Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

SANT DARSHAN !!

SANT DARSHAN !!

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 22 Mar 2005

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH. I reproduce this message sent to a mailinglist by my good friend...S Harkinder Singh from canada. A good read. -----///-------///-------///-----////-----------////---------////----------////-------- Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh hai. In 1996, an old school time friend and I went to India from Canada. He told me that he wants to visit a Saint near Phagwara. We reached Phagwara by bus, and we bought some fruits for the Saint and took another ride to this place where Sant had his dera. From distance, we could hear loud speakers with Gurbani path at very loud volume. As we walked into the complex, we first decided to bow before Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji before we saw the Saint. In the main Durbar Hall, there were about five or more Prakash of Guru Granth Sahib ji and Pathis were doing path side by side in a row. (I saw similar set up at Nadha Sahib Gurdwara near Chandigarh). I found it strange that some of the Pathis slowed down and started staring at us while doing Paath. I was told that many Akhand Paaths are going on simultaneously as many Shardhaloos commit paaths from all over the world. Then we walked towards an enclosure where Saint was lying on a Munjj-da Manjja with a Dari spread over. It was drizzling a little, and floors were wet. As we approached this place I noticed many women were sitting and standing around the cot/Manjja of the Saint. Some were busy massaging the legs. Some were massaging the arms and others were massaging the bare chest of the saint. His mouth was half open and eyes sort of half closed. The flies were merrily sitting on Saint's lips, some were easily going in and out of his mouth. Once in a while another sewadar would scare the flies with a fan or a cloth. There was strange smell of burned desi ghee around. I noticed there were few empty cans (Peepas) of Desi-Ghee lying around and there was a small heating element on which was warm melted desi ghee as well. People were taking turns and toilingly hard & exuberently busy doing massage of Saint's body. Near Saints ears was a huge loud speaker, the kind we see on peoples' roof tops during marriages in old days Punjabi villages. There was constant Paath of Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji being done on this loud speaker connected to inside the durbar hall. By chance, at that time the paath being read was quite known to me and I noticed the person was reading it wrong. The sound was so loud that it was very annoying to the ears due to loudness and combined with misreading. I asked why do they have it so loud and close to the Saints ears as it would be harmful to his ear drums. People said, Saint is hard of hearing and also needs it running so that he can listen to Akhand Paath uninterrupted. There was continuous flow of Shardhaloos who were performing massage of the Saint. It was so busy that it was hard to take your turn. My friend took his turn and asked me to also gain the previlege of doing sewa to the Saint. I did not mind doing that as I thought it is just an old infirm man, and I have nothing to loose. I also did massage of the Saint's legs. I noticed that his legs were almost bare bones, no muscle and the skin was almost sticking to the bones. I sort of thought that the Saint may not be able to walk with his legs. I finished my turn quickly and steped back observing everything around. Some couples came and touched Saint's feet. In the meantime I heard many miraculous stories of how people benefitted from Saint's blessings. By this time Saint opened his eyes fully and looked around. A person known to my friend told the Saint that Karnail Singh from Canada has come for his Darshan. The Saint looked at my friend Karnail Singh and roght away asked him direct and crisp question: "Kinnay paisay bana leinna Kanaida vich?" (How much money do you make in Canada?) Karnail Singh fumbled few words " Bohut bann jandey ne ji bohut bann jandeyaey". Karnail Singh was visiting the Saint after a gap of about 12 years. I thought the Saint's first question to Karnail Singh was really weird. But Karnail took it normally. Karnail Singh then introduced me to the Saint: " Ah ji mera dost Harkinder Singh vi othon hi ayiaa hai". The saint did not bother much about that and told Karnail Singh to get Akhand Paath booked right away. I was glad that he did not take any notice of me, although I looked more like a Sikh with long flowing beard than Karnail Singh with trimmed and dyed beard. We did Fateh to the Saint and Karnail Singh touched his feet. I touched his knees out of respect for an old infirm man out of courtesy and also not to annoy Karnail Singh. We left. The crowd kept increasing around the Saint and his PA started diverting people ans stopping soon. As we walked away from the Saint, Karnail Singh asked me what did I think of the Saint. I said: He seems to be a nice old man, however, I think God has