Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

singhcousy · 23 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I got into a good an argument with a Hindu guy over Guru Granth Sahib Ji being idol worship and I'm dissipointed because I dont think I gave satisfying reasons as to why it is not. Could someone please give some good points as to why it is not idol worship so I can rip this hindu guy the nex time i talk to him. Hopefully something that I havent already said to him or thought about. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Fateh

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

RoopKaur · 23 Mar 2005

When we are bowing down to Sri Guru Branth Sahib Ji, we are not bowing down to the ink, the paper or te cover, we are bowing down to the gurbani, which is where Guru ji's jyot is.

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

santbir singh · 24 Mar 2005

the real key to understand how we treat guru granth sahib jee is to remember that guru jee is our monarch, or sachai padsha, our true emperor. the way we treat guru jee is the same way that people around the world have treated kings and queens for hundreds of years. the nishaan sahib, the shashtres, the rumalai, the palki, the chandoa, the takht sahib, the golak, the chaur sahib, taking off our shoes, covering our heads, bowing before guru jee, these are all things that people do in front of kings and queens, especialy in asia. we must treat guru jee with the utmost respect because guru jee is not only our spirtual emperor, but the true emperor of both worlds. guru jee is the true political power in the world and when we bow down to the guru and treat the guru with utmost respect then hopefully guru jee will give us kirpa to remember that there is noone higher than guru jee and noone we should ever fear or treat as greater than our guru. the way hindus and other religions treat idols is very different than how we treat our guru jee. they worship their idols as either the very essense of their gods and goddesses or as aspects of those "divine" beings. for us, love for the guru is two fold. one because of the bani contained in guru jee and secondly because our guru is a sign of our political independance from all governments in this world. santbir singh

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

Humble Singh · 24 Mar 2005

Essentially, the activities that Sikhs perform in the presence of Siri Guru Granth Sahib centre around EDIFICATION. When we have a deep respect for somebody then we will do what they ask without question. We will learn more from somebody we have respect for. Students will learn more from a teacher they respect. The acts of edification - bowing (matha-tek), new rumalas, the Chaur and Sukhasan - create more respect for SGGS Ji in our minds that consequently increases our belief in the message or Hukam provided by SGGS Ji and as a result we will be wiser. The words Ji and Sri are forms of paying respect. Forms of edification have have to have their limits and Sikhs through the power invested in them through Amrit and Panj Pyare have a duty to use their commmon sense to decide when edification has gone too far and has thus become a ritual i.e. Do we really also need to provide air-conditioning in the Sukhasan Room? If someone helps us during our time of dire need we automatically reciprocate by thanking them from the bottom of our heart and and edify him or her to our friends. When we edify SGGS Ji, in most cases we are doing so, in appreciation for showing us the right way and the wisdom we get from our Guru. There is a fine line between edification and ritualism/idol worship. When one worship an idol, it may create a deep belief in their mind for it but it cannot provide an answer, But in SGGS Ji there is bound to be an answer in one shabad for your problem. Not only you have created a belief in your Guru that things will go right for you but you can have an intelligent and logical discourse with your GURU.

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 24 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. The BEST answer to such persons is... QUOTE GURBANI.....tell him pankati after Pankati....Guru Ji says this and that....... Then ask him to QUOTE...his Bhagwan Krishan Moortee/sri ganesha moortee/mahakali devi mata etc moortee and ask him WHAT does His IDOL say on this subject and that subject.. You will find that his MOORTEES DONT SAY A SINGLE WORD...they are STONE DEAF/MUTE idols.....while GURU GRANTH JI has 1430 aangs of TRUTH. So how could our GURU GRANTH JI be an "idol" on the same plane as the idols in Hidnu mandirs ?? HAAN JI..BUT to a SIKH who doesnt KNOW even OORRa AAIRRA EERREE, who cant even quote the MOOL MANTAR....and who cant quote a single Pankati from GURU GRANTH JI....and doesnt even know how many Guru Sahibaans wrote Gurbani , how many Bhagats contributed Gurbani, How many AAngs Guru Ji has, who Sheikh Farid Ji is and what does He say in His sloks, , Who Bhagat kabir Ji is and what does He say in his sloks, .....then to that "SIKH" ???? Guru ji is an "idol"...something he just matha teks to BLINDLY...as GURU JI has NOTHING to say to this "sikh" Guru Ji is ...... IT is UP to US SIKHS to decide whethr GURU JI is an "idol" or LIVING GURU.. DONT BLAME others when they MISUNDERSTAND... Jarnail Singh

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

Rain drop · 24 Mar 2005

Tell him, I can talk to my Guru. He answers me. See, when we listen a person who is sitting behind the curtain, we receive the exact message; but we do not see the speaker. Similarly; what if; if we can not see Guru Nanak Dev Ji exactly how he looked. But we hear the exact message, HE is saying; when we listen Gurbani. Imagine; you are going to a Gudwara. You listen Gurbani, in the way. That is like; GURU is speaking Himself. So, Gurbani is no less than a living Guru. Read Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji 's Book on the subject.

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

anon · 24 Mar 2005

nice post jarnail singh but u accidently put 1430 angs instead of 1429 angs

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

Rocky · 24 Mar 2005

Author: anon Date: 03-24-05 06:26 nice post jarnail singh but u accidently put 1430 angs instead of 1429 angs ================== A good excuse for some Ragmala bashing. Let's go off topic again...

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 27 Mar 2005

rocky ji...rest easy...enough has been said about raagmaala ( it is neither raag nor maala by any shot..so why flog a dead horse. Continue about this thread on Guru Granth Ji Maharaj...and the 1429 AAngs of Gurbani. jarnail Singh

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

Balpreet Singh · 02 Aug 2006

Simple answer: a rock offers no knowledge or any other quality. It has no value. Sri Guru Granth Sahib has divine knowledge and all divine qualities enshrined in it and if someone reads Guru Sahib, these qualities will enter that person as well.

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

sidharth · 04 Aug 2006

Author: Balpreet Singh Date: 08-02-06 12:51 Simple answer: a rock offers no knowledge or any other quality. It has no value. ----------------------------------------------------------- Actually, it is not a rock, it is a morrti. Balpreet Singh, I think you deliberately fail to understand the difference. Please read the following carefully. A rock is of no value till it is carved into a moorti and similarly, paper is of no value till it is inked and made into the Guru Granth. Sri Guru Granth Sahib has divine knowledge and all divine qualities enshrined in it and if someone reads Guru Sahib, these qualities will enter that person as well. ---------------------------------------------------------- Similarly, for us, Raam moorti has these qualities. When we go and worship the moorti of Lord Raam, we immediately think of his qualities which we would like to emulate. In one of your earlier posts, you had said if you meditate on Durga Mata, what do you become (or something to that effect), well, when we meditate upon Maharani, we feel compassion, we feel patience, we feel inner strength. I hope I have been able to clear your views on Hindus, even partially. Everyone here says that they have no issues with Hindus doing moorti pooja, but this is not the case, evidenced by the number of threads and posts on the topic of "idol worship" Regards, Sid.

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

Seeker of the Truth · 04 Aug 2006

Guru Granth Sahib Ji (Page 1349): “If the Lord Allah lives only in the mosque, then to whom does the rest of the world belong? According to the Hindus, the Lord's Name abides in the idol, but there is no truth in either of these claims. || 1 || O Allah, O Raam, I live by Your Name. Please show mercy to me, O Master.”

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

Roopkaur · 04 Aug 2006

When we need guidance, advice or any other type of help from guru ji, we take a hukamnamaa. Yet if this was idol worship, we would not be able to have this communication. The definition for idol is an IMAGE used for worship, yet we as Sikhs do not worship the image, but the knowledge contained within. An idol is when something material, or of this world i.e. of the three guns is worshipped. Yet we worship the bani within Guru Sahib, which is out of this world and of the fourth gun, or treaa gun. A moorti of a god is still made of rock, but when bani is written, though it is written in ink which is of this world, and the paper is of this world, the bani itself is not. One might argue that the moorti of a god is also not of this world, but than, the moortis would all be same, but as we see, every moorti is constructed differently according to the whims of the artist, yet despite the colour of the paper or ink used, or despite how old the saroop is, Gurbani itself, is always the same in its laridar form.

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

singh13 · 04 Aug 2006

paakhaan gadt kai moorath keenhee dhae kai shhaathee paao || The sculptor carves the stone and fashions it into an idol, placing his feet upon its chest jae eaeh moorath saachee hai tho garrhanehaarae khaao ||3|| If this stone god was true, it would devour the sculptor for this! ||3|| Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaj Ang 479 no need to say anything else :D [%sig%]

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

aanjan · 05 Aug 2006

Ask the hindus what do they get out of worshiping a phallus ???

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

aanjan · 05 Aug 2006

***** "Simple answer: a rock offers no knowledge or any other quality. It has no value." Same holds for piece of paper and ink imprinted on it. ****** Brilliant logic?!?!?! Let me simplify it rock/wood/plaster of paris/cement offers NO knowledge AT ALL printed paper offers knowledge. Do you understand NOW???? Oh it was the heat of moment?!?!?!?

