Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Taking Parshad from monays

Taking Parshad from monays

?d?fso · 12 Feb 2005

what if i go to someone's house for an Akhand Paat Sahib, and the person giving out Parshad is a mona...should i not accept it?

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

gkd · 12 Feb 2005

cause he's not a human u should'nt not recognize ye' all man kind as one

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

P Singh · 12 Feb 2005

I 2nd gkd's thoughts

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

quiet · 13 Feb 2005

it depends, you certainly can accept it... whether you *should* accept it is an entirely different question. it depends on what your lifestyle is like... whether youre amritdhari... what kind of level of rehit you keep... ideally, an ideal gursikh would not accept that because they would keep bibek rehit.......... but that's ideally.

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

akj_4eva_and_eva_Amen · 13 Feb 2005

dnt accept it

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

. · 13 Feb 2005

If someone is VIOLATING Gurus Rehet then ofcourse you shouldnt take it.

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

a singh · 13 Feb 2005

i 3rd gkd's thoughts

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 13 Feb 2005

I would, because I see Prashad as a gift from God, not from monay. But that's just my opinion. If you feel otherwise, then decide as you see fit.

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 13 Feb 2005

NO there is no compromise on Guru ji's rehat. Karah parshaad is Guru ji's Kirpa and Blessing.... the people organsiing the AP should have the sense not to give out such seva to non-amritdharees. Maans kee jaat ek Pehchanbo is not meant in this way....a smoker is also human, so is an alcoholic/womaniser/hivaids sufferer/whatever..doesnt mean we must share our food/etc with them and any tom dick and harry. This tuk says DONT DISCRIMINATE on basis of jaat/race/.... In a christian church the Priest gives out the holy sacrament..a mona "sikh" certainly wouldnt be acceptable either...not because he is MONA just like the priest..BUT becasue he is NOT qualified according to their rules.. Today it is a mona giving our parshaad, tomorrow it may be mona reading out the hukmnama...and then.... No offense to any monas jarnail singh

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Kulbir Singh · 13 Feb 2005

Taking degh from a monna or even a non-amritdhari person is totally out of question. There are some sewa that only devotees i.e. Gursikhs of Guru Sahib can do i.e. Siri Akhand Paath raul sewa, Amrit Sinchaar Sewa, Langar sewa and Degh Sewa. No matter how politically uncorrect this stand is and no matter how unpopular this stand is but the reality is that according to Gurmat maryada only Gursikhs (amritdhari persons in good standing) can do degh sewa. It is very detrimental to encourage monnay and non-amritdhari people to do this sewa. Today they want to do degh sewa and tomorrow they would want to do Punj Pyaaray sewa. Don't interpret this to mean that we hate monnay or non-Gursikhs. Gursikhs love everyone in Guru Sahib 's creation including fellow human beings. But this does not mean that we should compromise on Gurmat maryada in order to please them. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Rashminder Singh · 13 Feb 2005

100% agree with Bhai Sahib Jarnail Singh Ji and Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh Ji Only & Only Amritdhari's (following atleast minimum akaal takht sahib rehit) can do these sewaas No comments on Meat Eater Gursikhs & Without Keski Wali Bibiayaan....... You decide on this VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

ms · 14 Feb 2005

no offence to amritdhari's but sometimes even monay's can be bettter people than amritdhari's, there are amritdhari's that are womanizers, there are even amritdhari's taht rape people, do you want your hukamnama from them or from a monay who does nothing like that doesnt drink, doesnt do anything that is wrong except for cutting their hair? i understand the rehit but this is a question of morals jsut want to know how you feel

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

blue · 14 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh ms take this seriously and think for a moment. Guru Gobind Singh Ji created amrit and said He wanted only rehit following Singhs etc dont know exact words. Thus only amritdhaaris can take care of some of the sewa. The question arises as to why is a mona a mona? does he not like the Guru da roop? Is he not committed enough to keep kesh and take amrit? then how can he be given such great sewas? Can a mona take a hukamnama when he himself does not follow the Guru JI's hukams? Now, lets look at amritdharris raping..... that is impossible, they are no longer amritdhaari: amritdhaaris are NOT those that take amrit but those that take amrit and then also follow all the rehit. So as soon as a amritdhaari does something bad they are no longer an amridharri. What do u mean that they do nothing wrong other than cutting their hair. Let me get this straight, our we talking abt kesh? kesh as in what grows on your skin? If we are then from what I know it is a great sin to cut hair! Sikhs have preferred to be cut into peices but not cut their hair and u say that it is all that someone does? I didnt used to respect kesh but now I do and I know that it is a joke to say that you want to do come great sewa in Gurdwaras as u are better than some amritdhaaris even though you have forgotten the kurbaanian of our beloved sikh brothers and sisters. What prachar can a mona do-we can only follow by example. morals? rehit and morals come together, read rehit and you will find that it fits in perfectly with your idea of morals. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Feb 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Dear ms ji, THAT is beside the point. I "may" be a million times "better"...but no one will touch me with a twenty foot pole in a mosque/church...because according to their rules i dont "qualify". Out of sheer necessity.... we have to go by PHYSICAL APPEARANCES. "inside" a very biba looking gursikh type amritdharee may be a chor.chughlakhor, nindyak, etc etc..BUT that aspect can only be seen by GURU JI...our eyes are limited. BUT then we still cannot "swallow" a fly in the soup..if we have seen it. IF a person cannot even keep kesh as Guru ji wishes...then what can we do ( inside the mona may be a jewel of a man kind, compassionate, god fearing...etc etc) BUT we are limited by our eyes ability to only see the OUTSIDE. Jarnail Singh

