Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

singh · 03 Apr 2005

This is amazing!!!!! http://www.sikhnet.com/sikhnet/news.nsf/SherePunjabPage1March25.pdf http://www.sikhnet.com/sikhnet/news.nsf/SherePunjabPage16March25.pdf

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

yo mama · 04 Apr 2005

this is definitely wrong. panj pyaray are male ie:- bhai daya singh, bhai dharam singh, bhai himmat singh, bhai mokkam singh, bhai sahib singh.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

t singh · 04 Apr 2005

listen to the shabad, eh hai more agiya. i think its in bhai nand lal jis varran, it is clerly written that amrit should be given by "panch singh"

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

hmm.. · 05 Apr 2005

why stop at males .. why not have it so you have to have those same names... how about one step further... why not only those 5 souls can be the punj pyare... so your saying if you weren't a punj pyare at the very first amrit sanchaar then you can't be one now.. right??? [%sig%]

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

OMG · 05 Apr 2005

if bibiji's can take amrit ...i don't see why they can't administer it too......try to live out of that little box of urs yo mama ji :)

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

Search For Tat · 05 Apr 2005

If that is the case, why are you just sticking to having the same sex. Why not also as part of this re-inactment have them the same age, and from the same parts of India? The Panj payres are simply to most spiritual 5 Gursikhs in the sangat......

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

. · 05 Apr 2005

Am i right that the original Punj did not marry either?

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

Manvir Singh · 05 Apr 2005

According to Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib, men and or women can administer Amrit in Amrit Sanchaar. Once a lady asked Shaheed Baba Jarnail Singh Ji Bhindranwale: "Baba Ji, men say that we cannot do Panj Pyaarian di Sewa. What are your vichaar? Men seem to be forward in doing everything." Baba Ji said: "Mother, our Great Gurus have conferred equal status to both men and women. Our sisters are equal in status to our brothers. In 1699 the Tenth Nanak, Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji asked for five heads. He did not ask for five men to stand up who are willing to give their life. He did not ask for a Jatt, Cheemba or Khatri etc. Guru Sahib asked for a head! Women can do Panj Pyaarian di sewa. Guru Sahib has given you gift of equality, but you will not be able to enjoy sitting back, you have to stand up and get the gift of equality which has been given to you by the Guru." (That is on a recording of Baba Ji's speaches, CD: "Anmol Bachan" - distributed to Sikh Federation in UK) bhul chuk maaf karnee ji

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

kabadi · 05 Apr 2005

Can you please give a reference for this Manvir Singh... Once a lady asked Shaheed Baba Jarnail Singh Ji Bhindranwale: "Baba Ji, men say that we cannot do Panj Pyaarian di Sewa. What are your vichaar? Men seem to be forward in doing everything." Baba Ji said: "Mother, our Great Gurus have conferred equal status to both men and women. Our sisters are equal in status to our brothers. .... on another note... I have heard one of sant ji's speeches talking about 'feminists', hes like soon bibian will be asking to lead the lavaan during anand karaaj, and asking for Waheguru ji ka khalsa , waheguru ji ki fateh to, WAHEGURU ji KI khalsI, waheguru ji KI fatehI... he said to just ignore manmukhs like these people...

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

Charanjeev Singh · 05 Apr 2005

The traits of Khalsa are beyond physical. Anyone who is blessed with those traits and conduct are Guru Sahibs Pyareh. Those who are Guru Sahibs Pyareh, are blessed to be in the Panj Pyareh.

Sorry - Galtee ho gayee

Manvir Singh · 05 Apr 2005

I apologise that I have mis-interpreted and not fully heard the lecture properly (it was a long time ago and reading the lecture it seems that I picked a wrong message and didn't hear some parts)... i have just read up the written lecture. Sorry - bhul chuk maaf. Read Baba Ji's lectures (in writing) on: http://www.lotusmedia.co.uk/sikhstudent/Documents/Human%20Rights/Sant%20Jarnail%20Singh's%20Speeches.pdf This is what the lecture said "Resolve here today that you will keep beards, give up intoxicants, and take Amrit". If you find the beard too heavy, (note that) at this place (Harmandar Sahib) God fulfills prayers very quickly. Pray to God saying: "The True King, you were kind to us and made us men and gave us birth in Sikh homes. But we do not like this Sikhism and manhood. Have mercy on us. Make us into women and make women into men. Make this exchange." Some say I consider women to be inferior. I do not consider them inferior. I say this only to make these young men ashamed of what they do, not to imply that women are inferior. Some of our sisters also object: "Sant Ji, why don't you give the Parshaad of the Five Beloved Ones to us. Why don't you include women among the Five Beloved Ones?" I shall humbly say this to (our) mothers: "Mothers, no Sikh is jealous of you. There is no discrimination. But this is your own weakness. It is not in my control. When our Beloved Guru (Siri Guru Gobind Singh Sahib), in 1756 (Bikram calendar, equivalent to 1699 A.D.), asked for heads, he did not say he needed the head of a man or woman. At that time, He only said He needed a head. Of the gathering of 80,000 no woman got up to have her head cut off by the sword. Only those will get Parshaad who had their heads cut off. How can others get it? For this reason, there is no discrimination in our mind. If someone does have it, it is his business. (Some persons shout the Jaikaara) Now, at this time you men shout the Jaikaara about women being mentioned in this manner, but note that in this protest movement, the share of our mothers has not been less than ours. It is true that there is this accusation (of not volunteering when Siri Guru Gobind Singh Sahib asked for a head) but keep in mind that Bhagats, people called Gurus, and those who were Divine Incarnations, were born of them. Stay united. If, in the course of my speech, I uttered a harsh word, I implore the entire Congregation to forgive me regarding me as an humble servant of the Congregation, and an uneducated fallible person. Once again, in concluding, I implore you to take Amrit and be prepared. Keep weapons and whatever orders are given by the Panth, obey them. Work to remove the (yoke of) slavery from our necks. To those who ask me what is in my mind, I say that Guru Sahib knows this and when the time comes, it will become known. We all have to work together. Don't fall prey to misgivings. "Vaheguru Ji ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji ki Fateh" (The Khalsa belong to God, Victory belongs to God).

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

behind the times · 05 Apr 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh This is late news Women have been acting as panjpyara & leading the lavaan during anand karaaj as well as holding akhandpaath with out male interference :) for 20 years already. Look in American community. So you're suggesting we should be saying Waheguru ji kE KhalsE Waheguru ji kE FatEh... We are all women before God ;) sakhi

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

khalistani · 05 Apr 2005

this is a NEW trend this never happened before did anyone read T SINGHS POST please read his post bibs cannot be i the panj its not a pregidous thing the western sence of equality is going out of hand next thing u know, i know of osme women who will prob say this, will say we shud be able to go topless just like men equality doesnt mean u can do everything the other person can men cant have kids, is god being pregidoius, no men are phyisically stronger in most cases, is god pregidous, no its nothing to do with equality just read t singhs post the topic shud have ended there but im amoorkh plkease, read t singhs post bhula chuka maf

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

kabadi · 05 Apr 2005

Author: behind the times Date: 04-05-05 14:52 Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh This is late news Women have been acting as panjpyara & leading the lavaan during anand karaaj as well as holding akhandpaath with out male interference :) for 20 years already. Look in American community. So you're suggesting we should be saying Waheguru ji kE KhalsE Waheguru ji kE FatEh... We are all women before God ;) sakhi .................................... I am not saying it... sant ji is saying it... and just cuz the women lead the lavaan in the last 20 yrs in America does not mean it is right... Look... when u get married the girls parents give her to her husband... so the girls parents are now the husbands parents... Guru Gobind Singh Ji even said 'putari da dhan bikh jananaa' - Recognize the property of a daughter as poison... which basically means the daughters parents have no right over their duaghter after marriage, and they should not look to the daughter for any type of support... the duaghter is now a member of the other family, and the husband is their to protect her... that is why the husband leads the lavaan, these feminists do not undersstand that

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

....... · 06 Apr 2005

i really respect Sant Jarnial Singh ji, but I disagree with him. I follow Gurbani, and its says the sex is only the external vessel, the khalsa is inside the vessel, the soul, the spirit and the conscious.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

Manvir Singh · 06 Apr 2005

Panthic Sikh Rehat Maryada states: Ceremony of Baptism or Initiation Article XXIV : (b) At the place where ambrosial baptism is to be administered, the holy Guru Granth Sahib should be installed and ceremonially opened. Also present should be six committed baptized Sikhs, one of whom should sit in attendance of the Guru Granth Sahib and the other five should be there to administer the ambrosial baptism. These six may even include Sikh women. All of them must have taken bath and washed their hair. (c) The five beloved ones who administer ambrosial baptism should not include a disabled person, such as a person who is blind or blind in one eye, lame, one with a broken or disabled limb, or one suffering from some chronic disease. The number should not include anyone who has committed a breach of the Sikh discipline and principles. All of them should be committed baptized Sikhs with appealing personalities. If the lady is fully Rehat-vaan, full Baana (including Dastaar) and got strength of Naam & Baani, then I don't see what's objectionable with women administrating as Panj Pyaare. Guru Sahib asked for five heads in 1699... If we want to go down the line of "they were five men" so Panj Pyaare shud always be men... then like as mentioned before by someone... then it would follow on that the Panj Pyaare should be representative of the different age groups, geographical locations and working backgrounds which they came. (??) If there geographical locations, age, "caste" which they were born into and working background are irrelevant... then why is gender relevant to the capability of a chardikala baan-baan, naam abiyaasiaa gursikh doing sewa at Amrit-Sanchaar as the Panj Pyaare? This is Daas' humble personal vichaar. bhul chuk maaf karnee ji.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

t singh · 06 Apr 2005

if you are going to respect akaal takhat on the issue of this, and act like its the be all and end all, dont be a hypocrite and support akaal takhat on kes as a kakkar too. Dont use akaal takhat as a point for one thing, and than reject it for another. This is not meant to start any debate on keski, as i dont want to cause needless comotion, but dont be a hypocrite and use akaal takhat just to support your points, and than disagree with akaal tkahat whenever it suits you

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

Manvir Singh · 06 Apr 2005

sorry - jus want to clarify daas does support sri akaal takhat sahib and respect all its decisions. Thanks

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

Tax Man · 06 Apr 2005

In the end it is Guru Granth Sahib that has final say in the decision and what not.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

heyheyhey · 06 Apr 2005

it doesnt matter if its woman or man because the soul inside are females and if only man stood up and they should be punj payari so the same punj payri should stand up today the shoud be same age hight skin color. what if a china takes amrit keeps fuul khalsa rehit he cant become punj paryie because no chinas stood up back then woman and man should both do seva of 5 payari

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

singh · 06 Apr 2005

Guru Sahib asked for a head! --------------------------------------------------------------------- That should be enough said!!!!!!!!

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 07 Apr 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh... Hey hey hey has said it all... NO American/Chinese/Japanese/Chilean/Argentinian/British/Irish/malaysian/Singaporean/Thai...a THOUSAND and ONE NATIONALITIES and RACES of SINGHS......can ever be a PUNJ PIYARA...BECAUSE we were ALL ABSENT on that Day in 1699...ONLY a LAHOREAN, DWARKAAN..etc can be PUNJ !!! ??? Hey hey that cant be and shouldnt be... The KHALSA is NON-GENDER/NON-RACIAL/NON-NATIONALITY/NON-CONTINENTAL.....the KHALSA is of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI...and GURU JI is in EVERYONE and EVERYWHERE.....those seeking to "lock up" GURU JI in some stereotype..are making a huge msitake. This MCP stereotype behavious is one baggage we all have to drop sooner rather than later..IF you read the messages and quotes above..you will notice that the answers are very NON-COMMITTAL....they cant come RIGHT OUT and say NO..according to Gurbani a Woman CANNOT be a PUNJ..and Here is the QUOTATION.....they play on words...and beat around the BUSH..because they DONT HAVE GURBANI BACKING......Gurbani declares on Dankey dee chot that we are all NAARS.....and the ONLY PURAKH is WAHEGURU.... so what atre we trying to prove by restricting the PUNJ to our own misguided viewpoint. Jarnail Singh

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

khalistani · 07 Apr 2005

it says PANCH SINGHHH but ure choice i dontknow hwo to explain, if u guys wont listen to sant jarnail singh je then y the heck wud u listen to me chalo satnam sri vaheguru je stay in chardi kala bhula chuka maf

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

Reply To This Message · 07 Apr 2005

So far there has been nothing but baseless arguements. You cannot make up your own rules to win an arguement. There is a big difference, which can be seen in society as well as observed in the behavior between the genders versus the arguements being used on race/caste/nationality/height/weight. This can even be observed in the temples where these is segregation based on gender for sitting as well as the use of latrine facilities. Bhai Nand Lal knew what he was talking about when he wrote that amrit should be given by "panch singh".

