Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Effusions of Violence

Effusions of Violence

Kulbir Singh · 03 Apr 2005

While in India, I saw some severe effusions of violence that I thought I would share with you all. In Punjab there is a story of a lion and an elephant that goes as follows: The Lion and the Elephant Once a cub of a lion was playing by himself and wandered away from his den. In that jungle a very fierce elephant lived from whom even the lion was afraid of. Incidentally, the elephant was passing by the same path where the cub was standing. The conceited elephant trampled the cub under his feet and killed it. A jackal was watching the whole thing and a herd of sheep witnessed this as well. The Jackal with great humility went to the cub’s father - the Lion - to inform him of the tragedy. The Lion knew that he was no match for the elephant but he was still very mad. He asked the jackal to take him where his cub was. Upon witnessing the trampled body of his child, the lion was greatly agitated. He roared and asked the jackal, “Did you witness this with your own eyes?” “Yes Hazoor, I was right here behind the bushes when this accident occurred”. “Then why did you not stop the elephant, you good-for-nothing thing?” Saying this the lion leapt forward and killed the jackal in one instance. After this he grieved over his child’s dead body and then moved over towards the lake, looking for the herd of sheep and lamb who had witnessed the murder. As he was walking, he saw the elephant who had killed his child. The lion restrained himself and amiably said salutations to the elephant, “how are you doing my friend?” “I am doing good, and how are you”, asked the elephant returning the gesture. “Have you seen the herd of sheep and lambs around here” “Yes, they are by the lake there”, answered the elephant walking away. The lion leapt forward and in great rage jumped on the herd of lambs and killed many sheep and lambs. Such sheepish and cowardly behaviour is found all over humanity now a days. I went to India and witnessed this many times. I will hereon narrate small incidents from there: Jalandhar Incident It was evening rush hour time and I made the mistake of getting out at that time. I arrived in the Adarsh Nagar area to get Cell-phone supplies for myself. I was with my kids and a nephew. As we were waiting for the green lights, we saw a young man pulling a cart making a left turn. Another young guy was on a bicycle and they both had an accident. Both fell down. Both were in their early twenties and about 5 feet, 6 inches tall. One of them uttered a profanity. The other returned the gesture likewise. Before we could think, they attacked each other. The bicycle guy must have been taking Karate lessons. He started doing flying kicks and soon thrashed the other guy quite badly. The police was standing witness to this. Within two minutes the fight was over. The bicycle guy picked up his cycle and humiliating the other one man, rode away. The cart-pulling guy got up and pulled his cart away. I was standing there thinking what the hell was going on and what I would have done if I had been in such situation. I was thinking if I had done anything wrong by not trying to stop this fight. I then thought what I would have done if one of the persons fighting had been a singh. Another Jalandhar Incident We were going somewhere with about 15-16 Singhs. We had 3 cars full of Singhs and Kaurs. I was driving in the middle and there was a car in front of me and a car behind me. Ahead of the car in front of me, there was a tractor trolley driven by Bhaiyaas (residents of Bihar UP). Despite honking for long time, the trolley guy was not giving us way. When he did give us way, as we were crossing it, he all of sudden changed his mind and changed lanes. His trolley hit the fender of one of our cars, in the front. The Singh in front of us, overtook that trolley and stopped him. The lone Singh came out and asked him what the hell he was doing. The driver of the trolley had about 3-4 other guys sitting with him, all from UP, Bihar and he started fighting back angrily because he had seen only one Singh getting out. In the meantime, we all came and surrounded his tractor and asked him why he was driving like this. We were still talking to him, when a Singh came from behind us and dived at the driver who was showing too much defiance and was a bit rude, and grabbed him by his collar. He shook him and brought him back to senses. He immediately admitted his mistake and we got this fellow released from the clutches of this Singh. A Ludhiani Incident We were in Ludhiana at that time and were waiting for the green signal. I noticed that to my left, there were two men arguing over something. Both were greatly agitated and were yelling profanities at each other. They looked really dangerous and I thought that they were going to murder someone there. They kept yelling and then one of them pushed the other guy. Then pushes started from both sides. Just then a tall Sardar Policeman arrived. He very calmly approached the angry young men who were fighting. To my utter surprise, he did not talk to anyone of them. He gave a thundering blow, a slap, to one of the men fighting. I mean the slap was really brutal. Then he showered him with another one and another one. After slapping one of the offenders, the policeman moved towards the other man and slapped him as well. The young angry fighters did not protest this treatment from the policemen and as the matter of fact, I did not notice a single expression of defiance or anger towards the policeman. I was just amazed and it reminded me of the story of the elephant and lion that I narrated in the beginning of this story. The lion did not get mad at the stronger and more powerful elephant. It is perplexing how we get angry at people if we know it would not have any negative repercussions to us but we don’t get angry at powerful people whom we know we cannot harm or reach. Sant Bhindranwalay used to say that if a maaRa banda (weakling) even utters an obscenity at you, just ignore him if you are not going to meet him that often but if the offender is a strong person, then never shy away from fighting. May Guru Sahib fill us with Bir Rass and may we never show back in the battlefield. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Effusions of Violence

singh · 03 Apr 2005

"I was thinking if I had done anything wrong by not trying to stop this fight. I then thought what I would have done if one of the persons fighting had been a singh. " ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- I question the same thing everyday, Guru sahib made us accountable for anything we do because of the roop he chose to give us, The question with situations like this, is a gursikh supposed to step in and help? and are we going against gurmatt, by standing on the sidelines? Are we cowards to are roop? Waheguru......

