Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

marriage

marriage

aikon · 27 Mar 2005

should a man get married to a woman who is amritdhari but has had a series of boyfriends including physical relationships, and has taken pesh 4-5 times for acts of kaam? is there something wrong or should you take her word that she is changing? does it effect your jeevan because of the number of tiems shes taken pesh for the same thing? [%sig%]

Re: marriage

s!nghn! · 28 Mar 2005

We all make mistakes. If, however, we are serious about Sikhi, we should never make the same mistake over and over. Repeatedly making the same grave mistake almost makes forgiveness a joke. Having said that, after committing her last mistake, if the woman in question got peshed and was forgiven by Punj Pyaaray, you cannot dispute it or hold the mistake against her. If Punj Pyaaray forgave her, we must as well. Forgiving her and being willing to marry her is two different things though. It depends on the man. We all have different levels of tolerance. My threshold for such a mistake would be maybe three times, tops. Anything beyond that should clearly demonstrate both complete disregard for Sikhi and a total lack of interest in mending her ways. You can forgive the mistake without necessarily forgetting the implications about the character of such a person who repeatedly makes these mistakes without any reform.

Re: marriage

Amritpal Singh · 28 Mar 2005

If guru sahib through panj pyaairey have forgiven her, and she has gotten peshed, and she is in good standing then theirs nothing against gurmat marrying that person Your jeevan will not be affecting by the number of times she got peshed. As long as after anand karaj and after she was peshed she is in good standing. Leave the judgement calls up to Panj Pyarey, but rest is your choice. If you feel comfortable with her then go for it. If you dont then dont do it. Just to add, I wouldnt correspond with her directly like it seems you are doing (if im wrong then correct me) SHE shouldnt be telling you anything about her changing etc etc. We as khalsa arent supposed to just arrange our own marriages and talk openly with them before marriage. You should talk to her through other gursikhs and other people, parents. seems as if you are caught in a dating/relationship situation and this bibi and you have an intimate relationship.... if im wrong then sorry...

Re: marriage

..... · 28 Mar 2005

i think you should be very cautious...

Re: marriage

des pardes · 28 Mar 2005

you will only get yourself in trouble in the end

Re: marriage

troubled · 28 Mar 2005

i posted a post few days ago - "can the past stay in the past?" and i am in a situation that is quite similar, apart from the fact that im not amritdhaari, lookin to get married, or have had a series of boyfriends, BUT i have made lots of mistakes in the past and am trying to change myself and i personally think there has been a difference in me. i am having the problem of a friend claiming to accept those changes but not actually accepting them and allowing me to put them in the past, even though i have tried to prove it to them...and this is really hurting me as i have genuinely made the change and yet im still being judged. what im trying to say is, is that sometimes you may need to trust and believe in someone when they say theyv changed. just think about what kind of treatment you would like if you were in a similar position. and anyway like amritpal veerji has sed if Panj Piyaarey have forgiven and forgotten her who are you not to? [%sig%]

Re: marriage

Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 28 Mar 2005

---should a man get married to a woman who is amritdhari but has had a series of boyfriends including physical relationships, and has taken pesh 4-5 times for acts of kaam?--- If one has kaam in their mind and get peshed for that, then that is fine. But when reacting to the kaam and having a physical relationship someone is wrong. If they have gotten peshed and guru ji has forgiven them, then what can you say? But i'm surprised that this person has gotten so many chances. is there something wrong or should you take her word that she is changing? does it effect your jeevan because of the number of tiems shes taken pesh for the same thing?---- You can not be sure if the person changes. I mean this person has made the same mistake over and over and over again. I personally dont think this person has changed, they might change in the future, but only guru ji knows that. Why not talk to elder Singhs to get some guidence. Dalrajkaur Khalsa

Re: marriage

Kulbir Singh · 28 Mar 2005

Aikon, I would suggest that you consult Senior Gursikhs (at least five) in your area on what to do. You should look at yourself too, that you had a relation with this person even after being an amritdhari. If you marry some other girl, who is clean, then would it be fair to her, since you have had a relation with some other girl before? Again, I personally believe that one should not get married to someone if one's heart is not willing to. If you believe that she is being earnest in her resolution of changing, then go ahead and get married to her but if you have a doubt, then you need to be cautious. Ultimately, it is all in Guru Sahib's hands. The worse person of the world can be really nice to you and keep you happy, if Guru Sahib is pleased and on the other hand the best person in the world may act like a jammdoot to you, if Guru Sahib is not pleased. Make your Guru happy by japping Naam, doing paath and keeping rehit. Only good will happen to you then. Kulbir Singh

Re: marriage

des pardes · 28 Mar 2005

if they have taken pesh 4 to 5 times for the SAME thing then i think there is something VERY wrong there then. I suggest you find out the reasons this happened and be cautious that it might happen again. on a personal note i would want the woman to have a clean past such as i have so i will not judge her or doubt her...

