Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS

Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS

Kulbir Singh · 03 Apr 2005

JSS under the thread of UK Nihungs wrote the following: Author: JSS Date: 04-03-05 18:55 Jarnail singh ji... we all have seen the DIRECT sant bashin here on this website... EVEN our respected brother KULBIR singh is GUILTY of bashing a pooran mahapursh whom he knew nothing about... note:...i think kulbir singh ji is very learned in sikhi...and applaud his efforts of going to the conference....at the same time...he is ALSO guilty of spreading negative FALSE remarks of great gurmukhs.... i hope he is taking his own advice too...

Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS

Kulbir Singh · 03 Apr 2005

JSS, ----------- EVEN our respected brother KULBIR singh is GUILTY of bashing a pooran mahapursh whom he knew nothing about... -------------- I think you are referring to my comments on Babu Jaswant Singh. I had with my own eyes read a booklet published by Brahm Bunga in which some Swami claimed that Babu Jaswant Singh was an incarnation of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee and had come to fulfill the promise he made to the princess of Sri Lanka. Any gursikh who would read that booklet would be offended, including you too. After that time, I did not hear of any retraction or condemnation of that booklet by Brahm Bunga society. My comments about Babu Jaswant Singh were in that context. Please explain to me, what you would do if you heard someone claiming to be Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee's avatar? ------------- note:...i think kulbir singh ji is very learned in sikhi...and applaud his efforts of going to the conference....at the same time...he is ALSO guilty of spreading negative FALSE remarks of great gurmukhs.... ------------- Neither I am very learned in Sikhi, nor I have spread any negative false remarks of Great Gurmukhs. Kulbir Singh

Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS

etka · 03 Apr 2005

never really read bhai kulbir singh dissing sants, but jarnail singh arshi guy, ... I've learn to ignore his sant bashing posts.

Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS

JSS · 03 Apr 2005

veerji... when i said that you are learned in sikhi...i was not sarcastic at all...i DO believe you are learned and i do learn stuff from your posts...well all the ones on history and other aspects of gurmat.... secondly... all publications on that book were banned as SOON as bauji saw that... in fact... bauji was very upset at that swami for writing such things... that swami doesn't even come to samagams anymore...he came to TWO samagams in his lifetime...and he was coming out of his own reasons... it is true...you did right false things about bauji....who was a GREAT GURMUKH... i suggest you go to amritsar and ask respected Bhai jeevan singh ji about how much respect he has for bauji... i have seen the letters from bhai sahib ji and they convey nothing but humble love from one gurmukh to another... just cuz someone misguided does something out of line...doesn't make it the great gurmukhs fault...there is simply NO logic in that whatsoever... you having not met bauji at all automatically said that he doesn't deserve to be in the list of gurmukhs the likes of bhai vir singh ji... and you continue to disrepect him by calling him "babu" trying to sound demeaning... furthermore, I have spoken to you about his booklet in the past AND explained how it was banned as soon as gurmukh took notice of it. you haven't even gone to pind dodra and seen the chardi kala samagams there...you haven't seen all the prachar that goes on there... you haven't seen how 200 to 300 people take khanday battay da amrit at each main samagam three times a year...they also have amrit sanchars at the smaller samagams in india.... you have not seen the letter written by akal takt that thanks the dodra management committee for all the seva they are doing for the panth.... so YES...veerji...you ARE SLANDERING a gurmukh.... oh by the way... i regularly attend akj samagams in TO...i love the peaceful atmosphere there and the kirtan...i have met people who claim that Bhai Sahib bhai randhir singh ji was an incarnation of Guru Gobind singh ji and that if guru gobind singh ji were alive today he would have made him guru.... now that is a VERY ANTI GURMAT THING to say... do i think any less of bhai sahib ji?...hell no...we infact have his books in our house and give him a lot of respect. you don't see me going on the internet and saying anything negative about him just because some misguided singh makes that sort of statement??? i have talked to jarnail singh ji arshi about the same thing...and at least he has said that he will reserve judgement until he actually goes and visits dodra pind and sees the samagams there...

Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS

Kulbir Singh · 03 Apr 2005

I am sorry if my use of "Babu" hurt your feelings. I just thought that this prefix was used before his name just as "Bayoo" is used before Bayoo Mal Singh jee. And what slander are you talking about. I did not say anything about him - good or bad. I just said that I do not think of him as equal to Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh and other Singhs mentioned there. I will repeat again that I think Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee was one of the greatest Sikhs of all times and I don't find anyone equal to him in the last couple of centuries. Again this is just my opinion and you may think Bhai Jaswant Singh to be the greatest Sikh and someone else may think of Sant Gurbachan Singh as the greatest Sikh. These are just our opinions. ---------------- i regularly attend akj samagams in TO...i love the peaceful atmosphere there and the kirtan...i have met people who claim that Bhai Sahib bhai randhir singh ji was an incarnation of Guru Gobind singh ji and that if guru gobind singh ji were alive today he would have made him guru.... now that is a VERY ANTI GURMAT THING to say... -------------- No Jatha Singh can ever say this. Tell me who said this. If a person did say this, that person should be peshed and severely reprimanded. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh was a Sikh of Guru Sahib and we cannot even imagine him coming even close to Guru Sahib. Bhai Sahib strongly condemned Guru-dumm tendencies. No Jatha member ever believes or says that Bhai Sahib was an incarnation of any Guru. Stop spreading such baseless lies, JSS jeeo. Jatha is not a Sant group and it does not believe in any living person as their saviour, other than Punj Pyaray and Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. No one can believe that Jatha can ever say such degenerating thing about Bhai Sahib. Please don't drag Jatha in this. Kulbir Singh

Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS

tera baap · 03 Apr 2005

it is pretty obivios that someone here is a super dodra fanatic, goes totally overboard at the littles mention of an insult. If 'someone based on the fact that arer infront of them says what is apprpriate for the situation and others find offence that equals to slandering? also i thought gursikhs get happy by being slandered, since cuts bad karma.

Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS

JSS · 03 Apr 2005

kulbir singh ji, i'm not dragging the jatha into anything...i have a lot of respect for the jatha...and have lots of friends in the jatha...and they too have heard the same things....but here's the thing....we KNOW it's not representative of the jatha...just like i'll tell you there are people in any group that are not totally understanding the message....you mean to tell me that every singlle member of the jatha or anyone who regularly attends jatha samagams is a perfect gursikh?? already i have received emails from tapoban admins regarding two "gursikhs" who are part of the jatha..whom everytime i mention their name it gets admin edited..... again...you have to realize that this is NO ATTACK on the jatha..i wouldn't do that...i wouldn't disrespect bhai sahib randhir singh ji and all the seva he did by doing that...but taht doesn't make every jatha member perfect... and tera baap...i'm not any type of fanatic.... i simply highlighted the fact that kulbir singh did slander of a gursikh...he hasn't addressed everything he said.... he tried to imply in earlier threads that bauji didn't believe in upkeep of rehit...he said that when he read bauji's lekhs, all that was in it was justification for not following rehit...and that is simply not true...if you go to dodra pind...you'll see some a lot of chardi kala rehitdhari singhs.... now i'm sure kulbir singh ji will respond saying ..."oh...it's simply my opinion"...that may be true..but when it's your opinion...it's a good habbit to say it as "my opinion"... otherwise you're trying to pass it off as fact...

Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS

kaur · 03 Apr 2005

>he tried to imply in earlier threads that bauji didn't believe in upkeep of rehit...he said that when he read bauji's lekhs, all that was in it was justification for not following rehit...and that is simply not true...if you go to dodra pind...you'll see some a lot of chardi kala rehitdhari singhs....< THere are some areas where Dodras compromise with rehit, such as letting krehitees do keertan.

Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS

Kulbir Singh · 03 Apr 2005

----------- e tried to imply in earlier threads that bauji didn't believe in upkeep of rehit...he said that when he read bauji's lekhs, all that was in it was justification for not following rehit...and that is simply not true...if you go to dodra pind...you'll see some a lot of chardi kala rehitdhari singhs.... ------------- But did they not allow non-amritdhari and even monnay people to do kirtan from stage? I could not agree to this and this notion is directly at odds with Gurmat and what Gursikhs like Bhai Sahib and other mahapurakhs preached. It is a known fact that once Bhai Sahib refused to do anand kaaraj of a couple which was not amritdhari. Bhai Sahib was very strict in keeping rehit, though he was a player of very high spiritual states. I just wrote what my impression has been after reading books written by "Khojee". I felt that they were undermining Rehit and the importance of rehit. If you could kindly refute what I have written above, I will be Khima da jaachak i.e. I will seek forgiveness. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS

Gurpreet Singh · 03 Apr 2005

kaur wrote: > >he tried to imply in earlier threads that bauji didn't believe > in upkeep of rehit...he said that when he read bauji's lekhs, > all that was in it was justification for not following > rehit...and that is simply not true...if you go to dodra > pind...you'll see some a lot of chardi kala rehitdhari > singhs....< > > THere are some areas where Dodras compromise with rehit, such > as letting krehitees do keertan. Kirtan is for everyone.......gurbani is for everyone...no one has a monopoly on gurbani....guru nanak dev ji went around to teach "krehitees" sikhi.....i don't see anything wrong if people do kirtan....one day with his kirpa they are gonna come around too...and i've been to my first dodra samagam in montreal...and trust me it was one of the most loving enviroment ...there i met so many gursikhs....everyone had love for each other and thats what we need in todays society now....we need love...Jin Prem Kiyo Tin Hee Prabh Paayo....lets learn to love each other...lets inspire each other to love and understand gurbani....to be that sikh of the guru...so when we walk by....people can say thats a sikh of guru gobind singh ji...thats a sikh of guru nanak dev ji.........wahegurooo...dhan guru nana :)

Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS

etka · 03 Apr 2005

sad.....Bhai Randhir Singh ji is definatly one of the greatest gur-sikhs along with many other brahmgianis....kulbir u r to lost in ur akj world..... Bhai Sahib is'nt the only one.....no matter what ur opinion is......i dont' care..... Bhai Sahib is super mahaan.........but there are a few more that come up to par with him.

Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS

JSS · 04 Apr 2005

Kulbir singh ji, if you go to dodra or any other samagams in india, you won't find any monas doing kirtan on stage...i haven't seen in the SRM that non-amritdharies aren't allowed to sing the praises of their guru ji.... i agree with you that bhai sahib randhir singh ji didn't allow it. But that doesn't mean that all other mahapurkhs didn't allow it either. Different gurmukhs have different approaches to getting people into sikhi.... in sadh sangat samagams people are encouraged to do kirtan, and other sevas....and through doing this, they build their relationship with guru ji and feel compelled to take amrit.... you might not agree with this approach...that's your discretion...but if you come to a sadh sangat samagam any time soon...you'll see that MOST of the kids have already taken amrit now...and that every samagam more kids give their heads to guru ji...and so obviously this approach is making people build their relationship wiht guru ji....they don't even have to be directly told...they start to realize that it is the righ thing to do.... even Sant attar singh ji was different than Bhai randhir singh ji...he used to do prachar with singing dharnas..and bhai sahib still respected sant attar singh ji...that was his way of doing prachar...the end result is the same.....people giving their heads to guru sahib... and Kaur ji... i have been attending sangat all my life...my whole family is amritdhari and so are many of the families i know...what lack of rehit are you talking about?...can you tell us what rehit is not being followed?...do you have inside information about amrit sanchars at sadh sangat samagams that i don't know about??...which part of rehit is changed???...which part doesn't agree with akal takt sahib???....the rehit is given by guru ji for amritdhari gursikhs....i haven't seen any part of the rehit that says people who haven't taken amrit can't do kirtan...would you object to little kids doing kirtan?? just cuz they haven't taken amrit yet???...kids who do kirtan straight from their hearts ....the same kids that all of us say are probably more connected to God then us geezers???.... next time you say that the "dodras"...i don't know where that term came from....there's no such thing as Dodras...just simple sikhs...who are trying to follow guru ji's path...of seva, simran, and sangat...some more along the path than others....but next time you say that the "dodras" are relaxed on rehit give us an example of wher amritdharis who've taken amrit at sadh sangat samagams are not following rehit....(rehit that is approved by akal takt)....... and kulbir singh ji, i have read many of bauji's lekhs...and i've NEVER once found him to criticize rehit....in fact...reading lekhs made me more inspired into sikhi...all he does in his lekhs is explain different aspects of gurbani... and time and time reminds readers that the true guru is Sri Guru Granth sahib....why would he write negatively about rehit when he himself took amrit at akal takt sahib and followed rehit himself.... if he spoke against rehit...why would their be amrit sanchars every three days at samagam in pind dodra??? explain that to me?.... the only thing he spoke out against was that when rehit is pushed without the knowledge of sikhi...without explanation...and actually it's a message that can also be found in the writings of great sikhs such as bhai veer singh ji and prof puran singh ji (in Spirit Born People).... and trust me the rehit they give at the amrit sanchars is fairly strict.... in fact many of my friends in the akj and i follow the same rehit except that they believe in keski as kakaar and i am taught that kesh is kakaar...and even then we still respect each other's belief and have a lot of piyaar for each other... and this part is off topic.. but to illustrate the piyaar between the kids of the various jathebandis... for the one year aniversary of the passing away of the gursikhs Parminder singh ji, rena kaur ji, and charanjit singh ji, the youth from the various jathebandis in Toronto have decided to come together and organize a joint Kirtan darbar which will take place on may 14th.... it will take place at Gurdwara Jot Parkash which is currently under construction... i encourage you all to come out...take part in seva, simran, sangat....and witness the piyaar b/w young sikhs..... see gursikha eko piyaar just as dear parminder singh ji used to talk about... veerji...i want you to know..that i don't write in malice.....if i sound upset, it is because i'm upset that fellow brothers and sisters, sons and daughters of the same great father can't get along, can't respect each other, and love each other...i write because i want to clear up misperceptions of sadh sangat and the gurmukhs who did soo much seva for sangat.... if after clearing those misperceptions, you choose to disagree, then i can respect that...i respect that path that you follow as was exemplified by bhai sahib randhir singh ji... i only ask that you respect your fellow brothers and sisters who are following sikhi in a different way from you (a path that is approved by akal takt also) and AT LEAST admit and respect the fact that gurmukhs like bauji did a lot of seva of telling people about Guru Granth sahib ji, spreading the word of sikhi....they might not be Great sikhs in your eyes...but they've done great seva of helping others to come into sikhi...and in the eyes of those singhs (as well as me) bauji will always be a great gurmukh who is deserving of respect... i don't know...maybe i'm naive and idealistic to think that perhaps we the next generation could learn to put aside differences and interact in a positive way to help each other in gursikhi....but from the looks of things...most of just like to toot our own horn and put down others...(sad part is...i'm probably one of those "most"...and i'm soo young and already falling into the trap)

Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Apr 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Veer JSS jio, I too have seen with my own eyes the Book by Swami ji....it was NOT just "somethign said by soemone....somewhere..orally....IT was PRINTED and PUBLISHED. Secondly when I was Manager of a Gurdawra in KL, we received a HUGE 50 inches by 40 Inches POSTER in ENGLISH from Canada to be passted on the Gurdwara Board. In it were ALL the QUOTATIONS fom that book in which Bau jaswant Singh was claimed to be GURU NANAK JI. I had a copy of that poster until recently .....until..a dodra satsangee came to join my Gurbani class and took away the poster for "photocopying"....and then he told me He LOST the poster in a INDIAN COFFEE SHOP ( Gursikhs dont go to coffee shops) He never turned up again..and i suspect the only reason he came was to get his grubby hands on the poster. I would be very glad to receive from YOU a copy of the BAN/CONDEMNATION of the said book and Poster from BB/Dodra....was this ban ever announced in WRITING ?? and was a REBUTTAL PRINTED.?? I would like copies..please. If you dotn have them never mind as I KNOW what I saw and read. As I have communicated to you.... I will visit a Dodra smagam and see for myself what happens there..beleive me..I can "see" things that even microscopes MISS. Please guide to any Tapoban post that BASHES a real SANT. This is attae wich loon brabar i think.....if it ever happened..BUT KUSANT BASHING...that happens and should happen all the time. I am never one to hide or sweep things under the carpet...no matter what....and also I am the FIRST in LINE to BHUL CHUK DEE KHIMMA..IF proven wrong. I am NOT a AKJ memeber ( yet)..but I do not beleive the allaegation about Bhai Sahib Bhai randheer Singh Ji...an AKJ memeber however "naive" WONT be THAT NAIVE to equate a HUMAN to GURU GOBIND SINGH Jis LEVEL...this just doesnt happen lol...I will Never beleive such in a million years. (THIS is MY OPINION) Bhai Sahib Jee would NEVER forgive such a jatha memeber !!! not in a milion years. Jarnail Singh. BTW this is the most useless post there ever was on tapoban Forum. I am surprised you wrote it.

Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS

Amritpal Singh · 04 Apr 2005

I"ve gone myself to see dodra smaagams, and I found the sangat misguided, or even at times undermining rehit. The last time I went to a dodra smaagam. I saw alot of pyaar for sikhi. but it was misguided. I went a few years ago in 2000 before i took amrit. The whole atmosphere that i saw was one of no rehit. maybe thats why on a forum based so heavilty on rehit,, dodra is getting bashed. I've gone to dodra smaagams in toronto and know a few of the inside people who go alot. And their hearts are in the right place, but without any rules and any disipline what is the point of gurmat? first of all... NOBODy said fateh. Only when people saw me some peole managed to say fateh, other wise it was dhan guru nanak and then straight for a hug. I dont mind the hugs if its all coming from guys. but at dodra smaagams you see male, females hugging all over the place like TIGHT TIGHt hugs. I mean I know for 99 precent of the people its PYAAR for them,, But in gurmat i dont think its appropriate for young males to be hugging other young females. I found the young singhs there, all were filled with pyaar, and most all had good intentions on their mind, but still i dont think hugging the opposite sex (like same age) is appropriate. The major thing that got to me was that, withouth rehit your jeevan does not go anywhere. You can do as much gurbani and keertan as you want but 'aassurr nehe pehnda" . What is the point of allowwing a Mona do chaur di sewa, and also LEAD the sangat in keertan? they themselves do not follow sikhi yet they can lead sangat? this is the main and most HUGE difference between akhand keertan jatha and dodra. this is why JSS you complaining about why we cant all get along......its because the idealogies are fundementally different when it comes to parchaar. And Lastly.....I dont know the answer to this myself, so could JSS please explain to me why dodra smaagams arent held in gurdwara's?

Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS

Admin · 04 Apr 2005

This thread is not about Dodra Sangat or their practices. It was about whether Kulbir Singh slandered Bhai Jaswant Singh. He has presented his view here and JSS has presented his. This thread is now closed. The direction of this thread is leading towards discussion on Dodra Sangat and we don't want this discussion on this forum. Admin.