Re: Kunthhaagar kirtan
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 25 Mar 2005
Is this keertan that is performed without any "amrit keertan pothee" ?
Re: Kunthhaagar kirtan
Kulbir Singh · 25 Mar 2005
Most samagams we went to during our stay in India, Sangat did kirtan without pothis. There was no pothi there at all. We were surprised to see some gursikhs doing up to 15-16 shabads in one sitting, without amrit kirtan pothi. As an example, Bhai Gurjinderpal Singh of Patiala did 15-16 shabads in the morning Asa kee Vaar kirtan and then another 15-16 shabads during Ran Subaayee kirtan in the evening, all kanth. Not only him, other singhs there too had all these shabads that he sung, kanth. Few times, some kirtanees forgot some pankitis but there were plenty of Singhs in sangat who had the shabad kanth and sang out the pankitis.
Inspired by them, we thought of trying to see if we in Tapoban Sahib can do the same as Gursikhs in India.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Kunthhaagar kirtan
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 25 Mar 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh.
IMHO this is the ONLY way Kirtan should be done...then the Kirtaniyaa can FULLY CONCENTRATE on His GURBANI.....it is all there flowing in an unending stream from his "dasam duaar"... unlike the constant "flicking about of pages of amrit kirtan due to wind..and then having to put a /watch/pen etc on the page to keep it open etc etc...utter distraction....
Just have a look at a Raagi doing kanthh kirtan and one who is doing it from a pothi...the former will be more concentrated on Gurbani...result more pyaar, bairaag, passion...
IMHO, the sangat can be given the kirtan shabads on paper...so that they read along ( and also notice any mistakes made by the raagi...so that he can be informed later and will correct himself)...and as time goes by, most of the sangat will also kanth most of the regularly sung shabads..laahaa on all fronts...for everybody concerned.
A Wonderful idea ....my congrats to all oncerned.
jarnail Singh
Re: Kunthhaagar kirtan
can't think of a name.. · 04 Apr 2005
How about also making it mandatory to do kirtan in raag?
[%sig%]
Re: Kunthhaagar kirtan
Search For Tat · 04 Apr 2005
I think it is more important the paath and kirtan is Shud. If doing it kunt means on occasions mistakes are made, then it is better doing it with a pothi.
I think Tapoban should test this, and report back. If after a few months, too many mistakes are being made, then the policy should be reviewed. It may also be noteworthy to see if this is another barriers restricting young sikhs coming forward and doing keertan regularly.