My meeting with UK Nihungs
Kulbir Singh · 01 Apr 2005
Khalsa jeeo,
On March 27th, 2005 Parmjit Singh whom I heard belongs to the UK Nihung Jatha came to Toronto to speak in a conference organised by a Sikh organisation here. We found out about his arrival and decided to attend the conference.
Some Singhs reached there at 11:30am but I and four other Singhs reached there around 3pm. Couple of minutes after our arrival, Parmjit Singh started his lecture. He began his lecture by complaining how the definition of Sikhi was so broad in old days and how it became narrow in the last century or so. Others may not have known but I knew that he was referring to the Singh Sabh movement that brought clarity in Sikhi; the clarity that had been lost because of the fact that Khalsa was busy fighting in jungles and non-Sikhs were the custodians of our gurdwaras at that time.
He showed many pictures and newspaper clippings from last two hundred years. Then he showed the picture of Baba Khem Singh Bedi and he greatly showered praise on him. One of Bedi’s picture was an embodiment of Guru-dumm. It showed Bedi sitting on a throne and a person doing chaur on his head. I interrupted by raising my hand and voiced my comments that it is pure Guru-dumm to do this. Parmjit Singh said something like it was a practice of that time and also expressed his doubts on the authenticity of the picture. I was wondering, why show such a picture that can be misleading and can promote Guru-dumm. I was wondering why he showed such picture that he himself has doubts about.
The lecture continued with I continuing to interrupt where I found objections. I think Parmjit Singh was a bit upset at my comments. At one point, he said something along the lines that it is unfortunate that at one time there used to be idols in the parkarma area of Darbar Sahib but some fundamental Sikhs threw them out. I immediately stood up and corrected him by informing him that it was against Gurmat to have idols at Gudwaras.
He replied by saying that we should let idol-worshippers to come to Darbar Sahib. I replied back saying that even today all idol-worshippers are welcome to all Gurdwaras but these idol worshippers are not allowed to place their idols at our Gurdwaras. He said that if we let them place the idols at the parkarma, they would listen to kirtan and then perhaps change. I said that to do parchaar of Sikhi we cannot break the rules of Gurmat and maryada or Gursikhi. Others in the audience agreed with what I said.
I explained that these idols and other anti-Gurmat practices had crept in our Gurdwaras because the management of our Gurdwaras was not in the hands of Khalsa at that time but in the hands of mahants who did not follow Gurmat. The Singh Sabha movement fixed these problems and maryada was once again restored in our Gurdwaras.
Then he showed a picture of a woman who looked like a good and pious woman but did not look like a Sikh woman. She was wearing a Sari, had a bindi on her forehead and had earrings. Parmjit Singh said that this picture was of a Sikh woman Preacher or a Sikh missionary. I was shocked by his claim and so shocked was the sangat there and even normally mild Sikhs like the most famous Sikh lawyer of Canada – Sardar T. Sher Singh – had to speak up. He said that it was not wise or it was too early to draw conclusions from what the press reports say because even today in this age of knowledge, press does not always cover facts accurately, then how can we expect the press two hundreds years ago to be accurate. The whole audience totally applauded Sardar T. Sher Singh jee’s statement and it seemed that Parmjit Singh too had to reluctantly agree with him.
So ended his presentation. By Guru Sahib’s kirpa, no parchaar of Sanatanism was done in the conference because of the stiff opposition he faced in the audience that interrupted him at any slight deviation from Gurmat.
After the lecture we all came out and Parmjit Singh too came out. He and I said fateh to each other and shook hands. He expressed his desire to have a discussion with me and I readily agreed. While the third lecture started, I came out to stretch my legs and do some paath, that I saw Parmjit Sing there. He was sitting in the sitting area outside and I too sat beside him on a couch. We started having discussion.
I first asked him that why do UK Nihungs put down AKJ Singhs in UK. He tried to avoid this question saying that he did not represent the UK Nihungs but I persisted. I said that I wanted to know why they had to put other organisations down to forward their agenda. He could not answer this question and asked me to name some UK AKJ Singhs who had told me this. I said it was not about persons but about ideology.
I asked him why the UK Nihungs put down Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee and accuse him of being a British Agent? He could not answer this question. I then went on saying that at one time pretty much whole of Bhai Sahib’s jatha was in jail and he himself stayed in jail for 16 years. Then how could he have been a British stooge. He had no answer to this.
I then asked him, about how he was preaching in the lecture that Sikhs should be tolerant to all .e.g Udasis and Nirmalay but how come UK Nihungs were not tolerant to AKJ then? I said to him, "you can hug ganjay (skinhead) Udaasee saadhoos but repulse AKJ Singhs who are in baana like you guys." He could not give any satisfactory answer to this.
As we were talking there were two more Singhs with me – Baldeep Singh and Amritpal Singh. As I had finished discussing the above with him, some more Singhs came from inside. One of the Singhs, who was upset at his lecture, came directly to him and said, “You are a direct agent of Indian Government”. Hearing this, Parmjit Singh got upset and uttered an obscenity. The Singhs there respected us and restrained themselves and did not get physical with Parmjit Singh. Otherwise, they would have severely thrashed him for his stupidity.
I pacified them and then asked Parmjit Singh, if he had read the first salok of 21st pauri of Siri Asa kee Vaar. I explained how Guru Sahib tells us that one who utters obscenities is against Gurmat. I told him to apologise to the Singhs. I also told him that he would be in serious trouble with these Singhs if he did not apologised. He refused to do it first but then after few minutes apologised to those Singhs.
I asked Parmjit Singh, if it is okay for an amritdhari Singh to consume liquor. His answer filled not only me but everyone else there with total surprise. He responded saying that in dire circumstances consuming liquor is okay. My next question was what kind of circumstances are those in which a gursikh is allowed to drink liquor. He said that when Singhs used to go to battle or war, they used to drink liquor. He said that liquor helps one in battles. I asked him what was the position of Gurbani and Naam then? I asked him if Baba Deep Singh jee could have consumed liquor. He had no answer. Then I asked him if Gurbani allows for exceptions in drinking liquor. No answer at all.
The worse claim that he made was his support for polygamy. I asked him if a Singh can have sex with a person who is not his wife. To this he again said that in some circumstances, it is allowed. There were many Singhs who were present there who heard him say this and the liquor thing.
Overall, it was a satisfactory meeting with him and I ended this conversation with him requesting him to firstly, review his beliefs that do not seem to be on Gurmat e.g. liquor, drugs, meat and fornication / adultery. Secondly, I asked him to cut the spiteful and venomous attitude they have for AKJ. Whether he will heed to these requests, time will judge that.
What I have written is based on honesty and if Parmjit Singh wants to clarify any point, he is more than welcome to post here.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
Son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 01 Apr 2005
This is a wonderful news Kulbir Singh. I wonder if someone recorded the lecture. I don't think anyone from the Niddar Singh's Jatha has come down anywhere in US besides New Jersey so I haven't had a chance to see how they do their lectures. I would be interesting to hear them talk and see how they promote their ideas.
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
Abhiyaas.Blogspot.Com · 01 Apr 2005
It is good that you decided to have a debate with Mr. Parmjit Singh. The reason why he did not have anything to say to you was because of his ignorance on the issue, from the description that Bhai Sahib Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji has given, that it is always the Naam Abhiyaasis always win such battles.
Everything else is just a shallow show of egotism; without the blessings of Naam.
But, one thing that seems good is that the Toronto Singhs controlled their anger in all extremes, however, they should not have hesitated in giving him a taste of the spirit of Chandi (a good beating). This is because Singhs have two personalities, Saint and Soldiers, we should not hesitate in being righteous at the same time as Athai Pehar Japping Naam. Giving them a beating (UK Nihangs) would do more Parchaar to them than they already know of.
Glory be to the True Khalsa. Glory to the Great Guru!
- Abhiyaas.Blogspot.Com
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
so are you? · 01 Apr 2005
suprised that is
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
Wazir Singh Nihung · 01 Apr 2005
A real nihung would not have backed down from any battle and would have fought to the death. You should have let them attack Parmjit Singh and seen what would have happened!!
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 02 Apr 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh.
WELL DONE. IF only we took such strong stands at all such
meetings" and seminars and visits by radhasoami Gurus/rss agents/dehdhari gurus/so calaled kusants and what not..these people will get the message. This is very well handled...we SHOULD NEVER resort to Gunda Gardhi/beatings of Dhols and loud Kirtans etc to Intimidate the opposition...this earns us title of Kattars/fundamentalists etc and spoils the good name. GO there well prepared with GURMATT/GURBANI to answer questions and raise objections based RATIONALLY on gurbani....no one can then raise objections of rowdy behaviour. Even the Press ( usually hostile to Sikhs) will then have no "leg to stand on" to bash us... MY Congrats to the Toronto Singhs.
Dear Me...you are the one having an agenda of bashing people...and you know this becasue you are afraid of your own shadow ( my post wont be allowed !!! ha ha ha) NAME any ONE "SANT or MAHAPURASH" that has been "Bashed" on this Forum. This is a direct Challenge to you and your like minded cohorts. There are many FORUMS/websites.. where Bhai Sahib bhai RANDHEER SINGH JI has been NAMED and "bashed" with Full Blooded LIES and Outright Falsehoods. as someone else commented your ligths are not only dimmed..they are all going out kapoots man....this is what you get when you connect your wires to a so called "kusant" and try to get his juice to power your lights... get wise and get connected to the most powerful genrator in the Universe..GURBANI..
