Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Previous dicussion regarding the Darbar Sahib

Previous dicussion regarding the Darbar Sahib

UK KAUR · 21 Feb 2005

I would just like to clear a few things, after reading this previous heated discussion. althought I am not sure whether it is still continuing, i would like to put my views across. firstly, i do not think that we, humans are in the position to say who does right, and who does wrong, that is decided by GOD. Nor should we slander others for what they do, we should see everyone as God's people. Furthermore, i would just like to say to the people that slandered bhai sahib bhai Mohinder singh ji, that you should consider feelings that people have towards him. I for one was deeply hurt by the slandering, which is why i decided to post this message. If you have any questions regarding the reconstruction, then i suggest you go and see them and ASK them personally, i'm sure that they will be more than happy to answer your questions. Bhai Sahib ji does not order ANYONE to 'touch his feet', or enjoy it! he simply fulfills one's wish to do so. he is a great living mahpurakh which is why people bow to him and pay their respect. I dont feel whoever posted that message about seeing him at that 'business thingy' should question people's action, that is God's role, not yours! Well that is all i had to say, i hope i haven't offended anyone, thank your for reading my message. Whihaguru ji ka khalsa Whihaguru ji ki fateh

Re: Previous dicussion regarding the Darbar Sahib

Anon · 21 Feb 2005

Dear "UK KAUR"/"miss_lova_kuri@.." we live in a period whereby the Kaum is swamped in politics and corruption. Our own Gurdwaras are appalling run and in many ways our heritage is being destroyed. I can truly empathize with your feelings of hurt after hearing comments relating to Bhai Mohinder Singh which were perhaps not wholly positive. However you must realise that in the current state the Kaum is in often people will question everything and everyone with little regard to other people's feelings. Only Dharam Rai will pass the True Judgement but as humans we instinctively judge everything and everyone we come into contact with. This is a function of the Bibek Buddhi or discerning intellect. I am not condoning such talk on Bhai Sahib but it is important to put it into context of the time we live in and the general feelings of Sikhs. My personal opinion of Bhai Mohinder Singh is that he has good intentions as a person.

Re: Previous dicussion regarding the Darbar Sahib

blue · 21 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh I don't know who these Bhai Sahib are but I believe that as a sangat on this forum it is our DUTY not to speak badly of others if we have not met them ourselves to know who or what they are. Even if we have met them but do not like them, then we come onto this forum and do ninda, are we trying to say that our judgement of that person is correct? I'm not saying we cannot say that ''this Baba lets ppl touch his feet'', but we like to take it further and give our views abt what should happen to these ppl. I am aware that we have the fake sadhus in todays world but so did we 500 years ago. Was it not in Bakala that sikhs were faced with the problem of finding the true Guru --Guru Tegh Bahadur Jior one of the 22 fake'gurus'? If the Sikhs had turned away saying they can never be sure then where would Sikhi be? We need to stop doing ninda of every person that lets ppl touch their feet. Once at Hazoor Sahib a babaji pointed out a Chardikala Gursikh to me. I was at the top and this Gursikh was at the entrance of Sri Hazur Sahib. I did ardas in my mind that I wanted to touch this Gursikhs feet (don't ask me why) and he was walking toawrds the Nishan Sahib direction but he did a U turn and came up the stairs and stood right NEXT to me and greeted my and the babaji. It was a truly amazing experience. He kept on looking at his own feet but I was too scared to touch his feet because of what ppl would say. Then he went and I never met again while I was there. If the sangat saw me touching his feet there would probably be shock at the fact that someone had touched someones feet on the Parkarma. Baba Nand Singh Ji did not let anyone touch their feet but when this one person was dying to touch their charan, Babaji came and stood next to this child. Sometimes there is a great Gursikh right in front of us but we see in him what we believe to be a fault and then we endlessly try to put him down in everyway possible. If someone says to us that it is wrong to do ninda, we ridicule them saying that we know better. Sangat Ji I apologise as I do not know who this Bhai Sahib is and what exactly was said but that was just my views on the feet touching part. Sorry if I went off-topic in any way. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Previous dicussion regarding the Darbar Sahib

Tee · 22 Feb 2005

cnt remeber the xact story, but once bhai sahib randhir singh was standin next to a river, some people wer cumin, he fort they wer gona touch his feet so he walked into the middle of the river so nobody could touch his feet. however one perosn dived into the river still, to touch bhai sahibs feet. the fact that gursiks dnt want their feet touched shows ther humbleness they blieve they are the dust of the sangats feet, they dont want ther feet to be touched, becuase they feel they are worthless. if someone stands ther while evry one is at his feet, they rnt bein humble, they prob have ego, them bein higher than others. jus my opinion- bhul chuk maaf karna

Re: Previous dicussion regarding the Darbar Sahib

S Singh · 22 Feb 2005

To UK Kaur Why does "Bhai Sahib" not own up to the fact that the gold seva on the Darbar Sahib is a bodge up that is damaging the inner marble structure of the Darbar Sahib. I also hope that the Brummie Jatha does not make similar mistakes at Hazur Sahib. That is the only criticism of him I have ever made and it one made after listening to him deny that the seva was bodged. OK he may be civil engineer but he is no expert on conserving heritage and he did not consult any experts prior to during or after the gold seva. He should put his hands up get some experts in to evaluate the errors and then get it sorted pronto. This is not a case of laying blame we need to sort this out asap before the inner marble structure of the Darbar Sahib crumbles away (what the GOI failed to do during Bluestar we the Sikh Quam have started).