purposefully dried his legs because he was not using them. In Punjabi I said: Rabb ney sochyia honei ki eh banda apnia lattaan nu istimal tan karda nahi, chalo ehna nu suka hi dindey haan". Karnail Singh did not like my comments. Then I reminded him the very first question Saint asked him about how much he makes in Canada, and that why is this man wasting so much of Desi Ghee on his weakened dry useless body when so many people are dying of hunger just around the corner? What kind of Sainthood is that, that this man cannot even close his mouth and flies have a grand holiday in his mouth. I said this Saint has not respected the beautiful body God gave him and is lying like a dead corpse blessing who? He has lost his hearing power as his ear drums are perhaps punctured due to such a loud loud speaker. Why is that the Saint is not stopping these people reading Gurbani incorrectly right before our eyes while I can spot the glaring mistakes in reading even simple gurbani as it is? We left the place after Karnail Singh sorted out the day for Akhand paath and paid about 1500 Rs. The drizzle continued, the faithfuls continued to trickle in as we left that couldy winter day. My friend Karnail Singh thought that I was a very bad company because I said: Rabb ne ehdiaan lattaan hi suka dittiaan hann. He never forgave me for this comment. He said: " Harkinder Singh, mein terey te hairaan haan ki tu keho ja bandein yaar?" I said. "I am just like that you see". Karnail Singh could not see my point at all. He did not understand my discomfort with the idea that flies shouldn't be allowed to have a free feast in living person's mouth. He is still angry with me on this account. I don't think that he will ever take me to a Saint again. I told him that yes I believe that there truly are some saintly people around. But I had upset his mood too much. I tried to tell him the following Shabad to him but his face was very uptight and deep creases were visible on his forehead: Sanak sanand mahesh samannaaa| Seikhnaag tero maram na jannaa|| Sant Sangat Raam riday basaeee|| Hanumaan sar Grud samanaa| Surpatt Narpatt Gun nahi jannaa| Chaar beid arr simrat puranaa| Kamlapatt Kamala nahi janaa| Keh Kabir su bharmay nahi| Pag lag Raam rahay sarnaeee|| The four sons of Brahma and likes of Shivji who are known to stand at door of Mahakaal, and the Sheikhnaag, the thousand mouthed snake that supports the bed of Mahankaal, and sings new praise of the creator with each individual tongue, they all could not fathom the mysteries of life. They could never know that in the company of the Saint, Waheguruji comes to reside in hearts of the seekers. Hanuman, who was as powerful as Grud, the swari/vehicle of Vishnu; Inder, the lord of the angels; and the Kings of the people never could understand the merits of Sri Akal ji. The four Vedas and their derivatives, Simraties and Puranas, could never know the husband of Maha Maya. Even the Kamla/Luxmi could not understand her husband Maha kaal (Kamla-pati). Kabir ji assures unfailingly, what? That whoever connects to the feet of Waheguruji, shall never fall victim to the illusions and delusions of Maya, infact remains undeterred, unshakeable equipoise in the shelter of Waheguruji. Such Saints are rare. They shall never cheat any one at any moment...Aaap adoll na kabhoo dollay. Bani Prabh ki, sabh ko bollay!! Janam Maran duhoo meh nahi, jann parupkari aayeye. Jee-aa-daan deh bhagti layen, Har seo lein milaeye... Deekhyiaa, Aaakh bujhaeyiaa, Sifti Sach sameyio! Tinh kau kyaa updessiye Jinh Guru Nanak Deo?? Who can teach anything to them who have chosen Guru Nanak as their Guru? Guru Nanak made sure by bestowing grace, putting Naam in empty jholi of a Gurmukh, gave perfect instructions. The instructions that had been immersed in sifat salah, words immersed describing grandeur of Waheguruji. Hamari pyari amritdhari ggur nimakh na mann te tarrii re!! Darsan parsan harsan sarsan rang rati Kartari re| Khin ramm gur gamm hardam neh Zam, Har kanth Nanak urhari re!! Yes we love this Bani as it removes fear of death from our hearts. Even Guruji never shunned and missed reciting it. The mere seeing the words of Bani in Gurmukhi, the mere touch of Gurbani pages, bring unbound joy to hearts of its lovers. Why ? Because it is immersed in clolours o Kartar. Haan ji Sat Kartaar!! If only for a moment one gets touched by its powers! one shall acheive closeness to the Guru!! yes then never ever again shall that person have to face the angel of death (Neh Zam!!). And shall always keep this Gurbani as close to the heart as one wears a garland of love!!. Yes Pyarey ji: Nanak miriaaa, bohur na firiaaa!!! Whoever met Guru Nanak, shall never be wandering in cycle of life and death (bohur na firiaa..Shall never come & go!!) Preet preet Guriyaa Mohan Lalnaa!! Jap mann Gobind eikkaey. Awar nahi ko leikhaey. Yes, nothing else shall count but one Lord's Naam Jap shall be considered at accounting time. Therefore fall in love with that Guru Nanak. That same Gobind Saroop. Who else can be more enchanting than HIM?? Bhullan andar Sabh ko, abhull Guru Kartaar. Harkinder Singh

