Putting of ashes of the dead at Kartarpur in Punjab is anti-Gurmatt !!
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Feb 2005
IS it per Gurmat to go to Patalpure/Ganga river/ KARTARPUR in Punjab to aasthhian paan jaana of a dead person ( ashes of dead persons) ??
The Sikh Rehat maryada is very very clear on this. The ashes of a dead person are to be put in running water nearest to his place of residence or even buried at a suitable palce but with no grave/headstone/marrhi etc.
ANY one who goes against this REHAT MARADA is a TANKHIYAH.
Recently the ashes of Yogi harbhjan Singh of USA were taken to Patalpure Kartarpur..and the top Jathedars of Punjab were there..arrent they all tankhiyag=hs for participating in an anti gurmatt action.
Ramkali Sadd in Guru garnth Ji clearly says:
aMqy siqguru boilaf, mY ipCY kIrqnu kirahu inrbfxu jIAu ] kyso gopfl pMizq sidahu, hir hir kQf pVih purfxu jIAu ] hir kQf pVIaY, hir nfmu suxIaY, bybfxu, hir rMgu gur Bfvey ] ipMzu pqil ikiraf dIvf Pul, hir sir pfvey ] hir Bfieaf siqguru boilaf, hir imilaf purKu sujfxu jIAu ] rfmdfs soZI iqlku dIaf, gur sbdu scu nIsfxu jIAu ]5] {pMnf 923}
AAnte satgur boliah..mein pichheh KIRTAN karioh nirbaan jeeo, Keso Gopal pandit sadiah HAR HAR KATHA pariah puraan jeeo, Har katha pariah, Har naam sunneah, Har rang har Bhaveh… PIND PATIL KIRIYAH DEEVA FULL..HAR SAR PAVEH..
Guur Ji is telling us to IMMERSE ourselves in the HAR SAR of SADH SANGAT….instead of doing all those Hindu rites of patal kiriah deeva ashes in hardwar etc. Guur Ji says HARDWAAR is HAR SAR – SADH SANGAT.
Interestingly, even though PIND, PATAL, KIRIAH, DEEVA and FULL are mentioned in this TUK….the people concerned ONLY Take “ FULL” (ashes) to so called harsar BUT NOT the PIND DEEVA etc also mentioned in the same tuk ?? I wonder why ??
This taking of ashes to PUNJAB is GHOR MANMATT…..not sanctioned in GURBANI and BANNED by the SIKH REHAT MARYADA…YET Sikhs especially in the WEST ( not a single case from Malaysia/Singapore has been heard of yet) spend millions on this useless act..even being IDOLISED in Bollywood pictures like VEER ZAARA. Anything bollywood idolizes is BAD for SIKHI and this act of ashes carrying is certainly a BAD act.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Putting of ashes of the dead at Kartarpur in Punjab is anti-Gurmatt !!
Manpreet Kaur · 11 Feb 2005
WHY do we put the ashes into running water?
Re: Putting of ashes of the dead at Kartarpur in Punjab is anti-Gurmatt !!
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 12 Feb 2005
so that they all float away...leaving "no trace"...
The whole idea is that NO TRACE remains.. for "worship", "remebrance" etc like the Muslims christians do at their Graves stones... For a SIKH the only remebrance is of his good deeds...not hsi physical ashes/bones etc.
Jarnail singh
Re: Putting of ashes of the dead at Kartarpur in Punjab is anti-Gurmatt !!
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 12 Feb 2005
bhenji ( jka)...
there is no need to throw around inuendos..chori chori..
I have many students who are NOT 100% Mind controlled/brainwashed/monitored/ by me so that they DONT watch any Bollywood Movies..and when they come to class they do ASK questions and we answer them....so that HOW I "KNOW" exactly what happens in Each and Every bollywood ( and other) movies as well. IMHO bollywood is still "EVIL" as it is always 100% AGAINST Sikhi/GURMATT...
Chori Chori..hdiding behid aliases is bad and evil. Khallsa ji vichaars SHAREH AAM..in Malaysia as well as every where else...even watching bollywood evil !!! NO FEAR of anyone as Khalsa Ji is never afraid.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Putting of ashes of the dead at Kartarpur in Punjab is anti-Gurmatt !!
Kulwinder Singh · 13 Feb 2005
Dear Gyani Ji,
Why making Jatha of "Yogi harbhjan Singh of USA" target ?
the Gurdawara you are mentioning is in Punjab & Controlled by SGPC, and they follow directions from Akal Takhat, are you against Akal Takhat ? Or Akal Takhat is wrong now in your eyes?
or are you against "Yogi harbhjan Singh of USA’s Jatha" ?
If that was Harbhajan Singhs intention to send his family to India even one more time using this excuse, or he felt so much love for his mother land that he wanted even his Ash to go their, or he had his own reasons to do that, What give you the right to incite people to declare some others TANKHIYAH, Does Sikhi permote witch Hunt ? Have no room for compassion ? and either you are perfect ( you actually may be perfect, I am not being scarcastic I know you have great knowledge of Sikhi from your writings and also you teach Gurbani to Students , even then I am entitled to ask you questions where I feel it is questionable) even then does Sikhi give you right to show others down ? and should you be concentrating on pin pointing others actions ? unless you have received some authorisation from somewhere ? what is your final Aim of rising this question ? Unity of Khalsa Penth or Segregation of a Jetha ?
If you just wanted to raise the issue you could have done in general terms, that is why some people take ashes to Punjab ? is it against Gurumat ? or in your way “ It is against Gurumat and we should not do this”, without implicating some other individual or a Jatha.
What about: Jan Nanak Tur Manage Tis Gurusikh Ki Jo Aap Jape Awra Nam Japie"
I do not know about you Gayni Ji but Harbhajan Singh Ji connected much more non Sikhs to Gurubani then myself. So all I have for him in my heart is love, if he ever did anything wrong (not evil) that is between him and God, for me I should only see the Mohar of Guru on his head and face and show my respect just like Bahi Kehnia Ji showed even to Muslims enemies who was fighting against Guru Ji not against a good Sikh ( But Guru Gobind Singh Ji himself, I am sure you do realise the magnitude of this history have for Sikhs)I have nothing but love for any Gurusikh regardless of their status or services although no body dispute Harbhajan Singh contribution( I know there are differences over practices and methods).
Why we are so interested in showing others down, rather then uplifting ourselves, why don't you take inspiration or challenge that you are going to connect more, much more non Sikh people with Gurubani then Harbhjan Singh Ji did, I will love you even more then, I just find it sad that person like you, who have so much knowledge of Gurubani still end up in showing others down rather then saying, Every Sikh is from my real family (father Guru Gobind Singh Ji Family) and we love each other and cover each other in public and caution each other in private if we have something negative to say about.
Why Gurusikhs who are taught in Amrit Sanchar to face each other, sit together and hold the Baata in magnificently balanced way supporting each other, fail to sit still when according to their interpretation other do something wrong, especially when we are told that we are not Judes and should behave in humble way throughout life and turn blind eye to other misdeeds.
Please Gyani Ji explain to me am I wrong to crying over the unity in Sikhism, When I see these kind of showing down of each other, it really brake my heart.
Re: Putting of ashes of the dead at Kartarpur in Punjab is anti-Gurmatt !!
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Feb 2005
waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
First of all I welcome any criticism....i am far from perfect. ONLY GURU JI is all perfect..and I am a dust at Guru ji's Lotus feet.
I am NOT declaring anyone TANKHIYAH. This is DONE by the SIKH REHAT MARYADA.
Please refer to :
Rehat Maryada Sikh Code of Conduct and Conventions
Article XIX - Funeral Ceremonies a. The body of a dying or dead person, if it is on a cot, must not be taken off the cot and put on the floor. Nor must a lit lamp be placed beside, or a cow got bestowed in donation by, him/her or for his/her good or any other ceremony, contrary to Guru’s way, performed. Only Gurbani should be recited or “Waheguru, Waheguru” repeated by his/her side. b. When some one shuffles the mortal coil, the survivors must not grieve or raise a hue and cry or indulge in breast beating. To induce a mood of resignation to God’s will, it is desirable to recite Gurbani or repeat “Waheguru”. c. However young and deceased may be, the body should be cremated. However, where arrangements for cremation cannot be made, there should be no qualm about the body being immersed in flowing water or disposed of in any other manner. d. As to the time of cremation, no consideration as to whether it should take place during day or night should weigh. e. The dead body should be bathed and clothed in clean clothes. While that is done, the Sikh symbols - comb, kachha, karha, kirpan - should not be taken off. Thereafter, putting the body on a plank, Ardas about its being taken away for disposal be offered. The hearse should then be lifted and taken to the cremation ground; hymns that induce feeling of detachment should be recited. On reaching the cremation ground, the pyre should be laid. Then the Ardas for consigning the body to fire be offered. The dead body should then be placed on the pyre and the son or any other relation or friend of the deceased should set fire to it. The accompanying congregation should sit at a reasonable distance and listen to kirtan or carry on collective singing of hymns or recitation of detachment-inducing hymns. When the pyre is fully aflame, the Kirtan Sohila (prescribed pre-retirement night Scriptural prayer) should be recited and the Ardas offered. (Piercing the Skull half and hour or so after the pyre has been burning with a rod or something else in the belief that that will secure the release of the soul - kapal kriya - is contrary to the Guru’s tenets). The congregation should then leave. Coming back home, a reading of the Guru Granth Sahib should be commenced at home or in a nearby gurdwara, and after reciting the six stanzas of the Anand Sahib, the Ardas, offered and karhah prashad (sacred pudding) distributed. The reading of the Guru Granth Sahib should be completed on the tenth day. If the reading cannot, or is sought not to, be completed on the tenth day, some other day may be appointed for the conclusion of the reading having regard to the convenience of the relatives. The reading of the Guru Granth Sahib should be carried out by the members of the household of the deceased and relatives in cooperation. If possible, Kirtan may be held every night. No funeral ceremony remains to be performed after the “tenth day”. f. When the pyre is burnt out, the whole bulk of the ashes, including the burnt bones should be gathered up and immersed in flowing water or buried at that very place and the ground leveled. Raising a monument to the memory of the deceased at the place where his dead body is cremated is taboo. g. Adh marg (the ceremony of breaking the pot used for bathing the dead body amid doleful cries half way towards the cremation ground), organized lamentation by women, foorhi (sitting on a straw mat in mourning for a certain period), diva (keeping an oil lamp lit for 360 days after the death in the belief that that will light the path of the deceased), pind (ritual donating of lumps of rice flour, oat flour, or solidified milk (khoa) for ten days after death), kirya (concluding the funeral proceedings ritualistically, serving meals and making offerings by way of shradh, budha marna (waving of whisk, over the hearse of an old person’s dead body and decorating the hearse with festoons), etc. are contrary to the approved code. So too is the picking of the burnt bones from the ashes of the pyre for immersing in the Ganga, at Patalpuri (at Kiratpur), at Kartarpur Sahib or at any other such place. -
Now refer to: Article XXIV - Ceremony of Baptism or Initiation
TANKHAYIAHS: NUMBER 7: below...(.q. ) The following individuals shall be liable to chastisement involving automatic boycott: 1. Anyone maintaining relations or communion with elements antagonistic to the Panth including the minas (reprobates), the masands (agents once accredited to local Sikh communities as Guru’s representatives, sine discredited for their faults and aberrations), followers of Dhirmal or Ram Rai, etc. users of tobacco or killers of female infants. 2. One who eats/drinks leftovers of the unbaptised or the fallen Sikhs 3. One who dyes his beard 4. One who gives off son or daughter in matrimony for a price or reward 5. Users of intoxicant (hemp, opium, liquor, narcotics, cocaine, etc.) 6. One holding, or being a party to, ceremonies or practices contrary to the Guru’s way 7. One who defaults in the maintenance of Sikh discipline. THESE TANKHIYAHS have to beg forgiveness from the PUNJ.
As you can see clearly PATALPUREE, KIRATPUR, KARTARPUR SAHIB are CLEARLY MENTIONED as NOT to GO TO for immersion of ASHES. ANYONE who does so is TANKHIYAH under Number 7 of artilce XXIV listed above.
Also ADDITIONALLY SACRED GURBANI of ramkali Sadd AAng 923 GURU JI SPECIFICALLY FORBIDS THESE ACTS as well.
Now YOU tell me, can the so called "wish" of a SIKH be to immerse his "ashes" in the Motherland be still VALID even though it VIOLATES GURBANI/SIKH REHAT MARYADA ??
I am NOT against HS Yogi or his Jatha or anybody. BUT I also WRITE without FEAR or FAVOUR to anyone big or small. HS YOGI is "HIgh PROFILE"..whatever actions he/his jatha takes..MILLIONS of His SIKHS will FOLLOW..and Justify as YOU have DONE above. This means that "if" one is HS Yogi, if one ahs made millions of Sikhs...then ONE has the RIGHT to GO AGAINST GURBANI..BREAK the CODE of REHAT MARYADA ??? Am i right this is what you are saying ??
Are you aware that EVEN GURU GOBIND SINGH JI Himself "tested" His KHALSA JI and its commitment to His REHAT by bowing to a Muslim pir's Grave with His TEER..GURU JI was IMMEDIATELY HAULED UP by the KHALSA, PRONOUNCED GUILTY and TANKHIYAH and FINED. GURU JI ACCEPTED HIS "PUNISHMENT"..Maharaja Ranjit Singh broke the REHAT..HE WAS tied to a Tree Trunk in PUBLIC in Amrtisar and LASHED 20 lashes on his naked back by AKAL TAKHAT JATHEDAR Akali Foola Singh Ji. I am sure you are NOT SAYING HS YOGI is BIGGER than Maharaja Ranjit singh And GURU GOBIND SINGH JI ( because he led millions of sikhs ) ?? Pleae JUSTIFY HS YOGIS wish to have his ashes immersed at KIRATPUR at ANY COST..even break rehat/VIOLATE GURBANI.
Veer Ji, i am just "writing" ...on a computer and that is nothing great !!!! Akali Phoola Singh Ji had the MORAL COURAGE to LASH the MAHARAJA SHERE PUNJAB IN PUBLIC...the KHALSA JI had the MORAL COURAGE to SANCTION GURU JI.... DO you have what it takes to justify Harbahjan Singh YOGI RIGHT and PROVE ME WRONG ??
I AM DEFENDING AKAL TAKHAT MARYADA...how can i possibly be "agaisnt Akal Takhat" as you put it ?? What I wrote above is in the SGPC /AKAL TAKHAT MARYADA.....and Harbahajn Singh YOgi VIOLATED this Maryada....and in your eyes HE is RIGHT and I am WRONG ???Ashkay jayeeah veer Ji... you ask me for compassion ?? you say i am on a witch hunt ?? Wah wah Wah Ji....Nalleh chor nalleh chatrayee ?? HS YOGI BREAKS the CODE, Violates GURBANI,....and I am "wrong", "anti-Akal takhat, Anti-Sgpc" anti- Yogi's Jatha...etc etc....have "no compassion..." am witch hunting ??
