Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

Kulbir Singh · 07 Mar 2005

A Hindu veer in whom I bump into while going to work had the following conversation with me. The conversation took place in half-Punjabi and half-Hindi kind of style but I am writing it in English for the convenience of our readers: “Kulbir bhai, India is a truly democratic country. All top positions are being occupied by minorities. The prime minister is a Sikh. The president is a Muslim. Head of the army is a Sikh. Head of the ruling party is a Christian”, he lamented. Though he was praising India’s democracy but I could also sense how upset he was because of this. “I don’t understand one thing Vijay (name changed)”. “And what is that Singh”. “When we (Sikhs) ask for rights, you guys tell us that we are Hindus but when we get powerful or get into any position of authority, then you start calling us minority i.e. Sikhs. What is this Gorakh-dhanda?” He knew I had him. He sheepishly said, “What do you mean by this?” “You yourself had argued with me that Sikhs are Hindus, just last year. I had back then told you that it is Sikhs who are going to determine whether we are Hindus or not. And now if we are Hindus, according to your own opinioin, then why are you complaining now that a Sikh is a Prime Minister of India?” “So do you acknowledge that you are Hindus?” “No I am not acknowledging anything. I am simply reminding you that when we fight for rights and object to the Hindu act governing Sikhs in India, you guys tell us that we are Hindus but now you guys are crying when you see a Sikh Prime Minister. When we wanted to have the Nanakshahi calander implemented RSS and other fundamentalist Hindus got so upset saying that Sikhs are Hindus and they should not try to get separated like this but now why are their stomachs aching so much to see a Sikh on the position of chief General and PM?”. He did not have any answer to this and just kept quiet. I thought of pulling him out of this embarrassment and we started talking about something else. Kulbir Singh

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

MKaur · 08 Mar 2005

Its a good thing you let him know we are not Hindhus. So many people have that mistaken.

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

............ · 08 Mar 2005

why do hindus have a problem to mann sikh as separate religion? Manmohan singh is serving as a prime minister on his credits because he is a better prime minister than sonia. The hindus actually elected miss ghandi not manmohan singh. She handed the reigns to him.

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

RK · 08 Mar 2005

I was reading about Hinduism in one of texts today for an essay, and under Bhagat Kabir, the author says the following: "Kabir, a Hindu, had much in common with the Sufi Muslim teacher Dadu and with Nanak, revered by the Sikhs as their founding teacher. Each of these North Indian poetsaints came to have a circle of followers, termed a panth (path). The Kabir panth and the Dadu panth were in time absorbed into the general body of the Hindus and Muslims respectively, but Nanaks path ultimately emerged as a seperate boundaried community, the Sikhs, in ironic contrast to Nanak's unifying spiritual vision. Nanak's north Indian vernacular, Punjabi, became the language of Sikh literature and tradition." and in the Muslim Section: "Vernacular piety resulted in a rich common Hindu-Muslim religious culture. Kabir, a 15th century Hindu-Muslim mystic, is still venerated by Hindus and Muslims alike. The Sikh religious tradition, born in this milieu, was founded by Guru nanak, a follower of Kabir." The Hindu author is vasudha Narayanan, and the Muslim one is mahmoud M. Ayoub.

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

Jagjit Singh · 09 Mar 2005

As far as I am aware Manmohan Singh is the only Prime Minister is world history to ever hold such a position, without ever winning an election. I do not think he has ever even won a by-election or MP post. So we should not read into this too much. It was a complete fluke. If Congress had fought election with him upfront instead of Sonia, he would never have won. There is still alot of predjudice against Sikhs in India.

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

Bhopinder singh · 09 Mar 2005

Good point jagjit singh

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

Bhopinder singh · 09 Mar 2005

RK First of all, what is Hinduism?. Please think about the defination in your own mind. Is it something like the name you choose RK. who is the Mohmamd,christ,Budha,Moses,Nanak of Hinduism.What is the Mecca, Jeruslam,Nankana,Patliputra,Harmandir sahib of Hinduism.What is the single book ie Quaran,Bible,Granth Sahib of Hinduism. The name iself is given to you by your victors ( mughals) and please ask them.Yes Muslims i agree. Nanak was no follower of Kabir or for that reason any body. He was the prophet in himself. In the same way if i start telling you about the so called 33000000000 devtas of yours and their masters you will die with shame. I will never do that .