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

sahajdhari · 14 Feb 2005

99.9% of the time i look on my own mona kind, and dear "ms" that is the fault of the human not of the amrit..... but the topic at hand ......what was a mona doing distributing it? if you saw there was a mona going up to serve it to sangat, then what were u doing sitting down? you should have been up there serving it! i agreee 100% on the fact that moneh like myself should not being doing this seva or chaur sahib seva, and in respects to bibiks langar di seva...but the point is you sat there and a mona had to do the seva, (sum1 had to), and by no means can u turn down parshad no way at all..... its like saying that you go to a gurdwara sahib, and you could have been doing seva of guru ji, but you sat in the sangat soo sum1 has to do hukamnama, it should be a tyar par tyar guru ka sikh, but it happens to be a lost punjabi, whos prolly tryin to get on the right path....point being its still sri guru granth sahib, and its still hukamnama, you cant ignore that........ as far as i see it as a mona, a singh should be doing the seva's listed above.....a mona doing it means 2 things, 1. you were too lazy to do it, 2. there are not enough singhs in the area to do all the seva. plz forgive me if im wrong sumwhere, i do not know too much

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

shera di satt chamchey di ney! · 15 Feb 2005

theres nothing wrong with monnai doing seva, it will benefit them. but distributing degh should be done by Amritdharis to keep the rehat of Guru Sahib alive, there is no question about it.

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

tableji · 15 Feb 2005

well u can also take it in this light, this isnt only about you taking, its about the other person giving....now u either make a scene about it, by which u upset the other person....or u take it.... Does a mona really stop you from gurujis blessings.....of course jeevan is the most important thing, bt there exists a type of thought called, Bibek Budhi....just something to think about... Im not saying that its ok for a mona to give parshaad, bt it happens in this day and age, and you can not always do something about it....its about how u deal with it personally.... Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

honestly..what next? · 15 Feb 2005

if its good enough for guru sahib to accept, then who are we, for if guru sahib was able to give baba nand singh partakh darshan to eat langar, then are they not capable of coming forward and saying 'NO, mona what you think you are doing', this has not occured, thus meaning its acceptable. honestly , next we will be putting the steel glass into the fire, four times to make it pavitar, if a mona touches it, right?

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Singha · 15 Feb 2005

When familys hold langar at the gurdwara they normally do the seva of handing it out, should we take langar off them??? what happens if we eat the langar given by monas?? omg do we break our amrit?? *cries*

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Kulbir Singh · 15 Feb 2005

--------- When familys hold langar at the gurdwara they normally do the seva of handing it out, should we take langar off them??? what happens if we eat the langar given by monas?? omg do we break our amrit?? *cries* ------------ Singha jeeo, it is not a good idea to belittle and mock rehit the way you are doing. If you are a true seeker of Vaheguru, then you should realise that there can be something that you don’t know. Gursikhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee were not ignorant for going through so much sufferings in India to keep this rehit of not eating from hands of non-gursikhs. Sant Gurbachan Singh himself has written in his book (Gurbani Paath Darshan, published by Jatha Bhindraan) that when Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee went to Malwa Desh, there he refused to eat from hands of a family that had not accepted amrit after repeated hukams from Guru Sahib. This is a hukam of Guru Sahib to not eat from non-devotees. Monnay veer and bhains should not get upset or offended by this rehit of Gursikhs. Instead of having gursikhs to break this rehit they should move up the level where gursikhs would eat from them. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

J Singh · 15 Feb 2005

I agree that only amritdharis should do degh de sewa, but the question that I always get is that why do we accept money and other charawa from monney and non-amritdharies? Kulbir Singh ji, what is the rehit on accepting money charawa from non-amritdharies? We are not to have "roti-beti de sanj" with them, but can we have financial and business saanj? "Roti-beti de sanj" to me means that we should avoid all relationships with them. On a side note, how can we bring them closer to guruduare and allow them to change with the blessing of Guru ji? What sort of sewa should they be allowed to do? Can they construct gurduaras, clean toilets & joothe phandey, teach gurbani to kids etc.. etc.. VJKK VJKF

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh. When a Bibeki gursikh visited my family last week, i knew without asking that since my own family is not up to his mark in rehat ( although we are steadily progressing towards it..it is not something that you can accomplish overnight)...I wouldnt be offended if he didnt take anything from us even though we are Amrtidharee and have parkash of Guru ji and do kirtan rehat nitnem etc. Fair enough ...BUT his mark was even higher than that. So..?? In fact this visit ended up me having an easier time explaining to my family why this young man who used to eat with us..now has this rigid discipline..instead of alienating my family members or having negative thoughts about brahminism.such jhooth etc...the visit was positive plus point for me. I will now have a much easier time trying to get everyone on board. Thats the way this should work for everyone....imho. Jarnail Singh

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Me ME ME · 16 Feb 2005

There is this old Nihang Babaji, who I think comes on Sukhsagar Radio, who blatantly said at a Gurdwara, before he was about to do Kirtan that, no monay should come and give him any Kirtan Peta. Naturally the majority of the Sangat (being Monay or turbanned beard trimmers) were offended and walked out of the Gurdwara. I can't remember fully what he said, but I he was very blatant about Guru Ghar sewa from non-amritdharis. I admired him for saying that in a packed diwan.

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

P Singh · 16 Feb 2005

I have taken parshad from monays, what is the matter in this? these labels you put on people are absolutely horrible. What if a so called amritdhari (who you know is not of good character) is giving parshad out, would you take it?

