Offering before Guru sahib
panth di chardi kala · 09 Feb 2005
My question is if someone other than a gursikh brings food to the gurudwara, should it be used in langar? bhull chukk maaf
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
panth di chardi kala · 09 Feb 2005
My question is if someone other than a gursikh brings food to the gurudwara, should it be used in langar? bhull chukk maaf..... · 10 Feb 2005
id like 2 no this 2 guru kaa langar?kaur 156 · 10 Feb 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh i dont know but let me take a wild guess........................... if someone brings something for the langar then it should be used in the langar because if a non-sikh came and put money in golak we would use that to pay for stuff like food for the langar lol. and say the person is a christian, so what? if a mona, alcoholic can bring a bag of flour and that isa ccepted cos he is sikh then why not this? also, as long as he didnt buy it from a inappropriate place and you know that then what he brings with pyar will become part of the langar. Hope Waheguru Ji makes someone write the right answer as mine was a guess. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fatehRedwhiteandblue Kaur · 10 Feb 2005
I have to speak practically here... My concern would not be with Sikh vs. non-Sikh...it would be whether the person is a stranger to the gurdwara or not If someone completely unknown to everyone in my gurdwara walked in with a plate of brownies...I have to confess that I have the ego to think that even if the person was a Sikh, I would be wondering what was in the brownies. I wouldn't have the same concerns if a person brought in something packaged, such as a bottle of Sprite, a fresh sack of rice, or an unopened bag of snacks.Singh · 10 Feb 2005
A traditional Khalsa langar is one in which all the food is prepared and distributed by Gursikhs using money donated by Gursikhs. I'm sure many of us have heard the story of Akali Baba Phoola Singh and the English visitor. The visitor saw the langar and was so impressed that he wanted to make a substantial contribution. Akali ji refused to take any money from him and said that the Guru's Langar would run only on contributions made by the Guru's Sikhs.kaur 156 · 10 Feb 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh redwhiteandblue: in the Gurdwaras I go to they do not take anything thats been opened, not good especially when people pop over to the Gurdwara and drop off a bag of food with nails in it! Shame on them! Couldnt they find somewhere else for their black magic, better still not do it. Singh I think thats a great point so everyone ignore my guesswork in my previous post. But that means that we should strictly check out who brought what to the Gurdwara and if it is a mona (eg.my dad) then that should not be used. Right? Sounds great but we unfortunately don't follow it. WISH WE COULD THOUGH Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fatehRedwhiteandblue Kaur · 10 Feb 2005
Does "Gursikh" mean Kesadhari? Or does "Gursikh" mean Amritdhari? If "Gursikh" means Amridhari...does that mean any Amritdhari, or only those that have not committed a sin that requires pesh? I'm just curious...Singh · 10 Feb 2005
the way people talk on this forum, i have a feeling that in the future gurdware will only be for sikhs, only pure gursikhs can take anand karaj, only sikhs can place money in the toshkhana/golak, no food will be taken from non sikhs for the langar, if food isnt prepared by sikhs then no ones gonna eat it, only sikhs can do kirtan (even if they sing it wrong) and out of raag, we're gonna end up living as recluses because if we breathe the air of non sikhs its gonna effect our avasta, if i dont wear a dumala (samosa paags aint allowed in sikhi) which is larger then 12 inches in diametre i am breaking rehit, if we swallow a fly we gonna go to narak cos we aint meat, we cant laugh or have fun because its gonna effect our avasta, if our kare or kirpana aint made of a certain density or amount of iron then we cant gain spirituality, if our kachera are an inch too small its a break in rehit, if i burp i need to pesh, if anything is remotely deemed as hindu then ur labelled as a GOI agent, hate everyone who isnt the same as u, and anyone who is different its ok to slander them because its "panthic" and its our "duty" to uphold sikhi and if i dont stand up with a banner for the cause then ur dissed too, where is sikhi going?someone else · 10 Feb 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh next ppl will start saying we have to keep kesh! Singh wake up, maybe we drag on about the small issues that no one should care about but everyone knows that u can swallow a fly by mistake and not have to pesh and everyone is aware that a kacchera should not be the size of a thong(maaf karna please i had to use that example). Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fatehJarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 10 Feb 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. something akin to what is plaguing the "Kattar Muslims" in malaysia. These people DONT WANT TAX MONEY from the Pork eating / Alcohol consuming/gambling ...Chinese.... for theri MOSQUE BUILDING...but want to put that money in separate accounts to be sued for Public Roads etc..but 90% of the taxes come from the Chinese??? so ?? and ALL mosques are GOVT built and maintained ?? In the Recent TSUNAMI Disaster 99% of the AID came from the CHINESE/Others Non-Muslims.....and they happily consumed it all..SIKHS were carrying out so much aid effort..DISTRIBUTING KORANS ( donated by Muslim Chariites)...to Muslims. Get it...SIKHS collect FOOD/MEDICINES/TENTS/CLOTHES...for the Muslims....while MUSLIMS donate KORANS...and pass them on to the SIKHS to distribute ??? and these people were saying on TV..I just wished that the peroson giving me this aid..were a "fellow Muslim..?? OH how nice that woudl be ?? meaning I have to accept this from thsi sikh..but it would have been nicer if it had been a muslim ?? That is called RASSI SARR GAYEE par WATT NAHIN GUYAH... IMHO SIKHI is much higher than these petty concerns.. jarnail Singhkhalsa · 10 Feb 2005
