nihung
bhujangee · 31 Jan 2005
Is it true that if a nihung meets the Guru face-to-face that it is their duty to challenge the Guru to a fight? There are some rules that nihungs live by and this is one that I heard about.
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
bhujangee · 31 Jan 2005
Is it true that if a nihung meets the Guru face-to-face that it is their duty to challenge the Guru to a fight? There are some rules that nihungs live by and this is one that I heard about.Jarnail Singh Gyani · 31 Jan 2005
GOOD......FIGHTING with GURU JI is the only thing left that we have NOT done yet....as we have had fights with everyone else already. jarnail Singhsinghni · 31 Jan 2005
what a load of crap............... · 31 Jan 2005
lolManpreet Kaur · 31 Jan 2005
whooaa...REALLy?!?! To Challenge?!?!?!?!? I DON"T THINK SO..that just doesn't feeel or sound right IN ANY WAY. To challenge God you have to think that you are at the same level or something. THIS IS RIDICULOUS! haaaaa....CHALLENGE GURU SAHIB..Pleeeeeeease!BirRaas Singh · 31 Jan 2005
a true warrior will face mahakaal (vaheguroo) if faced by him, whether he can win is not the question, its the dying in battle and at the hands of the greatest warrior (akaal) which is focused on nothing to do with fighting guru jiGupt Singh · 31 Jan 2005
Someone pulling our leg. It's like going Gurdwara and fighting with Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. How does that work? Why the hell would a GurSIkh want to fight Guru Jee? I am getting bored of this Nihangs do this and Nihangs to that! The stories seem to be getting more and more far fetched. What next, Nihangs eat babies???!!! · 31 Jan 2005
> a true warrior will face mahakaal (vaheguroo) if faced by him, whether he > can win is not the question, its the dying in battle and at the hands of the > greatest warrior (akaal) which is focused on I've heard this before and it does not only apply to nihungs.Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 31 Jan 2005
I heard Nihangs are sock puppets on Sikhism bulletin boards...is that true??? ;-) LOL!!!......... · 31 Jan 2005
it seems nihangs themselves are saying it is. I am shocked. i think we should be following our Guru, not fighting him. BirRaas Singh wrote: > a true warrior will face mahakaal (vaheguroo) if faced by him, > whether he can win is not the question, its the dying in battle > and at the hands of the greatest warrior (akaal) which is > focused on > > nothing to do with fighting guru jiAKJ 4EVA AND EVA AMEN · 31 Jan 2005
vjkk vjkf attention all nangs if you think that fightin ur guru is good u obviously have no conception of guru ji or religion and i advise you just to give up and convert into christians as its a lot easier this way vjkk vjkf. . . . . . . . . . . · 31 Jan 2005
Why you always gotta pick on some group? This is not about the act, this is the 'warrior mentality'. And nihungs are soldiers.Amar Singh · 31 Jan 2005
"a true warrior will face mahakaal (vaheguroo) if faced by him, whether he can win is not the question, its the dying in battle and at the hands of the greatest warrior (akaal) which is focused on" what a load of rubbish. Khalsa is Akaal Purkh Ki Fauj and belongs to Waheguru and is not his enemy. Khalsa woships and longs for God which is why he/she takes weapons and fights against injustices (idealy). This is the source of a Sikhs strenght not fighting Waheguru. We will all fall at the hands of the greatest warrior Waheguru anyway.Singhstah · 31 Jan 2005
wat da heck! yeah sure go ahead and fight guroo ji if u want your head cut off [%sig%]Singh · 31 Jan 2005
You guys suck, real Nihangs are cool. And they can actually fight, which is something the vast majority of the Taksal/AKJ/GNNSJ/Whatever youth can't do. BTW a UK Sanatanist (aka Satanist) does not count as a Nihang. Wearing a blue dumalla and learning Shastar Vidiya does not make you a Nihang.volvic · 31 Jan 2005
Erm, is it me or have you all missed the last sentance 'BirRaas Singh' has written, 'nothing to do with fighting guru ji' [%sig%]BirRaas Singh · 31 Jan 2005
i would suggest some people go back to primary school and learn how to read, where has anyone stated that nihangs go out lookin for a fight? or there is any emnity against waheguroo, guru maharaj or anyone else for that matter? for the benefit of the people who cant understand simple english i will quote myself "a true warrior will face mahakaal (vaheguroo) if faced by him" IF faced by him, where does it say nihangs go looking for waheguroo or guru ji to fight them? lets not assume what others say, rather lets read what is written. who is the ultimate power in the world? vaheguroo, if someone trains in such a way that he may be able to challenge the greatest power in the world, then obviously he will have the dedication to surpass any other warrior, why look at lower beings and try to challenge them when the highest being is waheguroo. it is a mentality and focus which allows u to never give up. i dont expect anyone else to agree with me, nor am i here to apease certain individuals, this is my outlook and i will stick to it gurfatehA Singh · 31 Jan 2005
Read about Kharak Singh from Krishna Avtar (Sri Guru Dasam Durbar)fighting spirit · 31 Jan 2005
two words - fighting spiritbhujangee · 31 Jan 2005
Thanks for the info BirRaas Singh. That's exactly what I was looking for.gkd · 31 Jan 2005
"a true warrior will face mahakaal (vaheguroo) if faced by him" i agree man, singhs dont' back down. even though loss is inevetible against guru jis sword, even if it wuz smaller then his pniky finger.......... · 01 Feb 2005
if this these warrior mentality was there, then why in 1984 and after, they did not support the Singhs?Singh · 01 Feb 2005
What abour Kharak Singh from Krishna Avtar, expand if you can rather than saying a line with no explanation or reasion. Sikhs fight those in the wrong and are tyrants. Waheguru and Guru are the only ones who do not makes mistakes and are never in the wrong. Hence the whole concept of facing Waheguru or Guru in battle is foolish and idiotic. Perhaps those who talk the talk and like ACTING like hard men and thinking about challanging God if faced by him should start with the little Indian Goverment, unless all this is just talk. You are not going to face God or Guru in Battle so talking about it is stupid. But the much weaker tyrants of the World you can meet in battle, so put you money where your mouth is.. . . . . . . . . . . · 01 Feb 2005
Inaction is lack of warrior mentality. If you have this warrior mentality then you won't even let someone look at you Guru the wrong way, let alone walk into the Golden Temple with armored vehicles.sahajdhari · 01 Feb 2005
FYI, Isrealites (jews) supposedly faught god and won, looollll....... as for nihungs, we should leave them alone, buddah daal is great, alot of bhagats came from there, just cuz some ppl are messed up and call them selves nihung doesnt mean they are, and its obvious to us....nihungs arent all about fighting, they actully sooo alot of paat, and id like to point out alll other jathas draw back there lineage to buddah daal, pretty much thw whole panth.....now i may not agree with some things in the rehit, but they should still be respected nang is a derogetory term its like saying "nigger"sooo maybe we should try to treat fellow sikhs with respect no?Nihang Singh Budhal Dal UK · 01 Feb 2005
Just because we are meant to be warriors does that mean we should fight our Guru. We are Warrior but we should also be Sants. A Nihang is also Humble, so if Guru jee does challage A Nihang Singh, the Nihang Singh should be Humble, but willing to give hes life to Guru. BUDHAL DAL 4 LIFE.... · 01 Feb 2005