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Kulbir Singh · 16 Feb 2005

-------- I have taken parshad from monays, what is the matter in this? these labels you put on people are absolutely horrible. ----------- What is horrible is to see non-rehitdhari and non-amritdhari persons doing sewa that are reserved for Khalsa of Guru Sahib. Why are these questions only raised in Gurdwara Sahib? I have never heard anyone insisting on non-lawyers fighting cases in courts or non-doctors treating patients in hospitals or non-Chartered Accountants auditing and issuings audit reports. It is an accepted fact that one must be qualified to do certain trades, services etc. Even in serving public free of cost, there are certain protocol that one has to follow but when it comes to Gurdwaras, everyone is insisting on unqualified persons to do sewa that requires highly qualified gursikhs. Why this double standard? ------------- What if a so called amritdhari (who you know is not of good character) is giving parshad out, would you take it? ------------ If a so called amritdhar (who I now is not of good character) is distributing parshad, I would never ever take it. This happened in real life when we were in India, couple of months ago. We went to a samagam at a gursikh's place where degh was prepared by tyaar bar tyaar Khalsa but when it was placed on table near Guru Sahib, it got touched by non-rehitdhari but amritdhari Singh. Singhs over there prepared the degh over again. Rehit is rehit and if you are following a rehit, then there cannot be compromise in doing so. If it is a man-made rehit we are following, surely we can make changes and alterations to it but who has the right to change and alter Guru Sahib's rehit. We are hukami-banday of Guru Sahib and are supposed to obey hukams, not ask questions and make compromises. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 16 Feb 2005

At the risk of sounding like a moorakh (and a non-amritdhari moorakh at that), could someone kindly point me towards the Rehit? Is this part of Gurbani? Part of the Rehit Maryada? Both? Neither? Just trying to learn...

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Kulwinder Singh · 16 Feb 2005

My Most Dear Vir Kulbir Singh Ji, ( My stand on the real topic is some rehitdahary should server the parshad ) Benti with my lowered head, and folded hands think where we are going, You have such a great knowledge of Gurbani, Ucharan and viakhea,but some time you give comments which make me ask some hard questions, please forgive me in advance because I know you will give me very good reply and I will accept your argument providing I can see that I am wrong. Now I am going to say what I have to. I am extremely sorry to remind you, that up to the start of last century their were Muslim Ragis in the Shri Harminder Sahib, Amritsar. (although they were kicked out for very good reasons) By no mean I am suggesting that we should have them now too. But I am encouraging to think with not anybody’s view but the view and sentiments of Shir Guru Granth Sahib Ji’s . Guru Gobind Singh Ji had 52 Poets in his durbar and many of them was not Sikhs what was Guru Ji’s relationship with them segregation or uniting ( in real terms I am not fully aware of this relationships so you can actually enlighten me,.) Maharaja Ranjit Singh ‘s personal Doctor and foreign Minister was world famous Fakir Ajijudin Ji, and Maharaja Ji must have taken many medicines from him. Guru Nanak Dev Ji went to stay with Sajan Thag to get him out of evils deeds. Guru Nanak Dev Ji also went to Jogies on Sumair Parbat and they were not Sikhs and Guru Sahib must have eaten with them, Guru Nanak Dev Ji did the Sacha Soda and served all kind of Sadhus without feeling any thing else but love and compassion. Pir Budhu Saha Gave his sons to Guru Ji knowing well that they will become martyr you think Guru Gobind Singh Ji would have said to Pir Budhu Shah that, sorry I can not eat anything you have touched ? Our history is full of episodes where Guru Ji went to see some Shardalu and eat at their house, and blessed them and made them Sikh later with love and kindness. Also Guru Nanak Dev Ji, the world’s biggest thinker ever, what view he will take on this current issue ? On top of that Who is sitting in the Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, Bhagat Kabir Ji, Nam Dev Ji , Saadna Ji , Ramanad Ji , Baba Farid Ji …… ? what road we are going on ………? you tell me where this road lead too ? the episode you have mentioned where prepared the degh over again, I would have requested kirtan / kath of Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji’s Anag 1195 . Please do some arth of the shabad written below. ik oa(n)kaar sathigur prasaadh || maathaa joot(h)ee pithaa bhee joot(h)aa joot(h)ae hee fal laagae || aavehi joot(h)ae jaahi bhee joot(h)ae joot(h)ae marehi abhaagae ||1|| kahu pa(n)ddith soochaa kavan t(h)aao || jehaa(n) bais ho bhojan khaao ||1|| rehaao || jihabaa joot(h)ee bolath joot(h)aa karan naethr sabh joot(h)ae || ei(n)dhree kee joot(h) outharas naahee breham agan kae loot(h)ae ||2|| agan bhee joot(h)ee paanee joot(h)aa joot(h)ee bais pakaaeiaa || joot(h)ee karashhee parosan laagaa joot(h)ae hee bait(h) khaaeiaa ||3|| gobar joot(h)aa choukaa joot(h)aa joot(h)ee dheenee kaaraa || kehi kabeer thaeee nar soochae saachee paree bichaaraa ||4||1||7|| I am just sending hints to all to see what is happening to us. is this what Shri Guru Granth Sahib ji expect from us or else ..... [%sig%]

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Kulbir Singh · 16 Feb 2005

Veer Kulwinder Singh jeeo, ----------- I am extremely sorry to remind you, that up to the start of last century their were Muslim Ragis in the Shri Harminder Sahib, Amritsar. (although they were kicked out for very good reasons) By no mean I am suggesting that we should have them now too. But I am encouraging to think with not anybody’s view but the view and sentiments of Shir Guru Granth Sahib Ji’s . ----------- These Raagis may have creeped in when Guru Khalsa Panth was in jungles saving its existence. During this time the Gurdwara management went into hands of Udaasis and Nirmalas who did not always keep Gurmat Maryada. I don't understand how this argument goes in favour of monay doing degh sewa. These tobacco consuming Muslim raagis were kicked out of Darbar Sahib for a good reason and Gursikhs thank Guru Sahib for allowing Khalsa to do so. ----------- Guru Gobind Singh Ji had 52 Poets in his durbar and many of them was not Sikhs what was Guru Ji’s relationship with them segregation or uniting ( in real terms I am not fully aware of this relationships so you can actually enlighten me,.) ---------- We don't know what sewa Guru Sahib took from these 52 Darbari Rattans because all the literature that was produced by these scholars perished in River Sarsa. It seems like Guru Sahib employed their services in translating old scriptures and creating new literature for the sake of education of Sikhs of that time. I don't see how this argument goes in favour of monay being allowed to do degh sewa. --------- Maharaja Ranjit Singh ‘s personal Doctor and foreign Minister was world famous Fakir Ajijudin Ji, and Maharaja Ji must have taken many medicines from him. ---------- These were employees of Maharaja jee. Nothing wrong in having non-Sikh employees. Don't see how this goes in favour of monay doing degh sewa. --------- Guru Nanak Dev Ji went to stay with Sajan Thag to get him out of evils deeds. ----------- Guru Sahib converted this evil person to a missionary gursikh. Can't see how this goes in favour of monay doing degh sewa. ---------- Guru Nanak Dev Ji also went to Jogies on Sumair Parbat and they were not Sikhs and Guru Sahib must have eaten with them, ----------- How can you assume that Guru Sahib must have eaten from them? There is no historical reference that Guru Sahib ate from them. Guru Sahib went to see these great religious leaders and mystics of that time, to show them the higher path of spirituality. I fail to see how this argument of yours goes in favour of monay doing degh sewa. ------ Guru Nanak Dev Ji did the Sacha Soda and served all kind of Sadhus without feeling any thing else but love and compassion. --------- No one is saying that we should not have love and compassion for non-Sikhs. Sacha Sauda is perfectly in line with Gurmat. This does not prove that we should allow monay to do degh sewa. -------- Pir Budhu Saha Gave his sons to Guru Ji knowing well that they will become martyr you think Guru Gobind Singh Ji would have said to Pir Budhu Shah that, sorry I can not eat anything you have touched ? --------- Pir jee had become a Sikh of Guru Sahib. There is no doubt about this. The way he humbly submitted to Guru Sahib, only a Sikh could do so, not a friend. As for Guru Sahib telling him that he would not eat from his hands, I don't see anything wrong in saying so, had he not became a Sikh of Guru Sahib. Guru Sahib was Maryada Purshottam. ------- Our history is full of episodes where Guru Ji went to see some Shardalu and eat at their house, and blessed them and made them Sikh later with love and kindness. --------- Guru Sahib ate from their hands only after they became Sikhs of Guru Sahib. Guru Sahib does not say one thing in baani and do something else in practical life. --------- Who is sitting in the Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, Bhagat Kabir Ji, Nam Dev Ji , Saadna Ji , Ramanad Ji , Baba Farid Ji …… ? what road we are going on ………? you tell me where this road lead too ? ---------- They were all Sikhs of Guru Sahib. Govindwal pothiaan clearly state - Kabir Namdev Bhagat Gur Babay ke. All bhagats were Sikhs of Guru Sahib and were contemporaries of Guru Sahib. Please read the great book of Giani Gurdit Singh jee - Itihaas Guru Granth Sahib Bhagat Bani Bhaag. --------- the episode you have mentioned where prepared the degh over again, I would have requested kirtan / kath of Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji’s Anag 1195 . --------- The shabad actually solidifies Bibek Rehit more. It clearly states that everyone is jootha except for those ones who "Saachi paree bichaara" i.e. who do vichaar of Sach. Doing vichaar in Gurmat means obeying hukams of Guru Sahib - Satgur Bachan Kamavane, Sacha eh bichaar. So this shabad clearly states that all those persons who don't have Gursikhi are joothay and hence we should not do roti beti kee saanjh with them. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. IMHO, Guur Ji were sent to this World to teach us Gurmatt...even though many older "religions" were already present... Guru nanak's gurmatt is of a higher plane. Even in ordinary plane of health and fitness, we all know that "pure" food is healthy.... we are not to drink "polluted" water, eat polluted foods because we will get sick "physically"...this is widely accepted without question or prantu shaak doubts....why ? because this "purity" is of this world..and easily verified.... we also know that aperfectly "PURE plate of food can be easily CONTAMINATED by the mere touch of someone who has not washed his hands for example. That is WHY in hospitals, ICU etc not every one is allowed free entry.. Now on a "SPIRITUAL plane" all this is not so easily "seen"..but it is an undeniable fact that on this plane also this "pure foods" and "contamination" can and does occur....only we have to have special eyes to see and realsie this..just as Gurbani clealry says we need "special eyes" to be able to see WAHEGURU/GURMUKHS/BHAGATS etc. Just aa an uneducated PENDU...will NEVER beleive his water may be contaminated by the mere touch of a person who went to the toilet and didnt wash his hands....to the PENDU the ater in his glass looks just as "clean" as before....but an "educated" person will readily beleive the Doctor/health official who tells him to throw away the water.. Similarly only a "spiritually" elevated person can understand why the Degh had to be re-prepared..all others will not be able to see anything "wrong with it. Just like no one can force the Pendu to throw away his water...there is no compulsion in this either....anyone who inssits on eating the previously prepared degh can do so. Just as the "pendu" may scream bloody murder and say "tun bahlla brahman hai oiye shehriah....asee taan eho panee peeke waddeh hoiyan haan....the same comments will be passed about those who "refuse" the degh not up to their standard. There is always a tendency to "suspect" things we DONT UNDERSTAND, and in our attempts to come to an "understanding" to dismiss all this as brahminism, too high and mighty types, suchheh jhootheh, separatists etc etc....this is the way it has been all along....nothing new Trying to Learn...unlearn and RE LEARNING.... Jarnail Singh

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

J Singh · 17 Feb 2005

Kulbir Singh ji, how did Guru Nanak Dev ji made all the people His sikhs before eating from them? Was each and everyone who met Guru ji got "CHARAN PAHUL" and "Gurmanter" first? Do you extrapolate one charan pahul pankati to millions who were blessed with darshan of Guru ji? I don't agree that all Bhagats were initiated by Guru ji with charan pahul and gur-mantr. I believe that Guru ji approved the sach (truth) that came out of these great souls and included it in Guru Granth Sahib ji as his "sachi baani". Bhagat baani have influences of the place, religions and language they were born into. For example read Bhagat Sheikh Farid di baani. It talks about sift and bandagi of Allah. Does it ever mention Guru ji or him being Guru ji's sikh? Think about it. Also, I could be mistaking him with someone else but didn't Giani Gurdit Singh use to tie his beard!!! Gyani ji, you gave a great anparh paindu vs educated shehri analogy, but I reckon it should apply across the board to many other "rational" things as well, such as all of us taking part in killing many life-forms for food :-). I agree that we must keep rehit provided by GURU JI but please make this illiterate kooker understand how does touching the utensil from outside make food uneatable ("phitteya hoya")? Is it just because Bhai Sahib said so or is there any other reason. Consider me a paindu :-). Also, why do we have NO problem accepting help and money charawa from non-amritdharies & monney? We are prohibited from having "roti-beti de saanj" with them, but how come we have financial and business saanj (dealings) with them? VJKK VJKF

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

eman ruoy · 17 Feb 2005

it seems the Monays are on the Level of Shoodras when talking bout the Lifestyle of Gursikh (brahmin) who are the chosen ones. But Amritdharis bend just a little and say well you can come, sit down and watch us, but you can't do anything unless you become one of us and for that to happen you don't have to wait to be born in a Brahmin house, you just have to take Amrit. So indeed are we not following the Modified Version of the Birpan ke Reet which we are told to stay away from? If all you can see is the Outside of an Individual and not the inside, then you Judge somone because he is not up to the Standards of your Visual preference. You Conclude on only 1/2 the information...therefore how can you pass judgement knowing only Half. Is the outer half more importent then the inner? If no then why is the Rule made on only half the information. If Equal then only he who can look within and without the individual pass judgement. You pass Judgement based on the World of the Outside, yet we fail Miserably on knowing the inner depths of the individual. Nothing one wears on the Outside Guarantee Purity within. Is that not the Goal of a SIkh, to become pure within? Few know what lie within the heart of another, but that is given little importence. A Doctorhood of a Doctor does not lie in his Clothes, but in his Mind and Hands. The Sainthood of a Saint does not lie in his Safron clothes, but in his very existence. The Sikhi of a Gursikh not lie in his attire, but in the Fiber of his every thought and Action. If your Sikhi is only limited to your attire, then you are no different than the yogis who wear raakh, mundra...etc, only you wear the 5ks.

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Kulwinder Singh · 17 Feb 2005

Dear Vir Kulbir Singh Ji, In my last post on the very first line I declared that “My stand on the real topic is some rehitdahary should server the parshad “ but all your replies focused on this alone, I do not contradict you on need for the person serving the parshad of being Amritdhary. It is the debate within the debate, I referred in the most of the post. Anyway The central theme of the discussion is how we should treat non amritdaharies, Non rehitdharies and Monay or non Sikhs when they come to gurdawars or our homes, or we meet them anywhere else. Gurdawara being the symbolic place of Sikh values in physical form give us a display and interface with the rest of the world to present our attributes to the world. Now if Guru Nanak Dev Ji went to see these Jogies on the summer Parbat and there is no reference of them eating with them does not mean, they did not eat with them ( and vice versa). But whole Sid Gosht ‘s central theme was what is the point of being in the remote areas where you control your body and senses to live longer (i.e. not eating for long time, no breathing for long time, avoiding real world, avoiding family life) what it is going to achieve. ( now think for moment that would Guru Ji have demonstrated to them that Guru Ji himself can do that i.e. not eating for long time ? even though he was well capable of doing so. It does not go with the point what Guru Ji was trying to say to these Jogies and For sure Guru Nanak Dev Ji was not show off in any way. Guru Nanak Dev Ji who was prepared to read Namaz with the Muslims(allthough he knew what was the outcome of the episode).At least did not showed his allergy to the other non Sikhs ? am I right or wrong ? in principle he had no issues mixing with non Sikhs? In your reply to the Pir Budhu Shah’s question you have said, “As for Guru Sahib telling him that he would not eat from his hands, I don't see anything wrong in saying so, had he not became a Sikh of Guru Sahib.” I think if you want to believe in what you believe, at least give credit to Pir Budhu Saha’s intelligence that he figured it out that even if his sons died for Guru Ji, it was worthy deal for him and his sons,you think he will think the same if he was aware that Guru Gobind Singh Ji will consider food touched by him as uneatable ? Or our Guru Ji had such a way of looking at things that he will adapt that kind of view, knowing my real father who blessed the unworthy, had heart such komal that even those who he principally disagreed most when came under threat and were vulnerable ( of course I am talking about Brahmins) said to his father to give sacrifice and he knew very well that from then onwards their will be much more hard times for him and his penth. I think historical facts does not syncronise with your view my dear Vir Ji. You have also said that “ Guru Sahib ate from their hands only after they became Sikhs of Guru Sahib. Guru Sahib does not say one thing in baani and do something else in practical life.” Where in the Bani it says that if some non amritdhary touched the Degh from outside, then it is unapproved ? or treat non amritdhary people in the Gurdawar as third class citizens ? that their only touch from outside can make the degh / Langar unusable for the sangat or anybody ? Hyderabad’s Nazam presented a Channai to shri Darbar Sahib Ji Amritsar, which was seen with the pride of all Sikhs, does that make any difference in your opinion ? A Muslim Pir made a chor form the threads of Sandal wood, which was used to for Guru Ji, does that make difference ? Never mind all that, why Shri Harminder Sahib Ji’s foundation stone was laid by Muslim Pir Sai Mia Mir Ji ? You in reference to Bhagat Sahib Ji have said “They were all Sikhs of Guru Sahib. Govindwal pothiaan clearly state - Kabir Namdev Bhagat Gur Babay ke. All bhagats were Sikhs of Guru Sahib and were contemporaries of Guru Sahib. Please read the great book of Giani Gurdit Singh jee - Itihaas Guru Granth Sahib Bhagat Bani Bhaag.” Vir Ji some of the Bhagats in the Gurubani( may be Majority )are from pre-Guru Nanak Dev Ji’s time. So Gaini Gurdit Singh Jee’s saying Sikhism was started before Guru Nanak Dev Ji ? Your endorsement of Giani Gurdit Singh Jee( I have not read the book so I am taking your writing as his true writing) have strong smell of RSS’s version of saying everybody is Hindu, Just in this case it is every bhagat is Sikh, regardless of Kabir Ji Being Satnami, Bhagat Namdev Ji Being in love with Shri Krishan Ji, Baba Frid ji being muslim. I agree that they all have same wavelength in deed but I would not dare to change their religion unless they have declared in some clear sense which I think is not the case other wise we are converting people after they gone ? who will think that we belong to Guru Nanak if we did that, Guru Nanak Dev Ji accepted everybody and we want to convert people who have no say now. In reply to the Shabad you have said “Satgur Bachan Kamavane, Sacha eh bichaar” Yes indeed but who is ignoring the whole shabad ? when all physical things are declared Joothiea by Guru Granth Sahib ji Think my dear Vir Ji think by looking at our Dear Guru Granth Sahib Ji. And please reply to all the above, Now dear Gyani Ji I have come to pause and think for while of your comments “only we have to have special eyes to see and realise this..just as Gurbani clealry says we need "special eyes" to be able to see WHEGURU/GURMUKHS/BHAGATS etc. But we are talking about the physical touching of utensils ? Special eyes are indeed required so we just not use the outer look of somebody and make decisions based on the inner self. We agree on this 100%. You have also written that: “there is always a tendency to "suspect" things we DONT UNDERSTAND, and in our attempts to come to an "understanding" to dismiss all this as Brahmanism. I do not think there is anything which is suspected, either we treat people with dignity and respect, or we don’t Ek Bujea’ ta ho wani Pak, Bin Bujai tu Sada na Pak. I don’t know what understanding have to do with treating people with dignity ? You have said “too high and mighty types, suchheh jhootheh, separatists etc etc....this is the way it has been all along....nothing new” Yes Gyani Ji indeed it is been like this since the time of “”THE GREAT MANU JI””. And with the grace of “Mahan Brahmins of this yug” If we “Keep shutting and slamming door on Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, it will remain like this for centuries to come in Indian Society. “”””””Just like good old times no change just the way we like Pure and Just Pure Ultra mega clean Sikhi with no contamination of those lower class uneducated Pendu Sikhs.”””””” I would like to ask a open question what does it mean to be Pure, what exec tally it achieve for the person who follows it and to others ? Just simple answer will do please reply to above question. By the way you are right about one thing indeed I am very pendu and uneducated in Sikhi at lease in my eyes. I have small understanding and long tong to ask questions, but sadly that is the way I have always learned from people around me, all most all of my near and dear ones disagree with me greatly so I am bit thick to be 100% honest, no humbleness, just fact, and I do feel sad for asking difficult questions. Sikhism is the most torrent religion, No other religion accept hymens from other religion like Sikhi has done, No other religion has done holy war to protect the religion who’s principle was against it’s own. No other religion’s top worship place’s foundation stone has been laid by other religion’s person. No other religion allow other religious people to come to the most scarred place of theirs, No other religion’s Master have been desired by other religions as Guru Nanak Dev Ji being even today attempted to be claimed by Hindus and Muslims alike this is not because they want to diminish the importance of Guru Nanak Dev Ji but because He is The Badhsah , the Most Intelligent, loving, Compassionate, Lazawab Tofa of God to earth. And when we turning his home into Some Cultic, Fundamentalist, extreme, purist or anything else apart from what he wanted, we will be doing great injustice to His wishes and his Glory. THINK MY DEAR SIKHO THINK !!!!!!! Please Vir Kulbir Singh Ji and Vir Jarnail Singh Ji Reply. I must say one thing after all this, that is if you guys have some eyes to see what you see and I certainly like to know what do you see and how it is different from what normal people see, That is have you reached some stage where people like me just do not understand at all, If that is the case then please explain to enlighten me, As Guru Hargobind Singh Ji have said that what ever you are do not try to be something else neither say you are not what you are nor pretend what you are not. So I am asking you in truly no sarcastic way that if there is some stage where things start looking very different from average Joe Blog ‘s eyes like me. Then I need to know for sure. Please elaborate on that stage to enlighten me Bhul Chuk Maf Ji Kulwinder Singh Aap Ji da Moorakh Pendu [%sig%]

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

ms · 17 Feb 2005

sorry about that i was busy doing hmwk and stuff school is getting intense but im back with some response, what about someone who keeps there hair, doesnot yet wear a phug or kirpan or kachera or kanga but does their nitnem and because they are just not at that stage yet but they and listens to their share of bani and all are they not techniqually rehitdhari's just have not been blessed with amrit and about my last post i was not posting that for people to find taht offensive i've just be curious about this things especially differences between a someone who does have a phug and people who dont (whether they remove kes or not) and i never meant for people to think that i think amritdhari's are bad because i've heard of those "baba's" in the radio and on the papers who do horrible things in the name of sikhi

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 17 Feb 2005

Kulwinder Singh ji, Very well put, I am also awaiting the response. Although if you are a moorakh, then I'm....never mind, don't answer :) Chardi Kala

