before it was displayed for the public. His face shocked me – it was white, almost waxy. When I looked at him I remembered how he was when he was younger, full of energy. Now there has been this transformation and he looks so unreal - like an icon or a stone statue.[/i] This is not about the Pope, so please don't start any controversey about him. The thing to consider here is that no matter or material substance is missing from the body after death but still it becomes "white, almost waxy". Those who have seen a dead body know that how little resemblance is left between the dead body and the living body when the jeev was sitting in this aatma. Indeed the dehi or body becomes "bhasam kee dheri" or a pile of ash. Looking at the eyes of the dead body, you can't fail to notice that life is so blatantly missing from them. Same eyes, same everything but just because aatma is not there, they become totally lifeless. The strange thing is that despite the evidence that something goes missing from the body, most scientists ignore this reality. It is considered unscientific to suggest that soul or aatma or rooh has flown away from the body; therefore, no scientist who wants to protect his credibitily says anything about the aatma. They should do some effort to find out the subtle unseen reality of the aatma as well. But what can they, the unfortunate ones, do? They have not, the good fortune written on their foreheads, by mera Preetam Pyrara. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Dead body Vs Living Body

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 06 Apr 2005

there are some, who, because of bad deeds, look dead while living ...

Re: Dead body Vs Living Body

fff · 06 Apr 2005

Kulbir Veera, i'm no scientist, actually..i despise sceince:D but could it be that the skin looked "white, almost waxy" because the heart stopped producing blood? I mean, from a spiritual level, we all understand the aatma has left the body. It's impossible to ever really know... we essentially say that as soon as a body dies, the soul departs the body. therefore we can never really know if it's because of the soul, or the scientific reason behind the hearts lack of production of blood (and thus, circulation of blood)... but i guess i kinda see what you're sayin

Re: Dead body Vs Living Body

Singh · 06 Apr 2005

The body looks waxy in western countries a lot of the time because the face is actually covered in wax and make up. They do reconstruction work which makes the body look artificial. When this work isn't done, the body looks less scary and more life like like.

Re: Dead body Vs Living Body

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 06 Apr 2005

Quote: "They should do some effort to find out the subtle unseen reality of the aatma as well" 30 seconds on google says - there are many such efforts. http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=scientist+soul+hypothesis http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=scientific+soul http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=soul+debate+science

Re: Dead body Vs Living Body

Lakhvir Singh · 06 Apr 2005

WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh. KhalsaJi, When we witness the ultimate Truth, it dawns on us that we are all part of it. Some day, our day will come too, when our own body will lie just as lifeless when the Light within it ascends to its heights upon its departure from that body that housed it. If that house warmed the soul, it is blessed. If not, even the soul will find no peace and wander on into transmigration. 'Eh Sareera Mereea, Is Jag Mein Aye Ke Kya Tudh Karam Kamaaya?' Each Sikh of the Guru need to question the self, 'Oh body of mine, having come into this world, what deeds have you gathered?' It is the duty of the body to help the soul earn its Truthful gathering, because the body will not last forever, but the soul will. The soul needs to get back to its Maker and only the human body can help it. Taking a look at the body of the Pope, I'm sure many of us have witnessed it on television, the truthful soul weeps not for the body, but rather rejoices for the spirit that lived its earthly existence in a body that helped it remain attuned to God. The lifeless body shows not even the slightest sign of life as soon as the soul leaves it. But blessed souls do leave behind their body in a state of bliss. What do scientists know? Those who cannot acknowledge the vast expanse of the Creator, will never be able to understand the source of life. All their life, they will toil to explain how the body works, but will fail miserably when it comes to explain what kept the body ticking. It's only those who search their Roots that find the secret of their existence. WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.

Re: Dead body Vs Living Body

Simaro · 07 Apr 2005

Of course we know that a soul exists, but we can't prove it to other and so it does not fall under the umbrella of science. Science is all about demonstratable proof. If you can prove it to others, it doesn't exist as far as science is concerned. This is how it should be for science. Can you imagine what would happen if scientists started making medicine based on unproven facts? However, this self-imposed limitation to science has a downside too. The downside is that those who put all their faith into science alone will never experience that which is unprovable. I believe that the best scientists are those who endeavour to find new facts about the reality around us, utilising uncoventional or even "whacky" theories and methods. Who can be better scientists than the Sikhs of Satguru who investigate the soul, the true treasure in an otherwise dust-filled world.