Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

PANTHIK ETKA

PANTHIK ETKA

etka · 24 Feb 2005

I make this post to see what every Sikhs view on this site are about etka between all panthik jathabandais, more so between DDT and AKJ. Both AKJ and DDT are highly panthik, both only want chardikalaa of Khalsa panth and Sahib Siri Guru Granth Sahib ji, so my suggestion is that personal choices such as (dare i say it) ragmalla should be kep personal, and stop holding akj smagams or taksaali smagams but just smagams, where both go and enjoy 2gether. Panthik etka is important..if this carry's on, i fear that the sikh panth is gonna divide into to seperate religions. I would rather die then see that. Focus on your similarties which faaaarrrrr outway ur differences. Differences are very limited, but similarties are infinite. Please look back to the 80s and see how they fought together as one, and not as 2. See the love for each toher they had....... see how sant ji spread love for khalsa panth and not taksaal, see how bhai sukhdev singh ji fought for khalistan and not akjstan. thats all i want to put forth..... forgive me, i will post same on gursikhijeevan, my heart breaks when i see singhs/kaurs fight between each toher..i beg u from a nonsikh to sikhs plzzzzzzzz.

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

kaur · 25 Feb 2005

waheguroo - very nicely put - thanks

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

ANSWER · 25 Feb 2005

Waheguru So true.

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

khalsa · 25 Feb 2005

if you belive in your heart that raag maala isnt bani, how can you go about and keep your views on raag maala to yourself? Its disrespect to Guru Granth Sahib jee. Panthic Etka is only gonna happen if we have common rehit, and get rid of kaachee bani.

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

sanatan santra · 25 Feb 2005

khalsa that kind of attitude is wrong. During panthic morcha, baba ji, bhai fauja singh jis time singhs accepted each others differences because they had abigger things to deal with apostacy, sarkaria. Now after trying their best, these problems have got worse, so fighting over rag mala just screws things more for unity. We can have unity by agreeing to disagree. The problem is pro or anti will keep bringing this up and the time is not right because it wont be settled with a majic wand and apostacy will suddenly decrease or sarkaria will get off our cases. Then people like niddar and other sanatan forces take advantage of this to divide us up even more take a look at their site they are playing one jatha against another. Why should we be stupid and give in to that? Apart from being rehit oriented we must learn to become strategic with a lambi akh. Someone else can also accuse you of disrespecting their own way whether you are pro or anti rag mala it works both ways, pro will say disrespect for this is the ang of Maharaj, anti will say its taken from porn book. Disrespect is a never ending circle where do you want it to go? How many singhs will be left at this rate? Time we have to understand we are not doing the panth any favours fighting over this. It is unsettled when great people were around, it remained unsettled when the panth was put into jang. So we can only but carry on and hope.

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

Kulbir Singh · 25 Feb 2005

What you have written “Ekta” jee is very nice and good. I wish it was practical too. Ekta that is not based on Gurmat principles never survives for long time. Unity must be principled i.e. Sidhantak Ekta. There are not many serious divisions in Sikh Panth. Raagmala is probably the most serious one. Keski is not that big because I know most Gursikhs even if they don’t call it a Kakaar still advocate the wearing of it. Punj Baniyaan Vs Three baniyaan is not a big issue as most Sikhs recite 5 baaniyaan and I think Siri Akal Takhat Sahib will soon accept 5 baaniyan as opposed to 3 baaniyaan. Coming back to the issue of Raagmala, this issue is a very sensitive issue and it cannot be shelved for the sake of some short-term ekta. This issue was not a big issue before but with the emergence of Taksal in the late seventies, this issue became a big issue. It divided our militants very badly and so bad was the situation at that time that even the Jathedar of Akhand Kirtani Jatha – Bhai Raam Singh – was threatened by pro-Raagmala militants. Only after a statement from Babbar Khalsa they backed down. This is from late eighties. If we bury this issue now, it will come back to haunt us later on. Let us do a favour to our future generations and resolve this issue now. The only way to resolve this is through discussion with open mind. No other way. It must be discussed with open mind by all parties involved. Pro-Raagmala gursikhs have some very valid points that should be addressed and in the same way anti-Raagmala gursikhs have good points that should be pondered upon by pro-Raagmala veers. One important thing is that we realise that whether Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee or Sant Sundar Singh or Sant Gurbachan Singh Bhindranwalay or Sant Ishar Singh Rarewalay; they all were great gursikhs but were capable of making a mistake. Only Guru Sahib and Vaheguru are free from errors. If we stick to the Raagmala issue on the basis of Sants or Gursikhs of past and what they believed in, we will never be able to resolve anything. The proof of ekta is not that we not talk about Raagmala. The proof of ekta is that we not get upset hearing the opposing view. To start calling names to gursikhs who present an opposing view is very childish and this is not what ekta means. Ekta means to maintain pyaar and Sad-Bhaavna despite differences. If we would start getting offended because someone calls Kesh a Kakaar, then who is more stupid than us? Same way, if we preach Keski as Kakaar and don’t believe in Raagmala and meat, other gursikhs should be tolerant of this. We all do parchaar of Gurmat we understand. To get upset because of this is really childish and no recipe for ekta. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

