Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Khalistan How?

Khalistan How?

gabroo jwan · 01 Mar 2005

There must be a means to obtain an end. What means will it take for the kaum to obtain a Khalistan. Why is there a need for Khalistan today when high ranking generals in the army are from sikh background and the president of the country is sikh? If we do need a Khalistan how will it happen? 1. Political Movement? - through the political process by remaining law-abiding citizens. 2. Guerrilla Warefare? - using hit and run tactics like the insurgents in Bagdad. 3. Wait for Leader? - waiting until Sant Jarnail Singh comes back to lead a movement. 4. Blind Fury? - standing on top of rooftops and screaming Khalistan at the top of your lungs. 5. Other Method?

Re: Khalistan How?

KCF · 01 Mar 2005

The partition of india and pakistan was wrong becuase it was a 2 way split, more self-determined soveriegn rules should have been established because some nations had their own independet rules before the british occupied. Sikhs had khalsa rajj, the ruler was shere-e-panjab maharaja ranjit singh. We had our own FLAG, CURRENCY, ARMY, CONSITUTION, CAPITAL. Panjab was the last rule to be taken over. Other nations were tamils, nagas, kashmires, assamese, manipurs, who are still fighting today for liberation. india and pakistan is more a conflict between hinduism vs islam, with khalistan being liberated india will have to remove all its artilery from panjab which is good sign less chance of war, and pakistan will have to reposition or remove its artilery from facing khalistan, which will ease tensions between paks and hindus because their will be a gap between the two, a buffer zone. SIKHS shoudn't get involved in this war because at the moment darbar sahib is in hindu controlled panjab and nankana sahib is in pak controlled panjab, both shirnes must be guarded with our lives! KHALSA RAJJ (KHALISTAN) MUST BE ESTABLISHED TO SAFE GUARD OUR INTERESTS. [%sig%]

Re: Khalistan How?

MKaur · 01 Mar 2005

Don't know how it will come about...but it will. Khalistaaann Zindaabaadd!

Re: Khalistan How?

human · 01 Mar 2005

I doubt pakistan. It will still have reasons to infiltrate the so called khalistan. But where do we stand, apart from agriculture. Infotech and better infrastructure is still years away from punjab. Before khalistan we need prosperous and developed punjab so that people stop going to england canada by selling their lands for better oppurtunities and greener pastures. Nothing wrong in going abroad. But the thing that is wrong is staying away from a place where you want a new nation. Don't ever think that in that case Pakistan and India will not have interest in punjab due to strategical importance. So its better not to have it but let sikhism grow by leaps and bounds.

Re: Khalistan How?

ji · 01 Mar 2005

thats a solid point. the more we migrate out of punjab to west the less chance of khalsa ever gaining raj because there will be chain reaction. we leave others from different india part will move in.

Re: Khalistan How?

KCF · 01 Mar 2005

DEVELOPMENT WON'T COME TO PANJAB UNTIL KHALISTAN IS ESTABLISHED BECAUSE AT PRESENT PANJAB IS UNDER CENTER DELHI WHICH HAS BETRAYED PANJAB FROM 1947, CENTER HAS CONTROL OVER PANJAB'S WATERS, ELECTRICITY THE TWO MAIN POINTS OF DEVELOPMENT FOR PANJAB!!!!!!!!!! THEY NEVER PUT ANY INDUSTRY IN PANJAB UNLIKE OTHER STATES!!!! [%sig%]

Re: Khalistan How?

Jeevan · 01 Mar 2005

for this establishment we need to hold more Virtual NaamNet Smagams!

Re: Khalistan How?

heyheyhey · 01 Mar 2005

> 3. Wait for Leader? - waiting until Sant Jarnail Singh comes > back to lead a movement gabroo jwan sant jarnail singh is shahid he is gone

Re: Khalistan How?