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Bundha · 22 Mar 2005

Gyani Ji forgive me if I speak out of terms, but you spend so much time hounding men of God that when you breath your last only then will you realise all that wasted time could have been spent in contemplation of God. This Harkinder seems to only have two brain cells to rub together. How does he know that the ‘Saint’ does not help the poor and hungry around him ? If the ‘Saint’ has his mouth open what has it to do with Harkinder ? Men of God who do tapasia have no regard for their bodies. They have left this behind a long time ago and only know of the remembrance of God. Remember Sheik Fraid Ji did tapaisa for half his life and became old and frail and the birds and crows came down and pecked at his flesh, idiots and fools like ME would have pointed at Friad Ji and said “ look he cannot look after himself, and yet he purports to be a man of God” Friad Ji too had skin and bones because he did not care for his body, only of God. Gyani Ji, Sewa of a mahursh you know nothing about and is way beyond you. “Saints” work on different levels to us sunsaries and as such we mock and pour derision on them. We know not the ways of men-of-God and sometimes they will purposefully do things that we sunsaaries find difficult to stomach. Only those who have kirpa can know this. Did Harkinder stop to think for one moment that all this play may have been for his benefit to see what his ‘inside’ was made of or what avasta he had reached, in which case he failed miserably. Once again many thanks for your considerable effort in finding this article so that we can once again marvel at the foolishness of men who look at men-of-god with sunsaarie eyes and criticise and mock. [%sig%]

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Bundha · 22 Mar 2005

One other thing Arshi Ji, this Harkiaran never saw past the physical, the material of the “saint” did he ? He was repulsed by the physical garb of this man-of-God, which tells us more about Harkaran then the “Saint” Maybe if the “Saint” was well dressed with silky robes and dastaar this would have pleased Harkarn ? But I doubt it, he would then have proceeded down the other nindhia route, that of “The Saint was very well dressed and had expensive robes on, why didn’t he not spend all that money on the poor around him?” Can the men-of God ever win ?????? [%sig%]

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Rocky · 22 Mar 2005

Well said Bundha.... Just WAITING....for a REPLY from that Gyani Arshi ....

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

? · 22 Mar 2005

Gyani Jee - may be you should read the ashtpadi in Sukhmani Sahib about Sant Ka Nindak.

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

.. · 22 Mar 2005

I just would want to say that we should be very careful when critisizing people, especially nindha of sants as it could lead to many reincarnations.. (i know no one here would do something like that, just wanted to inform anyone else that might happen to read this)

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Bundha · 22 Mar 2005

? Ji, This Gyani and his like mock those who state the astpadhi about Sant Ki nindhia and say that this is always brought up.

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Bundha · 22 Mar 2005

I may have recounted this incident before, if so apologies. A sant is dhyawaan and parupkari, he will not care about the consequences when he is about to do parupkaar and help a person. We, dhunia walley / sunsaar walley look upon them with dirt filled eyes and we cannot see the whole picture. Instead of accepting this our hunkaar takes over and we start the nidhia. A man used to frequent a mahpursh but he used to eat meat. The mahapursh repeatedly told him that this was bad and that he should stop. The man could not. To a mahpursh it is his duty to do parupkaar so he went straight to a butchers are bought some meat. There were those who saw him and started the nindhia “we saw such-n-such mahapursh and he was buying meat, we always knew he was a dodgy bloke….” But the mahapursh ignored all this. Next he went to a river bank and dug up some worms, again some people saw him and found this strange behaviour from a “man-of-God” (parallel to flies in mouth ??). Mahapursh went to the mans house and said that he had brought him something. The man was surprised about this but nonetheless opened the bag. When he saw the mess of meat and worms he has disgusted. Manhapursh said “This is what will happen to you, you will become like this if you do not stop the meat eating” This was just the shock the man needed and he never ate meat again. Now, this tale is not about eating or not eating meat it is about men-of-god who work on different levels to us and have no concern about what people will say about them , and what we see we do not understand and hence we start the nindhia, and some people make it their lives work to do nindhia of mahapursh and will interject their venom in whatever conversation they are having.