Re: Previous dicussion regarding the Darbar Sahib

jugroop singh · 22 Feb 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, This is my personal experience from about 3-4 years ago... myself and another Singh visited Soho Road Gurdwara Sahib in Birmingham, Engaland to obtain some exhibition materials. Nishkam Sewak Jatha Sevadaars had very kindly agreed to let us borrow some of their prefessional exhibition materials at very short notice. They mentioned that we'd need to talk to Bhai Sahib Bhai Mohinder Singh Ji directly though. So, we arrived and waited for a while. While we were waiting, we were taken to a smallish room which i remember being impeccably clean, perfumed and generally pleasant. We then noticed that Bhai Mohinder Singh was sitting to one side whilst Sangat came in (monae and Keshdhari), in single file, and took Parshad from his hands, while he sat cross-legged - he was the only person distributing Karah Parshad. Many people were matha-tekking to him and others were touching his feet; he was not attempting to stop or discourage them. In the very same room was a wall which had a picture of the previous Sant Ji on the wall. This was a shrine-like installation, and people were also approaching this installation and 'offering respects', mattha-tekking etc. After a while, we were ushered into a room by a Sevadaar. As we walked in, there was a Keshdhari man on his knees, with Bhai Mohinder Singh's hand in his...he seemed to be pleading with him in a deeply devoted manner. As we came in, they finished speaking and then this man left the room. i remember being convinced that this very same Keshdhari man was one of the Punj Piyare pictured in some of the exhibition materials we borrowed from them. Bhai Mohinder Singh was telling this Singh to offer Ardaas to VahiGuru; which was all he could do on his behalf anyway. The Prem that binded Bhai Mohinder Singh and this indivdual was felt even in the heart of this moorakh, very much in the days when i didn't even know much at all about Prem. After this Singh had left, Bhai Mohinder Singh explained to us that a close family-member of this Singh's was about to undergo a major operation, and hence he was very worried and had come to him for help. We then spoke about the materials we wanted - Bhai Mohinder Singh was extremely helpful and delightful to talk to. i felt comfortable in his presence but nonetheless, i had the urge to ask him a question about what i had seen earlier that day - i didn't attempt to make this question sound blunt but i imagine it probably did (knowing me!). The question was: - How do you feel when people come and mattha-tek to you or touch your feet? Don't you think you should stop them? He answered (words to the effect): - The moment I start thinking they are mattha-tekking to me I've had it; that would be my downfall. There isn't much I can do about it. We have tried to put in place measures to discourage this [i think he mentioned a plaque somewhere in the building] but they carry-on...there is not much that can be done. i remember leaving that day with the following thoughts and feelings, which remain very much the same today: - Bhai Mohinder Singh is very inspiring; he has a certain charisma and i certainly felt attracted to him, as a worm would feel atttracted to someone they perceive as a GurSikh. - That day, when a Singh was looking for his persoanl intercession regarding the wellbeing of a near and dear relative, Bhai Mohinder Singh directed him towards VahiGuru. This, i believe, was the GurMat approach that should be taken in a situation. - The practice of mattha-tekking and feet touching is a major blemish that Soho Road Gurdwara must remove. i personally did not feel that enough was being done to discourage this and that more should be done. i am not aware if anything has or hasn't been done since that day. For instance: - Bhai Mohinder Singh could refuse to distribute Parshaad if people keep trying to touch his feet/mattha tek to him. There could be a public notice to this effect within the Gurdwara Sahib. - The installation featuring the previous Sant Ji could be removed; i imagine that would be the best way to honour a GurSikh...that is what a GurSikh would want is it not? - Bhai Mohinder Singh is placing into jeapordy his Jeevan by 'risking' a possible attack of ego and pride if this feet-touching and mattha-tekking were to attack his spiritual accomplishments. i think GurBani teaches us that all it takes to completely empty the pitcher of water (pitcher=Sikh, water=Bhagti/Avastha) is a tiny hole (tiny hole=a very minor attack of lower human tendencies). Someone once told me that the previous Sant Ji, Puran Singh, would spend significant amounts of private time every day dragging his face against the floor as he prostrated to Siree Guru Sahib Ji in order to counteract the instances of people touching his feet or directing 'respect' towards him instead of Siree Guru Sahib Ji. This is just an anecdotal account. These are my limited thoughts and shared experiences - they should NOT be taken as an attack upon Bhai Mohinder Singh or Nishkam Sevak Jatha. i sincerely hope they are not taken as such. These thoughts are just personal learning points which have helped me understand the whole Sant/Guru concept and it's implications within GurBani and GurMat practise. VahiGuru. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: Previous dicussion regarding the Darbar Sahib

blue · 22 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh I can understand why people are against touching feet. But maybe there are some great souls out there who are above all this and thus don't mind ppl touching their feet as it does not effect them in any way (ie.ego). Now, can we say that Baba Nand Singh Ji is wrong for letting one devotee touch their charan even though they didn't let anyone. If we think about it, did the same thing not happen to me at Hazur Sahib, wanted to touch that Gursikhs feet so I was hoping to and that Gursikh came and stood next to me. Is that then wrong? Would I have been wrong to touch his feet? Some people touch the feet of all their elders, are they allowed? If so, then why can't they touch the feet of elders who are also Gursikhs? Is that not better than touching the feet of your gran who is not a Gursikh? Afterall it is not blood relations that should matter, yet we see nothing wrong with touching our grans feet (at least some of don't ). BTW I don't know this Bhai Sahib Ji just in case anyone thinks I'm talking about touching their feet specifically. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh