Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
Kulbir Singh · 17 Feb 2005
Two fairy tales about Raagmala:
Pro-Raagmalas veers themselves don’t know who wrote Raagmala. It does not contain any heading or stamp of author to prove that it is Gurbani. No baani in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is without either author’s stamp or heading like Mahalla.
The stories we hear in relation to Raagmala are such that it does not take a rocket-scientist to figure out that these are false tales. Below are two saakhis we hear about origin of Raagmala:
1) The story goes like this. When Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee Maharaj concluded Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee and even wrote the seal or stamp of Gurbani i.e. Mundawani, Guru Sahib heard someone crying outside. They found out that Raags took embodiment of humans beings and had come to Guru Sahib with a request. They humbly requested Guru Sahib to give them respect as no one had ever given them respect and they were wandering from place to place. Guru Sahib had mercy on the bewailing Raags and decided to give them respect by writing Raagmala in the end of Mundawani.
What a joke this saakhi is. Here are some points to ponder upon:
1) I don’t think Raags are living beings. Raags are simply different combinations of keys of keyboard.
2) Even if we believe that they are in fact living beings, how did they get respect by creation of Raagmala? According to Gurbani only those who do simran have respect – Prabh ko simrae, sey Patwantay. If anything, Guru Sahib would have given them Naam and not create Raagmala to give them respect.
3) Now even if we believe that with creation of Raagmala, Raags got respect, then what happened to all the Raags that did not get mentioned in Raagmala? What happened to Raag Ramkali and other such Raags that are not mentioned in Raagmala? There are only 84 Raags mentioned in Raagmala.
4) Did Raags not get respect with getting included in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee already? Most of the baani is written in Raags. They already got respected this way. What was the need for Raagmala then?
We should not believe this kind of fairy tale. Guru Sahib has made his Sikh much wiser than this.
2) Second Story goes like this. After Guru Sahib had concluded Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee and had written the seal or stamp – Mundawani – some gursikhs approached Guru Sahib with full humility and with folded hands they implored Guru Sahib to now create such “Prem Mala” through which “saadi chauraasi kattee jaavae” i.e. we may become free of cycle of birth and death. Guru Sahib got pleased with them and created Raagmala.
What a joke this story is! Here are some points to ponder upon:
1) Which Guru-fearing gursikh would dare say that Guru Sahib’s work is incomplete.
2) Is Gurbani from Ik-Oankaar to Tan Man Theevay Haria, not capable of cutting our chauraasi? How could have Sikhs dared to tell Guru Sahib that their already created baani is not capable of cutting their chauraasi and that they need another “Prem Maala” to cut their chauraasi?
3) How does Raagmala cut their chauraasi when it does not have even one updesh or hukam or content of spirituality. It is simply an index of different families of Raags. How can counting names of Raags give us Mutkee and cut our chauraasi?
I request our pro-Raagmala veers to not get upset at reading this. We need to think with open mind as to what is right and wrong. Just because some mahapurakhs believe in Raagmala does not mean that we too should start believing in it.
And to those who say that we should keep quiet for the sake of unity, I request them with folded hands that unity does not come by burying important issues. Raagmala is a very important issue for Sikhs because in the opinion of most scholars and learned gursikhs, the presence of Raagmala in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is disrespectful to Guru Sahib. For this reason, it is now time to solve this issue for once and for all.
Siri Akal Takhat Sahib should step in right now and have an open debate on this issue. An arbitration of gursikhs should sit and decide at the end of the debate whether to keep Raagmala or not keep it. We should not let this issue lingering for too long now. It must be resolved.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
Kulbir Singh · 17 Feb 2005
Premi jeeo, there is no need to skirt the issue around. The issue on hand is if the stories that they tell about the origin of Raagmala hold any truth. If you have anything to say about the actual content, please go ahead.
Let us discuss the saakhees they tell about origin of Raagmala. It would be interesting to hear from pro-Raagmala veers and bhains on this issue.
Part two will follow at a later date.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
BirRaas Singh · 17 Feb 2005
Well said kaur!!
