Re: expressing the soul
jugroop singh · 08 Mar 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Veer / Bhain 'blue' ji wrote:
'The keertan today is like your in the middle of a football game. Blue thirty-two hut hut gruu gruu vagruu'.
i know i'm turning into a right moaner (!) but come on...regardless of the style of Keertan, have some basic respect and at the very least don't take the mick out of it.
Certainly, there are ways of putting points across and ways of NOT putting points across.
For instance, i no longer do Dhunni whilst listening to Kirtan but the thought of even jokingly referring to someone who does, and having even a mild dig at them, is terrible.
Remember, you yourself entitled this thread 'expressing the soul' - the people who are doing what you are describing above are expressing their souls. Is it appropriate to take the mick out of them?
i don't know; maybe i am just a moaner...who's getting old and just moaning more often!
((( : - )>>>
VahiGuruJiKakhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: expressing the soul
Kulbir Singh · 10 Mar 2005
Bhai Sahib did not do dhuni. This has been confirmed by many gursikhs. Yes at times it so happened that Bhai Sahib or other Ranglay Sajjan went into trance or divine spiritual tranquility while doing kirtan and Kirtan stopped. Sangat at that time started doing Vaheguru Vaheguru.
The late Giani Amolak Singh jee, Bhai Jeevan Singh jee, Bhai Kaur Singh jee Amritsar, Bhai Mahinder Singh jee Kala Sangha, Giani Harbhajan Singh jee Anandpur and other puratan Singhs have confirmed personally wiht us that Bhai Sahib did not used to do dhuni in Kirtan and neither did other kirtaniyaas of that time. Yes as stated above, in cases of extreme ecstasy, dhuni did happen but it was never in the way it is now - planned dhuni in every shabad and sometimes in every pankiti of a Shabad.
In any case, let us not divulge in this new debate.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: expressing the soul
mahaa huraami · 10 Mar 2005
How funny is this thread, the shabad is telling you to do dhunni and you keep quite lol hahahhaha
vaheguuurrrruuuuuu