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

an opinion · 17 Feb 2005

good debate - excellent post Kulwinder Singh. you've raised some very strong and relevant points

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Kulbir Singh · 18 Feb 2005

Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh! Veer Kulwinder Singh jeeo, -------- It is the debate within the debate, I referred in the most of the post. Anyway The central theme of the discussion is how we should treat non amritdaharies, Non rehitdharies and Monay or non Sikhs when they come to gurdawars or our homes, or we meet them anywhere else. ----------- On one hand you state that you have no objection to our stand that parshaad sewa should be done by Amritdhari only but then your whole post was trying to prove otherwise. As for the central theme of your post as stated above, you should have started a new thread if you had something else to discuss. This thread as far as I can understand was to discuss whether monay should be doing degh sewa or not. On one hand you stated that you are do not contradict us on Monay not allowed for degh sewa and then you start all this debate about Monay. Where did I mention that monay or non-Sikhs should not be respected or loved? All I have been writing is that there are some sewa that are reserved for only amritdharis and yet there some sewa that are reserved for amritdharis who do more sewa and keep more rehit e.g. Punj Pyaaray sewa. These sewa are based on merit and certainly there is discrimination as to who can do sewa and who can’t. -------------- But whole Sid Gosht ‘s central theme was what is the point of being in the remote areas where you control your body and senses to live longer (i.e. not eating for long time, no breathing for long time, avoiding real world, avoiding family life) what it is going to achieve. ( now think for moment that would Guru Ji have demonstrated to them that Guru Ji himself can do that i.e. not eating for long time ? even though he was well capable of doing so. It does not go with the point what Guru Ji was trying to say to these Jogies and For sure Guru Nanak Dev Ji was not show off in any way. ------------ To begin with, the central theme of Sidh Gosht is not to prove that living in remote areas is wrong. Sidh Gosht is much more than this. Sidhaas were the most spiritually elevated beings of their times. Guru Sahib discussed with them those great points of spirituality that we ordinary beings cannot even understand. Guru Sahib nevertheless wrote his discussion and debate in form of Sidh Gosht. As for eating there while discussing with Sidhaas, you yourself write that Sidhaas were capable of staying hungry for long periods of time and were averse to indulging in cooking food or doing other worldly things. They did not believe in formalities like asking Guru Sahib for food etc. They were more eager to discuss with Guru Sahib points of contention between their faith and Gurmat. Based on hypothetical situations or based on assumptions you cannot prove that Guru Sahib ate from the Sidhaas. If you have a solid point, then let us know and we can discuss that. ------------ Guru Nanak Dev Ji who was prepared to read Namaz with the Muslims(allthough he knew what was the outcome of the episode).At least did not showed his allergy to the other non Sikhs ? am I right or wrong ? in principle he had no issues mixing with non Sikhs? ------------- Where did I say that we should show allergy to non-Sikhs. Just because we keep bibek and believe in bibek rehit does not mean that we have allergy from non-Sikhs. Also please note that Guru Sahib did not mix with non-Sikhs out of leisure or entertainment. He did so solely for the purpose of doing Parchaar. We too have no qualms of mixing with anyone for the purpose of parchaar of Gurmat. ----------------- I think if you want to believe in what you believe, at least give credit to Pir Budhu Saha’s intelligence that he figured it out that even if his sons died for Guru Ji, it was worthy deal for him and his sons,you think he will think the same if he was aware that Guru Gobind Singh Ji will consider food touched by him as uneatable ? -------------- He would have been an extremely conceited and haume-ful person if he had thought like this. You are really putting Pir jee down by saying that he would not have given the sacrifice of his sons if Guru Sahib had not eaten from him. Pir jee’s ideal of love for Guru Sahib was not so lowly. He loved Guru Sahib unconditionally and I have no doubt that he had received Naam from Guru Sahib. Otherwise he would not have been so much in love with Guru Sahib. I have no doubt that he was a Sikh of Guru Sahib. How could he have remained a follower of Mohammad after falling in love with Guru Sahib? In Gurmat you can’t be a follower of both Guru Sahib and of Krishna or Mohammad, at the same time. --------------- I think historical facts does not syncronise with your view my dear Vir Ji. ------------- I think the other way. The historical facts that you are trying so intensely to be in your favour are not siding with your philosophy. You can’t base your assumptions on hypothetical situations like “Had Pir jee known Guru Sahib won’t eat from him, would he have sacrificed his sons”. This kind of hypothetical question cannot be used to prove your point. -------------- Where in the Bani it says that if some non amritdhary touched the Degh from outside, then it is unapproved ? or treat non amritdhary people in the Gurdawar as third class citizens ? that their only touch from outside can make the degh / Langar unusable for the sangat or anybody ? ------------------ Where in Gurbani does it even mention Degh? Then I ask you the question, where in Gurbani does it mention that we can eat if a saakat or a non-devotee touches degh? ---------------- Hyderabad’s Nazam presented a Channai to shri Darbar Sahib Ji Amritsar, which was seen with the pride of all Sikhs, does that make any difference in your opinion ? --------------- Absolutely not! Yesterday I saw a picture of Mr Straw making rotis in langar in Guru Ramdass Langar Amritsar. This is not going to change my opinion that non-Sikhs can make langar. There are eye-witness accounts of British from late 1700s about some Sikhs consuming opium and bhang. This is not going to convince me that consuming bhang or meat or opium is Gurmat. There have always been dhillay Sikhs in our Panth. We cannot follow them. -------------- A Muslim Pir made a chor form the threads of Sandal wood, which was used to for Guru Ji, does that make difference ? ------------- Same as above. -------------- Never mind all