sanatan santra · 25 Feb 2005

another thing no matter how high this rag mala issue is taken be that to akhal takhat it still wont be settled. Look at meat, keski, tables chairs. Hardly anyone cares. people follow what they believe. What happens then people will not obey what akhal takhat says. that mocks the instituition even more. We have to really rethink what we are trying to do and how we are going about it. If the sants of DDT say its bani DDT will never back down no matter what happens in sikh politics. IF akj says its not bani akj will never back down. So what will we gain? nothing. panthic unity can happen, but we should not drag issues like this into it cos it does come down to pyar to. Most of the time when i see youth argueing over rag mala frankly i am disgusted, just 15 years ago my beautiful singhs were tortured for their simplicity of trying to follow sikhi. We do no panthic service by causing divisions on this.

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

kaur · 25 Feb 2005

Kulbir Singh Jee - u say we should not simply mention the views of great passed Gursikhs, such as Baba Gurbachan Singh, Bhai Randhir Singh or Baba Ishar Singh on deciding the RaagMala issue. Yet on the hand, you advocate that we take a Gurmat approach to resolve the disagreements on RaagMala. This seems like a paradox. If great Gurmukhs of the past, with such high avasthaas could not come to a resolution, how do you expect the Singhs of today, who in no way have as much high avasthaa or pyaar for Guriskhi as the past - how can they resolve the issue. you also mention that we should approach things with an open mind and not prejudge. But you also mention that both sides of RaagMala have good points. If this is the case, most ppl have made up their mind - do u honestly think that you could ever change your mind? seriously, most ppl are entrenched and neva gonna change. instead up bringing up this divisive issue, we should just concentrate on the things we agree on, and keep up on trying to implement the rest of Gurbani in our lives (whether it includes RaagMala or not). For example, the Panth has been mourning the loss of one its great philosophers and lecturers, Maskeen Jee. His understanding and veechar of Gurbani was so high and great, that very few can emulate it. Yet he always said he knew nothing. Why don't we concentrate on the rest of Gurbani, like Maskeen did, and implement it in our lives. It is Gurbani veechar, not debates over Raagmala, which will give us our Adhaar. bhul chuk maaf waheguru

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

etka · 25 Feb 2005

kaur panji is a genius! The only way 2 go about it is keep it personal, and thats that. There need not be ne more discussion about it, just as akaal takht has commanded yet ppl discuss to their will, disobying akaals hukumn. we will in the near future see khalistan....but i don't know if we will see a peacefull khalistan?

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

Kulbir Singh · 25 Feb 2005

------------ If great Gurmukhs of the past, with such high avasthaas could not come to a resolution, how do you expect the Singhs of today, who in no way have as much high avasthaa or pyaar for Guriskhi as the past - how can they resolve the issue. ------------ As far as I know, gursikhs mentioned above never sat down to resolve this issue of Raagmala. Panth has never had a debate on this issue (in the 20th century) and I think it is now time that Panth organise a debate, a positive debate, on Raagmala and resolve this issue for once and for all. What other way do we have? We can’t leave this issue lingering till the next generation. ------------ you also mention that we should approach things with an open mind and not prejudge. But you also mention that both sides of RaagMala have good points. If this is the case, most ppl have made up their mind - do u honestly think that you could ever change your mind? seriously, most ppl are entrenched and neva gonna change. ------------ I am just one example of a person who was changed with vichaar. I was a staunch Raagmalist and changed to Mundavanist through vichaar. I know many other Singhs who changed through vichaar. Guru Sahib instructs us to “Gurmukh baitho Safa vichhaai”. How can it be wrong to do vichaar in an atmosphere of love and mutual respect? -------------- instead up bringing up this divisive issue, we should just concentrate on the things we agree on, and keep up on trying to implement the rest of Gurbani in our lives (whether it includes RaagMala or not). For example, the Panth has been mourning the loss of one its great philosophers and lecturers, Maskeen Jee. His understanding and veechar of Gurbani was so high and great, that very few can emulate it. Yet he always said he knew nothing. Why don't we concentrate on the rest of Gurbani, like Maskeen did, and implement it in our lives. It is Gurbani veechar, not debates over Raagmala, which will give us our Adhaar. --------------- Most of the times we do not discuss Raagmala. Out of 30,000 posts on this forum, how many are related to Raagmala? Not more than 300. This is only one percent. Less than one percent of total posts on this forum have been on Raagmala. This forum by the kirpa of Guru Sahib has tried to give out as much Gurmat literature as possible. You sound as if the only thing that is discussed on this forum is Raagmala. Having said that, it is not against Gurmat to discuss issue as important as Raagmala. If we don’t talk about Raagmala, then we do disservice to Panth because this way something we don’t believe to be Baani is going to stay in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Pro-Raagmala veers can conveniently say that we should not talk about this issue because they have nothing to lose. Raagmala is in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee at present time and many people read it out of ignorance. For them the best thing is to just not talk about Raagmala. We on the other hand have to talk about it in order to acquaint people about the reality of Raagmala. How come these pro-Raagmala veers were clamouring when Nanakshahi calendar was implemented? From the way people are trying to shut the voice of gursikhs opposing Raagmala, with good intentions, reminds me of an Urdu Shayer: Yeh Dastoor-e-Zubaan-bandi kaisa hai teri mehfil mein|| Yahaan tau baat karnay ko tarastee hai zubaan meri|| As soon as gursikhs say the truth, people who can’t answer questions and people who can conveniently say that we should not talk about Raagmala since it is already in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee, start clamouring at the top of their voice and raise issues like Panthak Ekta and harmony etc. What happened to ekta and Panthik harmony when Nanakshahi Calendar was implemented? Why were these segments who are now asking anti-Raagmala Sikhs to shut down, screaming and raising hue and cry over Nanakshahi Calendar? What happened to Ekta and Panthik harmony when SGPC had decided on Mangals and all Sants Mahapurakhs assembled against Panth to oppose the decision on Mangals? Tumaara khoon Khoon, Hamara khoon paani? I think we should be tolerant to opposing views and not get upset when we hear them. I don’t believe in Raagmala but if a person wants to believe in it and presents facts, I still would not lose Gursikhi love for that person. Lots of gursikhs I know and do sangat with read Raagmala. They respect my view and I respect their view on it? Let us be tolerant with each other’s views. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

Rashminder Singh · 25 Feb 2005

I agree with bhai sahib kulbir singh ji................ we all need to solve this problem.... i agree with him completely and even bhai maskeen ji was so intelligent and would have done lot of research on Raagmaalaa, He was strictly against considering raagmaalaa as a gurbaani.......

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

Akali Fauj · 25 Feb 2005

If both followed Akal Takht maryada, there would be no problem. I say if Nihungs, AKJ, and Taksal fix, up. Panth will be in chardi kala once again. Get away from egos and jathebandis. Join under Akal Takht Sahib. Call sarbat Khalsa, discuss and solve the issues, once for all. Or use Bhai Mani Singh method. Do whatever, but join the Panth. There is not one Panth anymore. There are many, AKJs, Taksalis, Nihungs, SGPCs, Nananksarias, etc. etc. This is totally wrong.

