is it ok to hold hands?
?d?fso · 12 Feb 2005
do u think its ok for a married couple (Amritdhari)...to hold hands in public?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
?d?fso · 12 Feb 2005
do u think its ok for a married couple (Amritdhari)...to hold hands in public?Rashminder Singh · 12 Feb 2005
i dont think its wrong...........gkd · 12 Feb 2005
no, if god wanted u 2 hold hands, he would have made them in a grasped position (jokes)akj_4eva_and_eva_Amen · 12 Feb 2005
why dya wanna hold hands? wear gloves if ur hands r coldg · 12 Feb 2005
sureP Singh · 12 Feb 2005
Its perfectly OK, your soul says its perfectly OK but the social conditioning in our society says otherwise. Don't follow the crowd, be yourself.Kulbir Singh · 13 Feb 2005
It is totally inappropriate for couples (gursikh couples) to hold hands in public. Only be-sharam and be-haiya (shameless) people who have no respect for elder gursikhs would act this way. This is western way and we should never adopt such inappropriate behaviour. Gursikhs are not cheap exhibitionists of love and never resort to such cheap stuff. A gursikh should not even have a portrait taken in this way as we notice in some gursikhs houses. This is definitely a step in the wrong direction. Daas, Kulbir SinghI'm not telling you · 13 Feb 2005
Er, are married couple allowed to look at each other in public? Yup, you get the gist of what I'm trying to say (unless you don't get sarcasm and in that case pretend you haven’t read my post :-))Photographer · 13 Feb 2005
Kulbir Singh, please explain when we degenrated into Shiria Law. As much as I know about Sikhi and thats not much compared to you probably but i'm sure thats what Islamic states like Iran and recently the Taliban led Afghanisatn used to beat up people who used to indulge in the most heinous of all crimes i.e. Married couples holding hands. Pleas don't get me wrong, Gursikh couples should have common sense and realise that we shouldn't copy their western counterparts but as people respect your views on THIS forum please try to explain to them instead of trying to declare a Tapoban Law. Maybe i'm wrong and people will believe you, they normally do after you post as before your post majority said it wasn't a big deal. I also like the portrait view, nice one. Telling people what they can have in their house. What about pictures taken on their wedding day, obviously they will be together in the picture, smiling and in a pose, mostly directed by the photographer. Is that acceptable? What about say pictures of spouses in wallets or on the desks at work, is that acceptable? You might think im being sarcastic and well your right. But I like posts which have good backup and yours was just telling people what to do and not much back up. [%sig%]Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 13 Feb 2005
My elders would be respected just fine if an amritdhari married couple held hands in publc.MKAUR · 13 Feb 2005
aah I agree with Kulbir Singh ji. Holding hands reminds me of the hole PYAAR and ISHK deal in bollywood movies. Its not a CRIME to hold hands, but for an amritdharee couple whos only love is vaheguru, it just doesn't fit right in being all lovey dovey with your partner. Theres other ways to express that. You know through seva for your partner, do path n' naam abhiyaas together and respect n' stuff you know. Displaying your effection through holding hands in public gives the wrong message. The pyaar between two amridharees is very different from the PYAAR we hear about everyday. Just my opinion though... Manpreet Kaurgkd · 13 Feb 2005
please if u are married refrain from have emotions for ur partnercommon sense · 13 Feb 2005
two Gursikhs holding hands is not a good idea (whether it is morally right or wrong lets ignore that for a minute). my reasoning is this. GUARANTEED most of our elder singhs would find this offense and all other Gursikhs who we would call chardikala would consider this type of public affection to be unbecoming of a Gursikh. now lets think for a minute... if Sache Patshah's tyaar bar tyaar khalsa is not pleased with seeing this... then how can SatGuru Ji himself be pleased if his beloved Gursikhs find offence in this? [%sig%]Kulbir Singh · 13 Feb 2005
