Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

DO NOT WATCH THIS MOVIE!

DO NOT WATCH THIS MOVIE!

Darshan Singh · 13 Jul 2003

Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!!! Sadh Sangat Jee, today I watched The League of Extraordinary Gentleman a movie that was released yesterday, Friday July 11th. Part of the reason I watched this movie is I was told that there was a prominent role in the movie played by a "Singh". I was told it was respectfully done: Full dari, Bana, 3 Foot kirpan, etc. Deciding this could be an interesting thing to watch I moved forward with my plans of watching it but not only that I also convinced 4 other Singhs to watch the movie with me, using the argument that they had a Singh in there who does gatka, knows martial arts, etc., things I had been told about the "Singh" who played this role. When the "Singh" was introduced there was some excitement flowing through all of us Singhs watching the movie: there was the full kulee daree, the 3 foot kirpan, and a uniform, not a chola but a respectful uniform which also was blue, a big plus. However, we soon figured out that the daree was fake. We were dismayed that it wasn't an actual Singh playing this role, however that is not that big of a deal because the portrayal was in no way disrespectful. The movie continues and the "Singh" plays a very important role. He is a expert in martial arts as well as gatka and this was very good as it displayed Singhs in the way they deserve to be displayed. The movie was going along fine and dandy. Then disaster struck. THE "SINGH" WAS WORSHIPING A HINDU GOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! It was totally outrageous and I was appalled as well as ALL the Singhs who were with me. One of them even yelled obscenities at the screen in disgust and walked out as we all followed him in a fury of rage. I URGE ALL SINGHS/SINGHANEEA OUT THERE NOT TO WATCH THIS MOVIE!!! Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!!! Daas, Darshan Singh

Re: DO NOT WATCH THIS MOVIE!

kulpreetsingh · 13 Jul 2003

veerjee i mean - that is TOTALLY justification enough to not like the movie, but could you give more details he went to a mandir or something? what exactly happened, thanks -daas VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH

Re: DO NOT WATCH THIS MOVIE!

jagga sandhu · 13 Jul 2003

sikhs just need to be strong enuff in their own mind and identity as to what they are and what we shudnt do, then if one want to watch it go ahead , if not then dont. but one thing majority of the time this media bandwagon is against religion generally cos u look at 84 what coverage did sikhs have in the 80s? why doesnt anyone know what happened? how cud the media have helped the sikhs? and wud that have been the most effective tool? how comes muslims are suddenly classed as terrorists due to one bin laden? why isnt rss given the same exposure? where do we point to? our tv sets and the mdia industry if dividing mankind and working on fear elements sells what wudnt they do? more muslims and minorities have died in india than sep 11. how many films do u recall that are positive about sikhs in the history sikhs have lived abroad? usually i find films and media usually mock most religions, hindi films they make mullahs and pandits to be gangsters, sikhs as jokers, in western films muslims are protrayed as terrorists. it jus shows u how low the media and these broadcasters r to make a quick buck. i barely watch tv jus for news and a few educational views as and when required otherwise its a load of nonsense we are filling our heads up with junk trash that shudnt be there. the media is the most powerful tool that influences peoplesminds today yet the control element is based on monetary factors what sells. i feel sikhs shud stand up strong and protest where need be on situations like this, but on the moral side ive kind of given up that sikhs wud ever be shown in positive sense.

Re: DO NOT WATCH THIS MOVIE!

no · 14 Jul 2003

you can still watch it, but just tell ur friends that this isn't a true portrayal of Sikhs. Just be strong about it, and inform your non-sikh friends that this is an inaccurate image of Sikhs and CORRECT the garbage that this movie has shown. but even otherwise, the movie sucked anyway. it was such a boring movie, i fell alseep. :-/

Re: DO NOT WATCH THIS MOVIE!

Gabroo Khalistan Dah · 14 Jul 2003

the sikh coalation should make contact, and do something bout mis-representation of a religion

Re: DO NOT WATCH THIS MOVIE!

captain nemo · 14 Jul 2003

Heres a picture of him... http://ffmedia.ign.com/filmforce/image/league_set6a.jpg

Re: DO NOT WATCH THIS MOVIE!

Mkhalsa · 14 Jul 2003

They never said he was a sikh! I tried to spread this message on all message boards. Captain nemo as originally written in 20,000 leagues under the sea was an indian who worshipped kali and dressed as an indian warrior. Jules Verne was not that knowledgable about the east, india, or sikhs, religions etc and just wrote the book. League of extroadinary gentelmen the movie went back to that. In extroadinary gentlemn comics and movies of 20,000 leagues nemo is a gora.. at least they made him indian again!! and to portray people with turbans as good for once is definitely a plus here in the US. So hes not a sikh, its played by a muslim/indian actor. I see where you are coming from, but its better than nothing.

Re: DO NOT WATCH THIS MOVIE!

.. · 17 Jul 2003

sikhs arent the only ones to wear turbans beards and carry swords. the veds demand a hindu to have unshorn hair and wear a turban and carry shasters. I am sure at some point in history hindus must have followed that. If you go to india there are still hindus who carry out the obligations of the veds though in very less numbers. Durga mata is considered a rep of shakti in hinduism maybe thats why he bowed to her statue. As was sed its not mentioned he was a sikh character on the site. When i went to delhi this year i decided to visit taj mahal i passed through muslim strongholds where i saw a protest taking place against the poto simi laws. I was surprised that a good numbers of muslims were wearing black triangular turbans with long beards and wearing what looked like bana but in black. I saw a video of a tirth yatra in rishikesh where hindus were donned in turbans with long hair and orange robes. Then my friend also told me when he went to beas radaswam centre most of the followers had pind style dastara with uncut tharey, im presming they were just locals, perhaps many more are monai in outside places. even afghans wear turbans and beards and carry swords by pathan tradition. To an outsider who would just see the turban beard and shaster in the western world could easily mistake that forbeing a sikh.

Re: DO NOT WATCH THIS MOVIE!

Surrey Singh · 17 Jul 2003

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH <<"sikhs arent the only ones to wear turbans beards and carry swords">> look at the style of Dastar he is wearing: i haven't seen any non-Sikh wear that style. I think they totally made this guy look like a Singh. WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH