Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Gurmat's relationship to the Vedas

Gurmat's relationship to the Vedas

Singh · 14 Mar 2005

I have read many posts on this forum over the years and I have learnt a great deal. BUT, there is one thing that keeps coming up in responses by Bhai Kulbir Singh and others that I still don't get. I would appreciate a detailed response to this as I have been thinking about this for so long that it has become annoying! I want to understand the relationship that other faiths (especially Hinduism) has to the Truth revealed by Gurmat. When I was younger, I believed that Sikhi was totally unique in every respect, but as I have been reading more, I'm realising that other faiths share many commonalities, even to the extent of other faiths also promoting chanting of God's Name (e.g. Hinduism, Christianity, etc.) I understand that God has lots of Names, but it was Guru Nanak who came to reveal the True Name, the name that God adopts for himself and that all other names are Kirtam Naams, not SatNaam. But... How is it that the Vedas and other scriptures of the Hindus, for example, are so right about things such as Bhagti, the soul, Karma, transmigration, Name, etc etc? They're not 100% correct as according to the Truth revealed by Satguru, but they are far more than a lucky guess. What do we conclude from this? My conclusions so far have been that people have been searching for that missing something for centuries upon centuries and that people have tried various methods, but some have been successful in moving up the spiritual ladder, even though they haven't been able to reach the highest stage of Sach Khand (only possible to do via Satguru). These Bhagats discovered many truths, such as karma, and they wrote down what they discovered in texts such as the Vedas. People were then taught these observations and progressed to simialar levels also. Gurbani refers to the Vedas and says things like "In the Vedas, the ultimate objective is the Naam, the Name of the Lord; but they do not hear this, and they wander around like demons." [919], so Guru Ji acknowledges that the Vedas have some understanding of Naam. How did the writer(s) of the Vedas etc get to understand so much about Naam without Satguru? Could it be that just as Bhagat Kabir had spiritual darshan of Satguru and received Amrit Naam, that others before Bhagat Kabir also received some kind of blessing from Satguru? In short, who wrote the Vedas? I'm really confused about this. Can somebody respond, or even point me towards a book?

Re: Gurmat's relationship to the Vedas

sarjitsinghkhalsa · 14 Mar 2005

if hundusim was ok then waheguru did not have to send baba nanak to come hundastan these was the corpurt country at tha t time and the latest suwaye by the economist india is no 4 morst corrupt country in the world at they idol prayers

Re: Gurmat's relationship to the Vedas

Kulbir Singh · 14 Mar 2005

------------- Gurbani refers to the Vedas and says things like "In the Vedas, the ultimate objective is the Naam, the Name of the Lord; but they do not hear this, and they wander around like demons." [919], so Guru Ji acknowledges that the Vedas have some understanding of Naam. How did the writer(s) of the Vedas etc get to understand so much about Naam without Satguru? Could it be that just as Bhagat Kabir had spiritual darshan of Satguru and received Amrit Naam, that others before Bhagat Kabir also received some kind of blessing from Satguru? In short, who wrote the Vedas? I'm really confused about this. Can somebody respond, or even point me towards a book? -------------- The translation that you have done is not correct. The translation should be as follows: From amongst religious means to reach Vaheguru e.g. Vedas, the greatest way to reach him is the way of Naam. Mad jeev-aatma does not listen to Naam and is wandering about like demons. Vedas don’t have Satnaam. Gurbani says that they talk about paap and punn but don't have the thathai saar Thathai saar. No Gurbani pankiti ever supports the way of Vedas or for that matter any other religious book. Guru Sahib only and only supported the way of Sat-Naam i.e. the True Naam Gurmantra. As for your question on who wrote the Vedas, one thing is for sure that Vedas and Upanishads were written by very learned men who were not only learned but also spiritually elevated beings. This is the thought of learned men of today. Vedas are the oldest religious scripture of humankind. According to the Hindu tradition, all 4 Vedas were written by Brahma and Gurbani too has acknowledged that Vedas came from Brahma, a powerful deity of Hindus. According to Gurmat, Brahma, Vishnu and Mahesh (Shiv jee) do exist but are much inferior to Gursikhs who reach the highest stages of spirituality. Gurbani also mentions that for a Gursikh, Guru alone is everything. Brahma, Bishan, Mahesh, and Parvati Maayee for a Gursikh is his Guru. He does not need any other deity and nor cares of anyone else. There are numerous powerful forces in this world but firstly all are forces derive their energy from Vaheguru and secondly all Gursikhs worship Vaheguru who alone is the energy-giver in this world. I suggest that you do more paath including Siri Sukhmani Sahib on top of your daily nitnem and read all books of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. You will get Gurmat from reading Bhai Sahib’s books. Most of everything else you have written is correct, according to my humble opinion. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Gurmat's relationship to the Vedas

fresno sikh · 02 Aug 2006

SSAKAL This question was put to Guruji who said Vedas are like water deep in the earth core. Its access is difficult , only to Brahmins through sanskrit, an extremely difficult language. Gurbani is like rain water coming from clouds which is accesible to everyone in simple Gurmukhi language. Whaeguru