Jarnail Singh.
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
jagjitsingh · 02 Apr 2005
waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, I have known Paramjit Singh and his brother Iqbal singh for almost 10 years. We first met when we all wished to learn gatkha in Southall and Slough. Both are highly intelligent young sikhs who have alot to offer, however my greatest shock is how Niddar and Jagdeep has manged to manipulate them, and entice them into their group. Paramjit is a young man who is highly articulate, and I am now told is one of the key players in the Uk nang scene (their own term which they fashioned for Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh, so I openly use it for them).
I know Veer Paramjit Singh will read this, so there is nothing to hide. Veer ji, it was me, Jagjit singh from Slough who informed Bhai Kulbir Singh that you were going to Toronto. You know me well enough to know I never walk away from anything. It was Iqbal singh that said challenge the views if you can.
I have alot of time for you and your brother, but I totally oppose your snaatanistic views and always will. We all want to learn gatkha, shaster vidya, and see the Khalsa martial side, but cloaking a thinly veiled art and flood it with Snaatanism is not Praatan sikhi or shaster vidya, and it does not even correspond to Gurbani.
So many times in UK, even in your own akharras these views have been ripped apart, yet in some cheeky way, you guys just laugh and put more rubbish on websites for more publicity. You know so well how much falsehood is on these sites, but in some sick way, you use to brainwash more innocent youth.
There is no heroism in any of these nihangs that you have taught, otherwise it would not have taken a number of nihangs to jump Sukhjit singh, in Hola Mohalla at Anandpurb Sahib.
I urge to really think about this snaatanism, and sincerely compare its philosophy to Gurbani, and see there is no match. Your false notions of Singh Sabha, AKJ and Taksal being British-made, does not give your intelligence any credit. Realise the errors of what you preach, and use your Guru given virtues to spread real sikhism. I have no enemity for you or your brother, you know I am not like that. However I will always oppose the spread of Snaatanism into Sikh Youth.
Waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
london singh · 02 Apr 2005
VJKK VJKF
Kulbir Singh Ji
I am glad to know that there are Gursikhs out there who have the knowledge to take on these Nangs. I am not surprised that Parmjit Singh could not give any facts to back up his views. I have heard him talk and most of the stuff he chats about is pure garbage. For those who don't know Parmjit Singh is co-author of the 'warrior saints' book and was featured in the 1999 BBC documentary 'Sikhs'. It's sad that such people whose views are so anti-Gurmat hold centre stage in Sikh studies
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
Gatka Beginner · 03 Apr 2005
Phaji wrote:
"There is no heroism in any of these nihangs that you have taught, otherwise it would not have taken a number of nihangs to jump Sukhjit singh, in Hola Mohalla at Anandpurb Sahib. "
Sorry I'm just a beginner and don't have any of the background knowlegde that so many others have. So I was wondering if anyone could tell me what the above quoted line was referring to.
GurFateh
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
manjh payara guru ko · 03 Apr 2005
bole so nihal sat sri akalllllllllllllllllllllllllll
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
Shabeg singh · 03 Apr 2005
Parmjit singh was defeated in the debate with s. Kulbir singh.
My question for him is what is his stand on Khalistan?
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
Kulbir Singh · 03 Apr 2005
JSS,
Please refer to the following link for response to your allegations on me:
http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=32716&t=32716
Let us stick to the topic under this thread.
Kulbir Singh
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
Search For Tat · 04 Apr 2005
for all the "Open Challenges " by jagdeep/nidar/parmjit on their websites, it seems when those challenges are accepted, they have nothing to offer!
nidar is unconvincing in his fight with teji, who seemed on top. Paramjit was clueless when faced by Kulbir Singh. Jagdeep (aka narsingha, notorious webmaster), when Amritpal Singh Amrit accepted his challenge for a debate at Hola Mohalla, he could not be found, and has been hiding ever since!
What is happening to the undefeatable, super-confident UK nangs????
F.A.O Gatka beginner:-
At Hola Mohalla, Anandpur Sahib, Kamalroop (UK nang leader) was stirring with India nihangs saying Satnam had been speaking against them in UK. Satnam stood his ground. Sukhjit asked kamalroop why he was stirring. Kamalroop asked him out for a fight, Sukhjit slapped him up, Kamalroop legged it with his tail between his legs.
Later a group of Uk Nangs in a jeep, without kamalroop cornered Sukhjit by himself and attacked him. One cut him behind his neck with an axe, and another hit him with a latthi on his face. But Sukhjit pulled his kirpan out and held his ground, causing them injuries aswell. Then some singhs came to help Sukhjit, and one of the India nihangs pulled out a gun. Singhs calmed things down and broke it up. I do not like to hear Singhs fighting Singhs or youth fighting youth, but the cowardice with which these UK nangs cannot fight one on one, and always need to fight 5 on one like pakistanis do in Uk.
