Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Who eats meat?

Who eats meat?

Vegan · 03 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! I keep hearing about these Amritdharis who eat meat. I have never met one. Does anyone on this forum eat meat and has also taken Amrit? Where do you but your meat from? How often do you eat meat? Just curious. Not having a dig!

Re: Who eats meat?

;;;';'; · 03 Feb 2005

from the Halal Shop like Nidder

Re: Who eats meat?

volvic · 03 Feb 2005

Author: ;;;';'; Date: 02-03-05 09:29 from the Halal Shop like Nidder ----- omG thats so funny I can't stop laughing.. NOT.. Grow up, if you don't have anything useful to say then don'y say anything at all.. [%sig%]

Re: Who eats meat?

khalsa · 03 Feb 2005

i thought it was funny :)

Re: Who eats meat?

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 03 Feb 2005

All I can do is speculate. I'm thinking that someday, yes, I do want to take amrit. But, while I don't eat a lot of meat, I don't see myself giving it up entirely. I have nothing against those that do. But I do not think it will be my path. I buy what is locally farmed...fish from a nearby fisherman's co-op, most everything else from the grocery.

Re: Who eats meat?

qwerteww · 03 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh Was that a joke or does Niddar really have halal? In case 'Vegan' bhenji/bhaaji is not sure we should tell him/her that Niddar is not what one would call a 'Sikh' but then we are not here to say that I am a Sikh and you or not. But I was genuinely interested to know if he does have halal so please answer this. As for amritdhaaris having meat, it is definately not allowed but some peopl ethink it is allowed because they like to twist the meaning of Gurrbaani to match the taste of their tongues. Bhul Chuk Maaf Karni Ji Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Who eats meat?

A Singh · 03 Feb 2005

Many of the products you guys eat believing them to be 'veggie' do in fact contain meat halal or otherwise. So who is the true vegetarian now?

Re: Who eats meat?

Singhstah · 03 Feb 2005

A Singh wrote: > Many of the products you guys eat believing them to be 'veggie' > do in fact contain meat halal or otherwise. > > So who is the true vegetarian now? like wat?

Re: Who eats meat?

khalsa · 03 Feb 2005

if u want to gain anything spirtually from sikhi you cannot eat meat. if an amritdari was to eat meat he is no longer amritdari as he has broken his amrit. if an amritdari was allowed to eat meat, then he wasnt really an amritdari in the first place because he went to an amrit sinchaar that doesnt follow rehit. think about it.... you have amritdari's who lose their amrit and become PATITS of guru sahib if they eat meat...and then on the other hand you have people who can eat meat freely and no affect to there amrit. its false. eating meat is not according to gurmat. You can go to whatever amrit sinchaar you want, but your only fooling yourself, and your spirtual level will go nowhere. call it tough love, but its the truth... redwhite and blue kaur...heres a read u might wanna check out http://www.tapoban.org/meat.htm http://www.tapoban.org/jhatka.htm hope you think this through and guru sahib does kirpa

Re: Who eats meat?

lachivalichai · 03 Feb 2005

i got a question there are two versions people believe how humans evolved. 1) 4 YUGS saintly people before did not eat meat 2) scientific people say we evolved and progressed that our forefathers ate fish and meats thats how our brains changed and we advanced. every sikh confuses me more which is the right one?

Re: Who eats meat?

Jammin' · 03 Feb 2005

Whats Chatka?

Re: Who eats meat?

qwerteww · 03 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh Redwhiteblue Kaur I know it may sound hard to leave meat but as soon as I took amrit I just left meat. Before that I ate meat every other day I think and I could not imagine life without it. But when one compares the benefits then it is like choosing meat(blood and flesh) over amrit(the sweetest water on the planet or should i say the universe). I wont say that I didnt feel like eating meat after that , in fact no one was in the room so I thought I would sneakily eat it, but then I didnt as I thought Guru Gobind Singh Ji were standing right there and looking at me. Today I cant stand the smell. lol Hope Guru JI do their beautiful and amazing Kirpa on all my brothers and sisters out there that they may all taste amrit and take the Guru Jis blessings by then following the rehit. Taking amrit seems like a sacrifice for some. I think not taking amrit is a sacrifice of the soul. We all pray and do naam Jap but how many of us value amrit ? We think it is not for us or lets wait til Guru Ji makes us take amrit. I dont think it works like that. WE have to make the effort and after that we can truly feel like Guru Gobind Singh JI is ours and we are Guru Gobind Singh JI's SIKHS.. NB: this was not for redwhiteblue at all, but a very general post to everyone. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Who eats meat?

S Singh · 03 Feb 2005

>>As for amritdhaaris having meat, it is definately not allowed but some peopl ethink it is allowed because they like to twist the meaning of Gurrbaani to match the taste of their tongues. Interesting, those that eat meat will say it is people like you who twist Gurbani. According to the draft Akal Takht Rehat Maryada you can eat as much meat as you want as long as it is Jhatka !!! There are Jhatka butchers in Amritsar. Also the Singh in Pakistan eat meat. Never encountered Pakistani Sikh Saint so maybe this whole meat thing is a Indian Saint inspired thing to emulate Brahmins. Nihangs have and still do enjoy meat. Some people say it is only modern Jathebandis who have brahminised Sikhi and banned meat consumption. Who knows what is right or wrong. Do what you think is right.

Re: Who eats meat?

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 03 Feb 2005

It's not a matter of sounding hard. I have tried a veg diet for an extended amount of time. It doesn't suit my health...particularly eliminating fish. I know some others that would not do well with eliminating milk, yogurt, or cheese from their diets. For me, there is no controversy. I am the only mortal that has to live with my body, health, mind, and soul...so that is my personal decision. I respect others decisions to follow a veg diet. Should one choose to disrespect me for my decision...there is nothing I can do about that.

Re: Who eats meat?

BirRaas Singh · 03 Feb 2005

the tuk which everyone loves to use "khalsa mero roop hai khaas" which is from khalsa mehima by guru gobind singh ji states that a khalsa never eats meat which has had the kalima read over it.... akaal takht has stated that only halal meat is a kureit, so give people their own choice rather then sayin "ur wrong ur wrong"

Re: Who eats meat?

busboy · 03 Feb 2005

so ur basically choosing meat over ur sikhi..and don't say im twisting ur words or im judging you, because whichever way you look at it, that is exactly what you are doing. If anything girls need meat less than guys, and im a teenage kid who gave up meat and im doing fine.

Re: Who eats meat?

Tarrandeep Kaur · 04 Feb 2005

penji you say you cannot eliminate fish from your diet, why is this? Fish provides protein, cant you get proteins from daal? There is always a solution to problems like that if you want to give up meat. Especially if ur thinkin bout takin ameit, you must give up meat sooner or later. Another question do you do ur paath? Someone once told me ''What is the point of filling up a bucket with with water if the bucket has holes in'' If ur not following the rehit then your bucket has holes so why fill it up with water (paath, simran etc..) Just have athink wat i have sed, penji no one can force you what to do, just listen to peoples advice. Its good tht uv stopped removing ur hair, ur gettin on the right path jus keep following it, and make more changes. sorry if i have offended you, didnt mean to :-) VAHIGURUJIKAKHALSAVAHIGURUJIKIFATEH

Re: Who eats meat?

singh · 04 Feb 2005

Pyaraee Redwhitandblue kaur bhain jee , do take this into consideration. This Shabad is by Bhagat Kabeer Ji in Salok Kabeer Jee on Pannaa 1377 kabeer bhaa(n)g maashhulee suraa paan jo jo praanee khaa(n)hi || Kabeer, those mortals who consume marijuana, fish and wine theerathh barath naem keeeae thae sabhai rasaathal jaa(n)hi ||233|| - no matter what pilgrimages, fasts and rituals they follow, they will all go to hell. ||233|| ** This is banis faisala (decision)

Re: Who eats meat?

