Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Voting rights to Sehajdharis

Voting rights to Sehajdharis

Kulbir Singh · 17 Jul 2003

If there is any good thing that Badal Government Badal/Tohra Akali Dal has done, it is to disallow the sehajdharis from voting in the SGPC elections. I am really surprised how the BJP government allowed such move and how they approved it. In any case this is a good news. I realize that many non-amritdharis and even the ones who cut their hair have faith in the Sikh Gurus but to prevent the Hindus from enrolling in as voters and meddling in the Sikh affairs, it was vital to disallow anyone who is not fully keshadhari to vote. I am very pleased with this move. As for the Rashtriya Sikh Sangat's condemnation of this move, I just want to mention that these keshadhari Hindus have no right to interfere in the affairs of the Sikhs. The leaders of this organization openly preach that the Sikhs are part of Hindus. Daas, Kulbir Singh Rethink move on Sehajdharis, says Sikh Sangat Our Correspondent Faridkot, July 16 The Rashtriya Sikh Sangat has expressed its deep concern over the decision of the NDA government to debar the Sehajdharis from exercising their right to vote during the general elections to the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee. Regretting the decision, Mr Sewa Singh Chawla, state unit president of the Rashtriya Sikh Sangat today said this would drive a large number of Sehajdharis to adopt other paths who strictly believe in Sikh maryada and the Guru Granth Sahib. Mr Chawla said this step would encourage anti-national forces engaged in disturbing the peace in the country, particularly in Punjab which had got respite from militancy after a long period. He said since 1925 more than 30 per cent of Sehajdharis were having the right to vote and depriving them from this opportunity at this stage may also affect bonhomie between Hindus and Sikhs. He said all 10 Sikh gurus always preached for strengthening the nation free from caste and creed barriers. The 10th Sikh Guru Gobind Singh created Khalsa by bringing five members from different castes, Mr Chawla said. He appealed to the Union Government to reconsider its decision in the interest of the country. He appealed to senior Sikh leaders and representatives of the SGPC to rethink in this regard to strengthen the ties of secularism in the state. Sehajdharis decry move on voting rights Tribune News Service Chandigarh, July 16 The Sehajdhari Sikh Federation has condemned the move of the Union Home Ministry, debarring “Sehajdharis” from exercising their right to vote during the general election of the SGPC. The president of the federation, Dr Paramjeet Singh Ranu, in a statement issued today claimed that “Sehajdharis” were an integral part of the Sikh religion and every Amritdhari Sikh before adopting baptism was a “sehajdhari.”

Re: Voting rights to Sehajdharis

jujhaar · 17 Jul 2003

well yeh gud point but i dont just think it stops at hindus. i have mentioned that only amritdharis shud be elected in committees and that only aprooved and voted in by gursikhs who lead a gursikh jeevan compared to the massive mona votebank. It wud be far more effective to even have a turnout of 300 votes in a election compared to 3000 if those 300 are dedicated with the view to having the panth sorted and that can only happen at the highst level from gurdwara downwards to the communityat large. a gurughar is not a temple or just a place of worship, its the epicentre of the community. A place that shud represent miri piri where we shud openly talk about what faces the sikhs today here and in india. A place where we shud recieve education on bani, a place that shud develop us as human beings and adapt into our society we live in without compromising our core beliefs. A place where we shud be equipped with learning and developing and providing support to the community as mentioned in my other posts. A place where we shud encourage political conciousness combined with sikh dharm from the very childhood of sikhs just like baba jarnail singh to born out selfless leaders. now im speaking from a local gurdwara election experience. each time it comes, one party and another comes, both have amritdhari members and kesdari and even monai. im not against monai my own parents r monai so was i just 1 year ago. But the way these parties operate they call in their cousins, bussiness partners, friends, on election day to vote for them as a loyalty vote . So Our gurdwara leaderships is determined by loyalty to a set of people who may or may not carry the panth fwd and majority of the time last 30 years u have witnessed a downward spiral urselves. y shud it be left open that our community leaders r voted in by cousins and bussiness partners? y shudnt amritdhari gursikhs alone have that right where it wud be 100% the panth has to push and develop and maintain maryada and work our way upwards to flourish the panth as was previously in which the panth khalsa flourished. i heard some people in previous elections accuse the other party of using hindus in their elections. now logic tells me whats the difference between a hindu voting for a party on one hand and a mona whos related to a party member? both wud generally be deemed to vote the party because they have been calld in. on the other hand there maybe hindus ( if the individual believes in sikhi more than hinduism)and monai who r still dedicated to putting the right party in power. BUT in todays world in todays situation the sikh panth cannot afford to mess up. We cant keep walking around an d offering 50 50 chances whether we screw up or succeed. we need direction, guidance, 100% or near so surety that our panth has to get sorted here and now WE CANNOT WASTE TIME OR TAKE RISKS GAMBLING OUR GURDWARAS AWAY TO SELFISH PARTIES. For that reason gursikhs with an amritdhari jeevan shud be handpicked by the panth and they shud decide who comes to power ( as they have the concious to select the party based on its commitments to serving) . The power of succession cannotbe decided by the whole community on the basis they give daswand as was previously, back the the sarbat khalsa held gurmattas , it wasthe khalsa who decide whats what with the sehejdari supporting the khalsa in thebackground as most sikhs back then were amritdhari in proportion to the sehejdari population. now its the other way round. But even the sehejdaris of today the third generation if not the indian ex pats wud agree the leaderships shud be placed in the hands of dedicated gursikhs voted in by sikhs who have the concious to select the party that will deliver to thepanth. Im not saying that because im amritdhari because im not, but i dont want a committee leaderin charge of our gurdwara who drinks on the side or tells me i shudbe proud to be a " jatt sikh" or one that spends 10 million building a new gurdwara that wudonly take 3 million tobuild. I want selfless gursikhs in charge who are going to take this universal quam and dharm to new heights from strength to strength.

Re: Voting rights to Sehajdharis

jujhaar · 17 Jul 2003

even if i was a mona i wud stick by my guns bcos i felt the same it makes logical sense that the khalsa alone shud make the choices of how our gurdwarey r run compared to the tom dick and harry who may not know jack all on maryada, how to maintain it, and carry the torch fwd or what solution to be applied to a particular problem. theres many political leaders reared up in the past but not harnessed with the vital important balance of sikh ethos and dharm with politics which is y amritdhari gursikhs elected in ONLY by respectable gursikhs shud be in the position of authority. I think a likely option abroad and in panjab, in the event of elections notifications shud be sent out to all amritdhari jathebandis and individuals who have taken amrit who believe minimum in the rehat of akhal takhat at the very least, then select a few resepcted gurmukhs from each group preferebaly in the locality of the election location as they wud be better in touch with the ground reality of the region what is needed in the place in order to select the appropriate party which shud match up with the agendas and goals it promotes to the wants and needs of the panth and functioning of gurughar in the area. Each jathebandi and amritdhari indivduals shud be represented on an equal balance in proprtion of statistics for a fair vote. The gursikhs selected for the voting procedure most likely wud have have slight variances in how they follow sikhi but their goal shud be singular on a ground basis that is to carry the panth fwd and maintain basic maryada educate the basic tenets without any controversial topics, open advice panels for the wider community and foster unity. This is y it is vital all jathas and sikhs shud be united on step one to move ahead and caste differences aside without that there can be no change without unity of goal. Having unity of Goal doesnt mean rehat has to be singular either look at the past in the 80s majority of jathas were united in their goal, when gurdwarey were liberated from mahants, when sikhs fought british and moghuls when they have to come together they do regardless of the rehet they follow. I dont see how being kesdari alone wud make me loyal to the panth and to my dharm or how that wud make me more eligable to vote than a mona. Both havent taken amrit and dont owe their allegience to the panth yet so how can they honour their commitment to the goal of the panth and its future?? we have all seen in hindi articles, news media, films, and generally may know seen kesdharis who also worship in mandirs to demigods , with tikkey on their foreheads doing arti which is against gurmat hence puts their dharm into question what r they who r they?, altough i dont condemn them its their choice freedom and love to all. but how wud u feel about such people voting in ur gurdwara? they look like sikhs but worship elsewhere, so wud their loyalty be to the guru khalsa panth? or not? shud such people be deciding the future of ur dharm leadership? being kesdhari alone doesnt mean one is a sikh. how many kesdharis do u know who drink, eat meat, believe in jaat paat, etc. I have even met a full kesdhari with uncut beard who wants to convert to islam. You want people like this voting and determining the future of the sikh leadership who are responsible for taking our dharm into the future? .So y shudnt that cap on sehejdharis be extended to even kesdharis who are not amritdhari as their very lifestyle wud not always reflect panthic requirements.