if u have ever practised a martial art properly u will understand wot that notion means, if i were to chalenge a superior master to a duel it would be becuz i am at their feet knowing i am going to die but willing to die by their sword or hands. It is not out of hunkar it is out of piaar for my master chalenging the greatest would only increase my martial arts potential. i think most of these people in these forums need to get out more and stop discussing these issues on the net. And actually practise a martial art and be willing to die at the hands of a superior warrior.chinky · 02 Feb 2005
all you people are too carried away with martial arts. I agree you need to know what to do in case of problem but it comes down to the man wid da heart of steel whos gonna say lets die if we have to but give it all the best . its got nuttin to do with your precious martial farts. Some gangsta pulls a trigger on you wheres your sher fly kicks go then? cs spray your eyes out youyr gone! chilla powder in your akha? your at the mercy. I seen a gal who did ghatka 5 years, some kala pulls a machete she gives in. i dont give two craps whether its shastervedia or ghatka. your mind jus gotto say sod it all the way to the end till im dead if thats what it takes. i agree with that. do do your martial arts but dont think ur invincible by that, if tyou aint got the heart for it your going down no matter how long you done your martial spartialz.jarnail kaur arshi · 02 Feb 2005
hey this is not kung fu...where u talk of masters and fighting againsts masters all the ABCDs out there have got this thing about masters and stuff and mixing gatka with other martial arts mixed up.....it is big time chinese and japanese adulteration the singhs draw their power from akalpurakh (waheguroo) and their guroo teaches them how to do it. How can u fight the akalpurakh when you draw your power and shakti from him. None of you know the sakhi from Guru Hargobind Sahibs time when Pende Khan (warrior trained by Guru Sahib) thought he was powerful enuff to turn againsts Guroo Sahib. What happened to him?????????Sewak · 02 Feb 2005
Gatka is just a mere martial art without Bhakti. If we have Bhakti behind us we won't challenge Guruji. The Guru's gave a Sant, not a Soldier, a Sword. There's millions of Solidiers with Swords but the difference with Sikhs is that Guruji made us Sants first then gave us the Sword. All this talk is rubbish about fighting the master. I don't even think a Nihang would have even said that. This sounds like a typical 'Nidar Santanic UK Nang Quote'.chinky · 02 Feb 2005
sewak is right i agree with him. You are in no position to challange God. God is where you draw your power from.chinese whisper · 27 Feb 2005
WAHeguru ji ka KhalsaAAAA WAHeguru ji kee FATEHHHHH on the foolish being's website, the following is quoted from sri dasam granth ji... ‘He who’s name the four Yugas [i.e., all time] contemplates, with Him let us duel and thus die and attain salvation.’ from this, the foolish nang deducts... "Within Dasam Guru Durbar, it is written that even if you meet God, considering He is the greatest warrior, a Khalsa warrior should challenge and engage the Master of the universe and thus die at the hands of the greatest warrior and attain eternal salvation." So from this claim, one nang passes it on to another and suddenly, most don't know why, but claim "yo did u know a nihang would challenge guru ji if he met him". how backwards and completely funny. reminds me of that post by kulbir singh about the monkeys (someon please post the link, and you'll see what i mean!) guroo guroohello sangat ji · 27 Feb 2005
It is not true that only nihung singhs are good at gatka. gatka comes from guru ji, not from any jathebandi or organization. trust me, join a gatka acedamy for like a year. u would not get anything in ur head without guru sahib's kirpa. i kno singhs who are so good in gatka because of their nam abhyaas. jus chill people, use ur judgement. [%sig%]sikh · 25 Aug 2005
well said Jarnail Singh ji.....these nihungs need to be taken care of once and for all, they should banned in the west due to religious incitment and be deported ......FIGHTING with GURU JI is the only thing left that we have NOT done yet....as we have had fights with everyone else already. jarnail Singhbull · 30 Aug 2005
what a load of crap if a nihang's duty is to challenge the guru to a fight then then nihangs are devil worshippers whether or not it's about warrior spirit. anyone ever heard of respect. how bout it's their duty to bow before the guru. why would they need to challenge the guru? if this is true then i gotta say nihangs are full of ****!!!!somebody · 31 Aug 2005
No offence but some guys on here really dont have knowledge do you?? Guru Hargobind Set up the Akaali Nihangs. Did they fight him?? Its not Guru they fight! They fight for the Guru. They also ill face any army u put infront of them, whether out numbered or not, they have no attachment for worldly goods and only crave death to be with akaal purakh!! You may mean Gurdev (teacher, according to some persons... the word used by gatkha bhajis is Ustaad). And quite rightly so if they "Gurdev" is not fit to teach Sikhi to others... Also its like a ranking thing, you fight the person above you for the power of the next step - ary style except you dnt just get awarded a new role... Nihangs are not bad people, remember, Guru Gobind Singh Ji was Nihang. Baba Deep Singh, head of Taksaal!!! He was Nihang!!! Remeber this, Nihangs arnt thieves, thieves become Nihangs! Bear in mind, if one puts on a dhumala and nihang bana he carries the appearance of the Nihang Singh. BUT it does not mean he carries the heart to go with it! The passion for Sikhi, the passion for Bani, the passion for death! WJKK WJKFjugroop singh · 31 Aug 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, niddar once said in a lesson of his i attended in Slough (i attended around 4 lessons around 1.5 years ago) that: "if an opponent knocks-off a Singh's Dastaar, that Singh should drink the blood of that person in return". in the interests of promoting 'Authentic Khalsa Practices', which is niddar's primary aim if his affiliated websites are to be believed, can one of niddar's students explain this...i am truly fascinated as to where this Asool has come from... - Is it based upon ANY even remotely Sikhi-related scriptures? - Is there some sort of cast-Sarbloh 'oral historical account' pertaining to it? i would appreciate an answer and not a 'go and ask niddar'. i don't want to speak to him because that would be to do the Sangat of someone who allows the nindiya of Shaheed Singhs amongst many other things...those students of his who are reading this: > if niddar is your 'Gurdev', then the least you can do is share the reasoning behind his beliefs with those who wish to learn more. i always feel the need to talk about my one and only 'Gurdev' - Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji. PARAMJEET SINGH, if you are reading this i would appreciate your intelligent response...perhaps you could also answer the following as well: - during which kind of specific circumstances are the 'Khalsa': "allowed to commit adultery/fornication"? - why would Punjaab be better-off if: "everyone was taking Bhang"? the first comment you apparently made in Canada - Veer Kulbir Singh Ji was present. the second comment you made to me during a conversation around 5-10 mths ago. if the UK Nihangs/Jatha Singhs are truly interested in debate and discussion and not 'they jump our guys, we jump their guys, the other guys jump our guys' behaviour, lets all prove it by discussing these fascinating issues with some maturity...with neither side waiting with baited and even fearful breath for the next violent episode. bhul chuk maaf karn jio. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!jugroop singh · 02 Sep 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, here's a thread called 'nihung' and not one of niddar's students seems to be willing to take part and at least offer some sort of answers regarding what i believe are fascinating issues and questions...? oh well... VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!- · 02 Sep 2005
I heard that a Nihang has to hop on one leg and tap his head with left hand whilst rubbing his stomach clockwise with his right hand... is this true? or is it just the after affects of them taking bhang?Singh · 02 Sep 2005
"-", LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!name? who cares? · 02 Sep 2005
there is no such thing as a real nihung.....we are nihungs when we take amrit(doesnt have to be the akj) the thing is we are supposed to become soormey and be able to fite wearing a huge dummala, carrying weapons on ur paag, and wearing a chola does not make u a nihung, uve gotta have the inner strenghSingh · 02 Sep 2005
Yeah real Nihungs really coo peps. You can chill, drink, smoke and eat meat with them. What better than getting high with the sadh sangatLakhvir Singh · 03 Sep 2005
WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh. The Guru fought mock fights with his Sikhs when practicing the art of warfare. It sharpened the skills of two great warriors. Of course the Guru is the Commander and always the best, no doubt. But sometimes, I like to imagine, that if the Guru were around today in a physical roop, he would have challenged a warrior Singh/Singhni to a duel in the art of shasters to see just how good he/she would be if faced with the enemy. If you want to know just good you are as a warrior, challenge the best. If the challenge is done in ego, no doubt the go-drunk warrior will be lying on the ground as a defeated man. No one can really challenge the Guru, but in the fun of it, even the Guru loves to have a game or two! WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.AS · 04 Sep 2005
This is an excerpt from: Understanding the Sikh Rehat Maryada Sunday 4th September, 2005 Gurmukh Singh - Panthic Weekly Staff Hemp (Canabis) Unfortunately in recent years many people who don’t follow the Khalsa rehat (way of life) strictly and have good moral characters have brought shame to the ‘Nihang’s by claiming to be Nihangs or associating themselves to the Nihang Singhs. A number of Nihang Singhs observe some rituals and practices, which are contrary to Gurmat, for example consuming ‘bhang’ (hemp/cannabis), has crept in to their customs from the period of when Mahants (Hindus) managed and maintained our Gurdwaras in 18th – early 20th century. However, those who follow these anti-gurmat practices claim that they are ‘old traditions’ from the Guru’s time, despite the fact that Gurbaani gives us enlightenment on whether these practices and observances are Gurmat (according to the guru’s teachings) or Manmat (self-willed). ‘Bhang’ or ‘Sukhnidhaan’, which is marijuana (cannabis) used by large number of Nihangs nowadays is justified through various means of quoting tales and stories and claiming to be ‘old tradition’s. However, our Guru is eternal and with us forever. Why do we need to refer to stories and justifying traditions by claiming they are ‘old tradition’s passed down, when we have Guru Granth Sahib Ji with us to tell us what is in accordance to Gurmat? Gurbaani clearly condemns the consumption of marijuana. Furthermore, medical studies carried out have proven that consumption of marijuana and cannabis on regular basis leads to schizophrenia, and mental problems such as memory loss. ਅਮਲੁ ਗਲੋਲਾ ਕੂੜ ਕਾ ਦਿਤਾ ਦੇਵਣਹਾਰਿ ॥ ਮਤੀ ਮਰਣੁ ਵਿਸਾਰਿਆ ਖੁਸੀ ਕੀਤੀ ਦਿਨ ਚਾਰਿ ॥ ਸਚੁ ਮਿਲਿਆ ਤਿਨ ਸੋਫੀਆ ਰਾਖਣ ਕਉ ਦਰਵਾਰੁ ॥1॥ “The Great Giver has given the intoxicating drug of falsehood. The people are intoxicated; they have forgotten death, and they have fun for a few days. Those who do not use intoxicants are true; they dwell in the Court of Vaheguru. ||1||†(Ang 15, SGGS) 'Janamsakhi Bhai Bala' states that Babur heard Guru Nanak Dev Ji sing the shabad: ਖੁਰਾਸਾਨ ਖਸਮਾਨਾ ਕੀਆ ਹਿੰਦੁਸਤਾਨੁ ਡਰਾਇਆ ॥ “Having attacked Khuraasaan, Baabar terrified Hindustan…†(Ang 360, SGGS) Hearing this shabad, Babar called Guru Ji and asked him to sing it again. Guru Ji sang it again. Babur said, "Friends, he is a nice 'Faqeer' (Holy man)." Then, he offered 'Bhang' to Guru Ji and said, "O Saint, eat the 'Bhang'." However, Guru Ji replied, "Meer Ji, I have eaten the Bhang, whose stimulation never ends". Babur asked, "Which is the Bhang, whose stimulation never ends?" Guru Ji asked Baba Mardaana Ji to play on 'Rabaab'. Guru Ji recited this shabad: - ਤਿਲੰਗ ਮਹਲਾ 1 ਘਰੁ 2 ੴ ਸਤਿਗੁਰ ਪ੍ਰਸਾਦਿ ॥ ਭਉ ਤੇਰਾ ਭਾਂਗ ਖਲੜੀ ਮੇਰਾ ਚੀਤੁ ॥ ਮੈ ਦੇਵਾਨਾ ਭਇਆ ਅਤੀਤੁ ॥ ਕਰ ਕਾਸਾ ਦਰਸਨ ਕੀ ਭੂਖ ॥ ਮੈ ਦਰਿ ਮਾਗਉ ਨੀਤਾ ਨੀਤ ॥1॥ ਤਉ ਦਰਸਨ ਕੀ ਕਰਉ ਸਮਾਇ ॥ ਮੈ ਦਰਿ ਮਾਗਤੁ ਭੀਖਿਆ ਪਾਇ ॥1॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ ਕੇਸਰਿ ਕੁਸਮ ਮਿਰਗਮੈ ਹਰਣਾ ਸਰਬ ਸਰੀਰੀ ਚੜ੍ਣਾ ॥ ਚੰਦਨ ਭਗਤਾ ਜੋਤਿ ਇਨੇਹੀ ਸਰਬੇ ਪਰਮਲੁ ਕਰਣਾ ॥2॥ ਘਿਅ ਪਟ ਭਾਂਡਾ ਕਹੈ ਨ ਕੋਇ ॥ ਐਸਾ ਭਗਤੁ ਵਰਨ ਮਹਿ ਹੋਇ ॥ ਤੇਰੈ ਨਾਮਿ ਨਿਵੇ ਰਹੇ ਲਿਵ ਲਾਇ ॥ ਨਾਨਕ ਤਿਨ ਦਰਿ ਭੀਖਿਆ ਪਾਇ ॥3॥1॥2॥ “Tilang, First Mehl, Second House: One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: The Fear of You, O Lord Vaheguru, is my marijuana (cannabis); my consciousness is the pouch, which holds it. I have become an intoxicated hermit. My hands are my begging bowl; I am so hungry for the Blessed Vision of Your Darshan. I beg at Your Door, day after day. ||1|| I long for the Blessed Vision of Your Darshan. I am a beggar at Your Door - please bless me with Your charity. ||1||Pause|| Saffron, flowers, musk oil and gold embellish the bodies of all. The Lord's devotees are like sandalwood, which imparts its fragrance to everyone. ||2|| No one says that ghee or silk are polluted. Such is the Lord's devotee, no matter what his social status is. Those who bow in reverence to the Naam, the Name of Vaheguru, remain absorbed in Your Love. Nanak begs for charity at their door. ||3||1||2||†(Ang 721, SGGS) Guru Ji clearly says that ‘ਭਉ ਤੇਰਾ ਭਾਂਗ’ (Bhau Tera Bhaang), meaning 'The Fear of You, Vaheguru, is my marijuana (cannabis)'. Thus, Vaheguru's Fear is the true 'Bhang' for a Sikh. Reading this holy shabad, how can anyone say that Guru Ji accepted ‘Bhang' and that he has not condemned it? If Guru Ji was pleased when Babur offered 'Bhang' to him, why did Guru Sahib not drink it? 'Janamsakhi Bhai Bala' does not state that Guru Ji drank 'Bhang', contrary to what some people claim in pursuit of defending their manmat practices.jugroop singh · 08 Sep 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, i've seen plenty of 'sanaatan/akali nihung/uk nihang' poster on this forum but none of them, it seems, want to have a discussion about the issues i raised eventhough i am raising them in a respectable manner. i wrote a post whihc included these questions: niddar once said in a lesson of his i attended in Slough (i attended around 4 lessons around 1.5 years ago) that: "if an opponent knocks-off a Singh's Dastaar, that Singh should drink the blood of that person in return". in the interests of promoting 'Authentic Khalsa Practices', which is niddar's primary aim if his affiliated websites are to be believed, can one of niddar's students explain this...i am truly fascinated as to where this Asool has come from... - Is it based upon ANY even remotely Sikhi-related scriptures? - Is there some sort of cast-Sarbloh 'oral historical account' pertaining to it? PARAMJEET SINGH, if you are reading this i would appreciate your intelligent response...perhaps you could also answer the following as well: - during which kind of specific circumstances are the 'Khalsa': "allowed to commit adultery/fornication"? - why would Panjaab be better-off if: "everyone was taking Bhang"? the first comment you apparently made in Canada - Veer Kulbir Singh Ji was present. the second comment you made to me during a conversation around 5-10 mths ago. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!avidya · 09 Sep 2005
Waheguruji Ka Khalsa Waheguruji Ki Fateh If there really is no ego in your seeming sincere desire to learn more about them, then I'm sure you will simply seek them out and speak to them. I was researching a particular group a year or so ago, and rather than talk to the wall, I sought them out and phoned them up. If I was qualified I'd answer any question for you, but even though I am what you choose to label a 'snatanist' (whatever that means, after repeated requests people on here have repeatedly failed to define it), I am not a Nihung and I do not study or practice Nihang maryada. In all honesty, of the people I know who are Nihangs or following Nihang maryada, I don't actually think they DO visit this forum for the simple reason that can be seen above of general disrespect to all Nihangs. If I may I’ll add that Bhai Jugroop Singh, I personally doubt your interest is sincere due to your openly stated sense of superiority (you state you 'pity' Nihangs). I'd advise you to recognise that a Sikh of the Guru should not hold such an arrogant superiority complex over others who you happen to disagree with, for the sake of your own kamai. I am generally surprised by that statement as I have been in the past impressed by your lack of ego in discussing certain topics. As a side note for the sake of clarification, I'll take it point by point. Would you define a snatanist as one who holds that the Guru is avatar, in the same sense as Sri Ram Chander and Sri Krishan Bhagvan? I look forward to your answer.A Singh · 09 Sep 2005
Gur Fateh! This is a really interesting post – it shows the mentality of both the pro-Nihangs and anti-Nihangs quite aptly. Despite the half-baked attempts by ALL organisations to link themselves to Guru Sahib as the one and only authentic Sikh movement, in reality anyone who endeavours to read through Sikh History with an open mind will soon realise that ALL of these institutions, schools, sampradhas, jathas and lineages are fake – Simple. As cheesy and over simplified as this sounds, Guru Sahib created the Khalsa Panth in 1699 and that was that! The rest is the result of the much quoted “time, space and circumstance” which some have chosen to give further credibility to by inventing supposed lineages and establishing what they believe to be “Tat Gurmat Maryada”. I’ll leave it at that for now with regard to “the real Nihangs” are chardikala and the “UK NIhangs are part of the Buddha Dal, which has lineage” and “we are all NIhangs!” and the “Hi I’m ChardiKala Singh who is dressed in the traditional Blue Sikh dress and Conical Turban (YEAH RIGHT! –read some history buddy!) and I’ll take you around the Gurdwara today to show you some excellent Pakhand Kirtan etc etc” blah blah – we are SIKHS! Let’s stick with that and move on… As for the “facing Akal Purakh” concept – this is nothing new. Jarnail Singh Gyani, there is no need to bring in Chinese or Japanese arts into question here, this concept is entirely Indian. Just like the term “Shaheed” comes from the Arabic/Islamic world, within India the concept was known as “Veergati” and can be found throughout the Puranic literature and beyond it - even in Greek and Roman legends. In a nutshell, it simply states that one who fights bravely and valiantly will receive blessing, paradise, heaven, kingdoms, fairies, eternal life etc etc. The fact that this gets mentioned in the Dasam Granth is nothing exceptional, as Guru Sahib has employed many poetic forms and with them traditions in the writings contained within this Magnus Opus. This is why one will find in texts that even the ‘bad guy’ will receive seeming compliments as he is fighting bravely and well – for instance in early literature, Ravan is actually depicted as a handsome, highly skilled and charismatic warrior, even if he is the ‘baddie’ in the story, so to speak. This concept is nothing to do with the khands described in JapJi Sahib and hence I personally cannot see the need for this discussion or elaboration of such a thought within a Sikh philosophy setting – understanding it for the purposes of poetical nuances and mental preparation is quite another item altogether, it does not in any event have any backing from Gurbani, where moral qualities play a much higher role than just “fighting” well – however this is nothing new as an idea within Sikh minds, as previously mentioned a few months back, I showed how the so-called Chardikala Singhs of the past actually fought for the Moghuls against Baba Banda Singh Bahadur and subsequently their “lineage” sought to write him out of Sikh history by accusing him of betraying the Guru to the extent of even questioning him being a Sikh at all. However, given the response I saw on that thread, I doubt this will have much impact as the one sajjan who stated “Sure Singh, you have evidence to back up what you say, but I still don’t believe you, I just can’t!” perhaps outlines why its best to simply let Sikhs today believe whatever they want, because that’s all they will do at the end of any discussion!!! Gur Fateh! A Singhjugroop singh · 10 Sep 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Dearest Veer/Bhain 'Avidya' Ji, you wrote: "If I may I’ll add that Bhai Jugroop Singh, I personally doubt your interest is sincere due to your openly stated sense of superiority (you state you 'pity' Nihangs). I'd advise you to recognise that a Sikh of the Guru should not hold such an arrogant superiority complex over others who you happen to disagree with, for the sake of your own kamai. I am generally surprised by that statement as I have been in the past impressed by your lack of ego in discussing certain topics" Veer Ji, that is a major assumption - not all 'pity' is based on ego although much of it may be based upon cloaking a sense of self-perceived superiority...my pity here is a sense of sympathy - just as i would feel sympathy for a homeless person... i can also sincerely say that i do not think i am better or worse than any of the 'UK Nihangs'...what more can be said about your statement? my interest is also 'sincere': when i have asked questions like the following in the past... - why were pages referring to Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh as a 'nang' taken-off the ShasterVidiya website in a clandestine manner, without an apology...and this despite the website's commitment to 'speaking the truth' no matter what? ...and the ones you see in my earlier posts within this thread, i do so to meet the challenge that jagdeep/niddar have set: that debate and discussion should ensue as a result of their writings/philosophy. regarding 'searching groups out', i guess that if every-time someone wants to get a response over the internet regarding these issues, they are told they are not being sincere, or that they should phone the person or carry on communicating with a 'wall', then there will be no open discussion - thats one way to stifle a debate. i did go to 4 lessons in the Slough area a while back but realised, through the words of a close Singh, that this kind of Sangat would lead me away from Siree Guru Sahib Ji. i have said elsewhere that to proactively do Sangat of such people is also against GurMat - to me, that is the kind of treatement that should be meted out to anyone who shows such contempt for Mahan Shaheed Singhs. and here's my GurMat test: would Siree Guru Gobind Singh Ji want me to proactively search out and spend 'quality time' with those who have slandered his beloved Shaheed Singhs..? i think the answer is simple...perhaps you don't. also, lets rememeber that the 'controversial Parchaar' that jagdeep and niddar have produced was not mainly conveyed via their one-to-one chats with people - the impact was created by publishing the info within the public domain via the websites...i am simply using the same domain (internet) to respond. what is wrong with this? now if i bumped into them on the street or at work as in one recent case, without my proactive intent to do their Sangat, sure i'd raise these points (i have raised points in the past with niddar and Paramjit Singh), but lets just say i wouldn't retire with them after the discussion to watch a movie and chill-out...i wouldn't really want to spend more time with them then i have to! Siree Guru Sahib Ji has taught us jsu how much of an effect that Sangat can have upon us - not only positively but also negatively. i would also like to respectfully say that where i stated the following... "'sanaatan/akali nihung/uk nihang' poster[s]...none of them, it seems, want to have a discussion about the issues i raised eventhough i am raising them in a respectable manner" ...it wasn't my intention to have a debate regarding the term 'Sanaatan' - i think you 'got' the import of my reference here...not to start a debate regarding a 'word' but rather to refer to a particular slant taken by some posters. i remember previously engaging in a debate with you on this very forum; it didn't really go anywhere - i'm sure you must have felt the same. anyhow, the word Sanaatan which i personally feel is pretty 'gaseous', isn't of central importance here...feel free to start another thread if you like Veer Ji about its definition and if it hink i've got something to contribute, i will take part. however, right here, right now, i would like my REAL QUESTIONS to be addressed by those who feel they would like to. ps - nice to see you posting after what has seemed like a significant gap. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!jugroop singh · 11 Sep 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, perhaps Veer/Bhain 'Avidya' Ji was right...no-one seems to want to discuss... VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!? · 11 Sep 2005
Author: AKJ 4EVA AND EVA AMEN dont you think you should rephrase your name to sikhi "4EVA AND EVA" As sikhs we should have tolerance and understanding before we lash out. you should treat everybody with equality and not differenciate between people just because they have a differnt interpretation and understanding that you. you should discuss any point you have with the individuals before just catergorising people. AKJ's or Nihang's or whatever Jatha has a right to practice sikhi. everybody is different and just because you belong to one sort of clique or group does not mean you are a better sikh that one from another jatha. Waheguru is prevading everywhere even in those that you are slanderingjugroop singh · 14 Sep 2005
bump....anyone....?realhistory · 14 Sep 2005
Jugroop Singh I think you have just been exposed to the typical method of debate of the Uk Nihangs. Firstly you are met with the accusation that your questions are insincere. Secondly not one of the UK Nihangs apart from their leaders seem to be accredited with discussing the Uk Nihang ideology. Even then you are liable to be told by them that answering your questions means you want them to spoon feed you and you need to look for the answers yourself. It's all very 'Kung Fu' grasshopper et al with a smattering of Karate Kid and Mr Miyagi! Thirdly any discussion you enter into will always get personal whether you yourself maintain a respectful attitude you will at a certain stage be accused of being a fanatic, a taliban or their all time favourite wahabi! Lastly be prepared to be waylaid into dead end discussion about define this and define that. This is similar to what Avidya has written asking you to define Snatan. Surely it is up to the creators of the websites who started to give life to a long dead word to define what it means. Afterall they are the ones who call themselves Snatan Sikhs.Jagwinder · 14 Sep 2005
Direct Talk between Prof Darshan Singh and Ranjit singh http://www.ggsacademy.com/1984/rehras.htmljugroop singh · 17 Sep 2005
bump...bump...come-on - interesting questions....jugroop singh · 22 Sep 2005
any 'UK Nihangs' who want to discuss these interesting questions...A Singh · 22 Sep 2005
Jugroop Singh, What questions are outstanding? It is clear that the concept of figthing Akal is nothing to do with Gurbani or Gurmat and is simply an adaption of the puranic "Veer Gati" thought, here used for the mental physche of the fighter - it seems pointless trying to link the two together. What else is there to discuss?akaali · 22 Sep 2005
they do this not to beat guroo sahib but to learn frmo him. guroo sahib is the ultimate fighter and when u fight someone harder it is training. back in guroosahibs day, when gurooji was a kid hed "mock fight" other kids. once they were training so hard apparently gurooosahib nailed the kid with his tulvar, the cut was deep in one of his shoulders. dont assume these uk "nangs" dont have dyaa. u guys put these guys down day in day out, and fine do it, see what happens at dharamraaj when u end up there.No more... · 22 Sep 2005
Quote/ THE BIG QUESTION- What is really going on?!!! Tarna dal is Getting Ready! You may have read recent messages on sikhawareness, sikhsangat, etc. In UK, there is some educated youth who seem to spend all day on computers with nothing else to do then manipulate things about AKJ. They have nihang thinking. Speaking to Nidaar, he is paranoid of jatha. He believes AKJ is greatest threat to Snaatan Sikhi. He believes Taksal are weak, and no threat, and he hates SGPC. The reason he is paranoid of AKJ is Bhai sahib Randhir Singh Jis book "Chaatka Maas Prathae Gurmat Tat Nirnae". He says this book has done most to stop sikhs eating meat and following Snaatan Sikhi. Well Done Bhai Sahib !!!!!!!! This is why all Nidar sites are very anti-akj, anti-Bhai Randhir Singh. They will try and find anything to put down AKJ. If all the new youth do not respect Bhai sahib and AKJ, then this book will have no impact. So Jnr nihangs have over last 2 years been going on every egroup slating AKJ. After most people in UK figured out who they were, and what they are about. They are a laughing stock! Their messages do not approved. Now they have hit the messageboards. I just think sikhawareness is the latest victim. Soon they will figure it out aswell. Best think AKJ can do is translate Bhai sahibs book and distribute everywhere. Best thing Taksal can do is sort their lives out, and stop helping Nidar and Co. Best thing everyone else can do is stop tolerating their ! Who are they : The Usual Suspects He uses names like Nihang Teja Singh, Narsingha, et c. He is PHD educated and very manipulative. He is the one who has made all the websites, and writes most emails. When approached about websites, he denied it was him. Nidar has confirmed it is him. On email Nihang Teja singh denies he is Jagdeep and says he has taken amrit and his name is Teja singh. Has he taken amrit again and is now Narsingha? Always in his mails, he speaks about searching for truth. If he is looking for truth, why when asked face to face does he deny everything. What kind of nihang hides? Why only speak on emails, not face to face, when we see him streets. This is just manipulation. He has been asking the same questions for over 2 years answered by many different people. It is not answers, but attention he seeks. He just wants attention to his websites, and he always brings them up in his mails. His main aim is to promote his warped view of sikhi via internet, at the same time, putting down number one enemy, which they state is akj. The internet is good tool for them as it amplifies their voice. In UK, they are laughing stock. All youth know who they are. Only a handful. Even Boss, now openly disowns them. They have nothing apart from 3 Gathka classes. Their latest one in Slough lasted one day, before Ramgarhia Gurdwara committee saw their website, and threw them out. Now they train in the park. If they are so truthful, then why are so many people coming to keertan programmes by AKJ, and regular amrit sanchaars, not only in Uk, but Europe and Worldwide. They just about run their 3 classes in Midlands, Slough one in park, no keertan, No amritsanchaars, no seva, no sharing bani, nothing apart from talk on internet. Nidar Singh: He is head of this thing. His thinking was explained above. Talks about Chatkaa gathka, but has been seen buying chickens from Sainburys supermarket!! The youth they manipulate over internet and classes start hating AKJ. Taksal first liked this, but when the new youth slagged Taksal off aswell, the Taksal went anti-nihang. After Gathka and hatred, they have nothing else to offer. Nidar nor Jagdeep do keertan or saanthiya, but slate everyone who does. A lot of youth do Cannabis. I have now heard of one youth who does heroin. I know his family, he started with cannabis and went on to heroin now. He was an Amritdhari youth, who they destroyed. A lot of other youth have drifted away from sikhi. They hate AKJ, Taksal, and after Nihangism, they have no sangat to inspire them. Youth in North America need to be careful. All Uk now know who they are, and now give them no platforms. But they are now using messageboards from abroad. I hope sikhawareness soon figures them out, and everyone else beware. Nidar said he maybe coming to New York soon. They use a quote from Dasam Bani : What is false I will call false. Even though the people may try to silence me. I do not care for what anybody says. I will speak but the truth from my mouth. (Akali Nihang Guru Gobind Singh, Treh Charittar No.266, Dasam Guru Durbar) Very clever, reverse pschology, aginst those who bring awareness of them. They use Gurbani, and Nihang culture to bring in Snaatan Sikhi or Hinduism. Gathka is just the attraction, the philosophy is so dangerous. Too many people give them time because of Ancient Nihang sacrifices, not knowing about this is new age nihangism. They are using Sikhi Bani & Sikhi Bani to manipulate Sikhi. Please forward to all messageboards they are on. Let them deny it is true. Jagdeep will just complain about AKJ paranioa, or manipulate something else. I am not AKJ, Taksal. But I respect both. I have no time for those who destroy Sikh Youth with drugs, and Jagdeep is doing that. /quotejugroop singh · 23 Sep 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Dearest Veer 'A Singh' Ji, as posed earlier (these q's being related to jagdeep/niddar's 'parchaar without basis'): " niddar once said in a lesson of his i attended in Slough (i attended around 4 lessons around 1.5 years ago) that: "if an opponent knocks-off a Singh's Dastaar, that Singh should drink the blood of that person in return". in the interests of promoting 'Authentic Khalsa Practices', which is niddar's primary aim if his affiliated websites are to be believed, can one of niddar's students explain this...i am truly fascinated as to where this Asool has come from... - Is it based upon ANY even remotely Sikhi-related scriptures? - Is there some sort of cast-Sarbloh 'oral historical account' pertaining to it? i would appreciate an answer and not a 'go and ask niddar'. i don't want to speak to him because that would be to do the Sangat of someone who allows the nindiya of Shaheed Singhs amongst many other things...those students of his who are reading this: > if niddar is your 'Gurdev', then the least you can do is share the reasoning behind his beliefs with those who wish to learn more. i always feel the need to talk about my one and only 'Gurdev' - Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji. PARAMJEET SINGH, if you are reading this i would appreciate your intelligent response...perhaps you could also answer the following as well: - during which kind of specific circumstances are the 'Khalsa': "allowed to commit adultery/fornication"? - why would Punjaab be better-off if: "everyone was taking Bhang"? the first comment you apparently made in Canada - Veer Kulbir Singh Ji was present. the second comment you made to me during a conversation around 5-10 mths ago. if the UK Nihangs/Jatha Singhs are truly interested in debate and discussion and not 'they jump our guys, we jump their guys, the other guys jump our guys' behaviour, lets all prove it by discussing these fascinating issues with some maturity...with neither side waiting with baited and even fearful breath for the next violent episode. " VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!A Singh · 23 Sep 2005
Veer Jagroop Singh Jeeo, Thanks for clearing up the confusion – as always, when a discussion starts on this point, the actual questions get clouded within the “nang this” and “Nang that” name calling. I am not a Nihang, let alone a UK Nihang and have no reason to defend or promote their views, however in the interest of academic discussion, here’s my additional 2 cents. I believe I was also in the lesson you referenced in Slough having just heard about a “new Sikh martial arts school” in London (in the park outside a Ramgarhia Gurdwara - please confirm this is the one you speak of?) I believe what Nidar Singh actually stated was words more to the effect that should one’s dastaar get dislodged during combat/battle, old Babas (most likely his Gurdev “Akali Katapa Singh”) would say Singhs should drink the opponents blood” This sounds pretty odd, however let’s put this into context of what actually was being said and done by Nidar Singh that day. I recall this clearly as the comment stood out as a strange one and I also remember his joke at the end of it! Nidar Singh, was if I am not mistaken, demonstrating a particular technique involving holds and responding to a strike – part of this actually could dislodge a dastaar (in fact one Singh, I believe had his Dumala come off during the demo and was retying it whilst Nidar Singh made this comment). He actually went on to say and quote passages from Chandi di Var concerning Kalika erupting from Chandi’s forehead during the last battle in the Var, and likened this to the situation at hand that with one’s Dastaar being dislodged and Kesh flying open, one can either run around looking for their Dastaar or adopt the roop of Kali and drink the opponents blood, when questioned further he said in reality it could either be a straight out bite/strike to the neck or simply tasting the blood of the opponent that may be on your sword. I walked away from that thinking – fine, this is definitely not any ‘written’ or ‘codified’ maryada, it’s simply something that either happened with one or two Nihangs in the past and people took to it, or something that his Baba told him in order to effectively psyche one up for battle. Again, it sounds to me nothing more than the above mentioned adapted ‘Veer gati’ ideas and romanticised a little bit for the youth today. Again, I cannot see this as being any ‘authentic’ Khalsa practice, but then again neither is much of what we see amongst those who claim to have “THE” Tat Maryada and will not accept that parts of what they do in the name of Gurmat are nothing more than ‘Bipran ki reet’ – examples of this can be found on most web forums at present. I would like to know more about the last questions that have been raised particularly for the attention of Paramjit Singh Grewal: <> What is the background to this, please could we have the full story as this sounds like a totally absurd claim if Mr Warrior Saints did suggest it! The second question << why would Punjaab be better-off if: "everyone was taking Bhang"?