Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi
Jarnail Singh Gyani "arshi" · 03 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh.
Read some of the past Issues of the INTJSA..International Journal of Sikh Affairs....published in Edmonton Canada under the able Chief Editorship of Dr. Awatar Singh Ji Sekhon Machaki. There is a lot of factual stuff in there that will clear ALL your doubts.
For Subscription and past issues enquiry please contact.
Address: Sikh Educational trust
Box 60246,
University fo Alberta Postal Outlet,
Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2S5.
Email: [address removed]
Gyani Jarnail Singh Dhillon "arshi"
Guest Editor INTJSA.
As a short course on MK Gandhi.. He HIJACKED the Swadeshi Movement initiated by Ram Singh namdharee..
He HIJACKED the NON-VIOLENT MOvement of the Sikh Akali Lehr
He called Guru Gobind Singh a BHULLAR DESH BHAGAT.... as compard to national HERO Shivaji.... this is agreat INSULT and msirepresenttaion of Sikhi and Guru Ji.
He was the main Architect by having a fast unto Death stunt TO SABOTAGE the move by Dr Amdekar and his millions of Dalitsto convert to Sikhi
He wrote a lot of Untruths and lies about Sikhi and the Gurus in his monthly magazines
He was also one of those who lied to the Siksh about NO PAKISTAN..and thus the Sikhs got the worst end of the stick when Partition ocurred...even the Sarhadi gandhi got cheated by MK Gandhi...etc etc
Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi
AnotherSingh · 03 Feb 2005
Gandhi: Behind the Mask of Divinity
http://www.sikhspectrum.com/082004/gandhi_mask.htm
Gandhi Branded Racist as Johannesburg Honours Freedom Fighter
http://www.sikhspectrum.com/082004/gandhi_south_africa.htm
Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi
Search For Tat · 03 Feb 2005
The best book on this subject on how Hindus have systematically destroyed Punjab, and Sikh, was written by Sangat singh. It is called Sikhs In History.
It clearly has every speech, and time, and news ereport of events, and what MK Gandhi has siad about SiKhs. You will be shocked.
Sangat Singh worked as policy maker in India, so had access to alot more info than most.
A definate read.
Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi
.................... · 03 Feb 2005
he was anti sikhi
Juts like the RSS of today.
Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 03 Feb 2005
What did Gandhi have to do with the creation of Pakistan and the exodus of Sikhs from that part of Panjab?
I was on the phone with my uncleji, and he starts telling me of this long trip that he took with his mom at age 4...how he was on the train in only his kachheras, and how he remembers very little about the trip except the brutal hunger and thirst.
He blamed Gandhi for much of it...but I was a bit too overcome with the emotion of the story to ask why he blamed Gandhi.
Any ideas?
Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi
AnotherSingh · 04 Feb 2005
The Hindus has said that they wanted a united India, with Muslims and Hindus together. However, during congress meetings they would often make anti-Muslim remarks. Muhammed Al-Jinna, once a very staunch supporter of a united India, realized that Muslims would never be given equality in a country with a Hindu majority and decided that the only solution was the creation of an independant Muslim state.
Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi
Partition and Aftermath · 04 Feb 2005
Sat Sri Akal:
When the British were leaving India, they chose the representatives of the three religious communities of India: The Hindus, the Muslims and the Sikhs. They met with the British representative Lord Mountbatten to broker the deals of how India would be split up after the British occupation ended. The Hindus were represented by Nehru, the Muslims by Jinnah, and the Sikhs by Master Tara Singh/Baldev Singh. In the beginning, it would have been easy for the Sikhs to get their own homeland if they wanted to...even easier than the Pakistan that the Muslims wanted. However, the foresight of the Sikh leadership was poor and gullible. At one meeting between the parties concerned, Mountbatten even asked the Sikh representative Baldev Singh if they wanted a Sikh homeland. In his infinite wisdom, he stated to the press publicly something along the lines of "If the Sikhs want an independent nation, they will ask their Hindu brethern for it". (My father explained that Baldev Singh was a leading industrialist in India and perhaps due to his not wanting his businesses to be affected by a partition, he put his own greed ahead of Sikh interests). Baldev Singh upon his deathbed reportedly cursed himself for this decision over and over.
Jinnah was a very smart and shrewd man. Without having to send Muslims to violently or peacefully clash with the British, the man was able to broker a deal for an entire country. By far, the Sikh have and are still losing the most of this all. They lost the best farmlands (in spite of this, Guru Sahib's Kirpa is Beant...Indian Punjab, once a swampy marsh is now out-producing Pakistan Punjab), thousands of Sikhs and the current tragedies of recent history and present.
We have nobody to curse but out own near-sightedness. People blame Tara Singh and Baldev Singh (and others in that time period)...but what were the rest of the Sikhs doing? They followed these people with full faith, demonstrating that there was a general lack of awareness of basic politics and reality. Clinging to the belief that their Hindu brethern would be ever amicable to them, they were awakened to a tragic reality right after independence, when Nehru and the entire Brahmin Regime bared its teeth at the Sikhs and commenced its siege against the Panth. Whether it be the dressed up politicians in immaculate Kurta Pajamas, the Khaki Chaddi RSS, the thug-goon Shiv Sena, the cerebrally poisoned Arya Samaj or others, the Brahmin onslaught has been attacking the Sikh Panth mind, body and soul since independence. Who can we blame then and now? Nobody but ourselves.
Through this, a Sikh can only ask for the strength to follow the Almighty's Hukam through this tough time.