I am painfully aware that there have been thousands of "small fry" sikhs who have done EXACTLY what HS Yogi has done....and got away with it...but then small fry are just that small fry...and who knows they may have already begged forgiveness for their mistakes....BUT when a SRI SINGH SAHIB HARBHAJAN SINGH JI KHALSA YOGI MINISTER OF the WESTERN HEMISPHERE, Leader of Millions....VIOLATES GURBANI, VIOLATES the REHAT ??? it is criminal to close "one " or BOTH EYES. I am TRUE to MY GURU, HIS REHAT and HIS GURBANI.
Please show me where I am WRONG and MY HUMBLEST APOLOGY will be returned that Very INSTANT. I am awaiting.....
Jarnail Singh
Re: Putting of ashes of the dead at Kartarpur in Punjab is anti-Gurmatt !!
Kulwinder Singh · 15 Feb 2005
Dear Gyani Ji ,
First of all I must say that disagreeing with you and Kulbir Singh Ji does make me very sad, I know why I am sad it is not my humbleness or anything it is just a fact that you two have very high level of Jivean and I am no way near to both your shoes dust. but If I lose to you both then even it is my real gain because I feel privileged to have even engagement with you two, please believe me it is not fake humbleness it is true pride to have discussion with people of your calibure.
Now back to the point of discussion. I wrote 13 Questions as below,
1. Why making Jatha of "Yogi harbhjan Singh of USA" target ?
2. are you against Akal Takhat ?
3. Or Akal Takhat is wrong now in your eyes?
4. or are you against "Yogi harbhjan Singh of USA’s Jatha" ?
5. Does Sikhi per mote witch Hunt ?
6. Have no room for compassion ?
7. does Sikhi give you right to show others down ?
8. and should you be concentrating on pin pointing others actions ?
9. you have received some authorisation from somewhere ?
10. what is your final Aim of rising this question ?
11. Unity of Khalsa Penth or Segregation of a Jetha ?
12. What about: Jan Nanak Tur Manage Tis Gurusikh Ki Jo Aap Jape Awra Nam
Japie"
13. Please Gyani Ji explain to me am I wrong to crying over the unity in Sikhism, When I see these kind of showing down of each other, it really brake my heart.
And you have splendidly answered the 1, 2, 3,4,5,6,7,9 which is above 60 % and I genuinely thank you for that, and special thanks for forwarding the copy of code in the discussion related to the issue.
My dear Arshi Ji you have written
“DO you have what it takes to justify Harbahjan Singh YOGI RIGHT and PROVE ME WRONG ?? “
I do not think I have what it take to prove you wrong, I am not saying again for some humbleness but for facts as given below.
1. you are qualified in Sikh Scriptures (you are qualified Gyani) .
2. your Jiven is much higher then mine( no chaploosy but Fact )
3. You are much more well read then I am ( again no fake praise but fact)
4. you have far more experience of dealing with these issues then I do. It is an estimated “guess” but I am 99.99999 % sure.
5. You probably have far more access to learning material on Sikhi then I do. ( this is an estimated guess then fact as I have no knowledge on your collection but I am sure it is much better then mine).
I want to make clear that I do not do Puch Puch or fake parsing or Chaploosy to anybody when I compliment you , they are based on my observations rather then fake humbleness, and I will not dare to do any fake praise my dear Guru Sikhs. For me their no better challenge then challenging your own loved ones in loving way and when you lose to them it is again a pleasure and you always learn out of challenges.
But I will still attempt to give my best shot at proving my point.
Gyani Ji I looked on the internet to have Punjabi version of the text you have mentioned but the SGPC’s site’s Punjabi version is not working so I looked on the Encarta ‘s definition of (as I wanted to elaborate on Immersing) Immers..
immerse (immersing )
.
.1 completely cover something in liquid: to put something into a liquid so that the liquid’s surface covers it completely
2. transitive verb christianity baptize somebody: to baptize somebody by lowering the person’s head and upper body, or sometimes the whole body, into water
3. vr occupy yourself totally with something: to become completely occupied with something, giving all your time, energy, or concentration to it
I think in the context of the code of sikhi the 2nd definition is the valid one as it does synchronise with the average Joe blog’s perception of Gangs and so on..
I agree on the basis that if somebody think that by putting their ashes into Ganga, Kartarpur or patalpuri it is going to benefit dead or live for doing just that practice/ ritual, then it is a false and against the Gurumat, but I believe if somebody do it just as it give them excuse to go and do darshan of that Gurdawara, also keeping firm belief that it is not going to help the live or dead by this ceremony then it is ok, I am not sure but would like to know from your prospective. I will expend on that after your reply.
Also the point I made in the post was that the Gurdawara mentioned in your email is run by SGPC and as you know that the SGPC follow the advise of Akal Takhat then why they accommodate these things if they are as you mentioned in your reply ( I am flexible at this moment to consider that, going to these Gurdawaras and having the strong and clear understanding that this is not ritual or some ceremony which is going to help the dead of live then it is ok). I think some responsibility lies with the SGPC too, if you are right. My understanding would be if somebody want to go their, then SGPC should let them, but do not say or do something which can indicate and contradict the Code.
I am well aware of the Maharaja Ranjit Singh’ episode and Guru Gobind Singh Ji’s testing of Khalsa, they are both very valuable lesson from our Glories history, Both episodes reflect that prime value is humbleness and Discipline is very important to Sikhs. And both of these event shows us that even when you are very powerful and hold such a status you should be open to criticism and punishment where ever applicable and after the paying dues and truly regretting and remorse, you are fully allowed to participate as normal. Also Maharaja Ranjit Singh Ji’s episode was symbolic too, otherwise Maharaja Ranjit Singh did other thing which could be described as against Gurmat, which was never challenged.
To my question regarding compassion you have given your opinion, now my opinion is that many times in Sikh history and Literature comes references to where Guru Ji kept the dignity of Sikhs, and covered their awguns and blessed them, ignoring their faults, so how come we do not want to forgive people regardless of their status. Bhai Datu ji kicked Guru Amar Das Ji and did Guru Ji said anything to them ? nothing at all, country to that showed humbleness to ask if they got hurt while kicking Guru Ji. Now that is humbleness in true sense. Guru Gobind Singh Ji said to his Sikhs to be on guard at night and some of them went to see the Dance and drama in the village and those who went got worried that Guru Sahib Ji is Jani Jan and they will not be happy, and those who stayed was gutted to think they should have gone to enjoy, you know the rest of the story so I leave it to you what was Guru Ji’s reaction, should we not learn anything from our history when it come to compassion ?
I said “Does Sikhi permote witch Hunt ? “ and you explained your reasons for bringing HS Yogi in question context, but I feel Guru Gobind Singh Ji is ultra mega compassionate and he does have heart to forgive HS yogi if he made mistakes, My heart says that I do not know for sure If that is how I should feel but that is normally I feel for any Sikh regardless of their status. I think singling out somebody who done so much good regardless of our differences in practice and methods, it feel like witch hunt, when rather then showing respect and compassion you want to tarnish their status even if they made mistakes.
You have said “ and in your eyes HE is RIGHT and I am WRONG ??? “ I do not think that is the case, I said they may have made mistake and you should show compassion, and you are saying,
“Ashkay jayeeah veer Ji... you ask me for compassion ?? you say i am on a witch hunt ?? Wah wah Wah Ji....Nalleh chor nalleh chatrayee ?? HS YOGI BREAKS the CODE, Violates GURBANI,....and I am "wrong", "anti-Akal takhat, Anti-Sgpc" anti- Yogi's Jatha...etc etc....have "no compassion..." am witch hunting ??
and this above writing make as I mm some how contradicting that on one hand I am asking for compassion and on the other I am saying are you on witch hunt and that is suppose to be contradictory? Vir Ji if I am asking for compassion then it show that the other party may be guilty and that is the reason I asked for compassion why on earth I would ask for compassion, the witch hunt is mentioned by me as the Gurdawara you have mentioned does accommodate these things to happen which in my view are done for simply visit the temple as excuse rather then some ritual or ceremony which some how can help dead or living in any sense. If you see from the point of view of a Gurmat it says flowing water , does this include normal house hold sink there is a flowing water ? and City’s gutters are always flowing better then some rivers in India or else ware.
I do not see any contradiction if just simply going to a particular Gurdawara without believing that in any ritual or ceremony which is going to help dead or live is against Gurmat.
You have said” SRI SINGH SAHIB HARBHAJAN SINGH JI KHALSA YOGI MINISTER OF the WESTERN HEMISPHERE, Leader of Millions....VIOLATES GURBANI, VIOLATES the REHAT ??? it is criminal to close "one " or BOTH EYES. I am TRUE to MY GURU, HIS REHAT and HIS GURBANI.
I think the status Singh Sahib is granted by Akal Takhat Sahib Ji so that is well earned I feel, Minister of Western Hemisphere ? that I believe is your given status and also well earned ( I mean truly). Leader of Millions.. . I do not think he ever said that ?
Violates Gurbani, Violates the Rehat ?? To my knowledge he been to Akal Takhat Sahib many times why he was never charged with above mentioned allegations of yours? .
Gyani Ji I truly love you for “I am TRUE to MY GURU, HIS REHAT and HIS GURBANI. And I can not say a single letter against that. I can only add something to that how about also loving the Sikhs of this Guru too they are his family members too.
Guru Granth Sahib ji says many time that GOD forgive endless times, he do not even look at our avguns and never stop his blessing form touching us, how come believer of this GOD, look at others specially to those who motivated people towards the right path of HIM, to draw attention of others to somebody’s short comings, sound strange to me although I am open to your wise words.
Also Gyani Ji you have not answered my question no 8, 10,11,12 13 and I will like you to reply to them to as they are the part of this discussion.
If I got impressed with your view then by default that I will apologies for brining your compassion in question ? and additional apologies if I feel I owe them to you.
Looking forward to your reply
Kulwinder Singh
Re: Putting of ashes of the dead at Kartarpur in Punjab is anti-Gurmatt !!
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh...
Dearest veer Kulwinder Singh jio,
First of all I am not all that "gyani" "humble" "ucha jiwan" etc..Guru Ji alone knows how much more Painda I have before I reach those destinations..but your pyaar has won you even more place in my heart than ever before ( after reading all those replies from you on other threads )..you are a genuine Gursikh and I am proud to be communicating with you. ( like Veer Kulbir singh ji said..I would rather have you with us than agianst us..) Never for a moment even think that all this "learning process" is one way....I also have learnt a lot of things from you and will continue to do so..no "empty words" here from my side as well.
Now let me frist tackle the questions you posed which i failed to answer the first time. Q. 8..Should I be concentrating on pin pointing other's actions.
To me there are two ways of discussing an action....one is take the "general approach"..where no one is mentioned and the other "mention" cases with specifics, especially high profile ones for impact. This may be taken as "picking" on people, pointing out their faults. I have found that where "no one is mentioned"...it has little impact as everyone just "looks" at each other and guesses who is being hinted at. In Guur Amardass ji's time, there was a Tappa who was a FRAUD...behaving very jealously agaisnt the Guru Ghar, doing all the wrong things, like being holy outdise..and evil inside...Guru Ji's Bani shows that guru Ji did the Direct Approach and uncoverd this tappa and what exactly he was doing. If we read Sikh history and Gurbani there are always two approaches...when Guur Ji was kicked in open court by Dattu ji....Guru Ji took one appraoch..in the case of the Tappa..Guru Ji took the second approach. Guru Arjun Ji took the approach of Shanti..Guru hargobind Ji took the bull by the horns. This is my view of things...Guru Ji forgive me if i am wrong. We can go on and on saying things like "doing this is not as per Sikh rehat maryada..blah blah..and no body actually cares as no one is pointed out....until one points at a person and say: That is the person doing wrong....that is what we shouldnt do. Now if that "allegation" is false..then it is both wrong and ninda..but if the "allegation" results in a change in behaviour of others who come to realsie that it is not all "imaginary" but real people do real wrongs..then they might be affected differently. Just take the example of Guur Ji again... Guur Amardass ji "forgave" Dattu ji for KICKING HIM.... fair and square as this was PHYSICAL KICKING of GURU ji's BODY..and GURU Ji is Compassionate and Kind...But then Fast Forward to GURU HAR RAI JI....and look at the Action of Guur ji as concerns his Beloved SON RAM RAI, who " did not KICK" Guru Ji as datu ji did..but worse than that "Ram Rai KICKED GURBANI by changing it to please the emperor and earn his praise. Guru Har Rai ji....commanded his son never to FACE GURU JI again...and NEVER FORGAVE Ram rai. Why this altogether "different" attitude..Because Guur Ji didnt take any offense at someone kicking him..BUT anyone who OFFENDS GURBANI/GURMATT is striking at the very roots of Sikhi and cannot be as easily forgiven as dattu Ji was. Can we now turn around and say Guru Har rai ji had "no compassion"/couldnt forgive ?? No veer we cannot have 'compassion" for anyone who goes agaisnt GURBANI. THIS IS MY AIM and it also covers Q 10.
Q 11/12. UNITY of GURU KHALSA PANTH is more dear to me than my own life itself...but what does "unity" mean ? Some take "unity" as saying Dont say anything "against" anybody...it will hurt them..it will then hurt panth unity..in other words close one eye. For me Unity means following the One Sikh rehat maryada, One GURU Granth ji, .....and IF any group condones anything that goes AGAINST GURBANI and SRM....then it is wrong in my view. Jan Nanak DHURR mangeh Tis GURSIKH Kee... is absolutley right..I too look for such Dhurr of Gurskhs who Do naam japp and Japaa the Naam to others...any Gursikh who truly follows Gurbani. Here i must say that i used the Title Sri Singh Sahib..for Harbhajan Singh ji Yogi precisely because it is bestowed by Sri Akal Takhat. The second Title minister of western Hemisphere I have seeon on his Jatha webistes...and Leader of Millions..is MY "considered" opinion ( and not attributed to Harbhajan singh ji)..as I have been very impressed by what he did for Sikhi in the west. There must be at least a few million American Sikhs that he brought into Sikhi...all the more important that his family should do EXACTLY as GURBANI says so that RITUALS dont get a chance to grow and prosper in His following ( I fervently hope thy dont become a "jatha of HS Yogi" but become a Part of the Guru Khalsa Panth only.) There were TEN physical GURUS..BUT they all promoted JUST "NANAK"..and Now we Have GURU GRANTH JI/GURBANI... we should ideally JUST PROMOTE GURU GRANTH JI/GURBANI. ( see how even today people try to "separate" the Gurus and say i am "follower" of Guru Nanak ji ONLY, "I am follower of Guur Ram Dass ji only...etc etc in spite of the fact that the Gurus all only promoted ONE NANAK... so if anyone says I am a follower of "HSyogi only" that would be wrong in my view.. We all are SIKHS of GURU KHALSA PANTH ONLY.
Gurbani has already clearly defined that this human body..when DEAD/separated from its Soul..is just a piece of dead meat...some are burnt, some are buried..some get eaten by DOGS ( and wild animals, crows, vultures..whatever..)..on a dead person you can put amrit/perfumes..no use..you can heap dirt..no use either...so you can come to your own conclusion about flowing water of sinks, drains, rivers canals. GURBANI clealry DOESNT PLACE an IOTA of "value" on the ashes....but our own "MOH" MAYA" does this..our culture/society friends relatives..do impose a HUGE VALUE on the dead body and its ashes..( I am no different..before my late dad died he had specifically told us to DO EXACTLY as Ramkali Sadd says on AAng 923....so when he actually died we had no problems with performing Kirtan non stop so loud that no "lady" dared to cry/wail..no one was permitted to matha tek/etc and put any chadraan khes as we ourselves didnt do it..just a simple white cloth gathra kirpan etc and a garland of flowers that his dearest friend brought....and at his saskaar we did gurbani paath continuously all three days, collected his ashes and went to the nearest flowing river... a lot of older relatives and friends tried to say do this and do that we just disregarded all..but i know the "fight" we had doing that)..BUT the point is that the MORE we rely on doing EXACTLY what GURBANI tells us the LESS and lESS we will have the rituals etc...but if we give prominence to RITUALS..then i will tell you that Rituals have a way of GROWING like weeds....each time there is soemthing new that "MUST" be done. ( people used to quote us..saying but the Gyani's sons DIDNT DO ANY SUCH THING...like going thorugh the ashes for bones, washing them in milk, etc etc..so it cant be gurmatt....and when they go to another funeral...and they come back...these same people will "remind" the youngsters..Eh beta..Where is the MILK?? didnt you know we have to wash the bones..look for every small bone..cannot fo this and cannot forget that etc etc..you MUST have NEW batta, new baltee for the milk, RED Cloth for this..etc etc..and THROW away the baltee/battas etc because cannot re use dead person's things !! We didnt Chhrrra clothes bistra etc at the Gurdwra..and a few people after that followed suit...but just one funeral where the people chhrra expensive bistra bhandeh etc..and everybody started doing that again..!!! RITUALS do grow like weeds.)
In the statement that "HS YOGI" violates Rehat..etc MY APOLOGY if that is misunderstood. I mean that HIS FAMILY and His jatha violated GURBANI ?REHAT by taking his ashes to immerse at kirat pur when this is specifically prohibited ( and I have been made to understand that this was instructed by Yogi ji before he passed away..and he did it for "love " of his motherland. imho, the love for the mother land could have been shown by distributing the ashes from aeroplane all over India just as Nehru's ashes were done. I am aware that the gurdwara is run by SGPC and many of the top Brass of SGPC were also there. This in no way ABSOLVES anybody. The SGPC allows violation of its Own Maryada by allowing JYOTS at Akal takhat and Harmandir sahib, its own jathedars are sacked and appointed at will by the politicians, it allows many wrong things that directly VIOLATE GURBANI also...that is a different equation alltogether...so the "presence" of the sgpc jathedars, sgpc gurdwara etc doesnt make this right and as per Gurbani.)
Q 13. You couldnt be more RIGHT...and I am all for this Unity in the Guru Khalsa Panth. IF I am WRONG in pointing out the mistakes of others and this makes for "disunity"..and GURU JI forgive me for this..but i dont beleive that sweeping things under the carpet improves unity in any way. the faster anyone is reminded of his shortcomings. the faster he should improve and give no quarter for any more criticism. Get the "criticism" corrected instead of shooting the messenger. ( I dont mind getting SHOT). IT breaks my heart too...when i see things happening that are anti gurbani/anti gurmatt..and Guru ji forgive me..this is the only way i know of trying to draw attention to these...even though it makes me many enemies/detractors..i persevere. Maybe you are not aware, I have all the lectures, video tapes, etc that HS Yogi's jatha/Organisation prepared of his sermons, speeches, discourses. They were sent to me FRee of Charge by one Shanti kaur Khalsa years ago and I use them for my Gurbani religious classes...WHAT is RIGHT i call RIGHT and have been doing so for decades..What HS Yogi did is beyond comparison and i have no hesitation in saying this.. and GURU JI in His infinte Mercy will look after his departed servant.....and my students know that i dont "put anyone down" just for the fun of it...I write what i fervently beleive in myself.
In conclusion let me say that this has been a very "profitable" discussion for me. I have more "pyaar" for you than before..and fervently hope that you will take all this in the spirit that i wrote it and lets progress together on the path of the GURUS we love so much. None of us is beyond reproach, and I extend my sincerest apology if anything i said hurt your feelings.
