Mangals and Mool Mantar
Bijla Singh · 27 Mar 2005
Could someone please explain the reasons for keeping the Mangals the way they are now in Guru Ji's saroop? It is pretty obvious why consistency is needed and Professor Sahib Singh Ji's writing leaves no doubt but I would like to know what the reasons of the opposition party were? If someone knows please post or at least refer me to any source. I would like to study both sides. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Mangals and Mool Mantar
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 28 Mar 2005
vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa
vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!!
forgive me if i have misunderstood your post... are you suggesting that guru sahib ji's suroop needs changing?
guru sahib ji's suroop is guru sahib ji's bhaanaa
guru sahib ji says:
so sikh sakhaa ba(n)dhhap hai bhaaee j gur kae bhaanae vich aavai ||
aapanai bhaanai jo chalai bhaaee vishhurr chottaa khaavai ||
bin sathigur sukh kadhae n paavai bhaaee fir fir pashhothaavai ||1||
guru sahib ji's suroop does not need changing
we need changing
from filthy to clean - using the original suroop of guru sahib ji to guide us.
guru sahib ji is perfect
please forgive my mistakes
vaaheguroo jee kaa kahalsaa
vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!
[%sig%]
Re: Mangals and Mool Mantar
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Mar 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Please re read Bijla Singh Ji's post...no one is suggesting that GURU SROOP needs to be "changed"...
GURU SROOP has ALREADY BEEN CHANGED.....DECADES AGO by the COMMERCIAL PRINTERS !!!! This BEADBI has been going on for decades...
The Commercial Printers changed the MANGALS from PRIME POSITION of TOP RIGHT HAND CORNER of AANG to whereever it suited them...
THE SGPC tried to REVERT BACK to ORIGINAL POSITION...but the SANT DERAWADDI LOBBY objected....and Of course the Commercial printers LOBBY SERIOSLY OBJECTED as their Printing Plates and thousands of sroops already in the market will be "WRONG"....and need to be corrected !!! which Buisnessman wants to incur a LOSS
I can understand why the business men want the STATUS QUO...but the SANTS-DERAWADDIS ??? they OPPOSE simply because whatever the SGPC does they MUST OPPOSE !!!
Now lets hear from the others......as Bilga Singh has requested. ALL the Proofs are in Sahib Singhh's Darpan ( TO REVERT BACK TO ORIGINAL)..I would like to see Proofs to Keep the STATUS QUO.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Mangals and Mool Mantar
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 31 Mar 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
For decades the sroops have been Printed, Published and SOLD by the Booksellers in Amrtisar....with hundreds of mistakes !!! Each new Type-setting made new mistakes !!!
SGPC made the First Attempt to Correct the mistakes, make PLATES of the AAngs so the msitakes wont happen during typesetting...etc and thats wehn they decided to REVERT the Mangals to their ORIGINAL Space as in the Kartarpuri Bir..... the "Opposition" raised a hue and cry saying the SGPC is CHANGING GURBANI !!! STOP THEM...and the effort died a natural death.
Read Prof Sagib Singh ji's explanation on this subject and you will agree how ridiculous Some placings of mangals turn out to be...but we continue to read them as they are printed in commercial sroops.
Now this COMMERCIAL DISEASE is rearing ts ugly ehad in the Form of GUTKAS.....naturally a GUTKA being such a small thing..no one really cares what you PRINT...so in the Market place you cna find all sorts of GUTKAS...with all sorts of Spurious additions, kachi banis, sakhis against gurmatt etc etc..some have long banis some have short banis...any Tom Dick and Harry ( he doesnt have to be SINGH/KHALSA/even SIKH) can get together some banis/etc etc and get a GUTKA printed and sold/distributed.
Just look at how much MONEY the "compiler" of Amrit Kirtan Pothi has made...after all it is just a COMPILATION of SHABADS....BUT every Kirtaniya in the world or wanna be kirtaniya has to have a COPY of AKP on his Vaja ???...but who checks if the shabads are correct/free of mistakes etc ??? NO ONE becasue this si a commercial pothi...
Looks like the Opposition to SGPC Mangals Reversion is not coming up with an answer...because there is NONE. Bijla Singh Ji dont hold your breath.
Jarnail Singh