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

Bhopinder singh · 09 Mar 2005

I forgot to ask you RK.Who were you talking about with regards to Hinduism. Brahmins or the Kashtriyas or for both of them. Please dont forget the shudras termed untouchable ( achoot) by your religion as they also want to define you.

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

Bhopinder singh · 09 Mar 2005

RK So you can see their is no such thing as Hinduism and theirfore i request and invite you to join the panth of Nanak as it is the only and true religion of india.

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

RK · 09 Mar 2005

you misunderstood me, my point was not to say that we are part of them, but to show you the propaganda that they use to distort the fact that SIkhism is a unique and independent religion. My point was to show that each person is trying to show Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji as part of their religion, because they have such a hard time accepting the Sikhs. you have totally misunderstood my intentions, but I am at fault there as I did not explain the quotes, I just presented them. I was aiming at showing the faulty logic others use to make SIkhs a part of their group. THis is just some excerpts from this text, wait till you read what they have written under the SIkh section. By the way, I am NOT a Hindu.

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

. · 10 Mar 2005

hindus do not have a real religion as such. Their fluid concepts allow just about anything and everything to enter their mind. 99% of hindus i know would rehash the same thing as above the indian media has a big effect on them. Manmhan singh was not democractically elected by hindus. Hindu treatment of sikhs can be seen on bollywood films with no protest from hindus. If manmohan singh has power why does he do nothing to stop bollywood films ridiculing sikhs? So sanatnists too should explore the ground they walk on.

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

sarjitsinghkhalsa · 10 Mar 2005

any body if you thing india is democratic you are living in cooko land they khnow that sikhs are well educated now so they are puting puppets on high positions just like when a baby cry the mother give him milk to keep quiet afer doing so much crime against our race we are sleeping

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

Sundeep Singh · 11 Mar 2005

I think one of the reasons to put Manmohan Singh in power, if not the main reason, was that he is an Indian. Sonia Gandhi is white and foreign-born and this would have resulted in protest from the right wing hindu fundamentalist parties. Also, Manmohan Singh is one of the few (maybe only ) Congress MPs with a clean record. Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't it a coalition ruling India? So if the other parties decided they didn't want to be lead by a foreign-born white person then wouldn't that result in a withdrawal of support and another election? I'm just trying to point out that by appointing manmohan singh they are not even "throwing us a bone"; they are only trying to stay on top and trying to gain what additional PR advantages they can.

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

yo · 11 Mar 2005

sikhism needs its own space to grow. hindus generally are athiest and worship material elements. hindu and sikh do not mix in together its just plain fact, never did, the only thing sikhs and hindus ever had in common in the past were moghuls oppress them both. Now hindus rip down mosques 84 kill muslims in godhra and sikh in delhi. the khalsa is not anyones sub servient it is its own bastion built on shaheeds karbaani ever glowing throughout the night of kal yug.

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

Kulbir Singh · 11 Mar 2005

-------- I think one of the reasons to put Manmohan Singh in power, if not the main reason, was that he is an Indian. Sonia Gandhi is white and foreign-born and this would have resulted in protest from the right wing hindu fundamentalist parties. --------- Sonia Gandhi made a very wise choice by choosing Manmohan Singh as the PM of India. She knew that she could not become the PM without much tumult and tempest in the parliament and by choosing Manmohan Singh a person from a minority, she hit many targets in one shot. She vindicated the Congress Party from the allegations that it is a communal party. Congress even succeeded in pacifying the Sikhs by choosing Manmohan Singh. The recent rout of Akalis in Ajnala, by Congress is the proof of Congress' popularity in Punjab. Captain Amrinder Singh was an Akali but he was not given due respect and his place due to rife nepotism in Akali Dal Badal. He went to Congress and led it to victory in Punjab. Now Congress has kicked out Jagmit Singh Brar and who knows history may repeat itself if Brar joins Akali Dal and leads it to victory against Congress Party that expelled him. Another reason why Sonia selected Manmohan Singh is that no other leader is more selfless and loyal than Manmohan Singh. Eventually, Gandhi wants her son Rahul or her daughter Priyanka to lead the party but till that time is reap, she wants her loyalist to lead the party and Manmohan Singh is very very loyal. We know that Manmohan Singh is going to be the PM only for a short period of time but there is no doubt that his appointment has been very positive for Sikhs in India and abroad. To see a Dastar wala person leading a nation of 1 Billion people certainly helps our image in the world. And his honesty and work ethics are unmatched. If he stays as PM of India for two terms, India will make great progress economically. No doubt about that. I think he is going to go down in the history as the greatest PM of India ever. That is only if he can lead the country for two terms. Kulbir Singh

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

ns · 11 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh wonder if he'll free up 50000 or so Sikhs have been rotting in jail without trial for the last 20 odd years.

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

Kulbir Singh · 11 Mar 2005

------- wonder if he'll free up 50000 or so Sikhs have been rotting in jail without trial for the last 20 odd years. ------- I had written that Manmohan Singh was loyal to Sonia Gandhi and Congress and not necessarily to Khalsa Panth. I personally have no expectations from him as far as the plight of our brothers rotting in jail. It is a shame that no political party including Akali Dal has done anything to release the jailed Sikhs. Akalis ruled for full 5 years but did nothing to release Sikh prisoners. What can we expect from Amrinder Singh and his party or from Manmohan Singh and his government? May Bandee-Shod Satguru Siri Guru Hargobind Sahib jee have mercy on his sons rotting in jail and release them. Who else is capable? Kulbir Singh

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

yo · 12 Mar 2005

perhaps we should have a panth programme, centralise certain issues on the forefront send this to akhal takhat pressure them to intervene and help. failing that what about drawing a mass petition never seen in history 23 million sikhs right? why cant we get 23 million signatures asking for freedom for brothers and sisters unfairly held in jail? Thw world will have to take notice of this. What about demonstration by sikhs in every noook and corner of the world? has any world religion sat back and let 50 000 of its people rot in jails without trying their best to help them? the next political party cannot ignore something that affects 23 million concentrated people. How about sending a team of gursikhs to certain jails to visit our brothers and sisters who are rotting away to show them the whole sikh nation is united and cares for them and give them courage and hope. establish contact with jail authorities to at least provide the detainees with more facilities, so they may be able to at least pas stheir days in joy and happiness ie rensbhais, kirtan in jail and access to different banis. Maybe even if sikh times or a major sikh newspaper decides to slot in one section to each detainee with a photo and their life story each week and then this could also work in conjunction with panthic websites like this and others to help create unity and understanding of forgotten lost 50000 of our detained brethren and sisters. Just ideas, if anyone can come with more please post. From what i have read 50 000 sikhs were just unfairly detained without appeal or courts. This is a gross violation of human rights.

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

yo · 12 Mar 2005

you see a lot of these trips to india and stuff yatras going to different gurdwaras, or the "golden temple express 5 star hotel" ( hotel located near darbar sahib). Our present thinking is getting commercialised, luxurious, fanciful to suit the tastes of a western born sikh. The real essence of panthic community is down the pan. So why not include the yatras in a double package that is both a yatra , an educational experience by meeting families of shaheeds, and slotting in some days to visit our brethren in prisons. That way yuth come back with memories, accounts, experiences to share and our brethren know their karbani is remembered world over.

Re: India a truly democratic country: A crying Hindu

ns · 12 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fate Veer yo jeeo you make excellent points and they should be followed 100%..it makes my stomach turn everytime I think of our brothers in jails.YES A MASS Petition is muc needed. Late panth Rattan Giani Maskeen Jee used to goto jails and do katha for Sikhs, I haven't heard many people mention that seva of Giani Jee but it's a fact that he used to go ..how many kirtan darbars are there in jails for those Sikhs today..they should definitely be happening, this is the bare minimum we should be doing , there is no hope for them from Punjab... I pray to Guru Ji that Sikhs take up this seva...may Guru Jee bless us with it as soon as possible......