Re: marriage

eye · 28 Mar 2005

personally..if shes been forgiven once..maybe even twice its okay but the fact that the same "mistake" is constantly being repeated..then do her actions honestly show that shes learned anything? i doubt it.. but theres always the "if the panj piaray forgave her then you should too" but forgiving her and continuing a relationship with her are two differnt things.. if i were in that situation i probally wouldnt do it...

Re: marriage

sajjana · 28 Mar 2005

"should a man get married to a woman who is amritdhari but has had a series of boyfriends including physical relationships, and has taken pesh 4-5 times for acts of kaam?" i would not marry this girl. a)she has taken pesh 4 times which shows you alot about how serious she takes Gurus amrit. If she takes amrit that loosley how do you expect her to take her sikhi and your sikhi seriously. b)you should forgive her...not marry her. you would want someone who has their feet firmly on the ground, not someone who hasnt been able to stay in a set relationship without giving into kaam... c)how would you feel about not being her first..theres alot of expectations to live up to..plus you would judge her alot and look at her differently knowing she has been around..youl never be equals these are my own personal views but i agree with bhai kulbir singh...have some elders know about this issue so it can be properly resolved..

Re: marriage

Me · 29 Mar 2005

How many times are you allowed to get pesh? Isnt there some sort of limit to the amount of times you can, I mean, otherwise people will just keep on sinning and treating it as a joke?

Re: marriage

singh · 29 Mar 2005

this is an awkard one. depends if you yourself dated. if you did not as the prevuious post said how would you feel knowing she had been with someone else? and moreover could this not be on your mind after your married to her when you wake up every morning by her side. another thing you must grasp is the reality of her bumping into her exes down the road how will you be able to handle that? i myself would probably get really peed off. if you can handle that and she has sincreley changed from inside and been forgiven by the panj piare then her life starts afresh, but the habit needs to be killed inside the person, inside the brain level, that can only happen with loads of naam and bhagti. So best people to consult as bhai klubir singh suggest older singhs in your area. i would talk to the panj piare about this if i were you.

Re: marriage

MOW · 29 Mar 2005

LOL if someone doesnt learn after 1 pesh, there is serious po involved...if they havent learnt by the 2nd pesh....its quite obvious they live in po mansion. dont do these tengs, you will regret it in the end. its blatant something is wrong if someone hasnt learnt after peshing 5 times for the same (massive) mistake. amrit is not a game. tanks.

Re: marriage

SriSahib · 29 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!! We should never stop questioning ourselves and our intentions. Also the implications of our actions. Newton's Laws say evry action has a reaction. IMHO that doesn't mean stop or detain/ reftain the action- just be prepared to deal with the consequences. Stay strong sangatO. One knows what's inside oneself. Judgments of other mere mortals do not matter an ounce. Also, lets' not forget husband and wife are sangi-saathees. Their jeevans should preferably be on the same wavelength. That isn't to say either is perfectly clear of 'sins' or whatever. It's called GuNnaa dee Saanj- where one maybe slightle weaker/ vulnerable to attack- the other is there to SUPPORT them and lend a helping hand- not a slapping hand!! Guru Ji doesn't say just turn the other cheek (as Christianity preaches) but kiss the feet! (das remembers reading a funny Nihang anecdote of this exemplified at a railway ticket station). I myself have seen this attitude in the most chardee kalaa Gursikhs. However, I do not BASE my Sikhiaa on what I see in others when I know I have Sri Guru Granth Sahib MAHARAAJ always there 4 me. That is what having your feet on the ground is- being rooted in SIKHI and having a 'down-to-earth' , not lofty attitude to life. Forgiveness is the first stage, and then there is moving onwards. The only way is up.....unless you wanna fall doen the slippery slope. Eat to live- don't live to eat. From what angle are you debaters seeing it? From the perspective that YOU have of marriage, ie. primarily to satisfy sexula needs/ URGES!!LOLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLZZZZZZZZZZ. Shame on you if so. We should have higher values and standards than society. That is because we go under the authority of Panj piaarae, Akaal Thakat sahib, and Guru Khalsa Panth----->EKTAx Chardee Kalaa! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!