.. · 02 Mar 2005

Badal who is close to SGPC did nothing for the IT park he himself established in Mohali. Just by giving land doesn't make it and IT park. You have to build that infrastructure. You have to sell your idea to invite companies. Who would have gained from it? Our sikh youth. But who wants to work on that. Did nothing for the roads. See the highways of haryana and punjab. You will see a marked difference. See the difference in the buses that both states have. Why we do not have other industries is due to the fact that raw material has to come from far off states, thats why it does not make business sense Infotech makes sense as we have good hotels and airport in chandigarh but again no one thinks above agriculture and petty political issues. Centre not only controls waters in punjab but in all the states.

Re: Khalistan How?

Singhstah · 02 Mar 2005

the only way for us to get raaj is waking up and doing nitnem at amritvela everyday

Re: Khalistan How?

BHOPINDER SINGH · 02 Mar 2005

Centre not only controls waters in punjab but in all the states. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- who controls the water of karnataka and tamilnadu what is happening to the dispute of kaveri Why we do not have other industries is due to the fact that raw material has to come from far off states, thats why it does not make business sense ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ how far is harayana from these raw materials how come it has all the bulk of industries and also author always write your name and you will never be able to fool us

Re: Khalistan How?

singhji · 02 Mar 2005

wow sum interesting view here, never thought of ne of these before, can i just quik pose a question tho, why do we need khalistan, singhs bak in the days never had one why do we need one??? i cant think of any reason has to why we need one? can sum 1 pleez help me wid dis!!!!! nuff luv goin out

Re: Khalistan How?

Premi · 02 Mar 2005

I thought the SGPC was going to open up a chain of KFC's (Khalsa Fried Chicken), jhatkaa approved, that is and do parchar via of this route. Buy a bucket of Khalsa Chicken get a phreeeee pamphlet on what we are all about. Maybe Tapoban Singhs can give them some Sarbloh stuff to help in making the Khalsa Chicken? Kulbir Singh you up for it? And Gyanee Arshee you can right up something on fake saadhs and maybe throw in one of your Dharnaa's?? What do you think? Or maybe Bibi Jagir Kaur can open a young women's counselling service in order to get the message out. Her motto can be "Don't dispair, we will cremate your body without an autopsy, but we are great because we implemented the calendar, Women have equal rights" Get some counselling and an a phreeee pamphlet on what we are. This is a sure strategy to win over the GOI as they love chicken, good articles and to give women there rights. *****All joking aside unless we change our mentlaity we will get nowhere. We need to take charge as a collective sangat of Sikhs and throw the goofs out of power. We need to set aside our minor differences and work for the greater cause of the Panth. Sorry if I have annoyed anyone, I have a tendancy to poke fun**** Premi

Re: Khalistan How?

BHOPINDER SINGH · 02 Mar 2005

THE DAY INDIAN ARMY SET ITS FOOT IN SRI DRBAR SAHIB AMRITSAR SAHIB that is the first and last reason thats it dont waste your time should we or shouldn't we yes how should we ?

Re: Khalistan How?

pipz · 05 Mar 2005

i try to understand the views of two types of thinkers one that says we will wait for babaji to come and everything will be ok, the other that says we must try to understand the panthic problems, and address them instead of waiting around. Take for example one camp says babaji will return. In this process sikhs are migrating from punjab, hindu biharis move in, gujjar muslim farmers are overtaking in some parts it is the gujjar who is balaing the bakareyh now. the face of punjab is now different from what it was 10 years ago. This affects the whole social set up. I not question the status of babaji but suppose he come back what will he come back to? his sikhs are now moved to canada america uk. What will he be around gujjars and biharis? The remaining sikhs who could not make it are now cut haired and becoming radaswami and dehdaris. The " we will wait for babaji approach" means just sit back tight someone will come and save us. do not mean bad but what can we do for panth then meanwhile? The other camp few small groups are trying to reflect upon what is happening and how we can correct the problems through active measures like dal khalsa proposes a ban on immigration. Might sound unfair but if immigration continues into punjab what will happen? No matter how racist you call this, we do not want to see our homeland taken over . But the problem does lie in us that we moved out in huge number. We need to talk about what is happening there now and how we can tackle problems that exist right now.

