Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

AKJ rehat - position on leather, photographic film, etc?

AKJ rehat - position on leather, photographic film, etc?

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 25 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fateh Some vegetarians use a limited amount of animal-based products in their life - such as leather athletic shoes or photographic film. I can understand why - these products are not consumed in the amount or frequency that one would consume food, the products do not go in to the body, and they are very difficult products to substitute. (example: film used for X-Rays). But many of these products would be offensive to vegans, who are more selective. I know the rehat is not as strict as vegan for diet - but what about non-food animal products? Not having a dig...just curious!

Re: AKJ rehat - position on leather, photographic film, etc?

AnotherSingh · 26 Feb 2005

Their fine. I think it depends upon the product and the way it's manufactured. For example, dairy is fine. Also, goatskin for tablas are fine - this is mentioned in Bhai Gurdass Ji's Vaars. Although, if the animal must endure cruelty to create that product than maybe it's not allowed. It's one of those situations where you must use your judgement.

Re: AKJ rehat - position on leather, photographic film, etc?

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 26 Feb 2005

Thank you very much, veer ji!

Re: AKJ rehat - position on leather, photographic film, etc?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 26 Feb 2005

i read somewhere that baby shampoos and such products are manufactured by torturing thousands of live rabbits to death..their eys are kept forcefully open and shampoo drips into the red bloddy eyes to make shampoos that dont sting eyes....and dont for a moment think this is in "modern industrialised" contries only.. I also read about how Gujjars in INDIA use thick Danddeh on the INTERNAL organs of cows to bash out every single drop of milk from their cows.. and just this morning I also read how "milk" made from Caustic soda+some chemicals is widely sold in Punjab...Khoya/Barfi/etc made from this "wholesome chemical milk" is sold all over Punjab..what people wont do for some quick MAYA ?? IMHO..BE ON GUARD....always and use your Guru Given Bibek Budhi... Jarnail Singh

Re: AKJ rehat - position on leather, photographic film, etc?

etka · 26 Feb 2005

according 2 the no cruelty logic, meat is aiight then 2? am i wasiting my time by trying to give up meat? its b'n 3 days

Re: AKJ rehat - position on leather, photographic film, etc?

Jugroop Singh · 27 Feb 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Veer/Bhain 'etka' ji, By giving up the NEEDLESS slaughter of animals for the pleasures of taste, you are getting closer to your Beloved Siree Guru - don't let anyone convince you otherwise. But remember, it is the means and not the end...just like Kesh, Nitnem, Amrit etc. are the means and not the end. Always stay hungry for VahiGuru then all these practices/Asools will be useful...otherwise they will be rituals and actually keep you away from VahiGuru throught the pride they generate within you. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: AKJ rehat - position on leather, photographic film, etc?

Rashminder Singh · 27 Feb 2005

thats Y i buy shampoos and soaps that says "not tested on animals" i always had this question in my mind about using leather wallets, shoes & Belts I am still not satisfied why is it allowed in sikhi??????????? Waheguru

Re: AKJ rehat - position on leather, photographic film, etc?

Jagga Jatt · 27 Feb 2005

I think we Have 100% Freedom to do whatever we want to do ..........Guru Ji Gives that freedom & says "Jo Mai Kiya , so mai Paya"..... if u you eat meat it will effect ur Health......."Baba hor Khana Khusi Kwaar jit Khade Tan Peeriye man mae Challe Vikaar"......same way for our dress " Baba hor pana Khusi kwaar jit paiede Tan Peereya man mai challe vikaar"

Re: AKJ rehat - position on leather, photographic film, etc?

Anon Singh · 27 Feb 2005

No. I think we do not eat meat for a different reason. There is nothing wrong with leather. Everything in Sikhi is to improve Avastha.

Re: AKJ rehat - position on leather, photographic film, etc?

heyheyhey · 28 Feb 2005

arent table made out of animal skin and so are the nagaras why do we use them

Re: AKJ rehat - position on leather, photographic film, etc?

Rain drop · 03 Mar 2005

Though, vegetarians are not neceesarilly more kind hearted or humble than non vegs, Non vegetarians do carry with them killed animals in their stomach, throghout their life and even after that. Cruelity is to be avoided, not the meat. Touching or using skins of dead animals is no way cruelity.

Re: AKJ rehat - position on leather, photographic film, etc?

etka · 03 Mar 2005

u pay for the animal 2 die, animals death is murder