Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told
Amritpal Singh · 28 Mar 2005
Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told
Warning from top religious authority
Says marriage backers will be shunned
MARTIN REGG COHN
ASIA BUREAU
AMRITSAR, India—The world's highest Sikh authority has admonished Sikh-Canadian MPs to block the gay marriage bill in Parliament, saying anyone who votes it into law will be ostracized by their community for flouting their religious duty.
In a blunt warning to observant Sikhs, with possible repercussions on the Canadian political scene, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti described the severe consequences facing any MP who dares to defy his directive on "the laws of nature."
Interviewed in the revered Golden Temple, where he occupies the highest Sikh temporal seat, Vedanti disclosed for the first time that he personally reminded six visiting Sikh-Canadian MPs during their visit here two months ago of their religious duty to oppose gay marriage legislation now being debated by Parliament.
Bill C-38, which has already passed first reading, is expected to become law this spring.
"The basic duty of Sikh MPs in Canada should be to support laws that stop this kind of practice (homosexuality) — because there are thousands of Sikhs living in Canada — to ensure that Sikhs do not fall prey to this practice," he said.
Dressed in a traditional white kurta cotton shirt and maroon turban, Vedanti grew impassioned as he described his occasionally tension-filled encounter with the visiting MPs last January on the eve of Prime Minister Paul Martin's official visit to nearby New Delhi. Martin had been scheduled to make a personal visit here but it was cancelled to make time for stops in Thailand and Sri Lanka in the wake of the Dec. 26 tsunami.
In bypassing Amritsar, Martin avoided a potentially embarrassing encounter with Vedanti, who would have hosted his tour and waded into Canadian domestic politics. But the visiting Sikh MPs were not able to escape the stern lecture delivered by the revered religious figure, who repeated his strong wording during an interview in his private study overlooking the temple precincts where pilgrims come to worship.
"I told them about Sikh teachings and how Sikhs should come forward to protect these Sikh tenets," said Vedanti, acting as the Jathedar Akal Takht — the highest Sikh authority.
"The Sikh religion would never accept such MPs. Nobody would support such a person having such dirty thoughts in their mind because it is against the Sikh religion and the Sikh code of conduct and totally against the laws of nature."
Sikhs around the world must maintain fidelity to these religious teachings, he argued, and no politician is exempt. Anyone who disobeys his directive risks the wrath of all Sikhs.
"Most of the Sikh community would resent them, and the majority of the Sikh population living in Canada would boycott them," he predicted, referring to the more than 280,000 Sikh Canadians.
Gesturing sharply with his hands, Vedanti singled out rookie Liberal MP Navdeep Bains (Mississauga-Brampton South) for daring to disagree with him during their meeting last January.
"There was one Sikh MP who didn't agree," he recalled, citing Bains by name.
The other visiting MPs "preferred to remain silent on this issue" and merely listened respectfully to the high priest's message.
Vedanti's words were echoed yesterday by Manjit Singh Kalkatta, another highly respected Sikh preacher who sits on the governing body of the Golden Temple, the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee.
Kalkatta, a former Punjab state cabinet minister who personally hosted a visit to the Golden Temple by former prime minister Jean Chrétien in late 2004, confirmed Vedanti's account of the encounter with the visiting Sikh-Canadian MPs two months ago.
"We expect from every practising Sikh, whether he is a member of a legislative assembly or Parliament, that he would abide by his faith," Kalkatta said.
If not, he cautioned, "it might be that they are censured."
He described how Bains made his views known and was subjected to strong pressure to amend his views or face the consequences.
"I was successful in putting a message to him that he should not espouse this cause publicly, as the Sikh people would reject that and he would lose his own people's support. He is a baptized Sikh, and must adhere to the principles of his religion."
Kalkatta noted approvingly that Liberal MP Gurbax Malhi (Bramalea-Gore-Malton) stated his opposition to same-sex marriage, but expressed dissatisfaction that fellow Liberal Ruby Dhalla (Brampton-Springdale) was non-committal during her visit.
"The lady MP (Dhalla) she abstained from saying anything" during the discussions in Amritsar, he said.
Dhalla is believed to be leaning toward the bill but has said she will consult her constituents. Health Minister Ujjal Dosanjh, also a Liberal, supports the legislation. Conservative MPs Gurmant Grewal (Newton-North Delta) and his wife Nina Grewal (Fleetwood-Port Kells) are known to oppose it.
Parliament is expected to have a free vote on the same-sex marriage issue, except for cabinet ministers who must support the bill. But the bottom line is that every vote will be closely watched by Sikh religious figures here and in Canada, Kalkatta predicted.
"The advice given by the highest Sikh temporal authority to every Sikh is saying that it is unnatural and ungodly, and the Sikh religion cannot support it. When the appeal is made to every Sikh from the highest authority, then MPs come under the same thing."
Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told
Amritpal Singh · 29 Mar 2005
Sikh leader's advice to MPs dismissed
Faith officially impartial to gay unions
Vedanti has `no understanding' of issue
PRITHI YELAJA
STAFF REPORTER
A top Sikh leader in India who admonished Sikh Canadian MPs to not support same-sex marriage legislation has no authority to do so and, moreover, shows a remarkable lack of understanding of the issue, say some observers here.
Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti — acting as the Jathedar Akal Takht, the highest Sikh authority in Amritsar — told the Toronto Star's Martin Regg Cohn this week that he warned six Sikh Canadian MPs visiting India that they would be ostracized from the community if they supported Bill C-38.
"With the utmost respect, Mr. Vedanti and the Akhal Takht have no understanding of the Canadian context on this issue and have no jurisdiction to tell Canadians how to deal with it," T. Sher Singh, a Guelph lawyer and trustee of the Sikh Foundation International, said.
"He's no more a priest or high priest than I am the Queen of England," Singh added. He noted that Sikhdom does not have a religious hierarchy.
The Akhal Takht, whose office is across from the Golden Temple, has no authority on spiritual issues, but rather, rules on administrative and political matters facing the Sikh community in India, said Singh.
Same-sex union is not an issue the Sikh religion has an official stance on, so it's up to individual MPs to follow their own conscience, Singh said.
In fact, observant Sikhs, because of their religion's emphasis on human rights and tolerance, particularly for marginalized and persecuted groups, have an obligation to support the legislation, he said.
"It would be wrong to oppose it because certainly gays have been mistreated and denied equal rights to date."
Others point out the proposed legislation is a legal issue and not a religious one.
"I'm dismayed that it's being turned into a religious issue," said Sat Gosal, a Mississauga lawyer and founding member of the Sikh Centennial Foundation.
"The legislation makes it clear that there is no obligation on religious organizations to sanctify same-sex marriages. Some people who are vehemently opposed to the legislation haven't taken the time to understand that distinction and it has not been made clear to Vedanti or others in the sangat (congregation)."
There is a generational divide in the Canadian Sikh community on the legislation, said Gosal.
"The people who've grown up here and understand the significance of the Charter generally support it, while the sangat who haven't grown up here, don't."
The issue highlights a puzzling dichotomy, said Gosal. The right of devout Sikhs in Canada to wear the five K's required of their religion — the comb, bangle, underpants and most visibly the kirpan and turban — is protected under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
Bill C-38 is being proposed under the same Charter.
"It's incongruous to support the Charter of Rights in one instance and then wholesale jettison it for other minorities when it doesn't suit your purpose."
Liberal MP Navdeep Bains (Mississauga-Brampton South) apparently was the only one of the six MPs to disagree with Vedanti during the meeting.
Bains said yesterday he tried to educate Vedanti about the legislation, telling him it doesn't "trump religious institutions" but rather extends civil rights.
"We have a very diverse country and the only way minorities can coexist peacefully is (because) we have the Charter. That's what I'm trying to defend here," said Bains.
"It would be a different scenario if religious institutions ... the synagogue, the church, the mandir, the gurudwara, if these institutions were not protected" under this legislation.
Bains said his reasons for supporting Bill C-38 are rooted in personal experience. Growing up in Mississauga wearing a turban, he felt like an "outcast."
"The only thing that allowed me to practise my faith was (the Charter.) That's why I feel very adamant about upholding the principles of the Charter because it has done so much for me on a personal level."
The other five MPs could not be reached for comment.
However, Liberal MP Gurbax Malhi (Bramalea-Gore-Malton) has voiced his opposition to same-sex marriage, and Conservative MPs Gurmant Grewal (Newton-North Delta) and his wife Nina Grewal (Fleetwood-Port Kells) are known to oppose it as well.
Liberal MP Ruby Dhalla (Brampton-Springdale) has been non-committal, saying she will seek the opinion of her constituents. Liberal Health Minister Ujjal Dosanjh supports the legislation.
Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told
Amritpal Singh · 29 Mar 2005
The only person im really concerned with is Navdeep bains...hes the only amritdari out of the list of Mp's.
Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told
Amritpal Singh · 29 Mar 2005
what if people wanted the right to marry dogs and horses?
should we let that into the charter of rights??
The charter shouldnt be a document that allows activity such as homosexuality. its wrong and why should we allow its behaviour to be accepted into our laws?
Its against sikhi and its also against most other religions as well.
Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told
Amanpreet Singh Bal · 29 Mar 2005
What's Vedanti trying to prove by degrading homosexuals? People like him should think before they speak. It's normal to have different opinion but opposition must be done in a civilized and rational manner. What is Sikh Rehat Maryada's position on fake Sant Babe? Alcohol is taboo in Sikhism but few days ago State govt in Punjab held the auction of Liquor shops. Why such a double standard?