This is not shaster vidya? Singh fought Sava lakh se Ek laroun! These nangs cannot even fight one on one!
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
can't think of a name.. · 04 Apr 2005
Have to say I agree with Dogma Ji's point here.. How about a little compassion for those who you don't agree with, if you talk with abit of consideration you might be taken seriously instead of pushing people away. Having a go at people isn't going to help at all.
Peace.
Ps, I'm not on either side so please don't go off on one at me.. I'm merely expressing my opinion!! :p
[%sig%]
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
Birmingham Singh · 04 Apr 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fateh jio
Tapoban Sangat
Guru di kirpa, you handled the situation well, once these Nangs get a foothold, they with try to put doubts in all the sangat ther.
And you watch once you defeat them (as you have) they will result to obsenictities, violence( as in panjab) and then back to their favorite (where it all started from) cussing the Akj
now i am not blaming anyone else and I am also responsible for not standing up but how come the Singhs in Uk have not taken the same approach in challenging them
Has anyone been to Nang Niddars classes to confont them about their views?
Has anyone openly challenged them to a debate in UK like Veer Amritpal Singh did in India?
Has anyone been to the 3 gurdwaras in Uk where they have classes and oppose the committees in supporting these Nangs?
This issue started in Uk ( 6-7 yrs ago)
now SURELY it's time for all uk sangat to unite as one and challenge these Nangs intellegtully and show them for the Nangs they really are.
The time has come
we need to stand up and be counted,-
Saint-Siphai
Akaalllllllllllllllll
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
Gurjant singh · 04 Apr 2005
I herd many times Balpreet singh has defeated Parmjit singh in debate and that is not once but thrice.
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
moddehhalakainach · 04 Apr 2005
i have to say jag singh i agree with a lot of what you say and perhaps i disagree with a lot of what roopkaur penji says but one thing is certain bhai mardana ji and bhai bala ji sandhu may have been hindu and muslim to start with. But they became gursikhs of Guru Nanak Ji. I have researched this it is either inside Guru Granth Sahib Maharaj or bhai gurdas Ji vara cclearly states they became sikhs.
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
london singh · 05 Apr 2005
Jag Singh
>>Correct me if I’m wrong but in order to reach maya, you DO NOT NEED to belong to a group. Being part of a group might help you become enlightened but it is not a necessity<<
It's not Roop Kaur Bhainji who is confused it is you who doesn't even know the basics of sikhi yet want to give us lessons on what it means to be a Sikh! Good luck in your attempts to reach 'maya'..lol
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
Jagjit Singh · 05 Apr 2005
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, many of us have turned up to their akharas, or had conversations with them. We have gone as individuals, we are not intimidated by them. If a khalsa gets intimidated so easily, then he needs to look inside. The bottom line is even in their akhaaras, they know and have admitted their websites are wrong, and usually shuffle the blame on each other. Comments like these youth that people say are Niddar chelas, are nothing but a "bunch of monkeys". Or they deny they have control on the site.
Basically their is a complete lack of honesty, and shamelessness. These guys just love the attention, which is why most of us do not really bother anymore with them. There biggest weapon has always been shocking people to get more attention.
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
BirRaas Singh · 05 Apr 2005
Could people stop reffering to guys who train at the akhara as "sanatanists", most people there do not conform to the whole sanatan sikh ideology nor does everyone there have a hatred for the AKJ as is being depicted on this website. Infact there are allot of AKJ youth and Taksal youth who turn up at the akharas to train, and they have never had any problems there.
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
jugroop singh · 05 Apr 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Veer 'BirRaas Singh Ji',
You wrote:
'Infact there are allot of AKJ youth and Taksal youth who turn up at the akharas to train'
Piyare veer Ji, when one keeps in mind the level of complete and utter contempt, venomous statements and slanderous opinions which have been projected via the two websites towards Gurmukh Piyare, to do Sangat with such individuals....wow!!!!
Call me a fanatic by all means, but this kind of fanatacism is firmly within Gurmat - should we get into a discussion regarding panktis which tell us why we shouldn't do Sangat with people such as this...!?
If anyone 'likes to label themselves' as Jatha or Taksaal, then it is truly mindboggling to think that such people, who clearly enjoy 'affiliating themselves' would want to do Sangat of such people.
If the above doesn't make sense then anyone feel free to tell me about my 'puritanical close-mindedness'.
VahiGuruJiKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: My meeting with UK Nihungs
Harminder Singh · 05 Apr 2005
Grow up!
be productive, read paat, at least focus MORE on the gurbani veechar. There are many people on this site who have alot of stuff to share and their words can, at any time, inspire us in the right way...