----------- Kulbir Singh, please explain when we degenrated into Shiria Law. As much as I know about Sikhi and thats not much compared to you probably but i'm sure thats what Islamic states like Iran and recently the Taliban led Afghanisatn used to beat up people who used to indulge in the most heinous of all crimes i.e. Married couples holding hands. Pleas don't get me wrong, Gursikh couples should have common sense and realise that we shouldn't copy their western counterparts but as people respect your views on THIS forum please try to explain to them instead of trying to declare a Tapoban Law. -------------- First of all, how often do you see an amritdhari gursikh couple holding hands in public? As the matter of fact I have never seen an amritdhari chardi kala couple (from any jatha) holding hands in public. How come? Because it is against the spirit of our Sikh culture. It is not "Taliban" in nature as you have mentioned. It would have been Taliban if I had suggested that we should force people to follow a certain law. Someone asked a questions and I replied to the best of my knowledge. How is this Taliban like? People who are introducing this kind of be-sharmi (shamelessness) in our culture are not friends of our Panth. Let us not forget our values. There is no need to exhibit love in public. As saadi bachee Manpreet Kaur wrote, there are many ways to express your love for your life-partner. If today gursikh couples start walking around holding hands then tomorrow you may see them kissing in public. Many be-sharam people would even argue that what is wrong in kissing in public. May Guru Sahib save our Sikh quom from such shamelessness. Khalsa jeeo, I urge you to not lose sharam and never indulge in such cheap exhibitionist behaviour as holding hands with your partner or kissing in public. If we show such cheap gestures in public, our next generation will go two steps ahead of us and God knows what they will do. Daas, Kulbir SinghDAVINDER SINGH · 13 Feb 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh! I have been around Amritdharies all my life. And for 22 years I have never seen any amritdhari Singh hold a Singhnees hand in public. Just try to imagine a Singh and Bibi holding hands and walking on a sidewalk... can't you just see that something is wrong with this picture. The majority of the Punjabis I see are at the gurdwara. Not once have I seen anyone holding hands. Why is that? Is it because of the fear of guru sahib? Or the fear of being seen by others while holding hands? If it is, then shouldn't amritdharis always see guru sahib as hazar nazar all the time regardless of where they are? Guru sahib says that a Sikh should be the same on the inside as on the outside. If no one holds hands at a gurdwara, then why hold hands in public? Is that hypocrisy or what? Some things just don't suit Singhs regardless of it having western roots. This is one of those. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!ws · 14 Feb 2005
ok...i have read these replies and seems like both sides have made good points. On one side, Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji has said that we shouldn't do this because it doesn't look good (could this mean that it shows emotinal attachment?) on the other hand it could be said that its just natural for a couple to hold hands if they feel comfortable. Why must we always try to impress the world? Our 'elderly' people also believe that to marry out of your 'caste' is wrong. i think i am at a draw on this one...i really don't know if its ok or not.S Virk · 14 Feb 2005
Changing topics, how about something more important, like the issue of shoeslaces versus velcro. Is it really right to use shoelaces? What are your views. I think many debates are trivial in nature, this one being one of them. This is a personal choice; if a couple wants to hold their hands together, we can't really do anything about it, now can we? There are infinte many ways to spend your wisdom and energy, spending time discussing and debating topics that are really no significane to our (own) lives is futile. You're gonna do what you're gonna do, why argue?hmm · 14 Feb 2005
holding hands - how many khalsas with avasta do we know who did that? taliban, imposing, islamis - why do we draw parralels with other religions? the issue revolves around two gursikh couples. its become the fad of the day, people want to fit in , hold hands to express their feelings. Its not the worlds baddest thing but its not exactly a prerequisite to expressing yourself. Perhaps Guru Sahib intended us to show the world in different ways how to express the love for the world smiling, curteous, helping people and seva. You dont need to hold hands to show others your not "taliban". This word needs to be erased on sikh issues its being used very constantly like a backdrop against maryada held every here and there. What goes on behind closed doors is different, thats your own home. How ridicolous will that look holding hands with bana and mala in public? By adorned in bana ( dastaar, thari, panj kakars and clothing ) your showing you are submitted to Guru sahib in his school. With the sikh form comes responsibility. As i waited for the bus yesterday, a couple were all over each other, you get my drift! This would not happen here 80 years ago in public. What does this signal to a little kid? question goes how far can this expression of free love be taken? once my uncle invited one of his associates family, i arrived by chance sat down 5 minutes and went. When they got up for dinner the swedish husband had his hands down his wifes jeans back pockets for prolonged periods. My little cousins all under 12 at the time were forced to watch this. I think it will come to a question at some point why do we marry? marital bliss? , procreation, or maya? or a balance of each? if so each then we should also take into consideration our roles and responsibilities to our Guru ji and see if it fits in with that. If you stick on the rajoh gun side you will see nothing wrong with this hugging and kissing holding hands in public. If you are committed to spiritual evolving you will ask yourself serious questions. [%sig%]hmm · 14 Feb 2005
then what will the next move be holding hands in a gurdwara? Confusion can only depart with understanding. It sure is not easy growing up in the west and following gurmat but we must inquire into bani, rehat, and itihaas. I have not seen one photo of any parathan sikh holding hands with any of their sikh bibis, nor did our Guru jis do that and if they would have seen nothing wrong with it with their all powerful thoughts and far seeing ahead , ie punjabi culture, ritualism, they would have told us its ok for husband and wife to do that in public. But if it was ok to hold hands in public then the gurdwaras is one of the most public places in sikhism in fact the heart of it for us. So if holding hands argument is for outside when you go supermarkets and city life then you need to ask yourself what your intentions are.Singha · 14 Feb 2005
Personally i dont see anything wrong with holding hands, if other people dont wish to do it thats their own choice, but why does everyone have to put on emotional blackmail on others? What seems acceptable to one person might not be the same for another, its personal choice, is there such a thing nowadays? Why does everyone have to enforce their views on others? Manpreet Kaur said "Its not a CRIME to hold hands, but for an amritdharee couple whos only love is vaheguru, it just doesn't fit right in being all lovey dovey with your partner." So is it wrong to tell your partner that you love them? If you only have love for waheguru does that mean you are emotionless to every other person around? If i only have love for waheguru that means you cant be intimate with your partner even behind closed doors? Whats next? Cant share a bed with your partner? Partner has to walk 10 metres behind you just incase you smile or show a bit of effection? Dont talk to each other incase you lose your love for waheguru?Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Feb 2005
its nothing to do with "kuttrrta", "talibanism" "extremism" etc etc..this holding hands in public, which will then "graduate" to putting ones arms around the waist, then higher up...and so on.....ALL this JUST DOESNT BELONG in Gurmatt/Sikhi. Our TRUE reason for existence on this world is GURBANI and Ucha Sucha jeewan...our True marriage is with waheguru...the worldy marriages are just affairs of this world. IF you really WANT to hold anyones HANDS then Pray to GURU Ji to have Kirpa on You that GURU JI will offfer you His Divine Hands to Hold... We Sikhs do all our holding of hands etc in privacy and not exhibit like the Westerners...that is not our culture or norm. Thats all. Jarnail SinghAnon Singh · 14 Feb 2005
I am inclined to agree with Kulbir Singh. Although many of the more "Liberal" Sikhs may disagree (and I can certainly see their viewpoint) I don't think it should be done publically especially infront of elders. Privately they can do whatever. But in public is it really neccesary?UkSingh · 14 Feb 2005
I've always thought that Gursikhs shouldn't show their emotions towards their spouse in public and i am forever telling my wife that. Up until last week, I've never been interested in holding my spouses hands in public But soemthing happened and i've only remebeered now this topic has come up. With Guru's kirpa we are expecting a little khalsa, anyway Singhni had some 'bleeding' and she was concernced, so we went to the doctors. So after we came out of the Doctors, Singhni was a bit upset, so I gave her a hug and held her hand for a few minutes as we walked to the car. Now this is the first time i done this, and not once did i think i was doing wrong, i was just doing simran inside and phyiscally trying to comfort Singhni now i think every situation is different and in this case I was happy to offer that bit of support when Singhni needed it. so there's no hard and fast rule, like anything if doing for the right reasons then there's nothing wrong with it.panjab e shera di nassal · 14 Feb 2005
there has been some of this arm in arm, and touching at some camps in the last few years by some people. They have been warned off they must not do this especially at a sikh camp. Ingrezi customs should be kept outside, by coming to america canada and uk your body and rehat does not become ingrezi does it? so adopting these customs you are now lost to what should and what should not be in your daily sikh life. For the gurmukh who represents his Guru as ambassador of sikhi wherever she or he goes this is not even an issue.blue · 14 Feb 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh ok UKSingh, the exception goes that u have to stop holding hands once the little khalsa is here. Seriously speaking, there is a difference as you held her hand to comfort her, you would do that to a friend and it was not to show your love in public, completely different to those that hold hands to show the world they are in love. but it must be ok to hold hands if you are walking in the woods or the countryside by urself? Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fatehP Singh · 14 Feb 2005
panjab e shera di nassal, we are tlaking about Husband and Wife, not some Camp.shera di satt chamchey di ney! · 14 Feb 2005
how many shaheed singhs have we known to hold their singhanis hands in publics? respects to uk singh partly i agree in that situation i think anyone would comfort their wife that way, but i do not agree that its ok to just do that freely outside when you go uptown for the sake of it to show others we sikhs are in love. Your first love is meant to be waheguru, yes partner is special but thats behind in the privacy of your own house.Tony Singhprano · 14 Feb 2005
maybe a little off topic, but what about young/old men in india that freely walk the streets holding hands. is that alright ??? under your narrow definition these guys are a bunch of dandy boys when in reality their just friends holding hands is an innocent display (father and child, friends, husband and wife), it's actually ones own limitations that lowers it to a lustful act. Tony Singhpranosahajdhari · 14 Feb 2005
when you talk to a singh with high avastha, and you say singh you know soooo muchhhhhh what is the most common reply? "no no, singh i know nothing at all, i am a lost soul" why do they say this, because they do not want the vice of ego to grow, they will consider all simple compliments as sumthin that can hurt them as far as i see it holding hands is just asking for Kaam to grow, its a "small" thing to some ppl but these tiny things effect your bhagti, wife or not!!not just the elders · 14 Feb 2005
hey, who wants to traumatize little kids? i don't know what i would have done if i had seen my parents hold hands. gross me out.gkd · 15 Feb 2005
u knwo ur parents did much more then hold hands 2 concieve u rite?just in shock · 15 Feb 2005
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh I just have to say it- I have just been in a kind of shock since I read >Only be-sharam and be-haiya (shameless) people who have no respect for elder gursikhs would act this way< To me the act of holding hands is something innocent done out of affection, protection, like a mother or father and child brother or sister. When I hold my husbands hand it's a similar kind of affection for him as my long time companion and friend, like I am a child, we are two children, has nothing to do with anything which could be considered shameful-unless the mind of someone is so shameful that shameful thinking is all they know! Sometimes it's even because I get disoriented and need support to walk or I should stumble and fall. My father in law was an amputee and depended on his wife to help him walk. My grandmother used to lean on my arm in the same way.I often walked through town holding hands with my sister or brother. Whether physical or emotional it's a kind of support. I just feel outraged! I'm sorry I don't like this feeling but I see 2 men holding hands at gurudwara, or 2 little girls holding hands, Or a newly married couple. I never think anything about it. Why does someone have to think something bad or wrong is going on? It's not like teenager at a high school making out in public who need to get a room or something. I was absolutely horrified when I visited a a school one day!!! Why does anyone thnk that two people of any gender married or not touching in any way has to be some sort of lustful act. I just don't get this. I guess I just don't think that way and get shocked when I find out that other people, elder gursikhs or whoever, are thinking shameful things. If they think such shameful things can they be even be thought of as gursikhs? Age 52 Amritdharishera di satt chamchey di ney! · 15 Feb 2005
