Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

A FRESH "LOOK" AT "NAAM AND SIMRAN" IN GURMATT

A FRESH "LOOK" AT "NAAM AND SIMRAN" IN GURMATT

Jarnail Singh Gyani "arshi" · 05 Feb 2005

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH. The very answer to the question "What is Simran?" depends on the answer to the question "What is Mukti?", for the destination and path are correlated. If Mukti is an internal mystical union with God, then the path of repetition should help. Jewish mystics are known to succeed with their experiences of Throne Mysticism, Christian mystics have sucessfully made internal journeys through The Dark Night of the Soul, the Indian Jogis have their internal experiences as can be found in Patanjili's Yog Sutras and Gorakh Bodh. But this is not GN's[GN=Guru Nanak or the Sabad Guru SGGS] path to Mukti. To Guru Nanak Ji an internal mystical experience is just another pleasure of the Mind, it is "Avra Saad". He has recommended Vichar and Keertan, and both are enemies of meditation---Vichar requires a thinking Mind, a fresh Mind that should ask questions. But meditation requires a Mind that does not talk; meditation requires a Mind that concentrates on a particular word only. And is Keertan not a disturbance to meditation? It is! There is a Gurudwara in Mohali where Keertan was replaced by "Satnam Waheguru". To my surprise it was a big success, and to my expectations all Keertan addicts stopped participating in it. However, good sense prevailed and after one year the Keertan was restored because the initial craze for "Satnam Waheguru" could not be "sustained". Keertan is taboo in Jog. Bodhis also donot have a tradition of Keertan. Mohammed banned all music because it is a hindrance to counting the 99 names of Allah. But when it comes to Sikhism, Keertan is central. OUR MUKTI IS NOT A MYSTICAL EXPERIENCE WITH THE "COSMIC". Our Mukti is through Naam and "Waheguru" is an expression of thankfulness to GN. "Waheguru" is spontaneous, an Anhad Naad. Naam is not an activity. It is another word for a sustainable way of life[the Gurmukh's]. It is not that a Gurmukh is not close to God, and it is not that he doesnot remember God. Only the path is different, and emotions are different. A guiltless Gurmukh listens the Keertan, does social work and the[resultant] pleasure maketh him utter WAH-E-GURU. A Gurmukh is a Sewadar who works for others, who socializes. A Gurmukh is concerned with making this world a better place. He is a person with a mission. He sees God in His creation, in the poor, in the needy. It is all Vismaad for him, and he sings Keertan to express that Vismaad and ecstatic love. His God is somewhere there. He loves Him like a mother who loves and yet never uses the artifices of rosary, idol or repetition to love her child. A lover uses Waris Shah's "Heer" to experience the bond with her NRI husband, and not a rosary or cassette to repeat his name! The SGGS passages on Naam are to be understood in this light. Guru Nanak Ji has redefined the duo of "Ram" and "Naam" to Omnipresence and an ethical way of living respectively. Leading the life of a Gurmukh is Mukti, but that is not easy, it requires a constant Vichaar, and yet Gurmukhta is not for all, because most stray. AMARDEEP SINGH

Re: A FRESH "LOOK" AT "NAAM AND SIMRAN" IN GURMATT

Who? · 06 Feb 2005

Which Amardeep Singh wrote this article? Or where did you get it from?

Re: A FRESH "LOOK" AT "NAAM AND SIMRAN" IN GURMATT

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 06 Feb 2005

I have always, as a rule of practice refused to use quotations from Guru Granth Sahib, writing in English for fear of misrepresentation,but today I will, make an exception,in the hope; should any translation be wrong or misrepresented it is a genuine mistake on my part, may Waheguru forgive me. A lot of discussion and various definitions have taken place over the issue of amrit vela.Every body has more or less given the definition of Amritvela as per Gurbani and their understaning. What appears to have been missed is, is it just AMRIT VELA that is important or what the person is doing at this defined time is of importance or great consequence? Some may mediate the NAM ,others may lie sleeplessly,some others may be thinking of their fields or other work to be done the next day, and feeling unsettled that they are not getting to sleep.Yet some one else may be crawling hideously to commit a crime,in these wee hours of the morning,eg like about to murder someone in their slumberous sleep,awaiting for a helpless lady to walk past to rape....are the doings therefore in this Amritvela of great and holy nature, or merely the defined amrit vela its self? Amritvela-the geat time defined in Gurbani and said by our Gurus, and long before them by moonis, pirs and pegambers- it becomes the most Holy and right time to link ones faith to Waheguru? In Jaapji Sahib Guru Nanak ji says "AMRIT VELA SACH NAU VADIIAII VICHAAR -early morning is the time for uttering and reciting his NAM. Amrit Vela literally means the ambroisal hour,or the last quarter of the night, or the pre dawn morning hours -which has been given great importance in Sikhism by the Gurus as a period of time for meditation and recital of the NAM. It is in this same sequence of faith,I believe that we have the NECTAR of BLISS-the khande da AMRIT associated to the word amrit(vela). Guru Angad ji says..CHAUTHAI PAHAR SABH KI SURTIA UPJAYE -it is during the fourth quarter of the night, joy sprouts in the heart of the awakened ones........TINA DARIYAWAAN SIO DOSTI MAN MUKH SACHA NAU-they go and befriend rivers and brooks ,have the true NAM in their minds and on their lips. (NANAK SAHIB MAN VASAI SACHA NAVAAN HOYE-O Nanak, the Lord dwells within their minds, and their cleansing bath is true). ( According hindu shastras a person who gets up before 3 am, takes a bath for meditation has given in charity a donation equivalent to one maund of gold for such a noble act. A person who gets up between 3-4 am and takes a bath for meditation has given charity a donation equivalent to one maund of silver. A person who gets betwen 4 -5 am and takes a bath for meditation has given in charity , a donation equivalent to one maund o milk0. I write the above to infer that the ambroisal wee hours of Amrit vela are also held in high esteem in other religions. Sheikh Farid is more forthright, he says ....FAREEDA PICCHAL RAAT NA JAAGEOHI JEVAD MU IOHI - Fareed, if you do not awaken in the early hours before dawn, you are dead while yet alive. What happens if the individual awakens in the ambroisal hours to commit a crime ?Is he blessed to commit his crime? JAY TAI RAB VISAARI A TA RAB NA VISARI OHI - Although you have forgotten God, God has not forgotten you. Guru Ramdas ji goes further , as he lays the daily regimen for a Sikh accorded to early rising to contemplate WAHEGURU's NAM. Guru Ramdas ji goes on to say,"let him who calls himself a Sikh of the GURU,rise early and meditate on the NAM of Waheguru."-GUR SATGUR KA SIKH AKHA AY SO BHALKEY UTHH HAR NAAM DHII AVAII. .UDAM KAREY BHAKEY PAARBATII ISNAN KARE AMRIT SAR NAVAII Upon arising early in the morning, he is to bathe, and cleanse himself in the pool of nectar. UPDES GURU HAR HAR JAP JAPAI SABH KHILVIKH PAAP DOKH LEH JAVAII-Following the Instructions of the Guru, he is to chant the Name of the Lord, Har, Har. All sins, misdeeds and negativity shall be erased. FIR CHARHI DIVAS GURBANI GAVAII BHADI AA UTH DI A HAR NAAM DHI AVAAI-Then, at the rising of the sun, he is to sing Gurbani; whether sitting down or standing up, he is to meditate on the Lord's Name. JO SAAS GIRAAS DHI A AY MARYAA HAR HAR SO GURSIKH GURU MAN BHAVAII- One who meditates on my Lord, Har, Har, with every breath and every morsel of food - that GurSikh becomes pleasing to the Guru's Mind. Guru Arjan says-JHAALAAGAY UTH NAAM JAP NIS BAASUR ARADHE.- Rise early in the morning, and chant the Naam; worship and adore the Lord, night and day. In the Varaan,Bhai Gurdas says-the Guru's sikh rises early in the morning, performs ablutions at amrit vela, and recites the Guru words. It is also said that amrit vela is the deathless time,as anyone who keeps vigil during this precious time in SIMRAN and BHAGTI of the Guru,need not die again.Such one who attains the blessing of the NAM becomes immortal ,while living within the mortal body. Because rising at such hour, needs the mind to be well tuned to the theory of a faith in Guru ji,like taking a cold bath,sit with full concentration and a ONE POINTED MIND and VICHAR, and contemplate ,on the greatness o the merciful Waheguru and sing his praises for the blessings he he bestows.To awaken oneself for amrit vela is like fighting with a tiger! As worldly people invariably find to arouse themselves from bed during the last PAHAR of the night is the greatest (worldy)DUKH,hence many people fail to realise that all happiness obtained by observing the Amritvela. Sant scholar, a shiromani kathakar, Niranjan Singh ji of Patiala used to say that singing the praises of the Lord during the AMRITVELA,is like watering the field of life,at its prime, and life becomes full of happiness and bliss. For a Sikh, who follwos the Guru' s shabad, observing AMRITVELA, is one of the key to successful mediataion with the NAM,doing SIMRAN of the WAHEGURU manter,Mool manter;recitation and contemplation of GURBANI- a sikh observing such is always in CHARDHI KALA and succesful in whatsoever he under takes in life's journey. It is not a prime hour chosen for its own sake.But for mediation of NAM.Otherwise no special auspiciousness is attached to AMRITVELA.Every moment of ones life is meant for the REMEBERANCE of WAHEGURU. As Guru Arjan Ji says,blessed is the hour(vela)when one gets absorbed in contemplation of HIM-DHAN SO VELA JIT DARSHAN KARNAA. As I said earlier, there are also those who rise arise at this blessed moment with lobh moh hankaar kaam and krodh, with clear intention to commit crime, robbery,murder, or rape.They have obviously used the tool negatively and failed to fight their mind or do sewa for the humanity.to such people AMRITVELA has no meaning or value,sadly they have missed the most ambroisal hour of their life. The Guru Jis teach us to fight this lobh moh krod kaam and hankaar in a positive manner using a process and time suited best, and be victorious over the mind in the end. HUMAN mind CANNOT FIGHT THESE on their own or engage to fight directly the evil,but at a strategic time-AMRITVELA-using the tools of Prayers,ARDAS ,NAAM SIMRAN- Waheguru himself ties up the mind to good deeds and brings it under control, to do more good deeds to humanity. Gurcharan Singh Kulim

Re: A FRESH "LOOK" AT "NAAM AND SIMRAN" IN GURMATT

Kulbir Singh · 07 Feb 2005

Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh! ------------- To Guru Nanak Ji an internal mystical experience is just another pleasure of the Mind, it is "Avra Saad". ------------ Gurbani does not say it anywhere that internal mystical experiences are just another pleasure of mind. “Avra Saad” is actually referred to ridhi-sidhi which are just supernatural powers that a Sikh should not indulge in. Internal mystical experiences that are experienced as a result of Naam Abhyaas cannot be classified as “avra saad”. Just read the first ashtpadi of Siri Sukhmani Sahib and it is clear from it that mystical experience are not a bad thing: Prabh kai simran nihchal aasan|| Prabh kai simran kamal bigaasan|| Prabh kai simran anhad jhunkaar|| Sukh prabh simran ka ant naa paar|| ----------------- He has recommended Vichar and Keertan, and both are enemies of meditation---Vichar requires a thinking Mind, a fresh Mind that should ask questions. But meditation requires a Mind that does not talk; meditation requires a Mind that concentrates on a particular word only. And is Keertan not a disturbance to meditation? It is! --------------- It is not!! I repeat, it is not, it is not, it is not! Kirtan is not a disturbance to meditation on Naam. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written in his book Gurmat Bibek that in olden days people used to go to mountains and caves to do meditation and achieve stillness of mind but in Kalyug, there is no place that can provide more silence to mind than Kirtan Akhaara. “Gurbani, Har naam samaaiya” i.e. in Gurbani Naam is merged and absorbed. When we do Gurbani paath or listen to Kirtan of Gurbani, Naam starts with full vigour inside us. More paath we do of Gurbani, more kirtan we listen to, more vigorously Naam starts inside us. The ones who do not experience this is because either they have not received Naam properly from Punj Pyaaray or they have done some Gurmat related mistake that does not let their Naam abhyaas from starting with vigour. Singhs (read Gursikhs) who do Naam abhyaas in kirtan (gupt gupt, not openly) experience that when their mind comes out of simran, it goes to Gurbani and then Gurbani hukams again push their mind to Naam. Gurbani is full of Naam. A person doing Gurbani paath cannot escape going towards Naam. ------------- There is a Gurudwara in Mohali where Keertan was replaced by "Satnam Waheguru". To my surprise it was a big success, and to my expectations all Keertan addicts stopped participating in it. However, good sense prevailed and after one year the Keertan was restored because the initial craze for "Satnam Waheguru" could not be "sustained". --------------- This I totally agree with you. A Sikh congregation is not supposed to have “Vaheguru Vaheguru” or “Satnaam Vaheguru” kind of jaaps. Only kirtan should be done in Gurdwara congregations. The recent trend of doing Vaheguru Vaheguru instead of doing kirtan of Amrit Gurbani is wrong. All gursikhs who have understanding of Gurmat do simran (gupt gupt) while listening and doing kirtan of Gurbani. For this reason there is no need to do open simran in public. Also, Naam simran cannot be done with non-amritdhari people; therefore it should not be done in open sangat. Only Gurbani kirtan should be done and not Satnam Vaheguru or Vaheguru Vaheguru. ---------------- Naam is not an activity. It is another word for a sustainable way of life[the Gurmukh's]. It is not that a Gurmukh is not close to God, and it is not that he does not remember God. Only the path is different, and emotions are different. A guiltless Gurmukh listens the Keertan, does social work and the[resultant] pleasure maketh him utter WAH-E-GURU. --------------- Naam abhyaas is definitely an activity. Naam is a word – Gurmanter that Punj Pyaaray give to all who get initiated. The purpose of Naam Vaheguru is to japp it. Japping in itself is definitely an activity. Without letting our mind get touched with Naam, one cannot get the mind purified. Naam alone does it. Kirtan is an aiding karam to achieve concentration in Naam. ------------- A lover uses Waris Shah's "Heer" to experience the bond with her NRI husband, and not a rosary or cassette to repeat his name! ------------- Very well said Arshee Giani jeeo. So true this is. Ranjha Ranjha kardi nee main aapay raanjha hoyee. Akho nee mainu dheedo Ranjha, Heer na aakho koyee. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: A FRESH "LOOK" AT "NAAM AND SIMRAN" IN GURMATT

ns · 07 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Man confusing or what, Kulbir Singh when I started to read your response it was all cool but when it vame to :: "A Sikh congregation is not supposed to have “Vaheguru Vaheguru” or “Satnaam Vaheguru” kind of jaaps." Then how do you explain SGGS Ji which mentions " satsangat kasi janeeaa jethaa ekoo naam vakaniyaa" sorry for spelling mistakes. You also say "The recent trend of doing Vaheguru Vaheguru instead of doing kirtan of Amrit Gurbani is wrong. " Are you the authority on this or how many sikhs have come to this conclusion, or has the Akal takht come to this conclusion? Again there are many lines in SGGS Ji which promote both e.g. "kirtan naam simrat rahoo" are you telling me that all the kirtanaee we have who promote naam simran in the AKJ are ALL WRONG and don't understand are just doing waheguru waheguru trend for the sake of it...??? When you mention "Also, Naam simran cannot be done with non-amritdhari people; therefore it should not be done in open sangat" Then all our kirtaneea are wrong again , they make us doo kirtan and naam simran. If doing naam is wrong then why not kirtan why isn't that wrong, both are usstats of God. I know for a fact in the in the AKJ there is a split over this and other things, so is this your version of AKJ Sikhism or your interpetation of Bhai Randhir Singh Jee. Then I don't understand , you say "Naam alone does it. Kirtan is an aiding karam to achieve concentration in Naam" are you defining kirtan is karam only so it doesn't help in any other way. Bhai Sahib you may not know there have been kirtanees in the panth who have achieved the ultimate state by kirtan alone.. I apologize I don;t mean to hurt anyone's feeling but I feel this depends on ones' personal experience. Bhai Randhir Singh Jee had his own experiences, Bhai Rama Singh Ji had his own..we have kirtanee promoting naam simran in smagams all over the world. By doing so they are making amrtidhari's and non amritdhari's do naam simran. I have actually heard non amrtidhari's mention how different they felt after going to a smagam and practising naam simran.So indeed they are ready to go again. I have spoken at times to AKJ panch in India and the UK from AKJ , both agree if one finds concentration hard then have kirtan on at the same time as you do naam simran see if it helps. And I can only say it helps me tenfolds. Sorry maybe I 'm lost if I am then please HEEELP!!

Re: A FRESH "LOOK" AT "NAAM AND SIMRAN" IN GURMATT

..... · 07 Feb 2005

waheguru jee kaa khalsa waheguru jee kee fateh interesting topic, keertan is not an aiding karam anyone who thinks so is confused, bhai sahid has clearly stated in one of his books that either gurbani paath, gurbani keertan and naam are all equally capable/powerful enough with guru ji.s grac to open the dasam duaar. all 3 are bhagti roop we must not get confused, we want amrit and all the 3 above are, only when we taste it or learn from gurmukhs experiences and achievemnts can we comprehend this truth waheguru jee kaa khalsa waheguru jee kee fateh

Re: A FRESH "LOOK" AT "NAAM AND SIMRAN" IN GURMATT

Thakur kaur Taksali · 07 Feb 2005

i love this topic. please continue. naam is both an "activity" and..life..in the way that we LIVE the "naam" that we have in us..example..a Naamabhiyassi can be spottted miles away...his aura, glow, bearing, personality..every hair on his body will be SHINING... I beleive just like a freshly washed piece of cloth shines brightly..(soap has cleaned it)...Naam cleans the Mann so that it shines brightly as sun through the clouds..so naam and naam abhiyaas are both activity and life. The "naam abhiyassi life" of the writers shines through in their replies...one look and we can see..there are differences...many many differences..even opposite stands....but the naam kamii can be seen clearly....i wish i was able to talk face to face with some of the writers on this Forum....i have wasted many years of my life already but it is still not too late..Guru Ji's Kirpa has brought me drifting here... bebe

