Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Views on Mercy Killing and Assisted Suicide

Views on Mercy Killing and Assisted Suicide

Sohagani · 19 Mar 2005

Sohagani asks about Mercy Killling and Assisted Suicide: Let's define the two term as follows: Assisted Suicide - assisting in death with the consent/request of one who does not have the means to take their own life. (ex. terminal illness, paralysis) Mercy Killing - Taking the life of a person, who can not consent to suicide, as an act of mercy. (ex. coma) 1) Is there a difference between mercy killing and assisted suicide? Why? 2) Should mercy killing/assisted suicide be legal? What impact would a Yes or No decision have on religion and society? 3) What is Sikhi's view on both these issues? 4) What are the views of other major religions on these issues? 5) What is your personal view on the issue? What do you believe is right or wrong? [%sig%]

Re: Views on Mercy Killing and Assisted Suicide

Kulbir Singh · 19 Mar 2005

Good topic Sohagni. Whether suicide or murder, both are wrong according to Gurmat. -------- 1) Is there a difference between mercy killing and assisted suicide? Why? --------- It seems like in case of which one is worse, mercy killing is a worse sin than assisted suicide. ----------- 2) Should mercy killing/assisted suicide be legal? What impact would a Yes or No decision have on religion and society? --------- Whether it should be legal or not is something for society to do but this should not get sanctioning from any Dharam. ------- 3) What is Sikhi's view on both these issues? --------- The best thing is to do paath for people who are in this situation rather than killing them or assisting them in doing suicide. We hear about so many stories where through paath, terminal illnesses have been cured. Just refer to the first story in Ranglay Sajjan, where Singhs cured a terminally ill person through Siri Akhand Paath Sahib. Other than doing paath to cure the problem, a Sikh should not be any part of mercy killing or assisted suicide. ------ 4) What are the views of other major religions on these issues? ------- As far as I know, all religions are united on this issue, just as they are on the homosexual issue. Religions don’t condone this at all. -------- 5) What is your personal view on the issue? What do you believe is right or wrong? ------ My view is same as in Question #3. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Views on Mercy Killing and Assisted Suicide

Sohagani · 22 Mar 2005

Okay, let's conclude that it's wrong to kill in such cases. Mercy killing and assisted suicide is dying unnaturally, or outside of Hukam. But what about keeping someone alive when there is no possible way for a person to recover? Can that be considered unnatural or against Hukam? If a person is going to die regardless of what we try and do to help, should we prolong the period of suffering until death is unavoidable? In western culture death is normally kept hidden, we don't see it very much. A person who is dying from cancer can not communicate. by the time the morphine and endless other drugs are pumped into the body, all that's left is a heart struggling to beat. If my father is dying of cancer and will live the remainder of his life in the state described above, should I make the decision to revive him and allow him to suffer as long as possible? Should I be in a position to make that decision? Should I let my father die a natural death instead of pumping him with more drugs to keep him alive? If I choose not to keep him alive, would that be considered mercy killing? Should the option of life take priority in all cases? Is keeping a person alive the right thing to do? [%sig%]

Re: Views on Mercy Killing and Assisted Suicide

Lakhvir Singh · 22 Mar 2005

WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh. KhalsaJi, In either case, it amounts to nothing less than murder. It's like giving murder a nicer name and making it acceptable. It is against the Will of God to end the life of any human being or animal, no matter what their circumstances of life. For terminally ill patients, it is within God's Will for the mortal to be in that state and when the time comes for the suffering to end, God will make that choice, not us. We are mortals and we have no power or authority to end anyone's life. Who knows what karams of the past they are currently paying for? Out of love and sincere pain, all we can do is pray. We can beseech Waheguru to help the suffering, and He certainly is obliged to honour the prayer of His devottees. An example of great determination and the will to live is of Christopher Reeve, who despite once asking his wife to pull off the life-support system in order to release his family from the pain of his state, lived to become a real man of steel, after his wife declined to take matters into their own hands. Finally, years after the terrible fall he took, life took its course and Reeve's end came naturally. Those who prematurely end their own life, or of another, will condemn the soul of the departed into unknown darkness from which it may never be freed from. What do mortals know? Why play God? When we make choices of life or death, the latter decision could cost our own soul torment when it too passes on. Sikhi has proved that even those that are not Sikh have been cured by the power of Gurbani. If God is to intervene in a critical situation, He will, through His Word. If His Will is to change the destiny of the mortal, He will do it in an instant. But sometimes, despite much prayer and ablutions before God, nothing may seem to change. We must accept the Will of God. Sometimes, even fervent prayers are to no avail because only He knows His Ways. Guru Nanak always asks his Sikhs to pray for 'Sarbat Da Bhalla' and through that, no matter who we pray for, a sincere and earnest prayer never goes unanswered. In conclusion, the ultimate call is God's, not man's. WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.