>> sounds little more than a joke. The level of discussion between pro and anti Nihang groups are not surprisingly poor, since both sides have simply read a few lines of their Jathedar/Baba/Bhai Sahib and considered it good research on their part to support their view and then when questioned are unable to really say anything constructive.jugroop singh · 29 Sep 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Dearest Veer 'A Singh' Jio, Thanks for your interesting points and clarification. May I address them one by one: Veer Ji, you wrote regarding Parmjit Singh's comments around the Khalsa and permissable fornication: "What is the background to this, please could we have the full story as this sounds like a totally absurd claim if Mr Warrior Saints did suggest it!" I am glad you think it is absurd; anyone who doesn't think it is absurd seriously needs to question what Sikhi they have gained. Please visit: http://tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=32872&t=32524#reply_32872 feel free to reply, after having read the thread, and having noted that NOT EVEN ONE response has been posted denying what Parmjit Singh said to Veer Kulbir Singh Ji…quite astonishing! I believe what Veer Kulbir Singh Ji has wropte because firstly I have no reason to believe he is a liar and secondly, because nothing he has stated has been denied. Veer Ji, you wrote: "The second question << why would Punjaab be better-off if: "everyone was taking Bhang"?>> sounds little more than a joke". This is what he said - it was pretty much the last thing he said before he left me and he wasn't laughing nor showing any signs of a sarcastic attitude - lets put it into context with the rest of the prior conversation, which may help… the 20min conversation we had just had, initiated by myself, was around the efficacy of GurMat Naam (which I have no direct experience of but have complete faith in) especially when it comes to accepting physical and mental pain as opposed to taking any intoxicants…I felt that having met Parmjit Singh, this would be a worthwhile discussion to have. My central question was: 'if the Khalsa needs cannabis to subdue pain, then what is the need for Naam, which Siree Guru Ji has shown to be effective in all situations?". I mentioned that the only reason Mahan Shaheed Singhs such as Shaheed Baba Deep Singh Ji were capable of such acts was because of their absorption in Naam; not because of any worldly intoxicants. Parmjit Singh would not relent and kept side-stepping what I felt was the central issue, and continued preaching the importance of bhang whereas I tried to impress upon him that to imply that the Khalsa need an intoxicant to 'cope' is to not understand the reality of Naam. This went on for a while - this is all I remember - he is free to respond for the purposes of clarification - if we meet again and he does so, I will post it on this forum. Veer Ji, you wrote: "when questioned further he said in reality it could either be a straight out bite/strike to the neck or simply tasting the blood of the opponent that may be on your sword". I attended around 3-4 classes in the park you mention…we may well have been in the same class on more than one occasion. Can I say that all we can all do is to do Ardaasan to Siree Guru Sahib Ji continuously, and ask HIM to directly give us an understanding as to what Tat GurMat Maryada really is…I am 100% sure that with the neccesary devotion, Siree Guru Sahib Ji will always do Kirpa upon the genuine devotee GurSikh and give him/her the inner-understanding and even more importantly, the Sangat that will make everything plain and simple. With that in mind, I am glad you have accepted this 'story' of niddar's is NOT GurMat Maryada because to do so would be to reduce the Khalsa to some kind of animist/cannabilistic cult! Is this what Siree Guru Sahib Ji wished to create - an army of blood-drinking (not to mention intoxicant-taking and fornicating) 'saint-soldiers'! If this is Dharam, what is Bay-Dharam (anti-Dharam)!!!! Veer Ji, I hope the above helps to clarify. As continually mentioned, I would really enjoy some kind of responses from nidddar/jagdeep/parmjit or any other 'UK Nihangs' regarding any of the points raised in my previous posts within this thread. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJKiFateh!A Singh · 29 Sep 2005
Pyare Veer Jagroop Singh! Gur Fateh Parvaan Hove!! Thanks for coming back to me – it is not my place to speak on anyone’s behalf, particularly if those persons are not known to me personally, so for the definitive answers, it is best to head on down to the Slough Akhara and ask Paramjit Singh and others directly. So, as per the fornication claim – I still have no idea where this assertion has come about, even after reading Veer Kulbir Singh’s post. In any event, I cannot accept that maryada permits adultery. Guru Sahib is very clear on his stance on such subjects: “Eka Nari Jati Soe…” As per the Bhang issue, I’m no scholar, however in the interest of clarification let’s consider this independently. I think there is proof enough that the Khalsa of the late 18th and early 19th century made use of Bhang and occasionally alcohol in the very specific incidence of battle/war. Whether we like this or not, like the matter concerning Black, Blue and Red flags, the latter with a picture/symbol of Durga on a tiger, is what happened – just like today, we have trim beard Singhs in positions of responsibility within Sikh institutions, or in some cases, particularly in Canada and North America, a Gurdwara committee full of monas – this is the reality of what happens, it maybe a million miles from GurMaryada, but it’s the way of the world. So is the historic use of Bhang amongst the Khalsa. This is not my personal view, it was is clearly stated in many historical texts and references contemporary to those times. What I personally cannot reconcile is the belief that this was a practice inaugurated by Guru Sahib, moreover for recreational use – this is simply absurd. In summary, there are two way to view this: 1. It’s a no-no, regardless of amount, situation, circumstance, person etc because Amrit Naam and Bani will take care of all illnesses and concerns. OKAY fine, however do those who share this view, then not (a) use over the counter (OTC) medication when ill? (b) local or heavy anaesthetic when undergoing surgery and to push it further (c) why even bother studying worldly subject, getting jobs, living in houses – as Amrit Naam / Bani will provide you with all the comforts and requirements of life? In which case, perhaps the Nihangs are correct about their chakravarti existence? 2. It’s fine – but only for medicinal purposes and in the extreme circumstance of war. OKAY, however, what constitutes ‘medicinal’? - Amputation? “Dutch Courage”? and what checks remain to ensure it is not abused as a recreational drug? Personally, I can see the logic if in battle, a person needs to use a (strictly medicinal quantity) of an anaesthetic drug (here, in the battle fields of 18th century Punjab, bhang would be have been easy to obtain) for physical healing as not everyone is necessarily as accomplished as Baba Deep Singh to undertake such pain and physical and mental trauma, so for the benefit of doubt, let’s say during ‘Yudh’ certain things became acceptable –HOWEVER, on the premise of ‘giving the benefit of doubt’ for this occurrence in Yudh, on what grounds do those who propose to maintain this “tradition” to date argue for its use during peaceful times? Is there any reason for the consumption of alcohol or bhang sitting in the veranda of your house? Or within the student digs at university other than recreational drug abuse? Let’s say you wish to remain steadfast for battle, fine – with the easy availability of OTC drugs and other less harmful and more legal substances, why the need to continue with Bhang? Moreover, even if we agree to the custom of Shaheedi Degh, at which juncture does that allow for the use of Bhang de Pakorae or Bhang dia Semeea (vermicelli) – these appear to be plainly for recreational use? Please [could the user/supporters of this substance] verify? I’ll leave that with the cyber-sangat for consideration.jugroop singh · 29 Sep 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Dearest Veer 'A Singh' Ji thanks for your reply Veer Ji - very interesting points... regarding proactively meeting them personally, please see my earlier response to 'avidiya' - my views still stand. please do not think i am fearful - i look forward to bumping into Parmjit Singh, niddar or jagdeep and discussing these issues further