Question on External Bebeaik
Son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 27 Jul 2003
vaaheguru ji ka khalsa vaaheguru ji ki fateh
Before I start this topic, I want to tell everyone clearly that I'm not starting this thread to discredit the Sikh Rehit Maryaada which has been kept by Gursikhs even in the tough times or to prove some elements of this Rehit wrong. Daas himself keeps bebeaik. I was recently talking to someone about Dhan Dhan Dassam Pitta Ji and we started talking about the Shaheedi of Choote Sahibzaade. That person told me how they have personally seen the glasses in which Moote Mehraa Ji brought milk for the Choote Sahibzaade. That made me wonder about BEBEAIK! Moote Mehraa Ji was not Amritthari Singh as far as I know but yet his seva was accepted by Choote Sahibzaade. So Khalsa ji, please enlighten me on this.
vaaheguru ji ka khalsa vaaheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Question on External Bebeaik
Kulbir Singh · 28 Jul 2003
>>>>>>>
Before I start this topic, I want to tell everyone clearly that I'm not starting this thread to discredit the Sikh Rehit Maryaada which has been kept by Gursikhs even in the tough times or to prove some elements of this Rehit wrong. Daas himself keeps bebeaik. I was recently talking to someone about Dhan Dhan Dassam Pitta Ji and we started talking about the Shaheedi of Choote Sahibzaade. That person told me how they have personally seen the glasses in which Moote Mehraa Ji brought milk for the Choote Sahibzaade. That made me wonder about BEBEAIK! Moote Mehraa Ji was not Amritthari Singh as far as I know but yet his seva was accepted by Choote Sahibzaade. So Khalsa ji, please enlighten me on this.
>>>>>>>>
I have not heard of this story anywhere. Most of these stories have been made by Dhaadees who like to add masala to the original saakhis.
First of all, glasses did not exist during the time of Sahibzadas. At that time they used to have only baatay or thaal; no glass-shape utensils. Baata was used to drink water or milk.
Secondly milk is a raw ingredient and many Sarblohi Bibeki singhs including Nihungs do take raw milk from outside and they then boil it in sarbloh. I should mention that some singhs do not take milk even and they are not wrong in doing so. To keep more sucham (spiritual cleanliness) cannot be wrong.
Some say that Gangu who ratted out the Sahibzadey was a cook in Guru Sahib’s kitchen. There is nothing more false than this. Why would Guru Sahib have separate kitchen when there was langar? Is it believable that Guru Sahib would allow a Hindu Brahmin in his kitchen to be a cook? We are talking about our Great Guru Sahib who has stated that if the Khalsa follow the Brahmin way, he will lose trust in Khalsa. How could that Guru allow a Hindu Brahmin in his kitchen? This is impossible!
So pyariyo, don’t be misled by such sakhis. They are false or they contain only half truth. Let us have faith in Sikh rehit and Sikh maryada.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Question on External Bebeaik
Kulbir Singh · 28 Jul 2003
daas wrote:
> Veer Kulbir Singh jee,
>
> They've had glasses for more than a thousand years - I don't
> know which planet you're speaking from.
>
> Jesus Christ had glasses at the "last supper" ... 2000 years
> ago.
>
> I'm pretty sure even the King Ram from 5000 years ago had
> glasses in the kitchens of his kingdom.
No they did not have glasses in India. India was not using glasses to drink. They used baatay. Baata was typically called – chhanna. This is a very recent thing. They used chhanay to drink milk or whatever. Glasses were virtually unheard.
I know that in Punjab, they were not using glasses for sure. People in those days did not keep crockery as they do now. Even recently in pinds of Punjab I have seen that all they had was a baata and even thaals were rare. People in pinds would put daal or sabjee in the baata and roti in their hands. In some cases, they did not even use baata and put everything on their roti and eat food that way. Even if there were glasses in India, they were extremely rare and the common person did not use them.
>
> The fact is clear - Guru jee accepted food prepared with love
> for God, from a person who earned an honest living - regardless
> of their religion.
>
Don't be too sure about this. Read Gurmat section of this site for more details.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Question on External Bebeaik
Son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 30 Jul 2003
vaaheguru ji ka khalsa vaaheguru ji ki fateh
Bhai Sahib, there's actually a Gurdwara Sahib named after Moote Mehra in Fatehgarh Sahib district and it is very close to the place where Choote Sahibzaade were kept with Mata Gujar Kaur ji. That's the place where the glasses are kept to this very day.
Can you also enlighten us more about Gangu and how he his role ever got into Sikh history?
vaaheguru ji ka khalsa vaaheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Question on External Bebeaik
Gangu Di Katha · 01 Aug 2003
Sat Sri Akal:
Gangu Brahmin was a Brahmin who was hired by Guru Tegh Bahadur to serve the Brahmins who sought out his help from Aurangzeb (The Brahmins would only eat food cooked by other Brahmins). Then he was released from Guru Sahib's service.
Upon leaving Anandpur Sahib, Guru Gobind Singh met up with Gangu Brahmin again. Gangu was told by Guru Gobind Singh Sahib to take care of his mother, Mata Gujri and the two Chhote Sahibzadae. However, Gangu got greedy and gave out the whereabouts of Mata Gujri and the Chhote Sahibzadae to Aurangzeb so he could get a reward.
It is to be noted that the Descendants of Gangu Brahmin are the likes of Nehru, Indira and Rajiv Gandhi.
Re: Question on External Bebeaik
Son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 06 Aug 2003
Thanks Guru Pyareo!!!
Now please do kirpaa and prove daas wrong again by telling us more about Moote Mehraa. :S
Thanks again!