Re: Khalistan How?

raj karega khalsa · 05 Mar 2005

heyheyhey, how do u kno sant ji is shaheed, did u see his body...btw im not gonna start arguein bout this. jus i think u shud keep those kind of opinions to urself, u mite offend sum1... why do we need khalistan???.....i dunno bout u but i don't like to see my brothers piked up from their homes and slaughtered, my sisters gettin raped and killed, HArmander Sahib attacked and thousands of innocent sikhs massacred, Akal Takhat literally blown up....i think i covered most of it....o except all the propaganda and b*** makin all sikhs look like terrorsits or clowns, liquor stores on evry other street..we need to be independant, we need freedom, with people like Kumar and Tytleer still gov't i dun think thas possible in india...n look at the name of the country, like seriously! Hindu-stan, majority of the ppl who sarificed their lives to overthrow the british and helped india get independance wwere Sikh... After all the papis who massacred innocent sikhs (Brar, KP Gill, Tytler, Kumar etc.) are puunished, we should do it politically, infrom all the major gov'ts in the world about wut has happened and continues to happen today... Bhull Chaak MAph Karni

Re: Khalistan How?

dil · 05 Mar 2005

VJKK,VJKF; It is of no use to think of khalistan at present time. Because tenets of sikhism has to be base of khalistan and our young generation is running away from these tenets. Then how you can dream of khalistan. Only way to achieve the aim of khalistan is to stirictly follow the tenets of sikhism in our family. Make your family and home like khalistan. Once every family becomes image of khalistan. No one can stop the creation of khalistan. Bhool chook Muaf

Re: Khalistan How?

gajj ke bolo Khalistan Khalist · 05 Mar 2005

We passed another leader in Maskeen Jee. He could have taken political moves to make a Khalistan because of his knowledgeability. Does anyone know if Maskeen ever spoke of or his opinion on Khalistan? If panth follow example of Maskeen then perhaps the Guru themself will bless us with Khalistan.

Re: Khalistan How?

pipz · 06 Mar 2005

does not matter how many leaders sikhi produces if sikhs keep migrating out of punjab who will a khalistan be left for?

Re: Khalistan How?

VJ · 06 Mar 2005

each is leader then all should take immediate action to gain Khalistan instead of wait for external leader going to come and grant all your wishes.

Re: Khalistan How?

awo · 06 Mar 2005

Has anyone heard of the prophecy that a sikh will be born outside of India, in a western country. And then that sikh will come and liberate all of the sikhs in india from the corrupt rulers to bring forth Khalistan. I think its in Sau Sakhi?

Re: Khalistan How?

.. · 07 Mar 2005

prophecies/second comings/ have already been settled inside Guru Granth sahib. Some ill informed sikhs are sometimes heard saying The Guru will be reborn as Neklank Avtar. The story appears to have been borrowed from hinduism where according to vishnu puran neklank or kalki will appear. He will ride a white horse and destroy evil doers. To counteract this misbelief the bhats wrote - " The True Guru, The True Guru is our Only lord. He disarms the powerful, smothers the mighty, fulfils the devotees, and is krishna and kalki in one". Guru Granth Sahib page 1403. In fact it is prophechies like this that do harm to sikhi creating a "lets sit and wait" attitude instead of facing responsibility for panthic issues.

Re: Khalistan How?

singhji · 07 Mar 2005

hey dudes the events described talks of masacre so on an so fourth but since the gurus this has always happened in sikhi, lets not run away from the world an make our own island we live with what comes our way.

Re: Khalistan How?

Bhopinder singh · 07 Mar 2005

Gabroo your first point is the best way. The same is being preached by pakistan to the kashmiris

Re: Khalistan How?

KHALISTAN KHALISTAN · 07 Mar 2005

RAW and RSS only has the nuts to abuse the poor farmers that are suffering enough as it is with water issues and so forth. They waste so much resources on cults like radhosoamis, etc. that it is laughable to the average sikh living abroad. When will RSS and RAW learn that majority of Khalsa are living abroad and once they come together and make a collective movement, there is nothing that they will be able to do to counter such a move.

Re: Khalistan How?

Singh · 08 Mar 2005

I will like to know this too. or it is just a myth?

