Re: SGGS pothis in robarsts library
Re: SGGS pothis in robarsts · 03 Apr 2005
imho smuggle saroop out of der.
or just grab and run out.
Re: SGGS pothis in robarsts library
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 03 Apr 2005
Was it pothis or was it a full suroop?
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaheguroojeekeefatheh!!!!!
Re: SGGS pothis in robarsts library
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Apr 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh...
Please do the needful Veer JSS Ji. Inform the authorities and provide them with the rumaals and tell them how to accord respect to such pothis.
BTW this is i beleive a Gora library ?? I was temporary librarian at the LARGEST GURDWARA in KUALA LUMPUR in1994...and when I started reorganising the books... I came across a Complete set of Bhai Gopal Singh Translation/ Bhai manmohan Singh Translation....and the TERMITES had eaten through completley the 12 volumes....and a few Sanchees of the SGPC..... how about that for "respect" ?? by SIKHS ?? any wonder why the Panth is in dire straits ???
we are always at the losing end... DECADES ago we had people who were not good at Danggar chaaring ( totally uneducated ) who became Granthis and Parcharaks...these people learnt a bit of Punjabi panj garnthis paath and became world class parcharaks.... NOW the Circle has gone 360 Degrees.... we are going to have GCE A level Pass "Sikhs" who are going to elarn a bit of Panj Granthi oorra airra eerree...and take over as granthis ?? Previosuly the Granthis knew NO ENGLISH...but knew a little gurbani itihas....now the Granthis KNOW ENGLISH..but a bit of Gurbani and itihass..and NO GURSIKHI JEEWAN.... the previous lot accorded so much respect they kept the pothis wrapped up all the time.... the new ones have so little respect they want the pothis on shelves for MAXIMUM EXPOSURE !!!
Obviously we NEED a little of BOTH ??
Jarnail Singh
Re: SGGS pothis in robarsts library
Harkirat singh · 05 Apr 2005
Jss
Taksal has no problems with dodra sangat or sadh sangat you can come and talk with us.
Re: SGGS pothis in robarsts library
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 05 Apr 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
Harkirat Singh Jio,
you seem to be lost.....this thread is about the pothis of sri guru granth sahib ji maharaj kept on shelves in a uni library....
BTW I am glad that taksal has no "problems" with Dodras/"sadh sangat (dodra)"..likeminded jathas should "fly" together in a flock.... and leave others to to their business. There should be more "understanding taksalis" like yourself..in Malaysia too the "taksalis" and other likeminded "jathas" are cooperating.....in many ways than one...
Jarnail Singh
Re: SGGS pothis in robarsts library
Balpreet Singh · 05 Apr 2005
I have spent a lot of time in the Sikhism section at Robarts Library and did not see any sainchees or pothees of GurbaNee there. I did see a Hindi transliteration published by Hazoor Sahib Committee in 2 Volumes and I also did see Dr. Sahib Singh's translation. There are also other books which contain some shabads in the context of quoting them in an essay or book, etc.
I did not think it was a big deal if these books were placed on a shelf as they were. I could very well be wrong here, but even in Sikh libraries I have seen these books placed in the same manner. I'm not sure if this is acceptable or not to the rest of the sangat, but at the time, it did not strike me as being very concerning.
I do remember when some beeRs of Sri Guru Granth Sahib were found in Toronto Public Libraries and with the help of some Singhs they were removed along with gutkas and sainchees. This was of course unacceptable.
Re: SGGS pothis in robarsts library
Jarnail Singh Gyani · 06 Apr 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheuru Ji Ki Fateh.
AS Sikhs we can accord the utmost respect to Gurbani even when it is in a history book....encyclopaedia, magazine article etc....BUT to enforce this rule in ALL Public libraries and etc is futile effort and self defeating..
As far i am concerned Books like Prof Sahib Sinh Ji's Darpan, Manmohan Singh Ji's teeka in 8 volumes etc are "books" and NOT SRI GURU RANTH JI MAHARAJ. Some may not feel this way..and at home in our own space we can do what we like but we cnanaot hope that all NON SIKHS will also feel this way.
SO as per MARYADA..ONLY the ONE SROOP BIR of Guru Granth Ji maharaj is GURU...and we can educate others on the respect to be accorded..but if we start insisitng that even maazine articles, books, gutkas etc are our LIVING GURU...then i dont know what to say?? IF two sanchees sroop is there we can still persuade the authorities to accord respect....but more than that it will be self defeating. To Non Sikhs this is just a study material..and If we lock it all up..there will be no studying...
This is only my IMHO.
Jarnail Singh