Re: Voting rights to Sehajdharis

Gabroo Khalistan Dah · 18 Jul 2003

as a mona i say that monaye should have a say (hard core joke) as a mona only khalsaye should have the rite, amritdhari nirmal pooran porosaye gursikhs should be the only ones 2 decide the actions or results of a gurdwara or ne panthetic element

Re: Voting rights to Sehajdharis

jujhaar · 18 Jul 2003

thats 2 non amritdharis with a mona background saying that only amridharis gursikhs shud have the say in our gurughars. come on amritdharis gear urselves up we need u running the scene, please help our community. we look up to u as the flowers blooming we one day aim to become, u are our role models. with you there at the top our panth can be sorted we cannot wait forever. Guru Gobind Singh vested the power in the hands of the khalsa not in omens like the hindus and jews waited for thousands of years and lost millions of their beloved people.

Re: Voting rights to Sehajdharis

sardara gill · 19 Jul 2003

u 2 may have thr right idea but until the day coms these amritdharis actually get involved in the community nothing will happen.

Re: Voting rights to Sehajdharis

Manmukh · 19 Jul 2003

I totally agree it should only be the amritdharis and the true Khalsawale who should be the decision-makers on what goes on within the Panth and the Gurdwaras and not mere muppets who regard themselves as a Bandas Banda, I want to see Sacha Guruji Ka Banda running the show. Theres a jewish saying which goes something like this "What a Christian does is their own responsibility, what one Jew does reflects upon the whole of the Jewish Community and Faith". Therefore, lets not live by the example of a Christian rather take on board and put into practice what the Jewish community has done to strenthen itself through adversity. Lets not live our lives through falsehood , rather through truthful living and acts which Dhan Guru Nanak Dev Sahibji taught from the very inception (sorry if I sound as if I am preaching). Its high time that the Panth got itself organised, rather than a disarray state it has been in for along time. There are too many indians and not too many Sikhs running the show. It upsets me deeply inside when I hear negative things that are going on in Guru Sahibjis Khalsa Panth and when hypocrites who call themselves Sikhs of the Guru, it is they who are causing more damage and disrespect than good, for example individuals such as Kala Afghana who would not have the audacity to blasphemise Desh Mesh Pita and to making derogitive statements about Amrit Sanchaar and individuals such as Narinder Grewal who have the nerve to try to place themselves higher than Dhan Guru Granth Sahibji. The Panth trully appears to be in a mess for the simple reason that there is no unity and there is more division which makes Guru Panth a laughing stock. Please forgive me if I have said anthing untoward. Another Mona

Re: Voting rights to Sehajdharis

jujhaar · 19 Jul 2003

what i have sed so far isnt out of discrimination for monas kesdaris or non amritdharis, as i was a mona and am a non amritdhari right now. The point is we r in such a bad situation we cannot afford to mess up, we have to tighten our vessels if that means capping votes on only those who are sure to sort the panth out with minimum rehat than so be it. Its not that numbers of so so dictate decisions or judging its a matter of survival, we have to push ahead with survival techniques and maintain our panth and increase it.

Re: Voting rights to Sehajdharis

._. · 20 Jul 2003

sehajdharis shud in no way be pushed away. they shud be encouraged as everyone else is with pyar gurus jot is in all so everybody is our brothers and sisters. Just because someone is a mona dont make them a bad person sometimes outer looks deceieve. However sikh history has shown the khalsa alone shud be running the show .that i guess is reality only if more amritdharis network together and mobilise for the challanges ahead. I have heard the amount of amritdharis there are now is more than b4 but it seems differenet because the proportion of non amritdharis has increased at the same time a lot more. But i think the amritdhari numbers can function well efficient if they just came togther. To give you one example akj in uk alone we have 2000 estimated members ( just for example sake) now thres 250 something gurdwaras here, now if we liased and worked with other ameritdharis if we functioned as a basic entity what is it there that is too difficult? the puratan sikhs put in time and effort. Fair enough if we dont have that we can share tasks with a larger number of sikhs. But that cannot happen until we are committed to helping the development of the sikh faith. Some say just sit there do naam naam or just take amrit everything else will sort itself out. But hey show me where in sikh history that happened? Everything our guru sahiban and puratan sikhs did was practical but was harnessed by spirituality. So yes nam and bhagti are vital pivots and they shud enhance and incorporate us to achieve to higher levels in all aspects that includes everything that has been previously discussed.No sikh worth his or her salt should sit back and just think about themselves or their indidvidual progress. We have to give a part of ourselves for a greater tomorow. If we cannot even give something back to humanity, to our faith what are we worth? We call each other brothers and sisters, so that wud make the children of your brothers and sisters as your children. what kind of a future have you or i contributed to for our children? do we realise the environment they will have to come into? the kind of problems and challanges they will face? would we like them to face it all alone? then how will they be? do you think teaching them to abstain from maya alone wud be a defence mechanism strong enough? what about the 99% more we can do? what do we need to push us? do we want a change? who will bring a change? will it come by talk or action? how can we make a start right now? YOU WILL BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE BY YOUR FUTURE GENERATIONS.

Re: Voting rights to Sehajdharis

Manmukh · 20 Jul 2003

Now all that has been said, please a bhenti to those sacha amritdharis put your hands up... especially the BIBIJI'S (we need more mai bhagos), its time to walk the talk, too much talking has been done and been going on. Lets get the wheels going, I am not an instigator rather a believer, I believe in Guru Sahibji and in his Khalsa.

Re: Voting rights to Sehajdharis

jujhaar · 21 Jul 2003

im not amritdhari but i will stand in the background supporting my amritdhari veers and panjis just like the monas supported the khalsa back in the old days, whatever needs to be done walking the walk lets us begin asap and not delay, and put this into practice here and now. bring as many amritdharis to this thread from outside to see what we can do, and non amritdharis who also can contribute like me in the background till i one day become like u. i will support wherever required as and where Guru Sahib dictates. For now i believe we shud start by forming a notification to all amritdharis and or committed people towards sikhism if we know any and or email larger e groups and bring them on here to view what we have sed causes, effects, symptons and results. From here continue and create a basic agenda and launch a bullet point letter to the Akhal Takhat Jathedar to take into consideration what we believe to be resulting from non amritdharis taking control of gurughars. To campaign successfuly for sarbat khalsa to be held in each gurdwara in election time to replace the present election system as an answer to combat the degeneration of the panth. barring non amritdharis from voting. launch an appeal for selfless gurmukhs to get more involved with politics ( without which badals and torhas keep warm in their seats) any more suggestions please? keep em rolling this is our start, lets not stop now!!

Re: Voting rights to Sehajdharis

disgusted · 26 Jul 2003

wow! only 1 or 2 people actually volunteer to come together???? Wheres the rest gone? why do we suddenly appear out of nowhere when we need to JUDGE others to show " they are not sikhs" or when we need to say things are wrong when we dont even have the balls like the real khalsa to just get up come together and face it and make changes? This shows how inneffective we are here and now. This is hypocracy! what is the diverse role of the khalsa that makes it totally different from the brahmins and maulvis who look down upon society but never contribute to it. whats happened? how do you define khalsa? SOVERIEGN if you dont want to work for sovereignty its not going to come on a plate. In future if we dont even want to unite and practically work for our goals then i suggest we should not give a speech over what is right or wrong and hang our heads in shames and not raise them if we dont even have the heart to follow it through like the puratan khalsa and go all the way. Look back to the days sikhi was the religion which spread due to the seva put in by guru ke sikh and active lifestyles led by puratan khalsey, if nobody wants to do seva today because of 9 to 5 jobs then keep letting your panth rot, your the ones who will loose out. Not even 100 sikhs can come together to rally a petition to akhal takhat over the politics of gurdwaras what a shame? No gursikh of the past would ever rest if they found out the state of our present guirdwaras, but we do. SO LETS ASK OURSELVES WHY? SARBAT KHALSA SANGAT IS MY IMAGE I WILL ALWAYS BE WITH THEM GUR BILAS PATSHAHI DAS, 56 KOER SINGH THE ETERNAL BEING THUS ADDRESSED HIS WORM I HAVE REGARDED YOU AS MY SON AND APPOINTED YOU TO ESTABLISH A PERFECT PANTH GO INTO THE WORLD ESTABLISH VIRTUE EXPEL VICE, FOR THIS SOLE REASON TO ESTABLISH VIRTUE WAS I SENT INTO THE WORLD BY THE DIVINE GURU EVERYWHERE TO ESTABLISH VIRTUE AND EXTERMINATE THE WICKED AND THE VICIOUS FOR THIS PURPOSE I HAVE GOT THE MORTAL BIRTH IBID