Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

STOP GURDAS MANN

STOP GURDAS MANN

Singhstah · 21 Feb 2005

Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!! Something needs to be done just after watching gurbani on alpha today and advert advertising Gurdas Mann's so called Vaisakhi concert, how dare he first of all have a music concert on vaisakhi, secondly he isnt even a proper sikh himself, he even made a song saying throw away your religious books and underwear this is how disrespectful he is towards sikhi. He should not be allowed to do a vaisakhi concert which is also just manmat anyway he HAS TO BE STOPPED.

Re: STOP GURDAS MANN

GKD · 21 Feb 2005

gurdas mann is a retard, something needs 2 be done i agree. i'm not anti-music, i'm just anti-anti-panthik.

Re: STOP GURDAS MANN

S Singh · 21 Feb 2005

Vasaikhi is also a cultural celebration and existed before Guru Gobind Singh Ji founded the Khalsa. If gurdas mann wants to celebrate it on a cultural level then that is up to him and we have no right to stop him from making his two bob. The other things need to be addressed but why should the Sikhs of the UK do it when the Sikhs of India, the so called Sikh mini parliament (SGPC) etc are not concerned. The Jathedar of the Akal Takht could easily summon him to the Akal Takht and tell him to sort his ideas out. There was a story that in the 1980s he started thinking he was some sort of big shot until Sant Ji told him to clean up his act. This put a stop to him for a while and he shifted out of Punjab to Bombay.

Re: STOP GURDAS MANN

. · 21 Feb 2005

im not sure but i herd gurdas man has sufi inclinations from his early days. sufis bottom line is inner search i dont think they believe in books.

Re: STOP GURDAS MANN

Kulwinder Singh · 21 Feb 2005

Improve you life, and forget about Gurdas Mann or anybody else. He is not going to kidnap you to watch him playing.

Re: STOP GURDAS MANN

an opinion · 21 Feb 2005

As far as Vaisakhi goes, I think his concert has more to do with the cultural festival than anything religious. As mentioned earlier, the cultural festival predates 1699. Regarding a song saying throw away religious books, he probably also says there is no point in going to religious places etc. This is nothing new and I have no problem with this as long as he doesn't implicitly or explicitly direct his comments at my Guru. Those sentiments (throw away books, don't go to religious places etc) are old sentiments, found in both Sufism and the Bhakti movement. I think its ridiculous to ostracize Gurdas Mann for expressing his opinions/thoughts via music. When/if he starts directing negative comments at Sikhi, then its time to take issue. I don't think of him as a Sikh but as a Punjabi singer, and truth be told, he has, in the olden days, written some very powerful songs. I urge readers to listen to the lyrics of 'Punjabiye Zubane' - very beautiful and painful - showing the origins of the language, how it grew under the hand of the Gurus, with the pyar of the sangat, and how we today are disrespecting our own mother language. The only other song I can think of, off the top of my head which mentions Sikhi is "Mera des mere dildaran da...." which says we will never be able to pay the debt owed to Sri Guru Gobind Singh ji. Take Gurdas Mann for who he is - a gifted singer NOT a Sikh representative.

Re: STOP GURDAS MANN

khoji · 22 Feb 2005

pata nahin asi kiday jhagdyan vich fasay hoyay haan... jay gallan naal rabb milda fer taan .....

Re: STOP GURDAS MANN

Just Punjabi · 14 Jun 2005

Gurdas Maan is the best Punjabi Singer in the history of Punjabi Music. One will be showing his/her narrow - mindedness by limiting Visakhi only, to Sikhs. Do not try to limit it only upto to Sikhs. At least try to say Punjabis !!! because then again, you sikhs will divide yourself among Jatt Sikhs, Arora Sikhs, Mazhbi Sikhs etc. etc. Proud to be Punjabi Ramesh Kumar Gupta

Re: STOP GURDAS MANN

.... · 14 Jun 2005

basakhi is celebrated as a religious event by sikhs and cultural event by north asians but more so punjabis to celebrate harvest season. . [%sig%]

Re: STOP GURDAS MANN

M · 14 Jun 2005

an interesting fact about Gurdas Mann is that he went to school with Sant Mann Singh Bheve.

Re: STOP GURDAS MANN

Kaptain Kabaddi · 15 Jun 2005

Vaisakhi is also a Jatt festival. people like Gurdas mann are keeping the panjabi boli alive, if nothing else.

Re: STOP GURDAS MANN

shan e punjab · 16 Jun 2005

well if he wants to say take away your religious books and underwear on vasakhi, that is a direct piss take on the khalsa panth sajjanah the day 5 kakaars were gifted to the khalsa panth. most of us are born from jatt homes , most jatts are sikhs so doing our beyadbhi like that deserves to be condemned. If such issues conflict with sikhi obviously we as sikhs condemn the person whether jatt or not. if such people wish to hold vasakhi festivals they should clearly only be cultural with absolutly no religious side attached to it such as even a phoito of the Gurus. It is time we seperated punjabi culture and or sufi lines where it directly crosses the lines against sikhi.

Re: STOP GURDAS MANN

Kabaddi Singh · 16 Jun 2005

Lets not look at the small issues in life and look at the greater picture...... Gurdas mann needs to be kept on ourside as he has also pulled out some good religous songs for the young out of touch community.... Don't be like little children looking for a reason to fight but use what we already have to extend our love for the Punjabi culture and Sikh faith... Rejoice my borthers and be happy that the Indian government did not kick our ass in 1984 to the extent that we were wiped out completely.