Re: Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
Sultan Singh · 17 Feb 2005
Great post Kulbir Singh Jee.
Kaur Jee, would you accept it if the Akal Takht were to decide that Ragmala is NOT bani?
One side i.e. anti Ragmala group is using logic and facts, while anti-Ragmala group is using "A so and so Sant Jee said that Ragmala is bani, so it is bani, no facts/explainations/logic needed". Even though I am not AKJ, and in many cases do not even agree with them on certain issues, but the fact that the anti-Ragmala group use facts to support thier views and not blind faith in what a Sant says has convinced me that Ragmala is NOT bani.
The way I see it is, one group is using facts, while the pro-Ragmala group is using blind faith. For me, facts are more convincing than blind faith.
[%sig%]
Re: Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Those who support Raagmala on the basis of the Kachian be-sir pair ( without head or tail) so called tall tales listed by Kulbir Singh Ji have no qualms about doing "kirtan" of Kachi bani through so called Dharaan..so I am not surprised that there are none giving out any facts to CONTRADICT the Sakhis ( because that is the ONLY basis for Raagmaala). IF these "mahapurakhs" feel no "guilt" in equating Kachi bani/poems/dharrana/two liners etc with GURBANI KIRTAN..then its natural for them to support kachi poem raagmala.
The other "arguments" like NO Author/Mehla..and they point to Japji Sahib as having No author/Mehla..BUT they Fail to SEE that KITHHEH Japji Sahib dee Mahan GUrbani OUTLINING the Very basis of GURU GRANTH JI....and REPEATED 31 times in the GURU GRANTH.....and kithheh a hotch-potch of Raags raagnees and raags' daughters sons etc story...with NIL Gurbani value/sikhiaa of any sort.
They also FAIL to note in Sikh history that JAPJI SAHIB was already SO FAMOUS that Bhai Lehna Ji was influenced to go and meet its writer GURU NANAK JI..and then became Guru Angad Ji...Simialar historical evidence is available for GURU AMardass Ji aslo coming to Guru Angad Ji due to having heard the paath of JApji Sahib. NO SUCH historical evidence exists or supports Raagmala that it was written by any Guru Ji. The August Gurbani JAPJI SAHIB is NEEDLESSLY DRAGGED in to Bolster the NO Author/No Mehla argument against raagmala.
IT was just to "maintain a false facade of superficial unity" that the Akal Takhat made the ambigious "decision" on Raagmala long ago. Such "decisions" cannot promote UNITY and we have the result before us...it would be better for the DECISION be made one way once and for all. Some are still calling for the "postponement"...sweep under the carpet, type of "unity" which fools no one..this wound will continue to fester until cut out and disposed off....70 years is a long time to suffer.
Jarnail Singh.
Re: Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
Kulbir Singh · 17 Feb 2005
I humbly repeat my request. Will some pro-Raagmala Veer or Bhain either refute what I wrote or prove that these saakhees they use to prove the truthfulness and authenticity of Raagmala, are correct.
Instead of making remarks out of frustration like "Why beat a dead horse", "Let us not break unity" etc, let us hear some real logical arguments.
Since 1984 pro-Raagmala elements have committed many injustices on innocent Raagmala opposing Sikhs, including forcing Raagmala upon Siri Akal Takhat Sahib. What right did they have, to impose their personal opinion on Panth? If Panth had decided to read Raagmala at Siri Akal Takhat, we would have been fine but the way they forced it upon us using guns, it reminds us of Chengiz Khan and Aurangzeb.
When it comes to doing a sensible debate they start threatening with curses and using illogical and childish arguments.
Come on, let us hear some real arguments in your favour and remember this thread is more about the saakhees about origin of Raagmala.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
Bijla Singh · 18 Feb 2005
Wah, Kulbir Singha. first you make it look like raagmalias have no logical points because they follow some "sants" and then you want a respectable debate by saying "don't get upset". how is it possible? but it is very easy to start a debate on this forum since all the admins are on your side and you guys completely control this forum. why was the last debate closed? it did not turn into any personal attacks. why not open that topic and you can start by answering those questions. the biggest joke is the story that Ashok made up and other lana bana just took his words without even thinking properly.