that, why Shri Harminder Sahib Ji’s foundation stone was laid by Muslim Pir Sai Mia Mir Ji ? --------------- I don’t believe Mia Mir jee laid the foundation stone of Siri Harmandir Sahib. Guru Arjun Dev jee himself laid the foundation stone of Darbar Sahib and Baba Budda jee did ardaas. This is written in all old accounts of that even. Only Giani Gian Singh’s book states this story of Mia Mir that I don’t believe one cent. ------------ Vir Ji some of the Bhagats in the Gurubani( may be Majority )are from pre-Guru Nanak Dev Ji’s time. So Gaini Gurdit Singh Jee’s saying Sikhism was started before Guru Nanak Dev Ji ? ------------ Please read the book yourself. No Bhagat whose baani is in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee lived before Guru Sahib. They were all contemporaries of Guru Sahib. How else did the idol-worshipping Kabir, Ravidas, Naamdev and Dhanna become Vaheguru-worshipping Bhagats? The answer is that they met Guru Sahib and learned from Guru Sahib about Nirgun Raam. According to Gurmat one has to have a true Guru to find Vaheguru. Who else is the true Guru but Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj? ------------ Your endorsement of Giani Gurdit Singh Jee( I have not read the book so I am taking your writing as his true writing) have strong smell of RSS’s version of saying everybody is Hindu, Just in this case it is every bhagat is Sikh, regardless of Kabir Ji Being Satnami, Bhagat Namdev Ji Being in love with Shri Krishan Ji, Baba Frid ji being muslim. ----------------- Hindus and Muslims do not have the capability to reach the highest pinnacle of Spirituality – Sachkhand. Therefore, they could not have written Gurbani that can be written only by someone who reaches Sach Khand. Without the true Guru, one cannot reach Vaheguru. There can only be one truth. Thus there can only be one Guru. That Guru is Guru Nanak Dev jee. One has to be a Sikh of Guru Nanak Dev jee to reach Sachkhand. No Hindu or Muslim wrote any baani in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. If you smell RSS version of Sikhi in me, I can only feel pity on your judgement. ---------- In reply to the Shabad you have said “Satgur Bachan Kamavane, Sacha eh bichaar” Yes indeed but who is ignoring the whole shabad ? when all physical things are declared Joothiea by Guru Granth Sahib ji -------------- They are joothiyaan only if used by ones who don’t do Sach daa Vichaar i.e. Japp Naam. Please read that whole shabad and see what message you get from it. ------------ I do not think there is anything which is suspected, either we treat people with dignity and respect, or we don’t ------------ Treating people with respect does not mean that we start eating from meat-eating, tobacco-eating, fornicators and adulterers. Ones who take birth in Sikh homes and cut their hair are chors and thieves who can never be accepted by Guru Sahib unless they keep their promise. They (and all others) promised while they were in the womb of their mother that they would japp Naam if they get released from the hell of being in the womb. They came out and forgot everything. They are promise-breakers and especially those ones who take janam in Sikh families and cut hair, drink liquor and then want to do degh sewa in Gurdwaras. Sorry sir, as long as Guru Sahib’s Khalsa is alive, this will not happen where ever they are present. ------------ I would like to ask a open question what does it mean to be Pure, what exec tally it achieve for the person who follows it and to others ? ------------- To be initiated into being a Sikh is the beginning of purity process and obeying hukams of Guru Sahib and following his hukams one reaches a state when one’s inner self becomes one with Vaheguru. That is ultimate purity. This purity will never come if we associate with the ones who cut hair, consume meat and tobacco, commit fornication and adultery. We will have to associate with Gursikhs. Kulwinder Singh jeeo, I suggest that you read the books written by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. I think your knowledge of Gurmat will augment if you do so. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 18 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Veer Kulwinder Singh jio, Veer Kulbir Singh Ji has "Morcha fateh Kat lia" without me....in other words there is nothing left for me to say that would be "value added". Leaving one tiny bit...IF "hindus and Muslims" had found WAHEGURU and the GURMATT GADDHI RAAH "before" Guru nanak ji came to this World..dont you think Guru Ji's coming is not necessisated ?? Why si Guur Ji coming to show the Same Raah? So the simple answer imho is that the Gurmatt gaddhi Raah of Guru nanak ji WAS NOT yet discovered by anyone...that is WHY Guru Ji was sent into this World. Therefore ALL the writing in Guru Granth ji is by SIKHS of Gurmatt. A "muslim" preaching" his shariah laws and Prophet Mohammed's divinity wouldnt be accepted in Guru Granth Ji..imho one of the "conditions set upon Guur Arjun Ji by Emperor Jehangir to escape Death was to Put PRAISE of Prop Mohammed Ji in the Gurbani/Guru Granth Ji.... Guur Arjun Ji refused POINT BLANK and preferred death. Jarnail Singh

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

RK · 18 Feb 2005

I agree with the above last posts. Muslim is someone who believes in the five pillars of faith i.e. a)that there is one God and Mohammed is his messenger, b) the practice of giving 2.5% to muslim community out of earnings c) the practicing of Rozey, or fasts, d)to go on the hajj atleast once in your lifetime and e) to do the namaaz, or prayers. What constitutes a hindu is more fluid, but generally they have to believe in one of the dieties and perform the rituals associated with that diety according to the area they live in and the diety they worship (this is a very generalized description). Now, when we examine the bhagats, they worshipped Vaheguru only, and did not participate in the rituals and such of the above mentioned religions, so how could they be Hindus or muslims, if they do not even fit the description? If someone wants to claim that they did indeed practice these rituals, then why would their bani have been included in Guru Ji, if they were practicing rituals that bani opposes? This leads to the conclusion that they were indeed Sikhs, and because of adopting Satguru Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji as their guru, were able to reach Sachkhand, which is why their bani was included in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.

Re: Taking Parshad from monays

Admin · 18 Feb 2005

We have decided to close this thread now. Admin.