how many tyar pur tyar singhanis and singhs have you seen holding hands in public places to show their physical pyar? how many shaheeds do you know who do that? how many gurmukhs with avasta do you know who do that? how many chardi kala singhnis and singhs do you know who do that? how many mahan gursikhs of the past Bhai Randhir Singh, Sant Attar Singh, Sant Jarnail Singh, Baba Thakar Singh, and the rest did that? How many chardi kala sikhs aproove of this today? First the for holding hands team need to reinterpret their misconception that this perhaps is a view held by elders for cultural reasons to recognise that nearly all chardi kala singhs singhanis would say no to this. Find me one that says yes. Lets ask the bibis with rehat how they feel? and then the young sikhs with rehat? (count me out im the dust of the kookar of kookars). Lets put this question to settlement by asking the Panj pyarey. I would be happy with any answer they gave for i know they represent the maryada laid down by Guru ji. Taliban talk needs to change the record, then we could apply taliban to nearly everything because sikhi has a piri side ie the matta that was passed banning taking Guru Sahib to hotels and tables and chairs. If people do manmut things obviously thats wrong in Guru jis bana. If you want freedom from Guru Jis rehat then you must either correct the thinking level or not bring Guru Ji down to your own temporary mind level that is not fair. Sorry if i hurt anyone and i do not hold anything high and yes i would be the worlds biggest hypocrite but even hypocrites like me understand wearing bana and dressed as Guru jis sikhs and then taking amrit this is no game you physically and mentally give your head your mind belongs to God. If this game is hard i would suggest people spend longer preparing in deciding before they take amrit. I myself have not reached this stage but even i know you dont mess around you are projecting Guru sahib whereever you go you are the singhs singhanis of Guru Gobind Singh Ji.UK singhnee · 15 Feb 2005
Guru Fateh parvan Ji... Just to point out...do we not have bigger issues than this to face...for the sake of our next generation...does it really matter if two people hold hands or not? If they feel comfortable with it then fine...at the end of the day anyone who has the naam kamaee and Gursikhi jeevan has obviously done bhagti and nitnem rehat...so if they can get that going i am sure they can decide whether holding hands is right or wrong. If we spend so long thinking whether it is right or wrong we will suddenly wake up to realise that we are losing our youths. Bhul Chuk Maaf karni Moorakh Dasa narrow mind · 15 Feb 2005
I bet the majority of those who see 'holding hands' in public are not born in the west, but in places like india. They have been brought up in an environment were affection cannot be shown between husband and wife, only behind closed doors. Those who are born in the west, typically do not see this as such an outragous thing, because of the environment we were brought up in/around. Is it wrong for and singh and singhni to hold hands in public ? in my humble opinion, NO. But to me they are not doing the 'Bollywood' thing, its just affection for one another, not the public advertisement of their love, but seen through the eyes of some narrow minded folk, it is simply that... going off on a tanget, how are we to draw people into the khalsa panth, when we are making sikhi, into something it is not! My parents sometimes used to hold hands, when out in public, both being chardi-kala gursikhs, back in the late 1970's/80's in the UK. And both were born in the Punjab...and both to this day continue to do there sewa at the gurdwara, every weekend, like clock-work ...i do not feel they were 'ber-sharam' And the earlier comment by Kulbir Singh, re. photographs, quite honestly, what next... Punjab/India is overwhelmed with cases of sexual assult, rape, etc. becasue of this narrow minded thought process. We all think that sikhs in india are far away from sexual desires, but the reality is that they are over thrown by it... (just read the who's who of sants, and there behaviour.) To conclude, argue till your blue in the face, but we are trying to make sikhi into a fundamentalist dream world, which it was never intended to be. Gurfateh, Kulbir Singh Dhillon UK walasingh · 15 Feb 2005
Is holding hands a bujjer kurehat or is it a kulbir singh rule.Kulbir Singh · 15 Feb 2005
------------- Punjab/India is overwhelmed with cases of sexual assult, rape, etc. becasue of this narrow minded thought process. We all think that sikhs in india are far away from sexual desires, but the reality is that they are over thrown by it... (just read the who's who of sants, and there behaviour.) ------------- Kulbir Singh Dhillon (UK wale) jeeo, I disagree that there are overwhelming cases of sexual assault, rape etc in India because of so called narrow-mindedness there. The kind of weird sexual assault cases that have occurred in the West have nearly never happened in India. And there is no narrow-mindedness in not exhibiting love in public. What is the need to exhibit love in public? And when I was referring to holding hands, I did not mean that one cannot help or give hand to one's spouse who is sick or otherwise needs help in walking. What I meant was that the way modern Western couples romantically hold hands while walking is not an acceptable behaviour for gursikhs. Western couples also kiss in public and I know many modern Sikhs don’t mind even kissing in public. But the reality is that this is be-sharmee and be-haiyaayee. It is actually be-ghairatee. What did Guru-Baba jee mean when he said, “Sharam Dharam doye chhap khaloye, kooR phirae pardhaan, Ve Laalo”. Sharam and Dharam go hand in hand. Losing sharam is losing Dharam. Guru Sahib put these words together to show how important sharam is. It is not extremism to not support holding hands romantically in public. Such expressions of love should be done in private and not in public. to equate not supporting holding hands or kissing in public to Talibanism is appalling. What is next? It is irresponsible to label any sensible rehit or social etiquette to Talibanisim. Well, if supporters of holding hands and kissing in public label opposition as Talibanism, we can say that supporters are practicing Kanjarpuna. I rather be a Taliban than be a Kanjar. Would you come in front of Guru Sahib holding hands as Goray do? If not, then how is it acceptable to do it in front of Gursikhs and other sangat? What lesson would we be teaching our kids if we display such behaviour like holding hands, kissing in front of them? Daas, Kulbir SinghKulbir Singh · 15 Feb 2005
-------- Is holding hands a bujjer kurehat or is it a kulbir singh rule. --------- Is holding hands part of Naam Abhyaas for you? Or is this the Naam Abhyaas you do? Is holding hands part of rehit that you are so adamant on doing so? Daas, Kulbir SinghRK · 15 Feb 2005
i agree with the above comment that the disgusting stuff that happens in western countries almost never happens in Inida. Lets say this generation, becuase of their "open mindedness" says holding hands in public is ok, then the next generation will be like, why cant we kiss in public, its just innocent show of affection, and then the next generation will go on degenerating our values. Guru ji made a nyaaraa panth, which means we should stick to and embrace our uniqueness, instead of calling it narrowmindedness. I do not understand why some people are so bent on adopting the western culture, which is much inferior in its values and principles, into the sikh culture under the guise of openmindedness. If screwing up sikhi for the generatins to come is what constitutes openmindedness, then I would rather be narrowminded and keep my principles intact.united panjabi · 15 Feb 2005
"UK singhnee Date: 02-15-05 06:24 Guru Fateh parvan Ji... Just to point out...do we not have bigger issues than this to face...for the sake of our next generation...does it really matter if two people hold hands or not? If they feel comfortable with it then fine...at the end of the day anyone who has the naam kamaee and Gursikhi jeevan has obviously done bhagti and nitnem rehat...so if they can get that going i am sure they can decide whether holding hands is right or wrong. If we spend so long thinking whether it is right or wrong we will suddenly wake up to realise that we are losing our youths. Bhul Chuk Maaf karni Moorakh Das" singhni you have raised a very good post and i respect 99% of what you say. BUT sikhi will move on whether we loose our youths or not there should be no compromise as far as tapoban/jatha stands and this is why i think a lot of people took amrit in the jatha in the first place because of what it stood for. Bhai Randhir singh came did huge simran n seva and loadsa people became attracted like magnets and took amrit . We should not worry so much about numbers at thgis stage but about keeping that rehit alive to its rightful position or at the very minimum agreeing to it. Once we agree to it, then comes aspiring towards full rehit. Then with pyar and nimrata we try to follow sikhi as much as we can. Look at bhai sahib he didnt do christian missionary style preaching, people just came in touch with him and he lived the example and their souls were touched by his dedication and love for sikhi. By gaining numbers we can look at the largest group sgpc, but they will be the most affecetd and falling over the years because i do not believe spiritual seekers would want to eat meat, and real seekers would want to delve more into bani and naam. Youths are not being failed yes it is upto them and mature enough to decide. Whichever way they experience both situation they will either learn from their mistake or get even more distant but sikhi will carry ahead.united panjabi · 15 Feb 2005