Re: Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
Charanjeev Singh · 18 Feb 2005
Dear Kulbir Singh,
I am sure you have heard of the sakhi of Guru Nanak Sacheh Patshash bringing Bhai Lehna Jee to the Darbaar of the Satguruu. While Bhai Lehna Jee was there he noticed beings sweeping the grounds of Sacheh Patshah Guru Nanak. When he asked them who they were, he was given the reply that they were the devis where pilgrims would go and take ishnaan in the respective teeraths, and they would come to wash their sins at the Lotus Feet of Sacheh Patshah Guru Nanak.
One must understand also, that Gurbaani is not only something to be read, but to be realized and by the Grace of the Guru the unstruck sound begins to resound. When Guru Sahib gives His Grace, all knowledge is given. It is only then that one can know the truth. Please do not follow anybody else whom you believe have been given this Grace, and only conclude you know the truth once this Grace has been given to you if one be so blessed.
Guru Granth Sahib Jee is the living Guru. Guru Granth Sahib Jee is Guru Nanak. Guru Granth Sahib Jee is Guru Gobind Singh Jee.
What I find so hypocrytical of people is this. They say Guru Granth Sahib Jee is Guru Nanak, 'Sarab Kala Samrath', then they still argue about Guru Granth Sahib Jee. Remember one thing, Guru Granth Sahib Jee takes care of you, and not you take care of Guru Granth Sahib Jee.
When reading many posts, one cannot miss the 'Abhimaan'. I have no doubt that veers like yourself have attained Guru Sahibs blessings and you have seen many unseeable things, however only Guru Sahib is Perfect. Only Guru Sahib knows all.
'Eh man chanchalla Chautarii Keheh na Payah'
We have so much chautraiah. By the Grace of Guru Sahib, he blesses us with many many ridhs sidhs and nidhs, and all of a sudden we think we know so much. We know NOTHING. Bhul Chuk Mauf
Waheguruu Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguruu Ji Ki Fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
Kulbir Singh · 18 Feb 2005
Could I have some answers Pro-Raagmala Veers please?
Re: Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
Kulbir Singh · 18 Feb 2005
I heard these saakhis in Faridkoti Teeka, Sant Kirpal Singh teeka of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee, in katha of different pro-Raagmala Sikhs.
No pro-Raagmala can ever say that these Saakhis are not true because the Mahapurakhs they believe in have narrated these saakhis with great passion. What they can do is one of the two options - stay silent or try to refute them. I think they will go with the former position.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 18 Feb 2005
Dear M Singh ji,
<
Re: Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
Sultan Singh · 18 Feb 2005
hello admin,
I seemed to have made a mistake in one of my posts on this thread. The mistake is from the following sentence I wrote:
"One side i.e. anti Ragmala group is using logic and facts, while anti-Ragmala group is using "A so and so Sant Jee said that Ragmala is bani, so it is bani, no facts/explainations/logic needed."
It should have been written as:
"One side i.e. anti Ragmala group is using logic and facts, while pro-Ragmala group is using "A so and so Sant Jee said that Ragmala is bani, so it is bani, no facts/explainations/logic needed."
By mistake I wrote 'Anti' where I should have written 'Pro'.
So please be kind enough to fix it for me. and if you do decide to fix it, there is no need to post this message up.
Thank you
Re: Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
Bijla Singh · 18 Feb 2005
"oye "bijla" singh u need not reply to any raagmala post as we all here know ur views and your former webiste and how u slandered bhai randheer singhs name on it."
I don't need your permission to reply. if I had intentions to slander Bhai Sahib then I wouldn't have removed anything. don't you think?
"and also we know of your love for anyone associated with akhand keertanee jatha and we also know that the new "jathedar" harnaam singh dhuma supplied u wiht all this info himself, and now hes a jathedar of taksal? that is laughable. "
I really don't see any sense in this. look at what happened in akj last year. Yes I do not agree with AKJ views. I never said I hate them. modern akj is very different than puratan akj. and modern taksal is very different than puratan. in fact, i don't even know which one real taksal is. just because I believe in raag maala doesn't make me taksali.