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

behind the times · 07 Apr 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khlasa Waheguru jiki Fateh Sorry misunderstanding when said leading lavan meant 'Preforming" lavan, conducting the marriage ceremony. Really though if the girl should lead for some reason the couple is just as married. ( haven't seen this tho) >'putari da dhan bikh jananaa' - Recognize the property of a daughter as poison< Maybe what he meant ws that parents shouldn't force their will on their daughter considering her as property and she should marry whom she chooses rather than parents choice. And the parent should relinquish rights and give her to the husband she wishes to spend her life with.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

Roopkaur · 07 Apr 2005

The word Singh does not necessarily mean male, because we all know that when referring to a collective group of khalsa, the word Singh is used. For instance, when we refer to Tapoban Singhs, Maliyaa waley Singhs, obviously we are not discluding the Singhneeaa from that picture because the word Singh covers them as well. Likewise, when we see a group of lions, we do not see "oh look, there is a group of lions and lionesses", we say, that it is a group of lions. The word Khalsa also ends in in a, so now should we use the word Khalsi for women? THese words refer to both men and women. By saying panch singh, I am sure it meant Amritdharee, tyaar bar tyaar Singhs, as opposed to any person off of the street should do the panj piyaareyyaa dee seva. As for the argument that they did not give their head at that time, well, we do you accept the singhneeaa's head now? Why do you not refuse them amrit now, since they did not stand up then? You are right, they did not do seva then because no singhneeaa stood up and gave her head then, but now that they do give their head, they can now do seva in the panj.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

jss · 07 Apr 2005

first off...if you're referring to the thankanamma bhai nand lal....there are a lot of questions as to whether he did write it... secondly...even if it does say panch singh...that could still include women... if you've read any of prof puran singh ji's books...you'll see that he is against calling women singhni....they too can be singhs... and before you start saying that no..amritdhari women are kaurs...i've heard that kaur was a name used later on?...

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

........... · 07 Apr 2005

i thought there was a story about where Bhai Randhir Singh attempted to allow a bibi to do seva in punj, but there was some warning from the Guru that discouraged them from allowing it.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

Mkhalsa · 07 Apr 2005

Sant Jee Says: >>>>Only those will get Parshaad who had their heads cut off. How can others get it? <<<< Fact #1 : When given amrit, you are, in essence, giving your head. Fact #2 : The same amrit is given to singhs and singhnees Fact #3 : I agree with sant jee then, those that have given their head have the right to be in panj pyare, singhs AND singhneea. Again, every argument u guys make can easily be torn to shreds with barely 30 seconds of thought. Theres more on my site that I have pasted here about 100 times.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

Mkhalsa · 07 Apr 2005

>>>>>i thought there was a story about where Bhai Randhir Singh attempted to allow a bibi to do seva in punj, but there was some warning from the Guru that discouraged them from allowing it.<<<<< I dont want to be groupist, but I have only ever heard this from taksalis which leads me to beleive this is a rumor in the same class as keeray in the mouth for not reading raag mala or not being allowed in the gates of sachkhand ROTFL.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

:::::: · 07 Apr 2005

Moving on to another issue, does the picture in the second link show the punj giving naam to teh abhilaakhi? this should be a gupt process, why would they have it in a public newspaper? and WHY in the world would there be a cameraperson in the amrit sanchaar room in the first place?

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

jss · 07 Apr 2005

if you ever read the forums on sikhnet....3HO doesn't believe that the amrit sanchaar is supposed to be closed off... i think this amrit sanchar was linked to 3HO

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

:::::: · 08 Apr 2005

ok, what about the naam drirh part? Does 3H0 do naam drirh?

Re: Amrit Sanchaar in chile, Bibi's In the punj

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 09 Apr 2005

Amrit Sanchaar will be held in the Open Stadiums..Bob Hope Style...if certain people have their way.... There are a lot of "western influenced" Sikhs going around who ADMIRE these EAGLE CAMPS,, HUGS and Kisses in Public, Rap Kirtan etc, Stadium Style Huge Gospel Meetings tv media etc, miracles being performed where the blind can see, and legless can run the 100 metres in 5 seconds...they are now busy selling gurbani/gurmatt through "modern music cds, Walking tall, Running Fast, etc etc types of muisc...claiming the traditional raags gurbani is boring to the Youth..so their kachee rap songs attract more youths..attract more youths..I dont know..but sell their CDs..YES..make money..YES Guru Raakha Jarnail Singh