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Bundha · 22 Mar 2005

“Saints” remember God all the time, whether the are awake or asleep. Even when they are having a conversation with someone inside there is a Chukar of simran going round and around “Satnam waheguru, satnam waheguru, satnam waheguru” or whatever shabad they are simaraning. There physical outer garb they are not concerned about, whether someone does there ustat (praise) or nindhia they do not care. Take ME for instance if I was sat and some men from Canada came to see me I would getup straighten my self out “get the flies out of my mouth” but for a “Saint” they do not care who comes or goes and if people are repulsed by them then it is their loss ! Do you think that it is the “Saint” who is getting the benefit of some one massaging their feet ? worldly comforts are of no use to them, they are looking forward to the comforts of the after life through their naam/simran. The benefit of sewa of a “Saint” is of the devotee, it makes their maan humble and with the coaxing of the Mahapursh they are put on the true path of Akalpurkh . But all we see is someone sat having his feet massaged and nindhia starts to flow. [%sig%]

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

? · 22 Mar 2005

Bundha Jee Why do they mock? Bani is Nirankar da Roop - it is sachi. Fateh

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Rocky · 23 Mar 2005

To be honest with you this Sant bashing bores me. We either blame the Sants or the Nihangs for all the problems we have today. It's always the same types of postings, particularly from the same people. Let's look in our own Ghars and look at what is going wrong. We should practice what we preach, instead of bash any GurSikh who is trying to do his/her bit. We're all in this together, there are no leaders, there are no sects. If you see differences then kill the ego.

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 23 Mar 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. firstly the "imaginary pictures" showing Bab Farid Ji as an old eamsculated man lying almost dead and scare crow like are based on SERIOUS MISINTERPRETATIUON of His Gurbani Sloks...Baba Farid Ji did no such TORTURE of HIS HARMANDIR in which HIS WAHEGURU resided....he of all people should know that his body is the abode of GOD and is to be kept Holy and Sound.....What a travesty of his Bani that people say he kept a Roti made of WOOD and bit it whenever he felt hungry....this is mocking bani. Secondly why should I be afraid of Sukhmani Sahib Ashtpadis on SANT...becasue as far as I am concerned the ONLY SANT is WAHEGURU/GURU/GURU GRANTH JI MAHARAJ. NO other human being ever dared call himslef SANT equal to this. Those that DO CALL themselves sant or allow others to call them are the ones MOCKING SACRED GURBANI...BEWARE...becasue followers of false gurus and sants die horrible deaths... IF this had been a real sant...would the FIRST question be about MAYA FROM CANADA ?? DO you think GURU JI asked each Sikh..Sunna bai Bhai so and so..kinneey ko MAYA laike aiyaan sadeh vasteh ?? This MAN asked this . ISNT it a GROSS INSULT to SACRED GURBANI to have MULTIPLE AKHAND PAATHS...just for MAYA sake. And the allegation that the Paathi was READING WRONG GURBANI and the "KUSANT with mouth full of flies" CONDONED THIS ?? They were truly FLIES...not some heavenly food as he is guilty of mocking GURBANI. Isnt it a GROSS INSULT to waste DESI GHEE on an old man while many go HUMGRY ?? Any historical instances where OUR GURUS ( TRUE SANTS) ever did like this ??? Did GURU NANAK ask Bhai lehna Ji to massage Him with Desi Ghee while he lay there...or worse still many ladies to do this ??? ALL those who supported the "kusant" and BLINDLY IGNORED the above INSULTS to GURBANI are themsleves blind and mocking Gurbani. Jarnail Singh.

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

how do u no · 23 Mar 2005

bundha how do u no if he was a sant or not, we can not possibly say hu is a sant only waheguru ji wud no.

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Bundha · 23 Mar 2005

I agree with Rocky, sant bashing is boring and we get it time and time again. <> Bhai Sahib Ji, I do not know if he was a true sant or not but I am fed up with people who just sant-bash all the time for no reason. These are men-of-God and in my small feeble way I feel I must stick up for them. Arshi Ji, you of all people should know Sheik Farids Shabad " ih doai neenna matt showo......" Where Bhagat Ji are addressing the crows who are pecking at his flesh and he is saying that you can peck all you like (again this reinforces the fact that for men/women who are of high avasta they care not of thier physical bodies) but please do not touch my eyes for I have not have had a darshan of my pir (God) " pir dakhen kee aas..." I say to all those sant-bashers - Get a life !

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Dogma · 23 Mar 2005

Arshi Jee, just out of curiousity, do you have a hatred for all Sants or just the one who you believe to be fake? I"m not trying to be sarcastic with you. I genuinely am question whether you believe a Sant even exists in this world. I am curious because even though Singhs I know believe that Gurbani only labels Guru Sahib/Sadhsangat as Sant, they also call Sant Jarnail Singh Jee Bhindrawale 'Sant.' I would argue that you also believe that Sant Jarnail Singh Jee is a Sant. So how does one distinguish between who is Sant and who is not? or at least how do you distinguish between the two? Your thoughts would be greatly appreciated.

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 23 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh. Dear Dogma Ji, this for me is a very simple deduction. Jarnail Singh Ji Bhinderawalah was a SANT-SIPAHI...who as one KEPT his word...giving his life for the Glory of the Guru Khalsa Panth. IF JSB were alive today and in "control" i can say with 100% conviction he would have sent his men to SODH the mannas and dhanwants...in fact no manna dhanwanta would have dared to peep out of their hell hole deras at all..but NOW they strut about as proud peacocks all over the Takhats as well. SO was Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji...who clashed "Swords" with the mighty British and kept his Sant-Sipahi spirit alive to the very end..for the Glory of the Guru Khalsa panth.. He and His jatha SODH so many FRAUD KUSANTS in their time SO are a lot of others "gupt" as well as not so "gupt" Genuine SANT-SIPAHIS...who are genuinely doing Gurmatt parchaar for the Glory of the Guru Khalsa panth ( they may have a few minor differences here and there over certain aspects of maryada like number of banis, time of amritvela,banna , food etc..BUT their FAITH in the Fundamental Principles of Gurmatt like Khanda Batta da Amrit/Gurbani/GURU GRANTH JI Maharaj is unshaken and unshakeable) I have NEVER...repeat NEVER written anything agaisnt people like Attar singh mastuana, Kartar Singh Khalsa, Gurbachan Singh Khalsa..etc etc ( although i may disagree with them on certain points of Gurbani translations, sakhis, sikh history etc etc, they were mahaan sikhs and no one can deny that..BUT THAT SAID i beleive ONLY GURU JI is ABHULL and a human can make mistakes..on gurbani translations, history etc. What I cannot stand are all those thousands of FRAUD SANTS ( KU-SANTS) who are in it for the MAYA and MAYA and MAYA only. Their "Sikhi Parchaar",amrit tours,kirtan smagams, MAHAAN PAVITTAR KIRTAN SAMAGAMS etc etc are all sham and cover-ups..for their SELF GLORY and SELF DERA PROMOTION. These are the ones who have HUNDREDS ( 500) of Simultaneous Akhand Paaths, sham amrit parchaars, etc etc....and all else besides ( what we read in the papers about molestations. massaging of bodies and etc etc) The LAST Para KUSANTS are definitley MORE than the genhuine ones..so the only solution is to IDENTIFY the frauds and expose them...and the GENUINE ONES have this solemn duty..IF any of them keeps QUIET.then he is CONDONING them and guilty as well...GUILTY BY ASSOCIATION. In our HISTORY GURU GOBIND SINGH JI himself Didnt CONDONE the MASANDS when they were WRONG...so How can a "genuine sant" claim it is NINDA to condone another FRAUD...unlesss they are all buddies inside !!as SANT SAMAAJ has proven time and agaian. Wouldnt GURU JI have quoted the SUKHMANI ASHTPADIS on "SANT NINDA" and made his sikhs SHUT UP ( after all all the masands were SANTS !!! very very HOLY holies of their time that Sikhs would take their charanamrit to drink !!! ANY SINGH of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI who CONDONES such modern MASANDS is guilty by association...and mocking Gurbani and Sukhamni Sahib. It is UP to us to check every..thing out...if we FAIL TO SEE then it is our own FAULT.....because we follow the wrong master. THis should put to rest BUNDHA Ji and his cohorts on Sant bashing by me.. Jarnail singh.

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Heera · 23 Mar 2005

Bhai Jarnail Singh Ji, If (note the word IF) for a moment I were to take and accept everything you say, why is it that you don't seem to have the same "fire" for all the other types of masants that exist - like gurdwara commitees, and "pardhans" etc They do alot more damage to sikhi than all the other frauds put togather.

