Should we strive to do Kirtan in Raag?
Manvir Singh · 04 Apr 2005
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Should we try to learn how to do Kirtan in Raag and do our best to sing in Raag or promote Raag Kirtan.
Is it important? Should we know the meanings of Bilaaval, Aasa, Gauree etc and use the meanings and significance of Raag when explaining Hukamnama or doing Kirtan?
Bhai Gurdev Singh Ji Australia Vale is a nice example of an AKJ Kirtani who sings in Raag.
Food for thought.
bhul chuk maaf karnee ji
Re: Should we strive to do Kirtan in Raag?
can't think of a name.. · 05 Apr 2005
'Should we strive to do Kirtan in Raag?'
Yes.
[%sig%]
Re: Should we strive to do Kirtan in Raag?
Sarbloh Kaur · 05 Apr 2005
Dear Sohagani and other misguided friends,
Even many "tunes" are in fact done in raag. Lots of the keertan that we would classify as "just tunes" is actually done in Bilaaval raag. Even the Canadian national anthem is in Bilaaval. Don't be so quick to judge what is raag and what is not if you haven't really got a clue. Raag doesn't have to be in teen-taal only and doesn't have to sound like your typical pakka raag. It can sound like "just a tune", but only someone with knowledge of raags would know otherwise. Of course keertan should be done in raag, but don't be so quick to assume that it's not being done whenever you hear a common-sounding tune.
Re: Should we strive to do Kirtan in Raag?
Manvir Singh · 05 Apr 2005
People may be singing in Raag - but not always the Raag the shabad has been written in.
Re: Should we strive to do Kirtan in Raag?
sangeet teacher · 05 Apr 2005
sarbloh kaur,
you have a nice point, but unfortunately you miss the point of doing keertan in Raag. just because the tunes are in some Raag, doesn't mean this counts as doing keertan in Raag. Doing keertan in Raag consists of doing the Raag in the correct format, which can only be learned from a proper teacher. There are certain scales of how to up and down a Raag. Also, shabads are written in Raag as well as Tala. Some shabads are meant to have the words structered in a certain tune so as to portray the message best (this knowledge is only of guru ji, but the concept remains). Some shabads are meant to change taal, and if they do not, the shabad is not being sung according to Gurmat Sangeet. I assure you there are far more concepts to be learned in Gurmat Sangeet Keertan. You cannot just say some tunes "are still in Raag" so it's fine...infact, every tune in the world is in some kind of Raag, so your claimed point isn't really a valid point.
Especially at a place like Tapoban, where the Sikhi is preserved the best, they should also strive to preserve keertan the way it should be done, this would include using string instruments rather than vaja. as far as vaja is concerned, it is a very bland and very bad choice for use with keertan if you want to do keertan the proper way. Vaja is physically impossible of portraying the same Musical touch to Guru Sahib's keertan. This is why string instruments such as the dilruba, taus, esraj, rabob and others are used. they are capable of going where the vaja is unable so as to create fascinating keertan. It is especially best when it is done by someone who is learned in Gurmat Sangeet.
Only advantage of vaja is that it is easily accesible and many people can learn it and get into keertan via vaja. So that's good.
[%sig%]
Re: Should we strive to do Kirtan in Raag?
Sarbloh Kaur · 05 Apr 2005
Sohagani Jee, what's wrong with making up tunes? There has barely been any effort made to preserve the original tunes Gurbani was meant to be sung in (ie. "Tundday Asraajai kee dhunee" for Asaa dee Vaar, etc). There is nothing wrong with making up a tune as long as you stay within the "rules" governing the raag. So I would say just about every single tune of keertan you've ever heard has been made up.
Sangeet Teacher Jee, first of all, are you really a sangeet teacher? I agree with everything you've written. I was simply saying that raag is being done more than most of us realize. But you're correct to say that the amount of raag being done is definitely not in the correct format. I fully agree that keertan should be done in the prescribed raag, at the prescribed time, in the prescribed taals, with the correct instruments, etc.
Amandip Jee, those were some nice links. Thanks for sharing.
I'll just add another thing here as well. Part of the problem is with tablachees as well. How rare is it to find a tabla player who can play anything other than kaharvaa? Most cannot even grasp the right sum/khaali in a simple teen-taal cycle, what can we say about paRtaals? The issue with preserving proper keertan formats doesn't begin and end with just the keertanee. Our tabla players need some work as well.
Re: Should we strive to do Kirtan in Raag?
Sarbloh Kaur · 07 Apr 2005
Amandip Jee, why do you say that the following shabad is in Darbaari?
http://www.ikirtan.com/Bhai_Niranjan_Singh_Jee/Guru%20Jee%20Ke%20Darshun.mp3
I thought this was Kaanra?
Re: Should we strive to do Kirtan in Raag?
Sarbloh Kaur · 08 Apr 2005
Amandip Jee, I have a feeling that you're right but I'm not quite sure why. I've only studied Kaanra as "Naaeki-Kaanra" -- is that the same as regular Kaanra or is it a different mix?
Frankly, I thought it was Kaanra only because I've done a very similar bandanaa/beginning alaap as is done in that link, but I did it for a shabad which was definitely in Naaeki-Kaanra. The only difference seems to be when he ascends to high-Sa and the way he holds it there. For example, in the link, at around the 3:08 mark when he begins the tuk, "Charan kamal adhaar jan kaa" and he holds the word "kaa"....is that why it's not Kaanra? I can't pin-point the difference exactly...my ears aren't quite as sharp for noting such differences as they once were, but I'm pretty sure that indeed it is not Kaanra and I was wrong. Can you tell me why you think it is Darbaari? Does Darbaari stay lower as opposed to the ascending nature of Kaanra, or is it the other way around?? I'm glad you knew it wasn't Asaa though.
Another question since I've finally found someone who seems to know this kind of stuff -- why isn't Naayeki-Kaanra in the Kaanra thaat? I think it falls into the Kaafi thaat. Is that right? Shouldn't it fall into its own thaat the way Shudh-Kaleyaan belongs to the Kaleyaan thaat and the way Asaavari belongs to the Asaa thaat?
Re: Should we strive to do Kirtan in Raag?
Sarbloh Kaur · 08 Apr 2005
Student, who are you learning Sitar from and where?
Re: Should we strive to do Kirtan in Raag?
Sarbloh Kaur · 09 Apr 2005
Student Jee,
This school sounds great! Irshad Khan, the great-grandson of Imdad Khan, was once my Ustaad Jee, so I was also a student of the Imdad Khani Gharana. Do you know if Shahid Parvez is teaching right now, or are these his 6 months away from the school? He is amazing. I was once arguably his biggest fan. How much do the classes cost? And if you don't mind me asking, what have your first few lessons been? Just "Da-Ra"?
Re: Should we strive to do Kirtan in Raag?
Sarbloh Kaur · 12 Apr 2005
Amandip Jee, thanks for the clarification. There was once a chart for Gurmat Sangeet similar to the "raagabase" link you've provided above, but it is no longer available online. It was definitely not as thorough as the "raagabase", but I'm all in favour of setting up something similar again. I'll try to find out where that site went as it would be a good start on which to build from. How did you acquire your knowledge on raags?
Re: Should we strive to do Kirtan in Raag?
Blue Morpho · 16 Apr 2005
Sarbloh ji,
Anwar Khurshid has been a great addition to the Brampton music community. I saw him play in a concert in Brampton at Loafers Lake. Can he ever play! He presented his students in the concert too and they were all very good sitar players and were very advanced. By far if anybody has produced some sitar players it has been Anwar. The Sitar School students sounded very commited to music and played very complicated rhythymic material. At one point in the concert there were 15 Sitars playing in perfect unison. I must say that was a brilliant concert, extremely professionally done.
I talked to some of the students about their learning experiences. They said that after going through almost all the teachers in GTA they have finally found a mentor in Anwar. The best thing about the school seemed to be the love that they all had for their teachers, Anwar and Ustad Shahid Parvez.
I was surprised by how much progress some of the students had made in an extremely short time. One student who had barely played for three months played a bandish in Jhaptal perfectly.
The concert took a special significance when Anwar asked for the lights in the hall to be turned on. He announced that his father was in the audience and it is the first time that he has come to see him play. He played a brilliant series of Alap, Jod and Teen taal vilambit gat, in which he played tishr jati with complete command for almost ten minutes. After that he played a tarana on Sitar in Ek taal with complete facility. He ended with a brilliant series of long chakardars in teen taal. He was perfectly accompanied by Harpal Singh Kallah. It was only Harpal ji who could handle such difficult playing, any body of a less stature would have been easily knocked out.
When I talked to Anwar about the concert he was extremely modest about his performance. He said that I only play a fraction of my great teacher. He kept on praising his teacher over and over again. He is genuinely interested in teaching Indian Classical Music in it's purest form and is a very commited and pure soul. He is very down to earth and quite a funny guy. Strangely, all through the conversation he was humming a very familiar tune that I could not pin point. The next day it occured to me finally that he was humming Wahay Guru.
I would strongly recommend Sitar School to any body who seriously wants to learn.
[%sig%]
Re: Should we strive to do Kirtan in Raag?
Sarbloh Kaur · 19 Apr 2005
Blue Morpho Jee, I'm pretty sure Anwar Khurshid was accompanying Shahid Parvez when I heard him live in concert a few years ago, and indeed he is remarkably talented. Hopefully I will start up lessons again soon.