Re: A FRESH "LOOK" AT "NAAM AND SIMRAN" IN GURMATT

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 08 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. What a refreshing read...thoroughly enjoyable. Naam is "activity" or "LIFE". I face this daily. Gurbani is Double faceted...that is Gurbani is NOT EXCLUSIVELY for the Next world...when Guru Ji talks about Pir and his avganwanti wife....this can be taken, applied to our daily married life. In a house where the husband and wife cannot get along..always fighting quarelling etc..there is no way anyone can do any Naam japping/remember Waheguru....their whole life will be spend trying to out do the other and put him/her down. Gurbani teaches us how to LIVE in this World..so as to PREPARE for the next...OF course PIR is WAHEGURU..and we are all his agvananti wives..that is the second meaning of Gurbani..but i always beleived Guru Ji would not just concentrate on the other side and leave us to settle this life on our own. MY students, my friends come to me daily asking me for "gurbani based" solutions to worldly problems..that is why we take a Daily Hukmnama....it depends on us how we take Guru Ji's advice to adapt it to our daily life, daily problems, suffering, dilemmas, struggles. I benefitted tremendously from the input received..especially Veer Kulbir Singh Ji's comments and Veer Gurcharan Singh Ji Kulim's long essay. Thank you. Jarnail Singh. Note: I have no knowledge of who Amardeep Singh is or where he is based. I took this comment from another Forum and posted it here for the comments. Thank you to all who participated to enlighten me. It is in this context that Naam japping is not just an "activity"..it has to be IMBIBED, into our daily life..we have to LIVE naam, breathe naam,...and then the Divine Light of that Naam LIFE will be visible in our daily life.

Re: A FRESH "LOOK" AT "NAAM AND SIMRAN" IN GURMATT

singh · 08 Feb 2005

Only kirtan should be done in Gurdwara congregations. The recent trend of doing Vaheguru Vaheguru instead of doing kirtan of Amrit Gurbani is wrong. All gursikhs who have understanding of Gurmat do simran (gupt gupt) while listening and doing kirtan of Gurbani. For this reason there is no need to do open simran in public. Also, Naam simran cannot be done with non-amritdhari people; therefore it should not be done in open sangat. Only Gurbani kirtan should be done and not Satnam Vaheguru or Vaheguru Vaheguru. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ As far as I'm aware, Bhai Rama Singh Ji started the trend of doing solely simran between 3-4 am in Southall, UK. Why is this wrong? He participated every day from the stage. When you talk of personal gupt simran with others, are you specifically referring to saas giraas?

Re: A FRESH "LOOK" AT "NAAM AND SIMRAN" IN GURMATT

Eak Naam amrit Ouh Daevai · 08 Feb 2005

Naam and Simran are the same source but have different existence. Naam gets given from the outside in the form of Akhar hence>>>Akhari Naam, Akhari Salah, Akhari Giaan Geet Gun Gaah. It is hard to explain but most easy to experience, therefore I request to the persons reading this mail to Jap Naam selflessly, read, understand and become what Bani says with mercy, forgiveness and compassion and do selfless Seva. We all Jap Naam but Simran is to Simar a deeper level it doesn't break, it stays within your breath, within your veins within your mind. It is that sort of avasta where another cannot know what your doing, you will look normal to them unless that person is an Abhyasi. If you look at the first Astpadi of Siri Sukhmani Sahib, each line almost begins with "Prab Ka Simran" Now lets take "Prab Kae Simran Garabh N Basae" we translate it to be 'By repeating God Name one doesn't enter the womb again. Please be true with yourself by Japping name with mouth and tongue do you think we can acomplish this line of Gurbani. With the thoughts In my mind repeating Gods name I wouldn't. Simran is always there "Sabad Akhut Baba Nanaka, Kahae Karach Than Maal" please correct me if I went wrong anyway, and forgive me for my mistakes i am a mere slave of Siri Guru Arjan Dev Ji.

Re: A FRESH "LOOK" AT "NAAM AND SIMRAN" IN GURMATT

Singh · 08 Feb 2005

The first chapter of 'Naam Abhyaas Kaamayee' by Bhai Randheer Singh gives a very nice response to the essay in the first post. It's definitely worth a read.