to answer your question of "where sikhi is going?" Sikhi isnt GOING anywhere. This is a part of sikhi. You cannot ignore outter rehit. it is very important. maybe you should ask yourself how well do you know sikhi yourself? if great sikhs and gursikhs in the past kept such strict rehit of Outter rehits like the ones you mentioned above.. there must be somthing too it. I suggest you open up your mind, and start reading more and experimenting with rehits all these Outter rehits might seem so pointless and distracting..but they are necessary for khalsa spirtual path. the outta rehits and the inner rehits have to work in unison. so yea it does matter how big your kashera is and who makes langer.. i wish the admin would translate some of Bhai Sahib Randheer Singhs writings on outter rehit and inner rehit....it would benefit all of us.......(hint admin....)RK · 10 Feb 2005
Singh, if you have issues with guru jis rehits, as I sense a high amount of egoism in your writing, I think you should not be using the name singh, since that word is usually applied to people who dedicated themselves to guru ji. What I do not understand is that people want to use the label SIkh but they refuse to accept the responsibility and dedication and love and devotion that comes with that title. THat is like saying you want to be a professor in a university without actually learning your ABCs. If you fail to understand the importance of rehit, than atleast have the decency and courtesy to not disrespect those who do. If a wordly army can have rules (eg. uniform, regiment etc) we cannot akal purkh's fauj have thier own rules? It angers me greatly when people think they can pick and choose parts of SIkhi they can accept and deal with, and then have the audacity to mock the other elements that they, for personal (usually because their haumai gets hurt) reasons, cannot comprehend. Guru ji asks for your head before he grants you sikhi, why be a sheep in a lion's skin if you cannot live up to the name????? · 10 Feb 2005
Many of our Gurdawars were built by donations from everybody( Sikhs, non Sikhs, mona etc.) So are we telling if it was built by money from everbody, it is not a Gurdawar. Interested to know if Tapoban Gurdawara was built by money from Guru Sikhs only.Singh · 11 Feb 2005
thank you RK for your excellent judgement of character, you must be antarjami if you can already judge someones character, maryada, and relationship with maharaj by reading one post, or maybe you didnt even read the post at all? since when was guru jis rehits as extreme as what i posted? sikhi is naam dhaan ishnaan, not pakhand, ninda and brahminvaad as is so much prevalent today. akaal purakh ki fauj? you must be joking if you think todays "sikhs" are a fauj, merely living off the glory of our ancestors, only thing so called faujis are good at is fighting amongst themselvesuk singh · 11 Feb 2005
sorry to interrupt the quibbling...but looking at this from a lateral point of view, what was the point of Guru Sahib starting the institution of langar and look at what it has turned into? nowadays it seems to have turned into a free ticket for anyone who feels hungry before or after the darbar to eat food? is this food really free, or do we have to pay for this food for not having done ANY seva when we stand pathetically in front of Dharamraj? how much do we donate in the golak in order to consume Guru Ka Langar? Not it is used by everyone who is NOT gareeb! Especially in Western Countries.RK · 11 Feb 2005
>>akaal purakh ki fauj? you must be joking if you think todays "sikhs" are a fauj, merely living off the glory of our ancestors, only thing so called faujis are good at is fighting amongst themselves<< My point exactly!!! FOr the most part, people want to call themselves Sikhs, but refuse to live up to all that SIkhi involves, and that includes following rehits. But That does not mean that there are not any true Sikhs today, because their are those who actually dedicatie their lives to naam, bani and rehit, just like the purataan Singhs did in the olden times. So that principal also applies to langar as well. Everything that we consume in, including visually, mentally, audibly, and through our food, has an effect on us, and guru jis langar should be such that aids in our spritual journey, not hampers us, and its sources, including who cooked it and provided for it all have an influence on our spirituality.sikh2b · 11 Feb 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. woud just like to say stop trying to bing in further divisions into gurdwara. if someone wants to make a donation to the gurdwara no one should stop them if they have pyaar for Guru ji and the sangat. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.