Love for all
Bhul Chuk maaf jarnail Singh
Re: Putting of ashes of the dead at Kartarpur in Punjab is anti-Gurmatt !!
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Feb 2005
waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh
Veer Kulwinder Singh Ji,
You never got back to me about reading the Sikh Rehat maryada. In the Punjabi Version under the sections on sanskaars... No. 3 Mirtak Sanskaar..Page 22 Last line says:..Phul chug ke Ganga, patalpuree, Kartarpur sahib aad thavaan vich ja ke panneh MANMATT HAI. ( There is NO EXCEPTION given as to reasons as love of motherland, love of pitapurkhee lands, etc etc..juts MANMATT vs GURMATT. Any SIKH would be aware of this.
I quoted the English version.
Both versions are available from SGPC website and hundreds of other sikh nets and web sites under Sikh Rehat maryada.
I think we can Close this thread now.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Putting of ashes of the dead at Kartarpur in Punjab is anti-Gurmatt !!
Kulwinder Singh · 20 Feb 2005
I will come back to you Gyani Ji, Just been busy in some other things.
Re: Putting of ashes of the dead at Kartarpur in Punjab is anti-Gurmatt !!
Kulwinder Singh · 24 Feb 2005
First of all I agreed with you on the Myradas’bit that it was not according to the guidelines of rehit of Akal Takhat Sahib Ji.
But, Big But,
Dear Jarnail Singh Gyani Ji, It is breathtakingly misadventure that when it comes to showing compassion, you chose to bring reference of “ Tappa “ a Dokhi ( Enemy) of Sikhs and Ram Rai “ who twisted Gurbani” either for his own benefits or out of fear in both examples either greed, fear or the enmity is at work in both of your references neither of them include mistake ? You go to some lengths to states when given well due praise that you are humble and refers to yourself as not being perfect then why on earth you chose to diminish the Shine of others .
Even Guru Gobind Singh Ji never condemned people who did not followed his advices or orders Remember “Hazar Gar-Hazer, Gar-Hazar Hazar, But some of the same guru’s Sikh in present times want 100% perfection from others, we all may do million things wrong but it is like haven to point out other shortcomings.
You have said “ No veer we cannot have 'compassion" for anyone who goes against GURBANI. THIS IS MY AIM”
I do not think anybody went against Gurbani as you written, they have not followed the guidelines in reference to Guru Mayrad, which they may have their own exploitation as I said before If they did not believe in any kind of benefit from doing what they did as ritual then I am willing to show compassion rather then throwing mud on this Jatha who represent us well, may not be as we are but never the less our Guru’s Glory is known via them too.
Gyani Ji ? what do you understand from ?
maattee kaa kiaa dhhopai suaamee maanas kee gath eaehee ||1||
How can dust be washed? O my Lord and Master, such is the state of mankind. ||1||
What is your aim ? Does not seems you are doing this for never mind Sikhism's glory not even a glory of a Sikh.
Gyani Ji Sikhi should make people ultra, mega soft and kind, anybody who is not becoming more and more kind could be on any path but religious or spiritual path regardless of their faith and Sikhism which ask for Sarbat Da Bhala start with Kindness, Dya Dharm Ka Mool Hai !
You have written
“UNITY of GURU KHALSA PANTH is more dear to me than my own life itself...but what does "unity" mean ? Some take "unity" as saying Don’t say anything "against" anybody...it will hurt them..it will then hurt panth unity..in other words close one eye. For me Unity means following the One Sikh rehat maryada, One GURU Granth ji, .....and IF any group condones anything that goes AGAINST GURBANI and SRM....then it is wrong in my view.”
Which maryada are we talking about ? Akal Takhat ? your own personal ? Taksal ? AKJ ? OR what else ?
You do not read RagMala ( it is not criticism just fact referred from your own writings, I do not have opinion on that of my own) + Your versions of Purity( not ins sync the Purity of Guru Nanak’s ) (do not think I am either pro or Anti Rag Mala)
Also Gyani Ji if you have some thing to say negative then you should do that in private rather then in public, that is the friendly way of doing things publicly announcing your negativity have more element of Mud in it rather then the pure concerns which you are saying.
Form the start I have raised the question of being compassionate towards others why because we all make mistakes and I rather ignore the minor mistakes of my human fellows to bring more love in the world rather then making divisions based on my own mat rather then Guru Mat, Because if you see from Guru’s eyes then love will overcome all the Man made obstructions in connecting with each other rather then segregation, leave the judgment to THE JUDGE I rather improve my own life rather then Judging others.
The Final word is this:
By lacking compassion we certainly lack Humanity never mind Sikhi which is million time more compassionate then average humanity standard.
Re: Putting of ashes of the dead at Kartarpur in Punjab is anti-Gurmatt !!
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 24 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh.
Dearest Veer Kulwinder Singh Ji.
Satbachan Ji....to all advice coming from you.
Jarnail Singh