Re: Khalistan How?

hmm · 09 Mar 2005

panth always had pearls with rehit, the more they progress the more they shine and inspire other. Bhai Saahib Randhir Singh ji, Baba Jarnail Singh, Singh Sabha, Akali Phula Singh n more. If you own a house, no one else down your road will volunteer to come and pay your mortgage and bills for you. Nobody else will step in to settle your affairs it is you and what God has given to you and how you will be that determines the outcome. In the same way no one else will come to sort your or panthic affairs in the world. It is upto each and everyone one of us to pull our weight. First we must face real issues inside sikhism and come to agreement.

Re: Khalistan How?

Gulzar Singh · 09 Mar 2005

WJKK WJKF What about places in Pakistan Punjab. If Khalistan is ever made, Lahore and parts, if not all, pak punjab should be brought back under khalsa raaj. I would be very disheartened if Khalistan is made and Nankana remains in Pakistan. :( WJKK WJKF

Re: Khalistan How?

Bhopinder singh · 09 Mar 2005

Gulzar nankana sahib will remain in pakistan.We will get free acess to travel like nanded and patna sahib

Re: Khalistan How?

sarjitsinghkhalsa · 10 Mar 2005

khalistan coming in2008 because khalsa panth was formed by waheguru we havegone abit weak we should see www.budhadal.com

Re: Khalistan How?

Bhopinder singh · 10 Mar 2005

sarjitsinghkhalsa How sure are you? Long time ago we use to wait for 97. It just wizzeled by, nothing happened.

Re: Khalistan How?

. · 11 Mar 2005

yup then we were told year 1999. then 2000 then 2004 now we in 2005 see this is the damage prophecies do sit back someone else down the rd will come and look after your house all you have to do is hands up relax and wait in the meanwhile agh lag gi.

Re: Khalistan How?

. · 11 Mar 2005

the same thing was said about sant jarnail singh ji's return. they were saying 2004. nothing happened. these dates r a waste. just false hopes. the true dates are when the Panth are strong in belife of Naam and Rehet

Re: Khalistan How?

heyheyhey · 10 Apr 2005

> heyheyhey, how do u kno sant ji is shaheed, did u see his > body.. yes ive seen pictures of his body and plus hes spose to be here in 2004 but its already 2005

Re: Khalistan How?

etka · 10 Apr 2005

I agree 100% that we should not wait on ne thing or ne one. To form a khalistan, a long term political resistence is needed. Start early end early. But this does'nt mean sant ji aint commin back, But why wait? why not get a head start? Make sure ya'll have educations, a person without an education is without value.

Re: Khalistan How?

KHALISTANI · 11 Apr 2005

Sant Ji will return when no one knows. but to get khalistan all akj's and taksalee's and any other jatha ppl have to stop bikering amonst themselves and work towards a common goal. WJKK WJKF

Re: Khalistan How?

whatever · 11 Apr 2005

Wake up call - Khalistan is a myth and why? 1. We cannot unite under one nishan sahib let alone run a country!! 2. Pakistan will def invade so-called khalistan to rejoin the two punjabs 3. We have no port......where do we do our trade - via india...fat chance of that they will be our biggest enemies time to grow up people and live in the real world - no one in punjab wants to see the dark days - and if you are still going to rant and rave on about it - go over there and do it - stop being wimps and go over a start your agitation there.......

Re: Khalistan How?

Bhopinder singh · 11 Apr 2005

whatever We have no port......where do we do our trade - via india...fat chance of that they will be our biggest enemies ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------How many ports does Nepal, Mangolia, Switzerland,Kzakistan, Uzbekistan, to name a fewhave? ________________________________________________________ Khalistan is a myth and why? ___________________________________________________ Pakistan will def invade so-called khalistan to rejoin the two punjabs Pakistan should first join east pakistan SIACHIN that india took in 1981in kargill type operation ___________________________________________________________ time to grow up people and live in the real world - no one in punjab wants to see the dark days - ....... ____________________________________________________________ How sure are you?Do you have any research to back up that statement?Time to grow up whatever. __________________________________________________________ and if you are still going to rant and rave on about it - go over there and do it - stop being wimps and go over a start your agitation there....... __________________________________________________________ What is that? Whom are you calling wimps?Please mind your language on the other hand i think the title befits you and you should keep it as your name rather than writitng WHATEVER.