For those people who are trying to equate Vedanti's statements as "word of god", I request them to get a copy of the Gurbilas Patshahi 6 and read it. If we are going to claim that whatever Vedanti says is correct and must be followed then are we going to allow the Katha of Gurbilas Patshahi 6 in our Gurdwaras? Gurbilas Patshahi 6 was edited by Vedanti and one other person and is full of anti-Sikhi material.
Amanpreet
[%sig%]
Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told
gurpreet singh · 30 Mar 2005
watever happens, jjust accept it, who cares, take it as paana, stop arguing over it
hukam maniyo guru kaira, gavo sachee bani
Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told
Princess of Guru Sahib · 30 Mar 2005
Amanpreet singh Bal jee, don't forget sikhi in try of supporting Bains. Your posts tell us you are a loyal supporter of bains but not a loyal sikh of Guru Sahib jee. On other hand, if you rethink seriously, you are being a big enemy of Bains by misleading him. All of his advisors are playing role of his real enemies at this time by advising him to support gay bill. Religion is above politics. In sikhi Politics without religion is nothing more than dirt.
You have no right to insult our Jathedaar like that. What do you know about gurmat?. Did you ever follow it? No one can be a sikh by geting birth in sikh family. You have to adopt it by chukking amrit and offering your head(not monna head but a head with uncut hair). It's funny, you never adopted sikhi and challenging Sikh Jathedaar. I feel sorry for Navdeep Singh who has that kind of manmukh advisors. Any one can see his dark future if he does not stop following this kind of people's advises.
Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told
General Narender bhullar · 30 Mar 2005
WSO has always tried to use the Sikhs as launching pads.Lets see the history they did the same in malhis nomination.
They brought Jagmeet sing brar in Dixie gurudwara where he swore in front of guru sahib that he is true Khalistani and now he is saying captain and maan are Khalistani.
They used the sikh vote in the nomination of bains and are now looking for the cabinet post but they will never get it niether did Inderjit bal .Guru ji will help Sikhs.
Their leaders play golf with the Indian counslate they even visit their homes i hope you post this
Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told
Princess of Guru Sahib · 30 Mar 2005
>>>>if someone wants to be gay and legally marry a gay partner whats it gotto do with you?
wheres the sikh duty in every other problem area? drug wars? caste? gender inequality? youth? need i carry on?
<<<<<<<<<
No one is questioning gays, drugies or any other problem creaters here. But Sikhs are not allowed to support above kind of paaps. Sikhi does not allow that. It's so simple.
Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told
Kulbir Singh · 11 Apr 2005
The reality is that the Gay Bill is not about freedom of Gays or anyone else. They have all the freedom they need here in Canada. The crux of the problem is that they want to use a word that is sacred to religions, to define their sexual union. Why do they want to use a heterosexual term to define their sinful relationship?
The term "marriage" for centuries, throughout the world has been used to define the union of a heterosexual couple. This term is a sacred term for most religions. Why are they insisting on calling their union a “marriage”? They already have all the rights they need because of the law they have passed for “civil union”.
You talk about the rights for Gays. What about the rights of religions in Canada? Today the Gays are asking that the term “Marriage” be used to define their sexual union. Tomorrow they will say that they want “Nikah” (a Muslim religious word for marriage) to define their marriage. Later they may file a lawsuit to have the Sikh holy word for the union of heterosexual couples “Anand Karaj” to define their sexual union. Where will this nonsense stop?
Today they are asking us to accept their homosexual sexual union as “Marriage” or “Anand Karaj” or “Nikah”. Tomorrow some perverted people may want to marry their pets like dogs and they may want to call it a “marriage”. Are we going to accept that?
It is time to stop this zaleel conduct now. If they want to do something like this they should do it in their bedrooms. Why are they defiling the whole society? Why do they want the society to stamp their abnormal sexual union?
Anyway, let us come back to Sikhi. What should a Sikh do today in the light of the government proposal to pass the law to allow the sacred term of “Marriage” to be used to define the sexual union of two homosexual persons? There is no obscurity in Sikhi about this issue. Siri Akal Takhat Sahib has declared very openly that Sikhs are not to indulge in this kind of sexual activity and that Sikhs are not to support any such legislation that may result in the degeneration of the society.
Apart from Siri Akal Takhat Sahib, SGPC has openly said that the homosexual conduct is not in accordance to Sikh faith. It is now time for Akhand Kirtani Jatha and Damdami Taksal to issue statements discouraging such conduct in Sikhs.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told
@~~~~~~~~~~ · 12 Apr 2005
gays and lesbians have asked to be legally married but not in religious places so far. If they did it would be upto the committees who run religious places to say NO instead of thinking about lining up their pockets.