Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

kirtan nirmolak hira

kirtan nirmolak hira

singh · 10 Feb 2005

is it ok to listen to kirtan performed by Namdharis?

Re: kirtan nirmolak hira

Singhstah · 10 Feb 2005

NO

Re: kirtan nirmolak hira

... · 10 Feb 2005

What is NIROLEE KIRTAN?

Re: kirtan nirmolak hira

Kulbir Singh · 10 Feb 2005

I agree with Singhstah that we should avoid listening to kirtan performed by the enemies of Panth. Would you listen to kirtan performed by a person who belittles Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee? I personally would not. Namdharis belittle Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee by claiming that Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee cannot be Satguru. Why listen to their kirtan? Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: kirtan nirmolak hira

Singh · 10 Feb 2005

Why listen to their kirtan? ======================== the bani is of sri satguru adi granth sahib ji, so whats the problem? i personally like to listen to their kirtan, its better then most sikh "kirtanis", at least they have an understanding of raag, if anyone is doing beadbi of bani its the people who dont sing kirtan properly and since when did naamdharis become "enemies of the panth"? in sikhi is there such a thing as an enemy? jab dhaarai ko-oo bairee meet tab lag nihchal naahee cheet

Re: kirtan nirmolak hira

J R · 10 Feb 2005

yes

Re: kirtan nirmolak hira

I.J · 10 Feb 2005

Moorkay Naal Na Lujia!

Re: kirtan nirmolak hira

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 10 Feb 2005

waheguru ji ka khasla waheguru ji ki fateh. Ashkhaye jayeah...those who BELITTLE Dhan Dhan GURU GRANTH JI Maharaj as a "mere book" are not ENEMIES.. ??? then what are they ?? bosom buddies ??? Then perhaps we should also hug the radhasoamis, the Narakdharies..... Whose SON are you ?? A person SITS on the THRONE meant for Dhan Dhan GURU GRANTH JI MAHARAJ.....and calls the GURU GRANTH JI a BOOK..not worthy of being GURU..and you still call him "friend". A TRUE SON of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI would never stand for such an INSULT to GURBANI. The namdharies have NO CHOICE but to USE "GURBANI" as their own So called "SATGURU" is INCAPABLE of writing his own "SATGURBANI"...so they STEAL GURU NANAK'S GURBANI.... Jarnail Singh.

Re: kirtan nirmolak hira

sikh76 · 11 Feb 2005

Really? So does this mean I should stop listening to kirtan from raagi singhs in Gurudwaras because they do kirtan and then drink like there's no tommorow or that there are "monay" that do kirtan but don't up hold the rehit. I see how the logic flows. [%sig%]

Re: kirtan nirmolak hira

I'm not telling you · 11 Feb 2005

Its all about 'Mitran keh pran ho'!!! Ps, and Madho Hum Aise Tu Aisa!! Pps, Tum Ho Sabh Rajan Ke Raja too! Ppps, how could I forget Jagrdang Nagrdang.. Oh and Dhur Ki Bani Aayi Pppps, omG Jale Hari Thale Hari is amazing! Feel free to add to the list :-)

Re: kirtan nirmolak hira

ts · 11 Feb 2005

vaheguru jee kaa khalsa vaheguru jee kee fateh sorry singh that your opinion they do not belive in dhan sri guru granth sahib ji as satguru and are using and abusing gurbani to their matt you are right they not enemies of the panth but worse they are niguri (niguri kaa hae nao bura) without the true guru. guru ji will be the judge of who is doing kirtan properly as in the end it is all about prem, sharda for the true guru, dhan sri guru granth sahib jee. vaheguru jee kaa khalsa vaheguru jee kee fateh

Re: kirtan nirmolak hira

tableji · 11 Feb 2005

there is such a thing as "bibek budhi", where by u take the good from everything, because when it comes down to it, there is always something to gain....fair enuff they are against our panth...bt that doesnt mean we cannot take anything from the way that they do keertan.... at the end of the day its a personal choice.....discerning mind

Re: kirtan nirmolak hira

BirRaas Singh · 11 Feb 2005

if sikhs have any "enemies", its only themselves :)

Re: kirtan nirmolak hira

. . . · 11 Feb 2005

Ill ask again! What is NIROLEE KIRTAN?

Re: kirtan nirmolak hira

akj_4eva_and_eva · 11 Feb 2005

vjkk vjkf it is best if kirtan is performed by amritdharis who follow the rehit, deifintely not moneh, meat eaters, naam dharis and so on vjkk vjkf

Re: kirtan nirmolak hira

singh · 11 Feb 2005

so the general consensus is no .....how about learning from them..like sikhs in England (U.K)...? is this akin to learning from nirankaris, ram raieye?