Re: Khalistan How?

whatever · 11 Apr 2005

Bhopinder Singh, I have followed the progress of the movement from a very young age and as time has moved on so have peoples minds and wishes. I was only 14 when the Harimandir Sahib was attacked and very hot headed at the time. Leading up to the attack on the Harimandir Sahib there was a lot of support for the freedom movement even though it was never openly declared as Khalistan. After the attack it became a movement to gain so-called independence. I know of many young people who joined the movement and they themselves admitted (by the late 80s) that the movement had no clear direction and had just become a tit for tat game with the police. Many of these guys died or fled the country to places like Canada and now wish to be no part of it. What was seen as a clear black and white issue by the Sikhs in the west was a multi-million coloured issue on the ground in Punjab. I go to india at least once a year and sometimes twice (and have been since the age of 8 years) and no one is interested in that ethos any longer. I saw how support changed from pro- militants to anti-militants. In the end people just wanted to live in peace and i respect that.

Re: Khalistan How?

Bhopinder singh · 11 Apr 2005

whatever ji Khalistan does not mean millitancy and only that. it is a god given right of freedom for every sikh.see the demand for freedom by sikhs should never be equated with terror They are asking for a very basic right of theirs and Indians are terrorising and exteminating their lot so in the real terms sikhs have a right to ask khalistan and India has no right kill them and then brand them as you mentioned. The terrorist is GOVT. OF INDIA

Re: Khalistan How?

....... · 11 Apr 2005

its no simple task to get a country up and running. one only needs to look to the situation in Afghanistan and Iraq. Most people in Iraq are now saying that they were a lot better off under the dictatorship of Saddam Hussein.

Re: Khalistan How?

khalsa · 11 Apr 2005

GURU GOBIND SINGH JI SAID THAT EVERY RELIGION NEEDS IT'S OWN SOVERIGN, SELF - DETERMINED, INDEPENTED RULE. RELIGIONS WITHOUT SELF RULE VANISH AWAY. '' RAJJ BINNA NAHIN DHRAM JALE HAIN DHARAM BINNA SABH DALE MALE HAIN '' SIKHS NEED THEIR OWN SELF - DERTERMINED, SOVERIEGN GOVERMENT TO SURVIVE, KHALSA RAJJ ( KHALISTAN ) MUST BE ESTABLISHED FOR SURVIVAL, EVERY ONE NEEDS THEIR OWN HOME !!!!!!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: Khalistan How?

JEEVAN SINGH · 11 Apr 2005

constitution of india states sikhs are long haired hindus ! thousands of sikhs killed by indian government all over india ! golden temple and 47 other gurudwaras attaked in 1984 ! circulars sent to DC's in india saying " The sikhs are a lawless people and a menace to the law abiding hindus...... the government should take strict measures against them ! when sikhs get married in india their marriage has to be registered under hindu marriage act ! sikhs have no self-determination ! PANJAB has no power over its waters, all power at center delhi ! no power over electricty, all power at delhi ! Capital city of panjab chandigarh taken away ! panjabi speaking areas taken away ! SGPC has no authority to hold elections with out consent of indian government ! and so many other issues have rose since 1947, sikhs were much happier and safier when they had a self-determined INDEPENDENT khalsa rajj ! HOW CAN SIKHS BE INDEPENDENT IN INDIA WHEN THE CONSTITUTION FAILS TO RECOGNISE THEM HAS A SEPERATE RELGION ? [%sig%]

Re: Khalistan How?

jinder · 12 Apr 2005

i cannot see a khalistan coming soon. the number of amritdharis are few thousand. most sikh women prefer men with cut hair, negating their duty of at least keeping kes. if kes cutting is encouraged then where will sikhi fall in place? it is bad if most bearers do not even want the basics. because the religion does need them. most sikhs do not support khalistan, if they did they would not be waiting for 2008 or another future forecast. go there and see for yourselves what is happening. drugs, booze, abortion centres, biharis marrying punjabi women, clubs, you name it. It is things like this sikhs do not want to do anything about, but rabbit on about sants dheras and groups. There are many rich sikh groups in the world. 17 million pounds can be raised for one gurdwara, 3 million in another, 1 million in scotland, 10 million proposed with money there. This is just in one country with numerous more sikh groups with millions but at the very least 31 million would have been sitting there from england alone, if sikhs used their brains and just refurbished gurdwaras instead of making them look like taj mahal which does nothing for sikhi practically. 30 million quid could have been spent in drug centres, education in punjab, many panthic projects. this is the face of sikh politics, money goes to the wrong place.

Re: Khalistan How?

whatever · 12 Apr 2005

Right on Brother - at last some one is talking sense. Punjabi folk are more interested in: Booze Cutting their hair Music Going abroad Drugs Singh Sabha Southall could have spent the millions raised on programs on the youth of today. But then again their are so many factions and all claiming their path to be the correct one.....no wonder the youth is no interested............! Welcome to Kalyug guys/girls

Re: Khalistan How?

Bhopinder singh · 12 Apr 2005

whatever Good distraction ,But still Khalistan is equally important .

Re: Khalistan How?

5 rivers valey · 12 Apr 2005

if sikh organisations around the world outside india got together and put their money down into one place i think it would easily top 150 million in just one point. thats not even including families yet. 150 million can do a lot when converted into rupees. it is the right for every hard working dutiful sikh on the planet who puts their daswand down every week to have the say how that daswand gets spent. Our parents work in factories 10 11 hours a day and give daswand for the cause of the panth for a big part of their lives . What cause lies in making a marble building? the committee decides what they want they should hold refurendum and ask the whole sangat what their wish is whether that should be invested into the future? their childrens welfare? the communities welfare and keeping maintenance costs of gurdwaras realistic low. One of the key reasons why world sikh organisations would not pit their resources together is their multiple maryadas conflicting unless they are at survival point. sikhs need progressive action to help the community where it is falling for its welfare and healthy upkeep. Sikhs have to learn to tolerate each other in many respects.

Re: Khalistan How?

kunjarwood murdabad · 25 Apr 2005

if khalstan meant to be then its meant to be. I have reservations about kashmir though being heavily polarised by force by pakistani immigrants after 1947 driving out kashmiri buddhists towards ladakh and sikhs kashmiris and hindu kashmiris into south kashmir jammu. So if kashmir ever gained independance it would be at the cost of ladakh which borders to china going to buddhist kashmiris and jammu going to kashmiri sikhs and hindu. To stop a repeat of that happening in punjab sikhs should halt moving abroad and try to get sikhs from outside punjab in south india to resettle into punjab.

Re: Khalistan How?

Singh · 25 Apr 2005

GurFateh to all of you. Khalistan must come. Gubroo Jawan u said that in India all the top positions are handled by Sikhs but did u ever think what r they doing for the sikh community. Did You forget what happened to Sikhs in the last 20-25 years. Did you forget 1984’s operation blue star? And the time after it. There are about lakhs of youth who are either killed or are in prison. What did our so-called sikh leaders did for them? Did anybody feel the pain to release them. No man nobody, I will say they are not Sikhs, they r like puppets in the hands of Hindu leaders. So I will say that Khaistan must come. We just need a leader like Sant Jarnail Singh who can lead us to achieve our goal as we cannot revert back the past but we should make sure that it does not happen in the future. [%sig%]

Re: Khalistan How?

rumpy · 26 Apr 2005

jammu should rightly be adjoined onto punjab considering that kashmiri sikhs were forced to leave, wealthy bussinesses, property, machinery, land, wealth, behind in kashmir by force and resettle in jammu. eventhough i respect bhai sahib jarnail singh i do not think sikhs are ever in a position where they can ever afford to sit and hope for leaders.

Re: Khalistan How?

