The puzzle of Sikhism in National Post on March 19, 2005
Harjinder Singh · 24 Mar 2005
fyi, Found this editorial and would like to share. It contains some highly harmful misrepresentation of the Sikhs as result of lack of research or deep rooted intentions to further tarnish the Sikh community.
Please post your response to this malicious smear campaign against Sikhism.
Please also write to this national Post columnist and paste its copy on this thread for the readers.
Harjinder Singh
""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
National Post
March 19, 2005
The puzzle of Sikhism
by [u]G E R A L D O W E N ( [address removed] )[/u]
The acquittal verdict on Wednesday in the Air India trial does not simply leave the case an unsolved mystery. The blowing up of an airplane and the murder of its passengers was the work of a few Sikh extremists. The judge, the defence and the Crown all agreed the leader of the conspiracy was Talwinder Singh Parmar, the founder of a British Columbia group called Babbar Khalsa, who was killed by Indian police in 1992.
One of the two defendants, Ajaib Singh Bagri, was a co-founder of Babbar Khalsa. “In 1985, when these terrible events occurred,” said Mr. Bagri after his acquittal, “I was a passionate advocate for an independent homeland for the Sikh people.”
That “was” is significant. This verdict is no victory for Sikh separatism. The project of Khalistan, a Sikh state, has faded. Today, Manmohan Singh, a Sikh, is the Prime Minister of India, leading a Congress party government, and he is a trusted friend of the Gandhi family. Back in 1984, it was another Congress prime minister, Indira Gandhi, who ordered the invasion of the Golden Temple in Amritsar, which led to her assassination by her Sikh bodyguards, and in turn to Hindu killings of Sikhs, and then the Air India bombing itself.
Here in Canada, Ujjal Dosanjh is the Minister of Health and was briefly the NDP premier of B.C. In 1987, he was “the most outspoken anti-Khalistani Sikh in the country” (for which he was beaten up), according to a book by two well-known Canadian writers, Clark Blaise and Bharati Mukherjee, The Sorrow and the Terror: The Haunting Legacy of the Air India Tragedy.
There is a puzzle about the Sikh religion. From the beginning it has taught and practised inward contemplation, and opposed external observances. But it developed another, more militant side, which could hardly be more external: a prescribed costume, almost a uniform.
The centre of Sikhism has always been the region of Punjab in what is now India and Pakistan, on the frontier between Hinduism and Islam. The founder, Guru Nanak, who lived from 1469 to 1539, was influenced by a longstanding Hindu devotional tradition, but also by Sufism, a side of Islam with affinities to meditative practices in other religions. Nanak’s breadth of mind is also illustrated by his wide travels, as far as Tibet, Sri Lanka, Baghdad and Mecca. He departed from Hinduism in saying unambiguously that there is only one God, but continued the belief in a cycle of reincarnation. He was against the Hindu caste system; in particular, he opposed the power of the priestly Brahmin caste.
Nanak was the first in a series of 10 Sikh gurus. This was the time of the Mughals, a usually tolerant dynasty of Muslim emperors of India from the 16th to the 18th century. But the Sikhs had some bad collisions with them. In 1606, one Mughal emperor executed Arjun, the fifth guru, who had appeared to favour a revolt by the emperor’s son.
The peaceable Sikh religion began to become more warlike. “Sparrows must become hawks,” said Gobind Singh, the 10th and last guru. In 1699, he instituted the Khalsa, a fraternity into which Sikh men would be initiated (whether some or all remains in question). They would comply with the “Five Ks”: uncut hair, a comb in the topknot, a steel bangle, the kirpan sword or dagger and shorts in a particular style. Gobind decreed that he would be the last guru; he may have designed the Khalsa (perhaps comparable to the Crusader military orders in the West) to replace the one-man leadership of the gurus.
The Mughals waned in the 1700s, creating a vacuum in which British power grew. Beyond the realm of the British East India Company, in Punjab, Sikh chieftains became strong. Above all, the one-eyed Ranjit Singh, who already commanded an army at the age of 10, acquired a large kingdom, ruling as Maharajah of Punjab, from 1801 to 1839.