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

dusht · 05 Aug 2006

Page 479, Line 5 ਜਿਸੁ ਪਾਹਨ ਕਉ ਪਾਤੀ ਤੋਰੈ ਸੋ ਪਾਹਨ ਨਿਰਜੀਉ ॥੧॥ जिसु पाहन कउ पाती तोरै सो पाहन निरजीउ ॥१॥ jis paahan ka-o paatee torai so paahan nirjee-o. ||1|| That stone idol, for which you tear off those leaves - that stone idol is lifeless. ||1|| Devotee Kabir Page 1158, Line 17 ਤੋਰਉ ਨ ਪਾਤੀ ਪੂਜਉ ਨ ਦੇਵਾ ॥ तोरउ न पाती पूजउ न देवा ॥ tora-o na paatee pooja-o na dayvaa. I do not pick leaves as offerings, and I do not worship idols. Devotee Kabir Page 1241, Line 2 ਭੁਖਿਆ ਦੇਇ ਨ ਮਰਦਿਆ ਰਖੈ ॥ भुखिआ देइ न मरदिआ रखै ॥ bhukhi-aa day-ay na mardi-aa rakhai. Your idol does not feed the hungry, or save the dying. Guru Nanak Dev Page 1264, Line 2 ਭਰਮਿ ਭੂਲੇ ਅਗਿਆਨੀ ਅੰਧੁਲੇ ਭ੍ਰਮਿ ਭ੍ਰਮਿ ਫੂਲ ਤੋਰਾਵੈ ॥ भरमि भूले अगिआनी अंधुले भ्रमि भ्रमि फूल तोरावै ॥ bharam bhoolay agi-aanee anDhulay bharam bharam fool toraavai. The ignorant and the blind wander deluded by doubt; deluded and confused, they pick flowers to offer to their idols. Guru Ram Das Page 1349, Line 12 ਹਿੰਦੂ ਮੂਰਤਿ ਨਾਮ ਨਿਵਾਸੀ ਦੁਹ ਮਹਿ ਤਤੁ ਨ ਹੇਰਾ ॥੧॥ हिंदू मूरति नाम निवासी दुह महि ततु न हेरा ॥१॥ hindoo moorat naam nivaasee duh meh tat na hayraa. ||1|| According to the Hindus, the Lord's Name abides in the idol, but there is no truth in either of these claims. ||1|| Devotee Kabir Page 1371, Line 16 ਪਾਹਨ ਬੋਰੀ ਪਿਰਥਮੀ ਪੰਡਿਤ ਪਾੜੀ ਬਾਟ ॥੧੩੭॥ पाहन बोरी पिरथमी पंडित पाड़ी बाट ॥१३७॥ paahan boree pirathmee pandit paarhee baat. ||137|| The stone idols have drowned the world, and the Pandits, the religious scholars, have plundered it on the way. ||137|| Devotee Kabir [%sig%]

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

Sitara · 06 Aug 2006

Idol Worship is not the be all and end all of a Hindus sadhana. If we want guidance we can read Bhagavad Gita (many scholars and scientistis have found a lot of guidance from it.) I think people here a purposely not trying to understand due to the Islamic like approach they take to religion. Why do you Sikhs have pictures of Shaheed Singhs, Babbar militants etc plastered all over your Gurudwaras? It is because when you look at the image it triggers off images/thought in your head about qualities etc that you want to emulate. You guys sound like a bunch of fundo Christians...you should listen to yourselves

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

ijs · 06 Aug 2006

sangat ji..............there seems to be a splurge of some anti-panthic people.......................intentional or unintentional it seems sum non-sikh ppl always try to digress from the topic............. they are free to voice themselves ........."fundo christians"...............i wonder if this forums gonna be full of such people....................... lot of other forums have these pseudo-khalistaanis and pseudo-knowledge waale brahmins getting at each other and the net just gives even fools the medium to put their view. wot makes this forum diff. is that it has lot of rehit wale singhs posting which makes it a joy to read and i very well accept replies from astute ppl like "chandra ji"....................... for the rest of u stop these insinuations and base ur replies on facts and scriptures and not ur paltry wisdom..................... that is precisely the reason i dont reply much coz i am just not in the league of lot of gyanis here.................i just sit back and enjoy the wise views and for all the pumped up fellas who wanna bring some religious revolution stay back..............this is not the forum for it [%sig%] Post Edited (08-06-06 13:11)

Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji - idol worship

Seeker of the Truth · 06 Aug 2006

LOL@ Hindus on this thread! Seriously, Idol Worshipping isn't part of Sikhi. I don't even know why this is an issue. There are actually MORE SERIOUS things to talk about here than talking about some idol/stone.