TUF · 26 Apr 2005

Do you know how we can get Khalistan? By preaching about Sikhi, and converting other indians, hindoos, muslims, chrisitians, jains, etc., to the Sikh way... not by force but by love. Once we've got a substantial population, then we annex and take half of India as well. Why are Christianity and Islam the two biggest religions today??? Because they convert... they're preaching religions... in the past they used force to get the job done, and now, in modern times, they preach and convert, and they preach to those they know they can convert... the poor and desolate... and they increase their population, and as you know, theres power in numbers. If we want Khalistan, we must adopt this approach... and I think its a lot easier to believe in Sikhi then to believe in some carpenter that lived 2000 years ago.

Re: Khalistan How?

Putt Sehmi da · 26 Apr 2005

whats wrong with carpenters?

Re: Khalistan How?

TUF · 26 Apr 2005

Nothing wrong with carpenters, although I, personally, think that there is something wrong in taking a carpenter who lived 2000 years ago, who may or may not have even existed, and believing that he is the son of god, and we must except him into our lives if we want to avoid hell... there is definitely something wrong in that.

Re: Khalistan How?

? · 26 Apr 2005

thats all sweet but what if other indians are not interested in religion at all just like a lot of our children are not?

Re: Khalistan How?

TUF · 26 Apr 2005

Something I've noticed is that the poorer people are, and the more suffering they endure, the closer to religion they become. Here in the west, everybody is rich and everyone thinks that they're so smart so religion has taken a backseat in most families, unfortunately. In India, all those poor peasants in states outside of Punjab have no hope so all they can do is turn to fate. Its like the atheist who suddenly gets terminal cancer or some other fatal disease... the first thing he does is starts to pray. I think Sikhism should start a movement to become a missionary religion... that is the only way to recruit more members and aspire to a dream like Khalistan... the way things are going in India, there are more chrisitans now than Sikhs... why, becuz all the poor are converting and they multiply quickly. I'm not saying that this is necessarily the right path to take, but I think that it is the only logical path if Khalistan is ever going to exist.... we're not Jews, no great superpower is gonna step in and give us our own land (like Israel)... Nobody cares about our Quam but ourselves... we've got to start thinking and doing... Khalistan Zindabad!!!!!

Re: Khalistan How?

. · 26 Apr 2005

we have to stop sikh girls converting to islam and make them honour the sikh identity by marrying a person in sikhi roop first.

Re: Khalistan How?

gulzar ghalib · 26 Apr 2005

islam would be the most likely candidate to establish rule on india in about another 100 years. bordered to the west pakistan, east bangladesh, north east china border jhiang jhang muslim province, with a staggering 20% muslim population in india already. The poor and dessolate hindus are meat eaters, and require practical hands on gain to establish power. in sikh religion meat eating makes one non sikh and sikh prayers are to help one break their 5 vices and achieve detachment from material objects and material plane. Islam allows the poor to carry on their meat eating and seeking to establish rule as soon as their are sufficient number of muslims.

Re: Khalistan How?

Lion in the West · 27 Apr 2005

Wahe Guru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahe Guru Ji Ki Fateh I have been reading through this stream and I think that there are issues that must be dealt with, within Sikhi and the way in which Sikhs get along with eachother. Why is it that we never work together or support a Sikh who is genuinely doing good for the Panth and Sikhi in general? Other religious groups support eachother in everyway possible... To start one thing that must happen as we figure out a way to achieve Khalistan, is for Sikhs to actually support one another and have a common idea of what it means to be a Sikh. Another thing is the culture of fear has to disappear, the events since Indian Liberation to present have made Sikhs in India fearful of expressing the ideas of Khalistan and Sikh independence... This is so much easier in this day in age, because Sikhs do have a stronger presence in the 'developed' world. The Indian government and the Hindu majority would not dare try to do what they did in the 40's, 70's, 80's, the world would never stand for it. Sikhs the world over have the political and economic strength to do something. If all us pardesi Sikhs and those in Punjab, actually did something to help our brothers and sisters in Punjab, for example, setting up organizations to actually help Sikhs in Punjab receive a modern education and one in Sikhi, they could actually make a living and support his/her family and Sikhi. It is so disheartening to see what we had with Sant Jarnail Singh was lost so quickly... Where is the Sikh spirit? What happened to the courage/pride/discipline of Sikhs? This dialogue will continue, I want to see some feedback Khalsa Fateh!