Re: Effusions of Violence

Kulbir Singh · 04 Apr 2005

---------- I question the same thing everyday, Guru sahib made us accountable for anything we do because of the roop he chose to give us, The question with situations like this, is a gursikh supposed to step in and help? and are we going against gurmatt, by standing on the sidelines? Are we cowards to are roop? ----------- If there had been a real victim, a gursikh would have been obligated to move in but if two able bodied, persons are fighting, I don't think a gursikh is obligated to move in to diffuse the situation. What if two able bodied men are fighting over some drug problem and what if they are drunk? Yes, if a person is being victimised by badmashs (rascals), then perhaps a gursikh should step in to stop the fight. Just my opinion. It would be interesting to know what others would have done in situations like above. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Effusions of Violence

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 04 Apr 2005

vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!!!! Bhai Uptej Singh Ji, ustaad of the Shaheed Baba Fateh Singh Ji Gatka Akhara in UK, told us at West Coast Sikh Youth Alliance camp in August of 2004 many situations in which he had seen people fighting or being beaten up. He made the same distinction that Bhai Kulbir Singh has made above - that there is a difference when somebody is being victimized and when two able-bodied people are fighting. First scenario is like veerji has mentioned above - two drunks or drug-dealers fighting over stupid issues, or maybe two egotistical bullies trying to impress somebody. There is no point in stepping in and possibly getting hurt yourself, over a stupid issue like drugs or ego. Second scenario is a battlefield - two people accepting their role in the battle and fighting as opponents. You shouldn't step in and interfere as that is unsportsmanlike conduct. You can only step in if one person clearly surrenders but the other is being merciless and doesn't not stop the battle. Third scenario is a victim scenario - somebody is surrounded by a larger person, an angry person, a rapist, a group of thugs, a theif, an oppressive person, or even a case of police brutality - then we need to step in and help the other person. Even if both people are thugs or bad people - if one of them is innocent in this situation and they are being abused or unfairly targeted, then a Sikh must help them. please forgive my mistakes vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: Effusions of Violence

Kaur · 04 Apr 2005

I was wondering from this story about the coward lion and the elephant. I was wondering, if a person who is not good at public speaking is somehow challenged in their beliefs by another person, but that person does not know what or how to say something at that time to defend themselves, is this wrong?

Re: Effusions of Violence

- · 05 Apr 2005

kaur, it does not seem wrong. don't worry, i used to be unable to speak in public without stuttering a lot. now, i have no problem whatsoever (although i'm not talking about standing up infront of acrowd! just in public generally)

Re: Effusions of Violence

Kulbir Singh · 05 Apr 2005

----------- I was wondering from this story about the coward lion and the elephant. I was wondering, if a person who is not good at public speaking is somehow challenged in their beliefs by another person, but that person does not know what or how to say something at that time to defend themselves, is this wrong? ------------- If you see a person challenged in his beliefs by another person but this person does not know how to respond and you know the answer, I think it is a good idea to help out the person getting who is lost for words to respond back. The only thing to consider would be that your support does not violate Gurmat. As for public speaking, it is one of the most dreaded thing in the world. I heard that for normal people, public speaking is the second biggest fear after the fear of death. The only way to overcome this is through practice. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Effusions of Violence

... · 05 Apr 2005

Kulbir Singh, Looking at the story in a different way...the jackal/sheep did nothing to prevent the death of the cub... What did you do in each of these stories to help prevent the anger/conceit... In each case, you seem to be a passive observer and did not do anything to help calm the situation...

Re: Effusions of Violence

Kulbir Singh · 05 Apr 2005

------------ What did you do in each of these stories to help prevent the anger/conceit... ------------- Nothing! I was a mere spectator. Things happened too fast and I was not sure if I should have interfered with events. ------------ In each case, you seem to be a passive observer and did not do anything to help calm the situation... ---------- Very true! There are many reasons why I was a passive observer. One of the reasons was that everything happened so fast that before you could think of doing anything, it was over and the fighters had dispersed. Another reason was that I was not not sure if I should have jumped in to stop the fights. And I was one of the hundreds of spectators of these incidents. I am not justifying my passive behaviour nor I am preaching that others should do as I did. I simply wrote these incidents as I saw them on my trip to India. If you could suggest what I should have done, that would be great. Perhaps this is one of the reasons why I wrote these incidents. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Effusions of Violence

tera baap · 05 Apr 2005

this si called the bystander effect. you are more likely to help someone if their and u were alone then if there are pwople aroiund.

Re: Effusions of Violence

... · 06 Apr 2005

By the same token, it can be argued that in the story of the lion/elephant, things moved too quickly for the jackal/sheep to react to what the elephant did. I note that in our society today, when ever anyone does anything wrong, we always seem to be very passive, and do not do anything to prevent any kind of wrongdoing. I can think of numerous examples where people just sat back and let someone do something wrong to another person.

Re: Effusions of Violence

... · 07 Apr 2005

I think anything would have been better than just doing nothing (shouting or something at the people to stop, calling for help, stopping the violence yourself)