whenever the occassion my arise, through VahiGuru's Bhana. in fact, jagdeep is the only one of the three who i have never actually spoken to face-to-face. regarding the fornication, look towards the end of Veer Kulbir Singh Ji's initial post; i believe it is safe to assume that if Parmjit Singh did not say this, then he or someone favourably connected to him would have responded. regarding the fact that the 'Akali Nihungs' did use bhang - i absolutely agree with you and i think 99.9% of the Sikh world do - everyone accepts what they were doing from a particular point in Sikh history onwards - it is clearly obvious. however, the bottom line for me is that consumption of Cannabis (as well as the consumption of dead animals and alcohol) is distinctly identified as something which washes away ALL spiritual efforts; this is what Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji teaches us. therefore they have erred and continue to do so. they try to prove that Siree Guru Sahib Ji initiated this tradition WITHOUT ANY PROOF WHATSOEVER. the person who speaks such about Siree Guru Sahib Ji will surely get severe punishment! saying that He initiated and took part in such MunMat practises is a one way ticket to Narakh! yet they make bold assertions without even the remnants of solid proof...a very risky strategy indeed...i believe that Siree Guru Sahib Ji will deal with such people, who dress like His children but act against His Will, very drastically.... the argument i put forward to Parmjit Singh, regarding the fact that Naam is the 'stabiliser of the mind', still stands - but remember we're talking about something of more importance here: the chance of someone becoming a BayMukh. taking bhang is a Kurehit and immediately means that person who does so can no longer continues to be a Khalsa. clearly, taking a medicine which does not include Bhang/Tobacco/Alcohol/Crack etc. is a different matter...i see no Hukams, via Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji (in the first and most important instance, and then via Akaal Takhat) that prevent us from doing so. there are better painkillers available nowadays and i also wholeheartedly agree with your point about what may have once been perceived as a neccesity, albeit a misguided perception i believe, to what has now become ritual drug. also, i don't remember the 'Akali Nihungs' taking part in any battles recently wheere such remedies may have been needed...in particular, i think 'that small incident' in 1984 passed them by... again, hopefully someone who is unashamedly pro-Bhang, pro-Fornication or pro-Blood-drinking may want to respond soon and put across what has been called the 'True Sikhi' as opposed to the 'Disney World' variety that the rest of the Panth is 'mistakenly' following... we can only hope that someone out there wishes to take part in such a discussion, and wants to do the Seva of propogating the 'True Sikhi'. but one question i am REALLY, REALLY interested in is the following: > why were pages referring to Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh Ji as a 'nang' taken-off the ShasterVidiya website in a clandestine manner, WITHOUT an apology or statement...and this despite the website's commitment to 'speaking the TRUTH' no matter what? the site's intro quote being: "What is false I will call false. Even though the people may try to silence me. I do not care for what anybody says. I will speak BUT THE TRUTH from my mouth". so, given that jagdeep/niddar changed their stance on Taksaal after 'new research', what 'new research' led them to stop thinking of Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh Ji as a 'nang'? surely their must be a very good REASON for such a u-turn... please do share.... VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!jugroop singh · 03 Oct 2005
i'm forever bumping this thread, bumping this thread i am forever doing....Scientific · 04 Oct 2005
Dear All The issue of bhang is knocked around on so many threads . Whether it was used or not in the past will be debated til the cows come home. The real issue is that there isnt a need to use bhang today. In fact the use of cannabis should be refrained from. There is clear evidence of drug induced psychoses being trigered by cannabis abuse. I have seen several young patients in the psychiatric unit being admitted with such backgrounds. To keep it in perspective most people who use cannabis will be ok and not suffer adverse psychiatric complications but any risk of developing a psychotic disorder should be scary enough to avoid this substance. In the times when it was used, its quite likely that the calming medicinal properties of this substance were noted and it was considered ideal to get through another day of being hounded like an animal on the battlefield. We should just remain focused on facts and science when dealing with these issues. Bhang is just not needed in todays world and the risks (for those who are completely healthy) outweigh any benefits. Scientificjugroop singh · 04 Oct 2005
i'm forever bumping this thread, bumping this thread i am forever doing.... trying to get REAL answers to my REAL questionsavidya · 05 Oct 2005
Waheguruji Ka Khalsa Waheguruji Ki Fateh Bhai Sahib Jugroop Singh ji, 'I'm talking to a wall and I'm getting everyone to look at me talking to this wall, and I'm making a really big thing about how the wall isn't talking back to me...' In the nicest possible way Bhai Jugroop Singh ji, have less of an ego trip and pick up a phone or at the least get a freind to ask your questions to them if you personally feel such disgust and pity for those individuals that you can't even face them. Another thought, surely a Gurmukh has enough moral fibre to go and speak to those they consider nindaks or 'fallen'? Of course this is the usual 'nang' response...(from neither a nang nor nihung)A Singh · 05 Oct 2005
Jugroop Singh, perhaps take these final questions, which only the UK Nihangs can answer themselves to the sites where they are usually present (sikhawareness etc). Gur Fateh! A Singh.jugroop singh · 05 Oct 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Dearest Veer 'Avidya' Ji, a few points: - you're absolutely spot-on - i am 'talking to a wall and I'm getting everyone to look at me talking to this wall, and I'm making a really big thing about how the wall isn't talking back to me...' for the following reasons: - jagdeep and niddar felt it IMPORTANT to call a Shaheed Singh Ji a nang, they felt it IMPORTANT to create two very detailed websites espousing the 'real deal' variety of Sikhi as opposed to the 'disneyland' version...yet they, nor anyone who shares their views, can be bothered to answer simple questions regarding this! - the last time i saw them (before the 'nang' page went up), i asked niddar, who looked over to jagdeep, to change the section that deviously tried to implicate certain untruths regarding the relationship/sharing of views between Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh and Teja Bhasauria. after conceding to my argument, niddar said it would be changed....it NEVER HAPPENED...and then not too long ago, someone adds even more nindiya about Bhai Sahib being a stooge of the British - how more DEVIOUS, UN-GURSIKH LIKE and plain CHILDISH can you get? - see my previous points about not actively doing the Sangat of such people. Dearest Veer 'A Singh' ji, - i made a promise to Siree Guru Sahib Ji a long time ago, after taking part in a thread that saw the COMPLETE SLANDERING of Great GurSikhs, that i'd never post another message on that cursed 'forum'. pls can both of you do the following Seva for me in light of the above - post a msg on 'Sikh Awareness' directing anyone who is in favour of the Khalsa drinking blood, fornicating or taking intoxicants to come along here and give us an insight about the REAL DEAL. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!