"any now u seem to appear to be some logical debater? please do not kid yourself."
only illogical thing here is thoughts in your mind.
"i dont mean to attack you but really i hate how you come alive all of a sudden when a raagmala post shows up"
really? so you never seen me posting on any other topics? wake up and smell the reality. if the admins had any answers they wouldn't have closed the last topic. this forum has become a stage for controversial topics and the quality has really gone down.
"yet publically you claim to be indifferent to the issue! and on the same hand ask for unity."
what have i claimed? I believe in Raag Maala and never did I say that I am neutral on this issue. I have met many akj gursikhs who are not neutral on this issue and yet ask for unity. need some names?
"please, stop your twisted logic/eakta/parchar no one can take u seriously"
you are right. no one with as much imaturity as you have can take me seriously. if you really have any guts then why not show your real name or come face to face and I will give you "logical" points.
my post asked for some answers which you failed to provide. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
Rashminder Singh · 18 Feb 2005
why cant i see any pro raagmaliyaaas with some saakhis bout its origin
pls stick to the topic........... there is not even one saakhi about its origin
Vaheguru
Re: Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
Bijla Singh · 18 Feb 2005
I apologize for going off topic singho. I just wanted to clear up the misconception of me being against AKJ which is not true. it is a fact that solid proofs of one side is a nonsense or fairy tails for the other. by proving bunch of sakhis right or wrong you cannot change anyone's mind. all i can say is that these sakhis are well documented in puratan sources, although differently that what Kulbir Singh wrote so you can go ahead and search for it if you really care. if last 150 years of fights could not solve this issue then how do you expect any different now? I think this topic will go for like 100 posts and then it will be closed by the admins w/o reaching any conclusion because it will turn into personal attacks. you can assume that raagmalias can't prove their point but then what? nothing will change and nothing good will come out of it. true gursikhs came, did naam simran and went to sackhand. go ahead try one more time and have this discussion. good luck to all of you. stay in chardee kala. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
note: admin ji, sorry if you think this is also off topic but i wanted to say it so please approve this post and remove this note. i don't think allowing these topics do any good to panth.
Re: Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
Khalistan_zindabaad · 27 Feb 2005
vaheguru ji ka khalsa, vaheguru ji ki fathe
whoever believes that raagmala is not bani is not sikh,
the tenth master, shri guru gobind singh sahib ji, started the damdamitaksal, and damdamitaksal state that raagmala is bani, why are we being pathetic enoguh to even debate over issues such as raagmala or meat, we all know what teh truth is but are just stupid that we cannot accept it, we just want to cause arguments. i am sure jathedar sukhdev singh ji babbar would not be having stupid arguments like this, but however would be reciting gurbani or doing quarm di seva, khalsitan has not been created yet, so why have we stopped fighting, the badla is not over, sajjan kumar, jagdish tytler, kps gill, etc are still aroung, what r we doing??????? ahahahahaa were on the net debating over meat and shri raagmala. great stuff singho, not wonder nothing is happening. there plenty of fake gurus walking out there cussing off sikhi, but we watch them do it, and debate about raagmala. i am sure sant giani jarnail singh ji khalsa ji, 'bhindranvale' wud not be doing this.
gurfatheh
Re: Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 02 Mar 2005
i firmly beleive in calling a spade a spade.....not chamcha. If a fairy tale is a tall tale....it cannot be called "Dhur Ki bani ayee tin saglee chint mitayee."
However I "respect" the right of anyone to keep on beleiving in fairy tales..my "love" for them is not diminished..as my own children also read Hans Christian Henderson's fairy tales..and i cant possibly "hate" my own children..now can I ??
that would be gross insult to Dhur Ki bani..in more ways than one
Jarnail Singh
Re: Fairy tales about Raagmala - Part 1
singh mehta · 02 Mar 2005
kulbir singh,
why try to cause a rift? we know this rag mala issue is not going anywhere. why even bring it up?
this just promotes separation. lets put the rag mala issue aside and work with the few things we have left which we share to bring up sikhi in our communities.
daas, singh