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

can't think of a name.. · 24 Mar 2005

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" wrote: IF this had been a real sant...would the FIRST question be about MAYA FROM CANADA ?? DO you think GURU JI asked each Sikh..Sunna bai Bhai so and so..kinneey ko MAYA laike aiyaan sadeh vasteh ?? This MAN asked this . ***** Well, if we look at the other side of the coin for a moment.. If this person was only bothered about ‘Maya’ then do you think he would have let the other Canadian (Harkinder Singh) get away without attempting to get some ‘maya’ out of him?? Just a thought.. [%sig%]

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Bundha · 24 Mar 2005

This Shabad is by Bhagat Sheikh Fareed Ji in Salok Fareed Jee on Pannaa 1382 kaagaa kara(n)g dta(n)dtoliaa sagalaa khaaeiaa maas || eae dhue nainaa math shhuho pir dhaekhan kee aas ||91|| The crows have searched my skeleton, and eaten all my flesh. But please do not touch these eyes; I hope to see my Lord. ||91|| [%sig%]

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

anon · 24 Mar 2005

bundha u contradict yourself, if u dnt know hu is a sant or not then surely u cant tell if some one is sant bashing or not so keep your nose out of it and take your own advice and meditate on God rather than arguing needlessely

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Rocky · 24 Mar 2005

We should all aim to be Sants. Isn't that what we are trying to do? "Khalsa Mera Roop Hai Khas"

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 25 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Dear Heera ji, OF course I have the "same" ( if not even stronger ) fire for the LOCAL PARDHAANS and Gurdawra Committees....( by the way our LOCAL Ex-Pardhan is also named Heera ?? what a small world !! and i wouldnt call him a bad pardhaan as he was quite strict in following the Sikh Rehat maryada in our gurdwara and thus earned the "anger" of the local SANTEES) But the trouble is the "local" pardhaans remain LOCAL....and DONT GO on World TRIPS to do "amrit Sanchaar",Kirtan Samagams,....and collect donations for their DERAS..and also dont go around attending other "Pardhaan Samagams"...and of course they dont form Pardhaan Samaaj and publish their own Rehat maryadas/fight elections and enforce their set of rules on all gurdawras... Remember BEHAZATEE !! the PLAY ?? it is about such local pardhaans and committees..BUT just look at the "FIRE" it got burning ???all over the world ?? The Pardhaasn and gurdwara cmmitees are the RESULT of LOCAL SANGATS and the RESPONSIBILITY of Local SANGATS.... I mean what type of Pardhaan/commitee you get is what you WANT...if each Local sangat wants a good pardhaan and commitee they can ELECT a good pardhaan...period..BUT the "Ku-SANT Masand" is Beyond any local sangat control...he has worldwide tentacles like a web spread all over. SO far our local Gurdawra committee and Pardhaan is doing a good job of enforcing the Sikh rehat maryada...so you dont find me writing anything about them...."fire" or Not...but I am interested in YOUR local pardhaan/Committee ?? How are they ? do you have any "fire" about them ?? The day my local pardhaans do something against the Sikh rehat maryada..I will write "fire and brimstone"...so far they have only "banned" all kusants and silly tall tales telling entertaining kathakaars etc..and that is GOOD for the local sangat. Jarnail Singh

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

ms · 25 Mar 2005

my comment on Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale is that he gave almost 300 to 400 people amrit at his sanchaars every week. he helped many thousands of people come into sikhi and get attached to gursikhi jeevan.

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Young Brit Singh · 26 Mar 2005

I have come cross many Singhs who have taken Amrit at Sanchars at various deras where 'sants' have been in the Punj Pyaray. They seem like real dedicated chardi kala Singhs. Agree that there are some incorrect people claiming to be sants but the recognised sants in history were responsible for helping thousands become amritdharis.

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Dogma · 26 Mar 2005

Thank you for your response Arshi Jee.. From what I gather I can see that you believe that a TRUE Sant requires not only Saintly attributes, but attributes of a Sipahi as well (?). Correct me if I'm wrong. You named Sant Jarnail Singh Jee and Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Jee as two men who fought against negative influences affecting the Panth during their respective times. However, from what I know Sant Attar Singh Jee, Sant Isher Singh Jee, Baba Nand SIngh Jee...(all sants that I have never heard your bash) did not " clash swords " against anyone (from what I know). How are these Singhs given repreive from your ' sant bashing ' when by your own standards they weren't truly Sant-Sipahi's? Also, I've noticed that many Singhs on this board constantly post topics that are meant to uplift and inspire the young Sikhs out there. However, I believe some of the issues that many of your critics have with you is that no matter what happens, you will not pass up an oppurtunity to bash a Sant. By your own admission, you have great respect for Sant Jarnail Singh Jee as well as a few other Sants. When will the Sangat see the day when you post something about how a SANT managed to help the Sikh Kaum or help a fellow Singh? Or will we be left to read posts about how bad sants are? My point is only that Arshee Jee your posts about how bad this Sant was or how it turned out this Sant was a fake do not do anythign to uplift or inspire this manmukh. Nor do I think your posts on Fake Sants do anything but create tension and anger in the minds of many of the youth out there. Negativity does not inspire anyone. Why give examples of what some true sants did in order to demonstrate what a Sant REALLY is?

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 27 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Veer Dogma Ji, You give me too much credit. My posts are merely my own opinions. Guru Nanak ji Sahib Himself gave us the MIRI-PIRI concept....note it is MIRI and then PIRI and NOT the other way around.????? Sant-Sipahi concept began with GURU NANAK JI Sahib when Guru Ji "clashed swords" with Babbar.... and continues till this day....a "Sant" got to be SIPAHI first before he can be a Sant....reason given by Guru Gobind Singh Ji...Raaj bina na dharam chaleh hain..dharam bina sabh daleh maleh hain....I always hear people say..."challo ji sanu kee politics naal..aseen taan siraf gurdwaraeh matha tekna eh..." BUT the question is IF we DONT have the SIPAHI PART...no one will let us practise our SANT Part..ONLY the STRONG can practise their SANTINESS in peace... So imho a TRUE SANT has to be a SIPAHI....however it doesnt make anyone less sant if he doesnt have this...the Sants you mentioned..Attar Singh Ji mastuana did their BHAGTEE and SIMRAN ( which by the way ONLY benefits the PERSON doing this as Gurbani is amply clear that NO ONE can do nay bhagtee for OTHERS)...and didnt do anything which would count as anti-gurmatt etc etc so no reason to criticise them. Why do I write about these Sants ?? Simple..these sants have volumes written about them by their chelas..I have SEVERAL of these in my library..why Makhi uppar makhi maarni ?? However very few DISCLOSURES about KUSANTS...in fact apart from the journalsits of Sanjh Saveraand other newspapers etc... NO ONE is interested in unmasking these frauds..it is our duty to warn others not to fall in their traps. Every one else just "HIDES" behind SUKHMANI SAHIB ASHTPADI on Sants !!!!..This is the reason why some of these "sants" are upgrading themsleves to be GURU NANAK/GURU GOBIND SINGH JI...apparently they find the "sant field too overcrowded...hence this UPGRADING to GURUSHIP...IF we are not careful...there will be so many "Guru nanaks/Guru Gobind Singhs" in every Village Dera..and there will be "ASHTPADIS" to keep us quiet too...Naa Ji Guruaan di nindiya nahin kareedee..narakaan nu janein hai ?? True Gurmukhs have nothing to fear as they never do anything wrong or anti gurmatt...the only thing sligthtly out of place may be they are called "sants" by their follwers.... a minor indiscretion which will disappear by education about a TRUE SANT....but the Kusants must not be allowed to flourish unfettered. Jarnail Singh

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Dogma · 28 Mar 2005

A little confused veerji about some of your statements. " So imho a TRUE SANT has to be a SIPAHI....however it doesnt make anyone less sant if he doesnt have this." --- you just stated that in order to be a true Sant one has to be a Sipahi as well, however you completely contradicted your whole argument by saying that if one doesn't have this then it doesn't make them LESS of Sant. Please explain. Secondly, you state that you do not write about 'legitimate' Sants because there have been many volumes written about the jeevans of these men and women. You state "why Makhi uppar makhi maarni ??". However, I've noticed that most people even today ask for stories about Bhai Sahib Bhai Randeer Singh Jee, Sant Jarnail Singh Jee...why is it wrong to speak of the acts of great men? I understand that in your mind this is useless as people have already written sakhis about these Gursikhs, but are we to stop talking about the glory of these gursikhs simply because people have already done it? I would argue that these Gursikhs are so beautiful and their jeevans so inspiring that I could hear stories of them ALL DAY! :) Also, (and please do not take this into offence)...I've noticed that you have placed a great importance on Sipahi aspect of Sikhi. You state that "Kusants must not be allowed to flourish unfettered." However, how are your postings on a message board probably read by less than 1% of the people in Punjab somehow effecting the Sant worship that you say is affecting the Panth? Regarding "kusants", if you have taken the "duty to warn others not to fall in their traps" then how are your posts in any way helping those Gursikhs who you believe are being misled? In the case of Gursikhs like BSB Randheer Singh, and Sant Jarnail Singh Jee they PHYSICALLY fought against oppression. Whether it be by going to jail or fighting with weapons, they established a physical presence in their fight. How much of a sipahi can one be if one is fighting on the internet? Aren't we supposed to be Sant-Sipahi's and not Sant-CYBER Sipahi's? Also, before you say that you cannot be held up to a standard to that such of BSB Randheer Singh Jee or Sant Jarnail Singh Jee please note that you yourself are holding OTHERS to this standard yourself by saying that these people are not Sants because they do not fulfill the Sipahi half of Sikhi. But then again you also said that NOT having the Siphai part doesn't make one LESS of a Sant... Please erase this confusion sir... Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh.

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Dear dogma Ji, First of all i write the word "sant" before a GURMUKH's name just for "names sake" as I DONT beleive there are any such EXCEPT for GURU SAHIBAANS and WAHEGURU and now GURU GRANTH JI MAHARAJ. To me all these are GURMUKHS and should be addressed as Bhai...Bhai Gurdass Ji, Bhai Mani Singh Ji......Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh ji...Bhai Jarnail Singh Ji bhinderawalah. THIS SHOULD set your mind at rest about what I BELIEVE IN. Secondly it is your "miscalculated opnion" that i am judging these Gurmukhs on their part/mixture of "sant-Sipahi"..who has how much in what proportion. I just admire some of them more than others...i cannot judge..but i can "admire" some of them LESS than others. Your claim that only 1% read the internet...may be true or false...or partly true....this doesnt "discourage" you from replying to me....and I have SOLID PROOF ( in the thousands of letters I have in my mailbox/hard drive/physical letters sent to me/ over the years that this method WORKS...i have influenced at least 700 people to DISREGARD RAAGMALA...and as for discouraging "sants worship"..the numbers are even more. So I am perfectly satisfied with my work in this regard. If the Internet is ONLY 1%...how many PERCENT of the WORLD'S BILLIONS are THE SIKHS ?? So by your argument GURU NANAK JI - GURU GOBIND SINGH JI "wasted" their time setting up a religion that has in 500 years grown to a miniscule 0.00001% of 8 BILLION humans ???? and we are also wasting our time ?? NO SIR i dont beleive in NUMBERS.....the PRINCIPLE COUNTS for me. Just because GURU NANAK JI didnt "Physically fight" like GURU HARGOBIND JI...dosen it mean anything different ?? Is Guur nank Ji any less a GURU than Guur Gobind Singh ji ?? It would be preposterous to brign this up...but you know a funny thing..a lot of people do beleive in this argument...thats whay they insist they are sikhs of GURU NANAK Ji and not GURU HARGOBIND Ji/GURU GOBIND SINGH JI. NOT every single "soldier" is a WAR FRONT fighter....each has his own duty....mine is WRITING....Pen is mightier than the sword...in some instances. Ever wondered why there are so many KUSANTS..as compared to KU-BHAIS/KU-GURMUKHS ?? Practically unheard of ?? Why does every DERAWADDI want to be known as SANT JI ?? and not bhai ji, gurmukh ji ?? NO GLAMOUR...and Most Important NO BACKING from SUKHMANI SAHIB !!!!..not much to scare people about doing nindiya of a gurmukh/bhai ?? No offense taken and none offered. Jarnail Singh

Re: SANT DARSHAN !!

Dogma · 28 Mar 2005

Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh.. I see now Veerji. You clearly do not believe in the label Sant to be put on ANYONE. Thank you for clearing that up. I was beginning to think something else. Also veerji, please do not say that I believe that Guru Sahib "wasted" anything. In fact, if you refer to my previous post, you can see that I never even mentioned the word 'wasted'. Sikhism, is the 5th largest relegion in the world, NOT a miniscule 0.00001% of 8 billion people. Don't forget veerji, I agree with you, Guru Nanak Dev Jee came here to save this world from drowning.. Kal Taran Guru Nanak Aaiyaa. In the interest of BOTH our lives, I suggest that we both refrain from even TALKING about Guru Sahib wasting time...Guru Sahib maaf karan. 700 people to disregard Raagmala. That's interesting I'm sure that someone out there has probably racked up the same numbers making people BELIEVE in Raagmala. However, Sant Jarnail Singh jee....*sigh* ...with ONE speech probably motivated THOUSANDS..TENS of THOUSANDS, no? But nevermind me veerji, you've made your opinion clear...and I'm happy you explained your opinion to a lot of the sangataa out there. Although I have a few more questions about your stance, I have a feeling that you may have taken offence at my earlier post. Therefore, in the aim of not angering anyone, I think it's best I shut down the discussion (from my end) here. stay in chardeekalaa veerji.. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!