Ranjit figured in global politics. After Napoleon and Tsar Alexander I made peace in 1807, the British feared designs on India by both France and
Russia, by way of Iran or Afghanistan. To secure their northern border, the British entered into a treaty with Ranjit Singh.
That was the greatest moment of Sikh power, but it was a far cry from 20th-century Khalistani separatism. In Ranjit’s state, there was a Muslim majority. “God intended that I should look upon all religions with one eye, he said. “That is why I was deprived of the other eye.”
His kingdom fell apart after his death and the British soon swallowed it. The Sikhs sided with them in the “Great Mutiny” of 1857-59 (now called the First War of Independence), not wishing to help restore the Mughals. Many Sikhs served in the British Army, most notably in the First World War. But Sikh-British friendship began to sour in May, 1914, when a shipload of Sikh emigrants was turned back from Vancouver harbour. Worse, in 1919 a foolish British general ordered his men to fire on a peaceful demonstration in a park in Amritsar, the Sikh religious centre. No single event did more to discredit the British Raj.
When independence came, the partition of India and Pakistan in 1947 split up Punjab, and 2 1 /2 million Sikhs moved into the Indian part, many of them leaving behind better farmland in what was now Pakistan. They became poorer, but also more densely grouped, which fed the fantasy of a Sikh nation-state to be called Khalistan.
In the 1980s, Indira Gandhi made a too-clever-by-half political manoeuvre. To weaken and outflank the established Sikh party, the Akali Dal, which was allied with the Hindu nationalist opposition, she assisted a compelling demagogic preacher called Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale, whose followers assaulted and sometimes killed non-Sikhs. Many people say that Mrs. Gandhi “created” him. Of course, that is no more true than saying the United States created Saddam or Osama bin Laden.
In December, 1983, Bhindranwale and his group took control of the Golden Temple and stockpiled arms there. (For comparison, imagine if the IRA were to store their weapons in St. Peter’s Basilica in Rome.) Something had to be done. Mrs. Gandhi was slow to act, but in June, 1984, Operation Bluestar was implemented. The Indian Army, complete with tanks, moved into the Golden Temple complex. The battle lasted from June 4 to 7, and hundreds of people were killed, including Bhindranwale; naturally, the buildings were damaged, too. In October, Mrs. Gandhi was murdered, and the Air India plane was blown up in June, 1985.
Twenty years on, the Green Revolution has made the farmers of Punjab more prosperous and calmer. But more than anything, the balance of nuclear terror between India and Pakistan has made Khalistan unthinkable. The two powers will never tolerate an unstable new factor in their midst.
[%sig%]
Re: The puzzle of Sikhism in National Post on March 19, 2005
Kulbir Singh · 24 Mar 2005
I think this article is a gross misrepresentation of Sikh faith. Shame on National Post for being so insensible despite being owned by a Jew.
The author of this article is a fool.
Kulbir Singh
Letter of Anne Lowthian ((World Sikh Organization) Re: The puzzle of Sikhism
Harjinder Singh · 24 Mar 2005
fyi
""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
Anne Lowthian
(World Sikh Organization)
Letter to the Editor
National Post
RE: Gerard Owen: 'The puzzle of Sikhism', The National Post, March 18, 2005.
From: Anne Lowthian, Executive Director, World Sikh Organization of Canada
One thing I only know - and that is that I know nothing. - Socrates
The age old battle that once pitted the 'wise and learned' against those who simply valued wisdom - is alive and well the 21st century. Proving that the only 'puzzle of Sikhism' is the confusion produced by a lack of research, Gerard Owen has been victimized by his own narrow interpretation of the Sikh religion, and has shamelessly misappropriated the voice of 23 million devotees around the world. (The puzzle of Sikhism, National Post, March 18, 2005).
Sikhs, like Socrates, seem to be treated as the 'gadflys' of society - repeatedly squashed for their efforts to sting the world into the pursuit of truth. Consistently challenging the powers that be, speaking on behalf of something far greater than them-selves, and criticizing all forms of injustice and corruption, Sikhs have been rewarded, as Socrates was, with poisonous public derision.
Perhaps Owen's article is the result of twenty years of promoting a lynch mob mentality during any discussion of the worst mass murder in Canadian history: Air India. But joining authors Blaise and Mukherjee in flaunting the findings of fact made by a B.C. Supreme Court Justice only supports the courtroom rebuke for intelligence gathering methods that are horribly negligent, inaccurate and indifferent.
Government, industry, and the media mercantile could all benefit from the learning opportunities that a proper Air India public inquiry could occasion, and such reconciliation might, by the way, inspire a 'gate keeping' editorial policy that is more inclusive, transparent and accountable to Canada's diverse population.
Personally, as a woman who aspires to join my Sikh sisters in that 'fraternity into which Sikh men would be initiated' I object to the characterization of the five Sikh articles of faith as in a 'militaristic uniform' intended for violent purposes, and exclusive only to men. Not only is this an offense to my feminine sensibilities, it is an outright denial of the religious principles of equality and justice represented in each of the Sikh kakars, and enshrined in Sikh scriptures and codes of conduct.
Journalists seem far too hasty in their dismissal of the fact that five hundred years before the United Nations put pen to paper, Sikh Gurus conceived of a world that provided the entire human race with equal dignity and respect - enshrining the equality of women (and all religions) in Sikh scripture. The Gurus who died as martyrs or 'Saint soldiers' defending freedom - did so to defend the beliefs of those they didn't agree with - exemplifying how true selflessness could bring an end to the practice of forced religious conversions. It is out of this same commitment to peace that many Sardars have distinguished Commonwealth Armies by earning fourteen Victoria crosses serving the cause of equality and the rule of law, around the world.
Yet salient facts like the Budge-Budge massacre that saw the gunning down of those 376 souls aboard the ill fated Komatagatu Maru - a ship full of primarily Sikh immigrants who were militarily 'escorted' from B.C.'s coast in 1914 - are suspiciously absent from any of Owens' circumspect evaluation of the 'souring' of the Sikh-British friendship. In actual fact, Britons and Americans seem learned enough to reassess the hundreds of millions of dollars in annual development aid that never seems to reach the millions of needy in India and will reject visa applications from Hindu nationalist diplomats found responsible for violations of religious freedoms. Meanwhile, Canada remains 'unconvinced' by the evidence that places India at the top of international lists of the world's most 'corrupt' democratic nations.
How simplistic to suggest that it was the 'density' of the Sikh population in Punjab, post partition that 'fed the fantasy of a Sikh nation state', when even a cursory examination reveals how the Green Revolution of the 60's and the diversion of the five river waters in the heart of Punjab have been an ever-flowing source of discord between state and central governments. The waters of life in India seem eternally damned by majority Hindu nationalistic policies and the oppression of dissenters from various religious and ethnic minority communities in all of the 25 states.
New Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, will have many challenges ahead, as the Energy Research Institute of New Delhi reports the land of the five rivers has had 98% of it's' groundwater exploited, losing over a metre a year, and forecasts a desert in the agricultural breadbasket of India by the year 2025. Since the economy of Sikhs in Punjab is dependent on agriculture, the legacy of the 'Green Revolution' is one of intensive water, chemical, pesticide and hybrid use that has depleted more than the soil.
Despite international pleas, political wrangling over diversification and distribution of revenues and resources, has added to the burden of price ceilings and production restrictions. The Economist Magazine, 5 March 2005, notes how India's average import tariff rate of 20% - makes the most basic of necessities absolutely unattainable for millions already impoverished. The World Bank notes that India has never adequately responded to the needs of 45% of India's women who remain illiterate - and without the most basic personal freedoms.
Some say deliberate policies of the central government of India have eroded the economic status of Sikhs since the British left in 47, and draconian laws and criminal police tactics murderously squelch the resulting public dissent. But there are enough independent international human rights organizations out there who can corroborate the documented plight of Christians, Buddhists, Jains, Dalits (untouchables), Muslims and Sikhs from across the Indian sub continent who continue to be targeted as seditious subversives - crimes associated with the pursuit of dignity, more equitable distribution of India's resources, more provincial autonomy, and the protection of the rule of law.
A 2004 US State Department report on international religious persecution notes that India's police forces and military continue to enjoy impunity though they "use arbitrary and unlawful force to arrest, detain and torture" - a fact reported long ago by Sikhs, Tamils, Sri Lankans, Kashmiris, Gurjaratis, and the enslaved untouchable castes, silenced by the presumption of guilt or generations of apathy.
In fact, in what can only be a most bitter of ironies, the same Punjab police chief responsible for the effective 'quelling of insurgency in Punjab' through extra-judicial killings, staged encounters and custodial deaths of thousands (including Air India's primary suspect Talwinder Singh Parmar) currently receives Canadian taxpayer dollars through CIDA programming. Thanks to our 'unconvinced' government, Punjab's most notorious state sanctioned murderer in uniform, is now receiving a handsome Canadian pension, as the head of the despicably named "Institute for Conflict Management'.
In spite of all this available public information, Canadian reporters win awards for accepting and propagating each sensational tidbit of the very same circumstantial evidence that was so wholly discredited and dismissed by a provincial Supreme Court judge last week. Sikhs must watch news with patient equanimity as historical footage is continually re-played of the emotionally overwrought angst of their frustrated brothers and sisters grieving the loss of their holiest of holies in 1984, a place of sanctity equal to that of the Catholic Vatican.
Clearly, the attack on the Golden Temple of Amritsar, the massacre of thousands on pilgrimage, the destruction of numerous historical artifacts and treasures of antiquity, and 13 other historically significant Sikh churches across Punjab by Indhira Ghandi in 1984 did more than 'damage' an entire religious community.
Whether it is turbans in the RCMP or legion halls, kirpans in schools, or beards in boxing rings - Sikhs have courageously faced down the specter of hatred - repeatedly demonstrating how productive and rewarding equality can be. They do so with full recognition that there are no news items that ever documented how 'Christian' Adolph Hitler was religiously motivated to exterminate 6 million Jews during the holocaust of the WWII', or how the political fanaticism of Christian Timothy McVeigh or Christian David Koresh had its roots in the fractious, violent, and sectarian history of their own faith practice.
It is the duty of the Canadian government to ensure one hundred million dollars and twenty years has not been entirely wasted on incendiary speculation about the underlying political or religious motives of individuals and the perceived extremism attributed to groups presumed guilty until proven innocent.
The plight of Canada's visible and 'invisible' minority communities should be convincing enough to Minister McClellan, as it is to those of us who recognize that our unapologetic indifference is more damaging to the security of Canadians, and citizens of the world, than any threat of terror that ignorance inspires. Sikhs know that from the right insight comes the right action.
Wisdom comes when you ask for it honestly. but it must start with possessing the humility to admit when you don't know. Canadians must begin to consciously choose to exit the safety of our dark cave, to ensure that our 'emergency preparedness' is no longer merely a rhetorical question.
The sophists once claimed themselves wise and learned, and subjugated the Socratics who, martyrdom aside, chose instead to honour the pursuit of wisdom itself. Socrates would have made a great Sikh.
[%sig%]
Re: The puzzle of Sikhism in National Post on March 19, 2005
World Sikh Council - AR · 24 Mar 2005
WSC-AR Statement on Verdict in Canada Declaring Two Sikhs Innocent
World Sikh Council - America Region (WSC-AR)
P.O. Box 3635, Columbus, Ohio 43210, USA
Phone: 614-210-0591, Fax: 419-535-6794
E-mail: [address removed], Website: www.worldsikhcouncil.org
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
March 23, 2005
Contact: Dr. Tarunjit Singh, Secretary General, 614-210-0591, [address removed]
Nearly twenty years after the June 1985 tragic bombing of an Air India Flight and after more than a four year long judicial probe, Justice Ian
Bruce Josephson of the Supreme Court of British Columbia (Canada) declared on March 16, 2005 that Ripudaman Singh Malik and Ajaib Singh Bagri, two Sikhs charged with the crime, are innocent.
The World Sikh Council - America Region (WSC-AR) is pleased with the verdict upholding the innocence of the two Sikhs charged with this crime.
WSC-AR is concerned, however, that those who are really responsible for the murder of 329 innocent victims (many of whom were Sikhs) of this tragedy are still free. Many news sources have repeatedly cited the notorious operations of India's intelligence agencies in Canada for masterminding this state-supported terrorism to defame Sikhs in Canada and all over the world.
We hold the families of the victims of this tragedy in our thoughts and prayers and, once again, we extend our unqualified support in pursuing their quest for justice through the identification, arrest, and conviction of the real perpetrators of this crime.
We call upon the Canadian government to establish a Royal Commission of Inquiry that will investigate all facts pertaining to this tragedy. We also request the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) in Montreal, to call upon the Governments of India, Canada, USA, Ireland, Britain, and Japan -- who were involved in the initial probe -- for their full cooperation for the sake of transparency and accountability, leading to the arrest and conviction of the real perpetrators.
Our thoughts go to Ripudaman Singh Malik and Ajaib Singh Bagri and their families, who have needlessly suffered this prolonged pain, agony, and confinement. This has caused a tremendous drain on their health, family life, and financial situation. We pray to the Almighty God for bestowing upon them the courage and determination to stand up against injustice and falsehood, and seek restitution.
Eminent investigate journalists, Zuhair Kashmeri and Brian McAndrew, of the Globe and Mail and The Toronto Star, concluded in their book titled "Soft Target" published in 1989 that "For several years, India has been engaged in a devious and ruthless operation to manipulate and destabilize Canada's Sikh population. The operation has been orchestrated by India's intelligence service and has left the Sikh community estranged from Canadian Society… To its credit, CSIS [Canadian Security Intelligence Service] eventually woke up just before the tragic Air-India bombing that left 329 people, mostly Canadians, dead in June 1985. It chased the
culprits right to the Indian embassy and consulates. But what it then faced was political interference."
For Sikhs across the world, the verdict in Canada is a sigh of relief, but the struggle for transparency and accountability continues. As it were, the Sikhs all over the world also suffered the agony of defamation and distortion, particularly because many media experts rushed to the conclusion by blaming the Sikhs for this tragedy-which reflects, rather poorly, on their professional integrity and their commitment for objective and informed reporting.
For Sikhs, this verdict is a renewed call for reaffirmation of our faith in divine grace for the ultimate victory of truth and justice. We sincerely thank all those people of good will, who have provided moral support, despite the official campaign of misinformation and falsification.
We take this opportunity to express our sincere gratitude to Justice Ian Bruce Josephson, who has demonstrated great courage and integrity of character and deep commitment for justice, despite overwhelming financial and diplomatic resources of the Indian intelligence agencies in providing fabricated evidence to confuse the situation in order to implicate the two innocent Sikhs.
We also take this opportunity to urge media experts to search their soul and provide their readers and viewers the truth in partial restitution of the injury of defamation, wittingly or unwittingly, inflicted upon two innocent Sikhs and the entire Sikh community.
The WSC-AR is a representative and elected body of Sikh Gurdwaras and institutions in the United States. Its members include 36 Gurdwaras (Sikh places of worship) and other Sikh institutions across the nation.
---
Some excerpts from "Soft Target:
How the Indian Intelligence Service Penetrated Canada", Zuhair Kashmeri and Brian McAndrew, James Lorimer & Company Publishers, Toronto, 1989:
"For several years, India has been engaged in a devious and ruthless operation to manipulate and destabilize Canada's Sikh population. The operation has been orchestrated by India's intelligence service and has left the Sikh community estranged from Canadian Society…To its credit, CSIS [Canadian Security Intelligence Service] eventually woke up just before the tragic Air-India bombing that left 329 people, mostly Canadians, dead in June 1985. It chased the culprits right to the Indian embassy and consulates. But what it then faced was political interference." (page iii)
"Asking the Sikhs [in Canada] to forget about what was happening in Punjab was like demanding that Canadian Jews disregard the plight of the Jewish 'refuseniks' in the Soviet Union. If only because they all had families still living in Punjab, the Sikhs would not turn their backs on their homeland." (page 38) "The CSIS [Canadian Security Intelligence Service] investigators slowly became convinced that the Indian Intelligence service may have played a role in the [Air India] bombings. And the further they probed, the more their suspicions grew." (page 84)
"CSIS [Canadian Security Intelligence Service] had enough circumstantial material to reach the conclusion that agents of the government of India were linked to the Air-India and Narita bombings." (page 93)
"The record of the Indian government shows that it will use both legitimate and illegitimate means to strengthen its political hold on a country the Western media calls 'the world's largest democracy.' The disinformation campaign made the public look upon the Sikhs as a menace and the separatist groups as the obvious culprits responsible for the bombings." (page 94)
"It seemed that the interests of the Indian government superceded the rights of Canadian citizens of Sikh origin to freedom of _expression, and these 'irritants' were standing in the way of an improved relationship between Canada and India, with its growing demand for foreign technology, skills, and marketable goods." (page 139)
"The perception of the Sikhs held by Montrealers, and without doubt by other Canadians, are largely a result of the Indian government's campaign to slur the Sikh community in Canada. And, despite the already-entrenched negative impressions, the Indian government has not relented in its quest to interfere in the lives of the Canadian Sikhs." (page 150)
---
Member Gurdwaras of WSC-AR:
1. Gurdwara Sahib Fremont, Fremont, CA
2. Guru Nanak Sikh Mission, Livingston, CA
3. Sikh Gurdwara of LA, North Hollywood, CA
4. Sikh Gurdwara Riverside, Riverside, CA
5. Colorado Singh Sabha, Denver, CO
6. Guru Singh Sabha of Augusta, Augusta, GA
7. Sikh Study Circle of Atlanta, Atlanta, GA
8. Sikh Religious Society of Chicago, Palatine, IL
9. Sikh Society of South, New Orleans, LA
10. Sikh Gurdwara of Michigan, Rochester Hills, MI
11. Sikh Society of Michigan, Madison Heights, MI
12. Guru Nanak Foundation of Jackson, MS
13. Sikh Gurdwara of North Carolina, Durham, NC
14. Garden State Sikh Association, Bridgewater, NJ
15. Guru Nanak Sikh Society of Delaware Valley, Sewell, NJ
16. Siri Guru Singh Sabha, Glenrock, NJ
17. Sikh Cultural Society Inc., Richmond Hills, NY
18. Sikh Cultural & Edu. Society of Western NY, Buffalo, NY
19. Sikh Religious Society of Dayton, Dayton, OH
20. Guru Nanak Found. of Greater Cleveland, Richfield, OH
21. Guru Gobind Singh Sikh Society, Bedford, OH
22. Guru Nanak Religious Soc. of Central Ohio, Columbus, OH
23. Tristate Sikh Cultural Society, Monroeville, PA
24. Mid South Sikh Sabha, Memphis, TN
25. Sikh Center of Gulf Coast, Houston, TX
26. Siri Guru Singh Sabha, Richardson, TX
27. Sikh Gurdwara of North Texas, Garland, TX
28. Singh Sabha Gurdwara, Fairfax, VA
29. Sikh Association of Central Virginia, VA
30. Sikh Religious Society of Wisconsin, Brookfield, WI
Other Sikh Institution Members of WSC-AR:
1. Siri Guru Granth Sahib Found., Anaheim, CA
2. Sikhs Serving America, Topeka, KS
3. Sikh Youth Federation of North America, White Plains, NY
4. Sikh Educational & Religious Foundation, Dublin, OH
5. Sikh Youth Federation of USA, Toledo, OH
6. Academy of Guru Granth Studies, Arlington, TX
---
World Sikh Council - America Region (WSC-AR)
P.O. Box 3635, Columbus, Ohio 43210, USA
Phone: 614-210-0591, Fax: 419-535-6794
E-mail: [address removed], Website: www.worldsikhcouncil.org
[%sig%]