Re: Views on Mercy Killing and Assisted Suicide

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 22 Mar 2005

absolutely correct points made by Kulbir Singh Ji and Lakhbir Singh Ji. It is all GURU Ji's HUKM.....IT is GURU JI who "provides" us with all those modern drugs to pump in...( and Prolong life...???)..and it is GURU JI who will MAKE the FINAL DECISION. IF you DONT beleive in this...then TELL ME THIS..Can YOU keep pumping in those DRUGS INDEFINITELY and keep the person alive forever ?? IF the answer is NO...then the so called drugs are NOT the LIFE GIVERS but GURU JI..because when GURU JI WITHDRAWS LIFE...all the drugs in the world become sawdust. WHO give you the right to WITHDRAW LIFE ?? NONE. LEAVE it to GURU JI. IF "suffering" is written in.....that is what you will endure...it is a falalcy to think we can alter things...we cant. Jarnail Singh

Re: Views on Mercy Killing and Assisted Suicide

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 22 Mar 2005

OH LORD..give me the COURAGE to accept things I CANNOT CHANGE... The COURAGE to CHANGE the ones I CAN...and the WISDOM to spot the DIFFERENCE....so goes a christian prayer....and it sums up our position on mercy killing suicides above as well. DEATH and SUFFERING....we have to accept....LIFE we can CHANGE and so we should..and GURU JI gives us the wisdom to see the difference between the two. jarnail Singh

Re: Views on Mercy Killing and Assisted Suicide

Sohagani · 22 Mar 2005

So we should keep people who have no chance at life alive and keep them in pain as long as possible? [%sig%]

Re: Views on Mercy Killing and Assisted Suicide

Roopkaur · 22 Mar 2005

Sohagani, why should you be able to choose when that person has had enough time to live when you are not the one that gave life?

Re: Views on Mercy Killing and Assisted Suicide

Sohagani · 23 Mar 2005

That's what I'm saying. Why should we desperately try to keep someone alive? Keeping someone alive is pure moh. It's because we're attached to that body and will do anything to keep it from dying. If a body is going to go, let it go. [%sig%]

Re: Views on Mercy Killing and Assisted Suicide

RoopKaur · 23 Mar 2005

>If a body is going to go, let it go.< When guru ji wants that body to go, he will let it go himself. The fact that we are killing someone because WE can't stand their pain is moh. We feel hurt that that person is going through pain, and we take it upon ourselves to decide ok, since I think this person has had enough I will do Vaheguru's job and kill this person.

Re: Views on Mercy Killing and Assisted Suicide

Sohagani · 25 Mar 2005

Good point Bhain Ji, letting them die for the reason of reducing pain is also moh. But what if that's not the case? What if you just let them die because there is no chance for life? [%sig%]

Re: Views on Mercy Killing and Assisted Suicide

Roopkaur · 28 Mar 2005

By letting them die, do you mean helping them die? I am not sure if this is right according to gurmat or not, but my personal opinion is that if a person refuses western medical treatment, i.e. chemotherapy for cancer patients, then I do not think this is necessarily wrong, depending on the circumstances. But I still do not think that we have the right to assist someone in dying, no matter what the circumstance, as we are taking Guru ji's bhaana into our own hands. This action is not necessarily out of Moh, it could be acceptance of bhaanaa and love for Guru ji as well.

Re: Views on Mercy Killing and Assisted Suicide

Singh · 28 Mar 2005

One of the hardest concepts of Sikhi that I've had to try to grasp is hukam. Guru Sahib tells us that the time of death for someone is beyond our control. As much as we think or feel we can control when or if someone dies, its not up to us. We are also told that good karams and bad karams are the same to a Khalsa. We don't want either, so whether we live a happy "good" life as compared to a "bad" painful life, all it is is us playing out our past karams. So if someone in your family is suffering think of it as a type of bhagti, which it is. Also, if they don't live out their karam in this life they'll live it out in their next and who knows when that will be. This is our turn to do bhagti and accomplish something. Thats why we're here and whether or not we're living a "good" life or a "bad" life, its really inconsequential. Don't take this life for granted. We wouldn't throw out jewellery because its lost its shine or doesn't look good to us anymore; its still worth a lot and we can't forget that. And don't forget: dhukh dhaaroo sukh rog bhaeiaa jaa sukh thaam n hoee || thoo(n) karathaa karanaa mai naahee jaa ho karee n hoee ||1|| [%sig%]