Harsimrat Kaur · 04 Feb 2005

Gurfateh, I think Amritdharis should eat meat. i don't think anyone should eat meant unless it is a nessesisty. I, myself woulf like to give up meat but becasue of health reasons i can not. Like it says in gurbani 'why build a graveyard in your stomach?' that is what you are doing by eating meat. you are building a place for dead animlas to go to. Gurfateh

Re: Who eats meat?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "arshi" · 04 Feb 2005

S Singh....you got me thinking...Ya..WHY NO "PAKISTANI SANT BABAS" ?? IN fact NO SANT BABAS from anywhere except PUNJAB. We had ONE GREAT "SANT BABA" in MALAYSIA...Sant baaba Sohan Singh ji GYANI..BUT he was NOWHERE like the SANT BABAS from Punjab..His Dastaar was never Round, he never wore a big Chola..and HE ONLY SPREAD the GURMATT of AKAL TAKHAT...he lived in a small 10 X 10 room at the Malacaa gurdwara ALL his life..and Never built a DERA..the Gurdwara Malacca is Still a SIKH GURDWARA just like any other. ( Its a different matter that "desi" types of SANT BABA FOLLOWERS.. Sant Sohan Singh have "hijacked" the name of "sant" sohan Singh ji malacca....to promote thier own brand of maryada..it is well known that in his LIFETIME SANT Ji NEVER used any maryada EXCEPT AKAL TAKHAT/SGPC MARYADA ONLY. Lets hear about any other "DIASPORA" or "foreign" sant babas ?? (Most of the ones settled in USA/ WESTern Countries are in fact DESI IMPORTS..like the infamous daljit singh chicago./baba narinder singh greal toronto..etc. IS there any authentic LOCAL born real sant baba ji ?? Jarnail Singh

Re: Who eats meat?

uk singh · 06 Feb 2005

Redwhiteandblue Kaur - when you eventually take amrit you will be following rehat. you cannot have halal but if you are to comsume maas it will have to be chatka. how would you chatka a fish?

Re: Who eats meat?

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 06 Feb 2005

-----if you are to comsume maas it will have to be chatka. how would you chatka a fish----- A cleaver comes to mind ;-)

Re: Who eats meat?

qwertyuier5345 · 06 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh I only read Guru Granth Sahib Ji to decide whether I think anyone is twisting bani. Does that mean we think Tapoban is twisting bani by going against it? I think not, it is not a matter of us twisting but following the Gurus. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Who eats meat?

eye witness accounts...history · 07 Feb 2005

To my fellow Brothers and Sisters.... Why is it that all eye witness accounts that i have read, and there are about a dozen of them, by british, french, and other European's, talks about how sikhs between the time of Banda Bahadhur and Maharaja Ranjit Singh, all seemed to state the fact that sikhs not only eat meat, especially that of a wild boar, but also did not refrain from drinking alcohol, yet would not smoke tabacco? Can anyone explain this? This is not one account, but several.... I personally believe that there is no restriction on eating of the flesh. I personally am a vegetarion. Kulbir Singh Dhillon. Uk wala

Re: Who eats meat?

akj_singh_4eva_and_eva_amen · 07 Feb 2005

vjkk vjkf red white blue kaur and co. you are completely devoid of all inteligence. eating chatka meat is no different to any other meat if you eat meat you area a maha paapi. killing living animals just to satisfy your greedy gut and health has nothing to do with it, any vital proteins from any animal can be found in vegetarian foods. if you want to eat meat then carry on thats your problem but please dont even think about calling yourself a sikh, because sikhs DONT eat meat vjkk vjkf

Re: Who eats meat?

_ · 07 Feb 2005

This could simply be folk born into sikh family. To British they are all seikh.

Re: Who eats meat?

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 07 Feb 2005

AKJ Singh 4eva, I'm sorry, I don't believe you. And to all of you... This has been very informative for me. I can understand a bit more about why many of you choose a vegetarian path, and, as I mentioned earlier...I respect that path fully. However, while I fully agree that such a path is permitted, I am still not convinced that such a path has been prescribed by our Gurus. With that, I pollitely withdraw...as I while I do think this is a subject that is worthy of discussion, I do not particularly feel that it is an excuse for the indulgence of krodh or ahankar. This is degrading in to a quarrel...and Guru Nanak said that only the foolish quarrel over such a thing. I greatly appreciate all of you that have informed me. I am here to learn :-) "Only the foolish quarrel over the desirability of eating flesh. They are oblivious of true knowledge and meditation. What is really flesh? What is really vegetable-food? Which one of is sin-infested? They do not differentiate between good food and that which leads to sin.... Men are born of a mother's and father's blood yet they do not eat fish or meat ... Meat is mentioned in the Puranas and the Katebas: It has been used in Yajnas on marriages and festive occasions". (p.1290).

Re: Who eats meat?

Waste of Time · 08 Feb 2005

Eating meat gives you bad KARM. Eating flesh for the sake of a 2 second taste sensation is cruelty. You eat it, digest it then secrete it. A child loses their mother, A mother loses their child. There is no humane way of killing, death is death weather Jatka or Halal. An animal will be in fear moments before their death, they are not willingingly giving their life to you. You are forcefully taking it away! How can one do BHAKTI after the have been a part of this infliction of pain?

Re: Who eats meat?

Sahibzaadeyian dee prernaa · 08 Feb 2005

This is not out of gurus bani what i'm going to write but if i'm not wrong then its either written by Bhai Gurdaas ji or in Suraj Parkaash(please correct me if i'm wrong) The meanings of those lines are that a goat ready to be butchered by a butcher questions him,' if i am going to be slaughtered that badly by you even i haven't done nothing wrong in my life and have just eaten grass only,what would become of you who are killing me for no reason.I'm so much worried O' butcher and not the pain i'm going to have as it is short lived as i would be pain free after i got killed but your suffering would start. I really liked it and i'm sure that you all would also benefit from it.Waste of Time wrote: > Eating meat gives you bad KARM. Eating flesh for the sake of a > 2 second taste sensation is cruelty. You eat it, digest it then > secrete it. > > A child loses their mother, A mother loses their child. There > is no humane way of killing, death is death weather Jatka or > Halal. > > An animal will be in fear moments before their death, they are > not willingingly giving their life to you. You are forcefully > taking it away! > > How can one do BHAKTI after the have been a part of this > infliction of pain?

Re: Who eats meat?

Sahibzaadeyian dee prernaa · 08 Feb 2005

Science developed afterwards , i mean after our gurus. Guru Nanak said,'pataala paataal lukh aakaasha aakaash....' means there are hundred thousands of other planets and stars.... And When did Science discover that we can reach moon and there is possibility of life on Mars etc.? Another example- Guru Sahib wanted us to use wooden Kangha as the plastic in use with hair creates static current etc. I'm not science literate but i do understand Guru ji's message Lastly a simple question to remove your doubts: Do you believe in Guru's hukum or science? Hope you agree!!!!!!!lachivalichai wrote: > i got a question > > there are two versions people believe how humans evolved. > > 1) 4 YUGS saintly people before did not eat meat > > 2) scientific people say we evolved and progressed that our > forefathers ate fish and meats thats how our brains changed and > we advanced. > > every sikh confuses me more which is the right one?

Re: Who eats meat?

S Singh · 08 Feb 2005

Fact. The Rehat Maryada issued by the Akal Takht clearly states you can eat meat. So stop beating about the bush claiming xyz is right or wrong. Follow the maryada and stop distorting Sikhi to back you brahminised inspired ideas about meat. If you dont want to eat meat then dont but if others do, dont say they are wrong. (I do not eat meat for personal reasons (not religious reasons) but I see nothing wrong with anyone wanting to do jhatka and cook meat).

Re: Who eats meat?

Admin · 08 Feb 2005

Eating meat is against the message of Gurbani and as such we advise all our readers to abstain from eating meat. Don’t create negative Karma for yourself by eating flesh. Stick to Lacto-Vegetarian diet. For details please read the articles in following links: http://www.tapoban.org/meat.htm http://www.tapoban.org/jhatka.htm This topic is now closed. Admin.