kulbir singh dhillon valey no one is saying punjab is free from sex lust or anything of the kind but fact remains holding hands in gursikhi roop its not the done thing. if you believe some here to be trying to make sikhi into a fundamentalist dreamworld then paaji quiet frankly why dont you go and spend time with them and find out what they are bout before making accusations. My whole family are monnai, my dad drinks, my friends are monnai, i have not imposed anything on them. Please clarify your fundamantelist point more clearly. It would make sense for you to say that if some sikhs here having a problem with holding hands were actually impacting the youth to stop that to follow their own footsteps if holding hands was the normal thing in sikhi from day one but we are now trying to stop that. But history has prooved that sikhs did not hold hands publically, the great sikh shaheeds did not either, nor did any great sikh or sant or majority of sikhs from the early 20th century, i would like to study more about 19th and 18th century sikhs. So this being a recent thing can only mean one thing that it is creeping into sikhi by modernists. I am not saying it will impact your parents sikhi, or yours, but every situation, man woman and child, and household is different from yours. tapoban is committed to preserving Rehit that is why youths are inspired to come closer to it, if we wanted to hold hands we would have joined some hippy group. Uk born walaunited panjabi · 15 Feb 2005
kulbir singh dhillon valey no one is saying punjab is free from sex lust or anything of the kind but fact remains holding hands in gursikhi roop its not the done thing. if you believe some here to be trying to make sikhi into a fundamentalist dreamworld then paaji quiet frankly why dont you go and spend time with them and find out what they are bout before making accusations. My whole family are monnai, my dad drinks, my friends are monnai, i have not imposed anything on them. Please clarify your fundamantelist point more clearly. It would make sense for you to say that if some sikhs here having a problem with holding hands were actually impacting the youth to stop that to follow their own footsteps if holding hands was the normal thing in sikhi from day one but we are now trying to stop that. But history has prooved that sikhs did not hold hands publically, the great sikh shaheeds did not either, nor did any great sikh or sant or majority of sikhs from the early 20th century, i would like to study more about 19th and 18th century sikhs. So this being a recent thing can only mean one thing that it is creeping into sikhi by modernists. I am not saying it will impact your parents sikhi, or yours, but every situation, man woman and child, and household is different from yours. tapoban is committed to preserving Rehit that is why youths are inspired to come closer to it, if we wanted to hold hands we would have joined some hippy group. Uk born wala [%sig%]united panjabi · 15 Feb 2005
kulbir singh dhillon valey no one is saying punjab is free from sex lust or anything of the kind but fact remains holding hands in gursikhi roop its not the done thing "in public"funktehpunkhaijunkbunjamonk · 15 Feb 2005
all those who think its ok to hug kiss hold hands in public ask yourselves when you took amrit what were the reasons you took it? how far did you research before you took amrit? the" taliban fundamental traditional punjabiat" finger pointing can be put the other way to the whitewashed with their own reformist agendas in the form of " innocent affection" BUT WE HAVE NOT BLAMED YOU. It is upto you your choice what you choose to do and how you behave but since the question has been raised on a site that actively encourages tat gurmat its sangat are bound to resonate a gurmat response whether its liked or disliked. It can only be fundamnetalist in nature if it is being pushed onto you but it is not, when you walk away its your choice what you do in your life you cant blame others. Tapoban does not have a magical miri piri raj over sikhs worldwide does it now? its a jathebandi dedicated to promoting sikhi. If its not liked well what can we do? life goes onpavan · 15 Feb 2005
I think that you are all wasting ur time over small things when u culd b doing something more useful such as seva. [%sig%]Gupt Singh · 15 Feb 2005
Its discraseful... what would you think if you saw a amritdhari couple who have adopted full rahat holdin hands? Holding hands causes negative thoughts. Why would you hold hand with any one else, when your true husband is the lord, waheguru, waheguru, waheguru,,,Admin · 15 Feb 2005
Topic now closed. Admin.