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

. · 26 Feb 2005

Maskeen ji did not beleive in RagMala(i)?

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

etka · 26 Feb 2005

agree with akali fauj singh/kaur. i'm not a person of 2 much gyan, but i remember hearing a story of the times of baba banda bahadur singh ji, and another greatt baba ji, both had a following, the bandai sikh, and taat khalsa or sommin, both knew that it wuz wrong to have 2 sikhs, so they setteled the dispute in the pawithar hazoori of sahib siri harminder sahib maharaaj and dhun guru granth sahib ji maharaaaj, and guru khalsa ji. It is imporant that the sikhs of 2day, b4 the struggle for khalistan starts make such a conclusion, cause otherwise we're just gonna have loss of brave singhs in the madaan.

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

Rashminder Singh · 26 Feb 2005

no he didnt............ bhai maskeen ji never ever respected raagmaalaa as gurbaani

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

> · 26 Feb 2005

>bhai maskeen ji never ever respected raagmaalaa as gurbaani< That is because he was Sikh Missionary.

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 02 Mar 2005

The issue of Panthic Ekta is really far bigger than what writers here are talking about.IT CERTAINLY DOES NOT REVOLVE AROUND THE AKJ OT DAMDAMI TAKSAAL-though both of them can do something about working towards the panthic ekta. Panthic ekta also does not revolve around the issues of AKJ or Damdami taksaal or any one of the other so called "original" Sikh organisations. It revolves around the independance and sanctity of the Akal Takhat sahib. It revolves around a matured mentality of the Sikh Psyche.Which is very seriously absent among to days Sikhs, no matter how gursikh and how close to an organisation they are or claim,it does not revolve around mere naam jaap and forget the rest of the world and issues attitude.

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

...... · 02 Mar 2005

put it this way if the issue was solved at akhal takt level a) resolution says it is against bani - other groups will not agree just like keski issue stands today akhal takt says it is kes. b) resolution says it is bani - akj will not change its mind just like it stands over keski and laridar saroop issue. so what is the real point in going over rag mala everyday like a ritual? sikho dont live in a dream world. The numbers in punjab are dieing out, sikh politics will soon fully be controlled by india if it has not fully got there yet. we argue over this topic and akj v taksal slag matches every other opportunity. Times are changing each decade sikhs are weaker than they were. One side can say it is not bani other say it is, what is the end result in all these years worth of debate? what have we got out of it?

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

Sohangani · 03 Mar 2005

At the end of the day, it's the Jathay that make these debates so deep rooted. It's when groups of Khalsa argue with other groups. It's their associations that strengthen them. Singhs/Kaurs who don't have affiliations with Jathay weigh out the facts presented and judged based on them. Anyway, you push for what you believe, I'll push for what I believe and we'll meet in the middle. But ofcourse, that only works if both of us haven't fallen on the way there. [%sig%]

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

Admin · 03 Mar 2005

This thread is now closed. Sohangni, We have taken your suggestions into account and will discuss them within our admin team. Admin.

Re: PANTHIK ETKA

Jagjit Singh · 03 Mar 2005

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, a Gursikh does Ekta on many levels. One is Panthik level, another is personal and spiritual level. In my years, I have seen many speak of doing Ekta, and it happens and we achieve alot. Then something happens and we fall apart again. Then we start again in a cyclic mode. Everyone sincerely knows it is important. We are called a brotherhood of the khalsa, but we all know deep down inside how brotherly we can be. Recently I was thinking how important sehaj is. Without we can never achieve any spirituality. We do Ekta, and we talk about it. But first we must do Ekta is our minds with our Guru ji. What good is worldly ekta, if when we do our nitnem, we cannot do ekta with our Shabad Guru. Our minds wonders so much. If we cannot do a sincere Ekta with our Guru Ji, then how are we ever going to achieve any Ekta on any other level. It all starts here. With this ekta we attain sehaj. With sehaj we can overcome any obstacle on a Panthik level. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh